Nye v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services)

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION

PARTIES:

Nye v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services) [2024] QIRC 37

Nye, Gerard

(Appellant)

v

State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services)

(Respondent)

CASE NO:

PSA/2023/216

PROCEEDING:

Public Sector Appeal – Appeal against a disciplinary decision

DELIVERED ON:

14 February 2024

HEARD AT:

MEMBER:

On the papers

Pidgeon IC

ORDERS:

1. Pursuant to s 562C(1)(c) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld), the decision is set aside and the matter is returned to the decision maker with a copy of the decision on appeal with a direction that the decision-maker provide reasons to explain the findings regarding grounds for discipline for Allegations 2, 3 and 5.

CATCHWORDS:

PUBLIC SECTOR – EMPLOYEES AND SERVANTS OF THE CROWN GENERALLY – PUBLIC SECTOR APPEAL – where the appellant is employed by the respondent as a Correctional Manager at Capricornia Correctional Centre –  appeal against a disciplinary finding decision – findings of misconduct and breaches of the code of conduct – allegations substantiated – insufficient reasons given to explain findings of misconduct – decision set aside and returned to the decision-maker with a copy of the decision – direction to provide reasons to explain decision on grounds for discipline

LEGISLATION AND OTHER INSTRUMENTS:

Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) ss 562B, 562C

Public Sector Act 2022 (Qld) ss 91, 129, 131, 133

Public Service Commission Discipline Directive 14/20

Reasons for Decision

Introduction

  1. Mr Gerard Nye (‘the Appellant’) is employed by the State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services) (‘the Respondent’) as a Correctional Manager at Capricornia Correctional Centre.

  2. On 22 September 2021, Queensland Corrective Services (‘QCS’) Ethical Standards Group (‘ESG’) received a referral from General Manager Richard Butcher (‘GM Butcher’) containing complaints from four female colleagues against Mr Nye and Mr Nye’s response to those complaints.

  3. The ESG conducted an investigation and finalised an investigation report into the matter. The investigator found the following allegation against Mr Nye was capable of being substantiated:

    Allegation 1: Between January 2021 and September 2021 Correctional Manager Gerard Nye failed to treat Queensland Corrective Services employees [Employee A], [Employee B], [Employee C], [Employee D] and [Employee E] with courtesy and respect by behaving towards and conversing with them in an inappropriate manner.[1]

    [1] I have determined to use pseudonyms in place of the names of each complainant; I also note that the Allegation as it relates to Employee B was not pursued.

  1. On 13 February 2023, Mr Gary McCahon, Deputy Commissioner Custodial Operations (‘the decision-maker’ or ‘DC McCahon’) wrote to Mr Nye suspending him from duty and inviting him to show cause in relation to the allegation set out above. The allegation was subsequently reframed into five separate allegations.

  2. Mr Nye provided his response to the first show cause notice on 1 March 2023.

  3. Mr Nye subsequently provided WorkCover with medical certificates and this resulted in the discipline process and suspension being placed in abeyance. This information is set out in the second show cause notice (see below from [9]).

  4. On 16 October 2023,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nye v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QIRC 37
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Nye v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services) concerns an appeal by Mr Nye, a Correctional Manager at Capricornia Correctional Centre, against a disciplinary decision made by DC McCahon. The disciplinary decision found Mr Nye guilty of misconduct and breaches of the code of conduct based on various allegations, leading to disciplinary action. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the decision-maker provided sufficient reasons to substantiate the findings of misconduct. The court was tasked with reviewing the adequacy of the reasons provided by DC McCahon to justify the disciplinary findings.

The court examined the decision-maker's application of the Briginshaw principles, which require the standard of proof to be proportionate to the seriousness of the charge. The court found that while the decision-maker applied a sound, considered, and reasonably justified reasoning process, there was a significant omission in the provision of detailed reasons for the findings on certain allegations. Specifically, the court held that the decision-maker failed to sufficiently explain the reasons for the disciplinary findings regarding Allegations 2, 3, and 5. These findings related to inappropriate conduct towards colleagues, including inappropriate physical contact and making colleagues uncomfortable.

In setting aside the decision and returning it to the decision-maker, the court directed that the decision-maker provide more comprehensive reasons to explain the findings on the grounds for discipline. The court emphasized the importance of adequate reasoning to ensure transparency and fairness in the disciplinary process. This direction aims to rectify the deficiency identified in the original decision.

The court's final order was to set aside the disciplinary decision and return it to the decision-maker with a directive to provide detailed reasons for the findings on Allegations 2, 3, and 5. This order ensures that the decision-maker has an opportunity to address the identified shortcomings in the reasoning process.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 562C(1)(c) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld), the decision is set aside and the matter is returned to the decision maker with a copy of the decision on appeal with a direction that the decision-maker provide reasons to explain the findings regarding grounds for discipline for Allegations 2, 3 and 5.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Respondent’s submissions provide a background to the matter, state the relevant legal principles, and describe its understanding of Mr Nye’s appeal grounds. The Respondent then addresses the decision-maker’s substantiation of the allegations and responds to Mr Nye’s submissions.Standard of proof and strength of evidence Firstly, the Respondent says that the decision-maker applied the relevant standard of proof in his consideration and application of the Briginshaw[5] principles. The Respondent says the decision-maker’s reasoning was ‘sound, considered and reasonably justified’. [5] Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336. Turning to Allegation 1, the Respondent notes that the Appellant does not deny sending the relevant email to Employee A, but he denies that the email contained a sexual connotation. However, the Respondent contends that Mr Nye failed to treat Employee A with courtesy and respect by sending an unprofessional and inappropriate email to a subordinate colleague after hours, on his personal mobile phone, in circumstances where Mr Nye had only spoken with Employee A once or twice previously, and with the words ‘… or just want to chat please give me a call. Any time drunk or sober’. While Employee A found Mr Nye’s email ‘weird’, no finding was made of sexual harassment or the making of inappropriate sexual connotations. The discipline ground was that of a breach of the Code of Conduct, so the Respondent says Mr Nye’s objection is misguided and the finding should be upheld.Allegation 2 Mr Nye ‘strongly refutes’ Allegation 2, but for Allegation 2(c) regarding his conduct involving a banana, where Mr Nye submits that a culture of ‘banter’ within the workplace is a mitigating factor. The Respondent says Allegation 2 pertained to a complaint made by Employee C. It is alleged that Mr Nye failed to respect her personal boundaries, inappropriately rubbed her arm, and made inappropriate sexual connotations. The Respondent particularises the allegation as follows:(a) That during a meeting with [Employee C] and Custodial Supervisors (CSs) Finegan, Lawson and Medlin, the Appellant pulled his chair towards [Employee C’s] chair and spread his legs so that his legs were straddled on either side of [Employee C]. The Appellant leaned towards [Employee C] and made ‘slurping noises’ with a lollipop he had in his mouth. The Appellant offered the lollipop to [Employee C], to which she responded with words to the effect, ‘no thank you.’ This was set out in [Employee C’s] initial written complaint and confirmed at interview. CS Lawson corroborated that the Appellant slid alongside [Employee C] and had one of his legs on either side of her. The email from CS Medlin, provided by the Appellant as part of his response to the NTSC2 confirm that there was a ‘tub of chuppa lollies’ at the meeting, though is silent on the offering of the lollipop.(b) That when on a phone call to CS Davis, the Appellant used his right arm to rub the top of [Employee C’s] left arm, near her bicep, several times. The Appellant admitted at interview to ‘touching’ [Employee C’s] hand. The decision-maker preferred the evidence of [Employee C] given the pattern of the Appellant failing to respect social boundaries, the overwhelming evidence that the Appellant made female staff uncomfortable and the inconsistency in the Appellant’s versions. The decision-maker’s reasoning was set out at paragraphs 45-48 of the NTSC2.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Nye appeals the disciplinary finding decision of DC McCahon dated 16 October 2023.The decision The second show cause notice issued to Mr Nye on 16 October 2023 is 34 pages long and addresses five allegations. DC McCahon determines that the second sub-allegation of Allegation 1 is substantiated and that each of Allegations 2 to 5 are substantiated and makes a disciplinary finding in relation to each one. The allegations are as follows:Allegation 1: In or around 2021 at Capricornia Correctional Centre (Capricornia CC), you failed to treat your colleague, [Employee A], with courtesy and respect by: The decision-maker goes into some detail regarding the period of time which elapsed between Mr Nye responding to the first show cause notice on 27 February 2023 and the subsequent absence of Mr Nye from the workplace due to either illness or paid suspension. The decision-maker then notes that while the first show cause notice was issued prior to the commencement of the Public Sector Act 2022 (Qld) (‘the PS Act’), the transitional provision makes clear that the new PS Act will apply to the discipline process. Next, the decision-maker sets out a summary of Mr Nye’s submissions made in relation to the allegations against him in his show cause response. DC McCahon notes additional submissions from Mr Nye providing background information regarding cultural issues at Capricornia CC, advice Mr Nye received from his union regarding the time period between the events complained of and the complaints being made, and an optometrist report stating that he needs to be within 40 centimetres of a computer screen. The decision-maker considers Mr Nye’s submissions regarding the investigation, the outcome of the investigation and the standard to be applied by an investigator in determining whether each allegation was substantiated on the balance of probabilities. DC McCahon records Mr Nye’s submission that there has been damage caused by the ‘reckless abandonment of the procedures, breaching confidence and collating the allegations in an unregulated fashion’. The decision-maker says that while Mr Nye has made submissions regarding his age, family situation and work history, these submissions will not be taken into account until such time as a decision is being made regarding what penalty, if any, to impose. DC McCahon then goes on to set out his findings with regard to the five allegations from pages seven through to 28 of the letter. From pages 28 to 31, DC McCahon addresses the matters set out at [14] and [15] above. The decision-maker explains that a disciplinary finding decision has been made, outlines Mr Nye’s appeal entitlements and requests that Mr Nye show cause as to the proposed disciplinary action. DC McCahon acknowledges that Mr Nye’s human rights may be limited by the disciplinary findings but concludes that the public interest in ensuring that Mr Nye complies with the Code of Conduct and other policies and procedures, and treats his co-workers with courtesy and respect, outweighs the impact on his human rights. The decision-maker concludes by reminding Mr Nye about the Employee Assistance Program (‘EAP’) and QCS digital support tools, and suggests that Mr Nye may also wish to seek assistance from his union.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established