Nwokeiwu and Tax Practitioners Board

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

Nwokeiwu and Tax Practitioners Board [2024] AATA 804 (28 March 2024)

Division:Taxation and Commercial Division

File Number(s):2024/0234, 2024/0302 and 2024/0306      

Re:Michael Nwokeiwu   

APPLICANT

Tax Practitioners BoardAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Mr Rob Reitano, Member

Date:28 March 2024

Place:                     Sydney

I dismiss the application for a stay of the Tax Practitioners Board’s decisions of 7 December 2023 terminating the registration of Mr Nwokeiwu’s, Mun Accountants and Tax Advisors Pty Ltd and Aussie Tax Professions Pty Ltd under the Tax Agent Services Act 2009, the effect of which is to dissolve the interim stay granted on 19 January 2024.

..................[SGD]..................

Mr Rob Reitano, Member

CATCHWORDS
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - STAY APPLICATION – tax agents registration – false and misleading statements – underreported income – good and services tax shortfall – fringe benefits tax shortfall - failure to lodge returns and business activity statements prospects of success - public interest – hardship – early hearing – dissolution of interim stay

LEGISLATION
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth)

CASES
Scott v Australian Securities and Investment Commission [2009] AATA 798

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v PTLZ [2008] FCAFC 164

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr Rob Reitano, Member

27 March 2024

  1. This is an application under s 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (AAT Act) by Dr Michael Nwokeiwu (Mr Nwokeiwu), Aussie Tax Professionals Pty Ltd (Aussie Tax) and Mun Accountants & Advisers Pty Ltd (Mun Accountants) for a stay of three decisions of the Tax Practitioners Board (Board) on 7 December 2023, which terminated the registration of each of them under the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth) (TAS Act) with effect from 22 January 2024.

  2. On 19 January 2024 the Tribunal, by consent, granted an interim stay until this application for a stay of the decisions could be heard. I have decided to refuse the application for a stay, and these are my reasons for doing so.

    THE REGULATORY CONTEXT

  3. Sub-section 2.5(1) of the TAS Act provides that the object of the TAS Act is to ‘support public trust and confidence in the integrity of the tax profession and of the tax system by ensuring that tax agent services are provided to the community in accordance with appropriate standards of professional and ethical conduct’. Sub-section 2.5(2) of the TAS Act provides that the object in ss 3(1) is to be achieved, amongst other things, through providing for a system of registration and regulation of tax agents, a Code of Professional Conduct (Code) and a system of sanctions and discipline of tax agents.

  4. Sub-section 30-10 of the TAS Act provides for the Code which includes a series of obligations with which tax agents are expected to comply. It is unsurprising that the very first obligation in s 30-10(1) is that a tax agent ‘must act with honesty and integrity’. In fact, many of the obligations are rudimentary matters of professional practice involving things like compliance with taxation laws…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nwokeiwu and Tax Practitioners Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 804
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for a stay of a decision by the Tax Practitioners Board (TPB) to terminate Mr. Nwokeiwu's registration as a tax agent. The dispute arose from an Australian Taxation Office (ATO) review and audit concerning Mr. Nwokeiwu's income tax return for the Krumn Trust for the 2019 tax year, which identified significant discrepancies in reported net income and GST. Subsequently, the TPB commenced a preliminary inquiry into Mr. Nwokeiwu's conduct, including allegations of false and misleading statements, underreporting income, GST and fringe benefits tax shortfalls, and consistent late lodgement of returns and business activity statements. The application for a stay was heard by Mr. Rob Reitano, Member, of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether to grant an interim stay of the TPB's decision to terminate Mr. Nwokeiwu's tax agent registration pending the final hearing of his appeal. In determining this, the Tribunal was required to consider established principles for granting a stay, including the prospects of success of the applicant, the consequences of refusing or granting the stay for the applicant and the respondent, the public interest, and whether refusal of the stay would render the final relief nugatory. The Tribunal also had to assess the time between the stay application and the final hearing, and any other relevant matters.

The Tribunal found that Mr. Nwokeiwu's prospects of success on the merits of his appeal were not good, based on the evidence and submissions presented. The evidence regarding late lodgements appeared to be documentary and contrary to Mr. Nwokeiwu's own declarations to the TPB, and the ATO's audit findings concerning unreported income, GST, and FBT also appeared straightforward. The Tribunal noted that Mr. Nwokeiwu's submissions contained concessions that he might be ultimately unsuccessful, suggesting a reduced period of cancellation or suspension, which indicated an acknowledgement that his case was not strong. Furthermore, the Tribunal considered that the public interest weighed against granting a stay, as the TPB, acting as the regulator, had made an adverse finding against Mr. Nwokeiwu, concluding that the public needed protection by terminating his registration. The Tribunal held that allowing Mr. Nwokeiwu to continue practising, even for a limited time, would damage public trust and confidence in tax agents, which is a core objective of the relevant legislation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The matters relevant to the granting of stay is well established. In Scott v Australian Securities and Investment Commission [2009] AATA 798 Downes J, President, considered the matters that were relevant to the grant of a stay. They included: the prospects of success, the consequences of the refusal of a stay for the applicant and for others, the consequences of granting a stay for the respondent, the public interest, whether the refusal of a stay would render the final relief nugatory, the time between the granting or refusal of the stay and the final hearing and decision and any other matters that might be relevant. This approach has consistently been applied by the Tribunal and I will apply it here. I will return to consider these matters after referring to a little of the background.BACKGROUND The background for present purposes can briefly be summarised by recording something about the chronology of events. I should make clear that I am by no means intending by this review of the background to be comprehensive as that is not necessary at this stage. Nor should I be thought to be expressing a final view on the background or the facts that give rise to the matter, as that will be considered fully upon a final hearing. The matters that gave rise to the present application have their origins in the review that was commenced on 2 February 2021 by the Australian Taxation Office (ATO). That review concerned Mr Nwokeiwu’s income tax return as the trustee for the Krumn Trust (Trust) for the tax year ending 30 June 2019. On 19 May 2021, the matter was escalated by the ATO to an ‘audit of [Mr Nwokeiwu’s] income tax return from 1 July 2018 to 30 June 2020’. On 23 February 2022, the ATO wrote to Mr Nwokeiwu advising him of the results of the audit, providing summaries of changes and reasons for its decisions. The letter attached an audit report that ran for some 39 pages which, identified that the 2019 tax return that had been lodged by Mr Nwokeiwu for the Trust, did not, amongst other things, correctly report net income and that GST on purchases and sales had not been correctly reported either. The letter contained a significant amount of detail about the conclusions that it arrived at. The discrepancies were substantial. The audit concluded that the ‘net income of the trust will be increased from $14,434 to $637,199’. The amount of $14,434 was the amount that appeared on the 2019 tax return that was lodged by Mr Nwokeiwu in respect of the Trust. The audit also concluded that there was a GST shortfall of about $74,000. On 19 July 2022, the Board wrote to Mr Nwokeiwu to tell him it was conducting preliminary enquiry in relation to his, Mun Accountants and Aussie Tax’s conduct. The letter set out, at some considerable length, various matters to which it sought a response. These things included; a consistent pattern of late lodgements of income tax returns and BAS statements for various entities associated with Mr Nwokeiwu with particular dates due and how late the lodgements were; false declarations about tax debts and lodgements, with particular reference to when the declarations were made and, what was false about them by reference to what was not done and what should have been done; matters concerning the failure to declare income for the 2019 tax year and, the incorrect supply of information concerning GST on sales and purchases again with particular reference to particular transactions which was the subject of the ATO audit; particular discrepancies in two particular clients of Mr Nwokeiwu’s tax returns for the 2019 and 2020 years; matters connected with claims for Jobkeeper and the cash flow boost; and matters connected with continuing education and indemnity insurance. The letter sought answers to 22 questions that, within many of them, had sub-questions most of which sought explanations or reasons for various things. The letter was clear about what was required to be addressed.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The position taken with the Board was much the same as that taken in the stay application. Although some additional matters were put forward they did not, in any real sense, engage with most of the particular allegations, especially so far as underreported income, GST, and FBT are concerned and so far as a failure to conform to tax obligations was concerned. There was some attempt to explain some of the late lodgements although the explanation was not particularly clear. SHOULD THE DECISION BE STAYED? Mr Nwokeiwu’s case, as things presently stand and without dealing with the actual evidence and full argument, does not appear to be a strong one. The evidence appears to be straightforward, supports the allegations and points only in one direction. The evidence about late lodgements, for example, is contained in documents which record many late lodgements that were contrary to written declarations that Mr Nwokeiwu had made to the Board. It is difficult to conceive that all this objective evidence will be shown to be wrong at a final hearing, especially given that Mr Nwokeiwu has produced little to suggest so much to date. Likewise, the evidence of the ATO’s tax audit findings concerning unreported income, GST and FBT, appears relatively straightforward. It is not necessary or useful to say much more about the strength of the case and its prospects of success especially given that there may be more, or different evidence at the final hearing and given that I have not heard full argument about the case. It is sufficient to note so far as what seem to be two of the most serious allegations Mr Nwokeiwu’s does not appear to be on strong ground. I should add that in some of Mr Nwokeiwu’s submissions there is something of a concession that he may be ultimately unsuccessful because he suggests he is, ‘[s]eeking for (sic) reduced period of my tax agent registration cancellation, a suspension and/or for a shorter period than cancellation’ or, that a final warning might be appropriate. His written submissions open with the words: ‘[s]ome decisions made by both ATO and TPB and factors relied upon in making those decisions were wrong’ or, ‘I take responsibility for lodging some related entities late, but this was an oversight…’. Those kinds of statements and references to some sanction as being appropriate tend to acknowledge that Mr Nwokeiwu’s case is not a strong one, at least so far as findings concerning the allegations are concerned. I consider that Mr Nwokeiwu’s prospects of success are not good based on the evidence and submissions made on the application for stay. Next, it is significant that the Board, that is the regulator, has made an adverse finding against Mr Nwokeiwu which has led it to the conclusion that the public should be protected by terminating Mr Nwokeiwu’s registration. That is consistent with its role and, more importantly, the object of the TAS Act. As things presently stand, in the view I take, the public interest is likely to be adversely affected by Mr Nwokeiwu continuing to act as a tax agent, even if for a limited time. Sight should not be lost of the fact that the whole of the scheme of the TAS Act is directed to the public interest in supporting trust and confidence in tax agents. That interest is damaged in circumstances where the Board, as regulator, has determined that Mr Nwokeiwu has involved himself in what are serious acts of misconduct in contravention of the Code, and which are not consistent with the registration requirements for tax agents. Even should he be permitted to practice for a short time until the hearing, the public interest will be damaged.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established