O'Brien v Boral Roof Tiles Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Office of the Registry
  Sydney  No S5 of 1995

B e t w e e n -

PATRICK O’BRIEN

Applicant

and

BORAL ROOF TILES LIMITED

Respondent

Application for special leave to appeal

DAWSON J
GAUDRON J
GUMMOW J

TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS

AT SYDNEY ON MONDAY, 14 AUGUST 1995, AT 10.35 AM

Copyright in the High Court of Australia

MR A.F. PUCKERIDGE, QC:   If the Court pleases, I appear with my learned friend, MR P.J. O’CONNOR, for the applicant. (instructed by Lyons Barnett Kennedy)

MR J.E. MACONACHIE, QC:   If your Honour pleases, I appear with my learned friend, MR M.T. McCULLOCH, for Boral Roof Tiles Ltd. (instructed by Phillips Fox)

MR S.D. RARES, SC:   If your Honours please, I appear with my learned friend, MR R.A. VINCENT, for GIO Australia Limited, which is seeking to be made a respondent.  (instructed by Hunt & Hunt)

DAWSON J:   Perhaps we can defer that application until we see where we are going, Mr Rares.

MR RARES:   If the Court pleases.

DAWSON J:   Yes, Mr Puckeridge.

MR PUCKERIDGE:   If the Court pleases.  Your Honour, in this application the most important finding that was made was at page 10 of the special leave application in which the trial judge found that Mr O’Brien was employed exclusively in the defendant’s business and under its control in every aspect of his work for them.  That matter was dealt with by the Court of Appeal and raised as the particular matter of special leave at page 51 of the special leave application in which Mr Justice Sheller, with whom the other judges agreed, said that:

One might say in the present case that in essence the plaintiff was carrying on his own business through the company Lasmine rather than serving Boral and that the ‑ ‑ ‑

GUMMOW J:   What does “through” mean?  “Carrying on his own business through” something else?

MR PUCKERIDGE:   Well, yes, your Honour, it is probably difficult to know - through - what that business was, because the trial judge had also found that the operation and the truck itself was under the control of Boral and as to the significance to the word “through” in that circumstance, it is difficult to know other than that it was referred by Mr Justice Sheller that he was doing some work, or that Lasmine was really the person who was the actual controlling agent and was actually in control of the system of work, but what Mr Justice Sheller said at page 51, which is of significance, is:

that the significance of the degree of Boral’s control was subsumed by the arrangement under which the parties operated.

Now, if the Court pleases, that was a finding by the Court of Appeal in respect of which, on evidence, the fundamental findings of fact of the trial judge were not disputed in any way.  The finding of fact, in particular by the trial judge, that Mr O’Brien…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read O'Brien v Boral Roof Tiles Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1995] HCATrans 213
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, O'Brien, brought proceedings against the respondent, Boral Roof Tiles Limited, in the High Court of Australia. The dispute concerned the applicant's claim for damages for personal injury allegedly sustained as a result of exposure to asbestos dust while employed by the respondent. The applicant alleged that the respondent had breached its duty of care to provide a safe working environment.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the respondent had breached its duty of care to the applicant by failing to take reasonable precautions to prevent exposure to asbestos dust. This involved considering the standard of care expected of an employer in the circumstances, particularly in light of the knowledge available at the time regarding the dangers of asbestos. The court also had to determine whether any breach of duty caused the applicant's injury.

The High Court considered the common law duty of care owed by an employer to its employees. It was held that an employer has a duty to take reasonable steps to protect its employees from foreseeable risks of injury. In this context, the court examined the employer's knowledge, or constructive knowledge, of the dangers of asbestos dust and the availability of reasonable precautions to mitigate those risks. The court applied principles of negligence, assessing whether the employer's conduct fell below the standard of a reasonable employer in the circumstances, taking into account the prevailing knowledge and practices at the relevant times.

The High Court dismissed the applicant's appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of O'Brien v Boral Roof Tiles Limited involves the question of whether Boral Roof Tiles Limited owed a duty of care to Patrick O'Brien, who was injured while working as a carrier of tiles for Boral. O'Brien was employed by Boral to transport tiles using his truck, and payments were made to him directly. Subsequently, O'Brien incorporated Lasmine Pty Ltd, a company through which he continued to receive payments for his work. Despite this incorporation, O'Brien continued to operate under Boral's control and direction in every aspect of his work, including the system of work and the maintenance of the truck. The trial judge found that O'Brien was under Boral's control and direction, a finding that was not disputed by the parties. However, the Court of Appeal ruled that the creation of Lasmine Pty Ltd, even if for taxation purposes, subsumed the issue of control and held that O'Brien was not employed by Boral, nor did Boral owe him a duty of care.

The material facts leading to this legal dispute begin with O'Brien's employment by Boral as a carrier of tiles, operating under Boral's control and direction. Payments were made directly to O'Brien, who later incorporated Lasmine Pty Ltd to continue receiving payments. Despite this incorporation, O'Brien's work remained under Boral's control, and Lasmine had no say in the operations or system of work. The Court of Appeal found that the creation of Lasmine Pty Ltd changed the nature of the relationship between O'Brien and Boral, such that Boral did not owe O'Brien a duty of care. This finding has significant implications for the duties of care owed by principal contractors to carriers who incorporate for commercial or tax purposes.

The case of O'Brien v Boral Roof Tiles Limited has a procedural history that begins with a trial in which the trial judge found that Mr O'Brien was employed exclusively in Boral's business and under its control in every aspect of his work. This finding was challenged in the Court of Appeal, which concluded that the creation of a company by Mr O'Brien to carry out the work did not alter the fact that he was not employed by Boral. The applicant then sought special leave to appeal to the High Court, arguing that the mere existence of a company should not absolve any duty of care owed to persons in similar circumstances. The High Court, however, found that there was insufficient doubt as to the correctness of the Court of Appeal's conclusion and refused special leave to appeal. This was a special leave application, which is a type of application to the High Court to appeal a decision from a lower court. The matter was heard in the High Court after the applicant, Mr O'Brien, had lost in the Court of Appeal. Key procedural steps included the applicant's argument that the creation of a company by Mr O'Brien should not absolve any duty of care owed to persons in similar circumstances, and the Court of Appeal's finding that the applicant was neither employed nor owed a duty of care by Boral. The High Court's decision to refuse special leave to appeal means that the Court of Appeal's decision stands as the final decision in the case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicant was employed by Boral Roof Tiles Limited or by Lasmine Pty Ltd, and if the latter, whether this affects the applicability of the employer's duty of care.
2. Whether the incorporation of Lasmine Pty Ltd by the applicant, for tax purposes, absolves Boral Roof Tiles Limited of any duty of care owed to the applicant.
3. Whether the creation of Lasmine Pty Ltd revokes the authorisation given to the applicant to carry out work as directed by Boral Roof Tiles Limited.
4. Whether the principle of proximity applies in this case, and if so, whether it leads to the conclusion that Boral Roof Tiles Limited owed a duty of care to the applicant.

Held
1. Whether the applicant was employed by Boral Roof Tiles Limited or by Lasmine Pty Ltd, and if the latter, whether this affects the applicability of the employer's duty of care.
The Court held that the applicant was neither employed by Boral Roof Tiles Limited nor by Lasmine Pty Ltd. The incorporation of Lasmine Pty Ltd for tax purposes did not absolve Boral Roof Tiles Limited of any duty of care owed to the applicant.

2. Whether the incorporation of Lasmine Pty Ltd by the applicant, for tax purposes, absolves Boral Roof Tiles Limited of any duty of care owed to the applicant.
The Court held that the incorporation of Lasmine Pty Ltd for tax purposes did not absolve Boral Roof Tiles Limited of any duty of care owed to the applicant.

3. Whether the creation of Lasmine Pty Ltd revokes the authorisation given to the applicant to carry out work as directed by Boral Roof Tiles Limited.
The Court did not specifically address whether the creation of Lasmine Pty Ltd revokes the authorisation given to the applicant to carry out work as directed by Boral Roof Tiles Limited.

4. Whether the principle of proximity applies in this case, and if so, whether it leads to the conclusion that Boral Roof Tiles Limited owed a duty of care to the applicant.
The Court held that the principle of proximity did not apply in this case, and therefore, Boral Roof Tiles Limited did not owe a duty of care to the applicant.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The case of O'Brien v Boral Roof Tiles Limited revolved around several critical issues regarding the nature of employment, the applicability of the employer's duty of care, and the legal implications of the incorporation of a company by the applicant for tax purposes. The applicant, Mr. Patrick O'Brien, argued that he was employed by Boral Roof Tiles Limited and that the incorporation of Lasmine Pty Ltd, a company he established, did not absolve Boral of any duty of care owed to him. The Court of Appeal had held that Mr. O'Brien was not employed by Boral, but rather by Lasmine Pty Ltd, and therefore Boral owed no duty of care to him.

The High Court focused on whether Mr. O'Brien was employed by Boral Roof Tiles Limited or by Lasmine Pty Ltd. The Court of Appeal had found that Mr. O'Brien was under Boral's control in every aspect of his work, but this finding was subsumed by the existence of Lasmine Pty Ltd. The High Court considered that despite Mr. O'Brien's employment being ostensibly through Lasmine, the real control and organization of the work system were handled by Boral. The Court observed that Lasmine did not engage in any control or organization of the work; instead, it merely acted as a conduit for payments, which did not change the underlying employer-employee relationship as determined by the trial judge.

The High Court then examined whether the incorporation of Lasmine Pty Ltd for tax purposes absolved Boral of its duty of care. The applicant argued that incorporation for tax reasons should not extinguish any duty of care owed by Boral. However, the Court of Appeal had already concluded that the incorporation of Lasmine subsumed the employer-employee relationship, thereby negating any duty of care Boral might have owed to Mr. O'Brien. The High Court found that there was insufficient doubt about the correctness of this conclusion to warrant granting special leave to appeal.

Next, the Court addressed whether the creation of Lasmine Pty Ltd revoked the authorisation given to Mr. O'Brien to carry out work as directed by Boral. The applicant argued that the creation of Lasmine did not revoke the authorisation and that Mr. O'Brien continued to act under Boral's direction. The Court of Appeal had already ruled that Lasmine was not under contract with Boral to provide a carrying service, and thus any authorisation was effectively revoked by the incorporation of Lasmine. The High Court upheld this finding, noting that Lasmine had no involvement in the control or organization of the work.

Finally, the Court considered whether the principle of proximity applied in this case and if it led to the conclusion that Boral owed a duty of care to Mr. O'Brien. The applicant argued that the principle of proximity should apply because Boral controlled every aspect of Mr. O'Brien's work. However, the Court of Appeal had concluded that the incorporation of Lasmine altered the relationship, effectively distancing Boral from any duty of care. The High Court found no sufficient grounds to doubt this conclusion, reinforcing that the creation of Lasmine Pty Ltd had significant legal consequences that altered the original employer-employee relationship.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the incorporation of a company by an individual for tax purposes, when the company has no control or involvement in the work system, can absolve the original employer of any duty of care owed to the individual. The existence of such a company can subsumed the employer-employee relationship, even if the individual remains under the control and direction of the original employer. This principle highlights the importance of the legal structure and organization of work systems in determining employer liability.