Nyarkoa v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read
DETERMINATION OF REVIEW PANEL
CITATION: Nyarkoa v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited [2024] NSWPICMP 318
CLAIMANT: Abena Nyarkoa
INSURER: Allianz
REVIEW PANEL
MEMBER: Ray Plibersek
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Thomas Rosenthal
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Drew Dixon
DATE OF DECISION: 20 May 2024
CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS – Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; claimant was injured when her car was hit from behind whilst turning into a driveway; she received injuries to her spine, shoulders, knee and leg; also claimed for treatment and care for a right shoulder rotator cuff surgery; the Panel found a total whole person impairment of 0%; as a result of the accident the claimant sustained a number of soft tissue injuries including bilateral knee sprain and lumbar spine; no evidence of significant structural damage or injuries shown to spine, shoulders, knees, legs or hands caused by the motor accident; GP records show that claimant has a significant past history of injury and disability including bilateral knee replacements; workplace accident in 2001 where claimant fell down some stairs and injured her left leg and knee; claimant’s GP records also show a history of shoulder and back complaints prior to the subject motor accident; Panel also found that the proposed right shoulder rotator cuff repair did not relate to the injury caused by the motor accident and was not reasonable and necessary; Held – original medical certificate set aside regarding permanent impairment; original medical certificate affirmed regarding proposed right shoulder rotator cuff surgery.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:  

CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION

1.     The Review Panel revokes the certificate of Medical Assessor Clive Kenna dated
3 May 2023 regarding permanent impairment.

2.     The Review Panel issues a new certificate determining that:

(a)   the following injuries were caused by the motor accident and give rise to a permanent impairment of 0%which is not greater than 10%:

·        cervical spine – soft tissue injury, and

·        lumbar spine – soft tissue injury.

(b)   The following injuries were not caused by the motor accident :

·        right shoulder – soft tissue injury, and

·        left shoulder – soft tissue injury.

(c)   The following injuries caused by the motor accident have resolved and do not result in a permanent impairment:

·        thoracic spine – soft tissue injury;

·        left hand – soft tissue injury;

·        left leg – soft tissue injury, and

·        bilateral knees – soft tissue injury.

3.     The Review Panel affirms the certificate of Medical Assessor Clive Kenna dated 3 May 2024 regarding treatment and care.

4.     The following treatment and care of a:

·        a right rotator cuff repair and biceps tenodesis as requested by Dr Baba on
13 July 2021,

does not relate to the injury caused by the motor accident.

5.     The following treatment and care of a:

·        a right rotator cuff repair and biceps tenodesis as requested by Dr Baba
13 July 2021,

is not reasonable and necessary in the circumstances.

REVIEW PANEL REASONS FOR DECISION

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 28 October 2020 Abena Nyarkoa (the claimant) was the driver of a vehicle. She…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nyarkoa v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWPICMP 318
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Nyarkoa v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited, the claimant sought compensation for injuries sustained in a motor accident. The dispute centered on the extent of the claimant's injuries and the necessity of proposed medical treatments. The matter was heard and determined by a Panel.

The primary legal issues for the Panel to resolve were whether the claimant had sustained a permanent impairment as a result of the accident and whether the proposed right shoulder rotator cuff surgery was reasonable and necessary. The Panel was required to consider the claimant's medical history, the evidence of injuries sustained in the accident, and the medical opinions regarding the necessity of the proposed surgery.

In its decision, the Panel found that the claimant had sustained soft tissue injuries, including a bilateral knee sprain and lumbar spine injury, as a result of the accident. However, it determined that there was no evidence of significant structural damage or injuries to the spine, shoulders, knees, legs, or hands caused by the motor accident. The Panel noted that the claimant had a significant past history of injuries and disabilities, including bilateral knee replacements, a workplace accident in 2001, and pre-existing shoulder and back complaints. The Panel also found that the proposed right shoulder rotator cuff repair did not relate to the injury caused by the motor accident and was not reasonable and necessary.

The original medical certificate regarding permanent impairment was set aside, while the original medical certificate concerning the proposed right shoulder rotator cuff surgery was affirmed. The Panel's findings and determinations were based on the evidence presented, including the medical records and expert opinions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Pre-accident treatment medical evidence New Granville Medical Centre The pre-accident medical evidence in the records of the new Granville Medical Centre show that Ms Nyarkoa reported a history of previous injuries.[9][9] Claimant's bundle A3 pp 35-95. On 17 January 2001 while working as a nursing assistant the claimant reported slipping down some stairs at work and twisting and injuring her left knee. Throughout 2001 and 2012 the claimant had a number of consultations and treatments with her treating GP Dr Wafik Latif about her painful and swollen left and right knees. On a number of occasions, Dr Latif advised the claimant that she seek a review from an orthopaedic surgeon for an arthroscopy and debridement. On 25 June 2002 the claimant reported to Dr Latif that she had stiffness in the neck and painful movements. On 22 December 2006 the claimant complained of pain over the low back pain over the right foot. Dr Latif noted right-sided sciatica and suggested a CT scan of the lower spine. On 2 July 2009, the claimant complained of right shoulder pain with restriction. The claimant complained of pain over the right shoulder and arm area, elevation of shoulder restricted painful tenderness over right upper shoulder area and joint currently on Naprosyn (anti-inflammatories ). On 23 February 2012 Dr Latif recorded an aggravation of right knee pain seen at emergency given analgesia and considered surgery. In November 2013 Dr Latif noted that the claimant had a total right knee replacement. In December 2014 Dr Latif noted that the claimant had a total left knee replacement. On 4 August 2017 Dr Latif noted that the claimant complained of pain over the left shoulder area down to the left upper arm for one month, no recent injuries or falls over shoulder. Examination showed tenderness over the upper arm shoulder arc to 90°, painful restricted rotation and abduction. On 10 August 2017 Dr Latif reviewed the results of the left shoulder ultrasound which showed a partial-thickness SS, tendinitis and bursal thickening. Steroid injection. On 6 September 2017 Dr Latif noted that the claimant was still complaining of pain over the left shoulder after having the steroid injection 20 days ago. Pain over upper half left arm. Examination showed arc 90°, limited abduction and external rotation. Continue conservative management. On 13 October 2017 Dr Latif noted the claimant was still complaining of a painful left shoulder. On 24 July 2018 Dr Latif noted complaints of left heel pain with a diagnosis of planter fasciitis with a calcified spur on the left heel. On 15 February 2019 Dr Latif noted severe pain down the right thigh to the lateral aspect of the right leg. He also noted obesity and movements difficult. Right-sided sciatica pain. On 21 February 2019 Dr Latif noted CT lumbar spine on 18 February 2019. Diagnostic imaging requested CT guided. Neural injection right L4/L5 facet joint, right L4 nerve root exit lower back pain right radicular pain. Please refer to CT scan report. On 15 March 2019 Dr Latif noted the claimant continued to have pain over the right thigh seen at emergency given Endo which is not helping. Known to have sciatic pain. Waiting for injection L4 on 26 March. Examination showed tenderness of lower back. Movements painful. Restricted right side.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established