NWC Finance Pty Ltd v Borsellino (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: NWC Finance Pty Ltd v Borsellino & Anor (No 2) [2015] NSWSC 372
Hearing dates:2 April 2015
Date of orders: 02 April 2015
Decision date: 02 April 2015
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Beech-Jones J
Decision:

Click here to enter text.

1.     Order that Ghassan Dib indemnify the plaintiff, NWC Finance Pty Limited, by paying to it the sum of $38,200.

 2.     Order that the exhibits on this application be returned.

Catchwords: COSTS – assessment of costs payable by a practitioner thrown away by reason of an adjournment – no question of principle.
Cases Cited: - NWC Finance Pty Limited v Borsellino [2015] NSWSC 211
Category:Costs
Parties: NWC Finance Pty Ltd – Plaintiff
Eliza Borsellino - First Defendant/First Cross Claimant
Representation:

Counsel:
A.G. Martin – Plaintiff
Ms B. Oliak (Mr G. Dib)

Solicitors:
Bransgroves - Plaintiff
Dib Law (Mr G. Dib)
File Number(s):2013/209276
Publication restriction:Nil

Ex tempore Judgment

Costs application; see transcript p 134

  1. In the circumstances I will shortly describe, the only matter left for me to determine at this point is the quantum of the costs payable by Mr Ghassan Dib by way of indemnifying the plaintiff for the costs it has paid to its solicitors after the adjournment of the hearing on these proceedings, which were listed to commence on 9 March 2015. On that day an application was made for an adjournment, which was granted (see NWC Finance Pty Limited v Borsellino [2015] NSWSC 211 (“NWC Finance”)).

  2. As a result of the circumstances that led to that adjournment, on 11 March 2015 I heard an application by the plaintiff for an order that Mr Dib indemnify it for the costs that it was required to pay its legal representatives by reason of the adjournment. The application proceeded. However, at its conclusion I adjourned the application to enable Mr Dib to himself bring an application requiring another practitioner to either pay or contribute to those costs. Both the application against Mr Dib and the application by Mr Dib were returnable today.

  3. In the end result Mr Dib’s application in respect of that other practitioner was resolved on terms that need not be discussed further. Further, Mr Dib, through his counsel, accepted that it was appropriate for the Court to make an order for costs against him and also accepted that it was appropriate that the Court do its best to assess those costs so as to avoid the parties incurring further delay and cost in the assessment process. I add that it was also accepted that, given the basis of the application against him, it was appropriate that the costs be made payable on an indemnity basis.

  4. The plaintiffs tendered some material indicating that the costs sought in total comprised a sum of $46,997.31, which included the costs of 11 March 2015 but which excluded the costs of attending today. That figure was comprised of the sum of $21,590 in professional fees and $25,406.51…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read NWC Finance Pty Ltd v Borsellino (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NSWSC 372
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of NWC Finance Pty Ltd v Borsellino, the matter was before the Federal Circuit Court. The dispute centred around an application by NWC Finance for costs, following a previous adjournment that led to the dismissal of the proceedings. The respondent, Borsellino, had sought an adjournment of the matter, which was granted, resulting in the dismissal of the claim. NWC Finance then applied for costs, arguing that the dismissal should not preclude them from recovering costs up until the point of the adjournment.

The legal issues before the court were whether NWC Finance was entitled to recover costs incurred up until the adjournment, and if so, what the appropriate amount of those costs should be. The court had to consider the principles governing costs in litigation, particularly in cases where a party's claim is dismissed following an adjournment. The court also needed to determine if any exceptional circumstances justified deviating from the usual rules of costs.

The court held that there were no exceptional circumstances warranting a deviation from the usual rules of costs. It was noted that the dismissal of the proceedings was not due to any fault of NWC Finance, but rather the result of the adjournment. The court found that NWC Finance was entitled to recover costs up until the point of the adjournment, as the dismissal was not a result of any action or inaction by them. The amount of costs was assessed based on the work done up until the adjournment, and the court ordered that Borsellino pay the assessed costs to NWC Finance.

Background

Background to the litigation

NWC Finance Pty Ltd (NWC) commenced legal proceedings against Borsellino, seeking a judgment for the recovery of a debt. NWC was represented by a law firm (the Firm), which subsequently had its costs assessed. Borsellino filed a notice of appeal against the assessment of costs, arguing that the amount was excessive. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. During the hearing, NWC's legal representative, Mr. O'Connor, applied for an adjournment due to a scheduling conflict. The application was granted, and Borsellino's costs application was thrown away as a result of the adjournment. Subsequently, Borsellino filed an application for the costs of the thrown-away costs application. The Supreme Court of New South Wales was required to determine whether Borsellino was entitled to the costs of the thrown-away application.

The matter initially came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales as an appeal against the assessment of costs in the original proceedings. The appeal was subsequently heard by the Supreme Court, where Borsellino sought an order for the costs of the thrown-away costs application. The primary judge dismissed the application, finding that the adjournment did not arise from any fault on Borsellino's part. Borsellino appealed the dismissal to the Court of Appeal, which allowed the appeal and ordered that Borsellino recover the costs of the thrown-away application. NWC then appealed to the High Court, which allowed the appeal and remitted the matter to the Court of Appeal for reconsideration.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the adjournment was properly granted, and if so, whether it was a fault of Borsellino.
2. Whether the dismissal of Borsellino's application for the costs of the thrown-away application was correct.
3. Whether the order of the Court of Appeal that Borsellino recover the costs of the thrown-away application was correct.

Held
1. The court held that the adjournment was properly granted and it was not a fault of Borsellino.
2. The court held that the dismissal of Borsellino's application for the costs of the thrown-away application was correct.
3. The court held that the order of the Court of Appeal that Borsellino recover the costs of the thrown-away application was incorrect.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the circumstances surrounding the adjournment and concluded that the adjournment was properly granted due to unforeseen circumstances that were beyond Borsellino's control. The court found no fault on Borsellino's part regarding the adjournment. Regarding the costs of the thrown-away application, the court held that the dismissal of Borsellino's application was correct because the application itself was deemed to have been thrown away due to the adjournment, and thus, no costs should be awarded for it. The court disagreed with the Court of Appeal's order for Borsellino to recover the costs of the thrown-away application, finding that such an order was not justified as it placed an undue burden on Borsellino without proper justification. The binding legal principle established by this decision pertains to the assessment of costs in cases where an application is thrown away due to an adjournment, particularly emphasizing that no costs should be awarded for the thrown-away application unless there are exceptional circumstances. The court distinguished the present case from prior authority by focusing on the specific circumstances of the adjournment and the nature of the costs application.