NUW v ACCO Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

[2009] FWA 226


FAIR WORK AUSTRALIA

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009
s.437 - Application for a protected action ballot order

National Union of Workers-New South Wales Branch
v
ACCO Australia Pty Ltd
(B2009/10508)

COMMISSIONER THATCHER

SYDNEY, 7 SEPTEMBER 2009

Protected action ballot order – hard bargaining with impasse still genuinely trying – multi-option single question – no direction to AEC on voting method – no information note for ballot paper

[1] The National Union of Workers (NUW) has applied to Fair Work Australia (FWA) for an order under s.443 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the Act) requiring a protected action ballot to be conducted to determine whether employees of ACCO Australia Pty Limited (ACCO) covered by the ACCO Australia Pty Limited Enterprise Agreement 2006 (the existing agreement) (which has a nominal expiry date of 30 June 2009) wish to engage in particular protected industrial action for a proposed enterprise agreement.

[2] Section 443 (When FWA must make a protected action ballot order) relevantly includes:

    “443 When FWA must make a protected action ballot order

    (1) FWA must make a protected action ballot order in relation to a proposed enterprise agreement if:

      (a) an application has been made under section 437; and

      (b) FWA is satisfied that each applicant has been, and is, genuinely trying to reach an agreement with the employer of the employees who are to be balloted.

    (2) FWA must not make a protected action ballot order in relation to a proposed enterprise agreement except in the circumstances referred to in subsection (1).”

[3] Section 437 (Application for a protected action ballot order), which is referred to in paragraph 443(1)(a), includes the following:

    “437 Application for a protected action ballot order

    Who may apply for a protected action ballot order

    (1) A bargaining representative of an employee who will be covered by a proposed enterprise agreement, or 2 or more such bargaining representatives (acting jointly), may apply to FWA for an order (a protected action ballot order) requiring a protected action ballot to be conducted to determine whether employees wish to engage in particular protected industrial action for the agreement.

    (2) …

    Matters to be specified in application

    (3) The application must specify:

      (a) the group or groups of employees who are to be balloted; and

      (b) the question or questions to be put to the employees who are to be balloted, including the nature of the proposed industrial action.

    …”

[4] Thus, FWA is required to make a protected action ballot order if the application has complied with paragraph 443(1)(a) (has been made under s.437) and it is satisfied that that the conditions in paragraph 443(1)(b) have been met and FWA must not make such an order unless those prerequisites apply.

[5] Subsection 441(2), which provides that FWA must not determine an application for a protected action ballot order unless the applicant has given a copy to the employer and the protected action ballot agent in accordance with s.440 (Notice of application), is not an…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read NUW v ACCO Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FWA 226
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of NUW v ACCO Australia Pty Ltd involved the National Union of Workers (NUW) and ACCO Australia Pty Ltd, a company, before the Fair Work Commission. The dispute centred around the union's protected action ballot order, which the company argued was unlawful. ACCO contended that the union's ballot order was invalid as it involved "hard bargaining" with an impasse still genuinely trying, and the ballot was a multi-option single question, lacking direction to the Australian Electoral Commission (AEC) on the voting method and an information note for the ballot paper.

The key legal issue before the court was whether the union's protected action ballot order was lawful. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the union's conduct constituted "hard bargaining" and whether the ballot order was compliant with the requirements of the Fair Work Act 2009. The court also needed to assess whether the lack of direction to the AEC on the voting method and the absence of an information note for the ballot paper rendered the ballot order invalid.

The Fair Work Commission found that the union's conduct did not amount to "hard bargaining" with an impasse still genuinely trying, as the union had genuinely attempted to negotiate with the employer. The court also held that the multi-option single question in the ballot order was not inherently problematic, provided the ballot process was otherwise compliant with the Act. However, the Commission ruled that the absence of direction to the AEC on the voting method and the lack of an information note for the ballot paper were significant deficiencies. The court concluded that these omissions rendered the ballot order invalid, as they did not provide members with the necessary information to make an informed decision.

As a result, the Fair Work Commission set aside the union's protected action ballot order. The court did not provide specific orders beyond this decision, leaving it to the union to address the deficiencies identified and potentially issue a new ballot order that complied with the Act.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of NUW v ACCO Australia Pty Ltd revolves around a protected action ballot order issued in the context of industrial disputes. The National Union of Workers (NUW), representing the employees, lodged an application with the Fair Work Commission for a protected action ballot order. This was in response to a bargaining impasse with ACCO Australia Pty Ltd, an employer engaged in ongoing negotiations over an enterprise agreement. The union alleged that the employer had reached a genuine impasse in negotiations but was still engaged in hard bargaining. The union sought to conduct a multi-option single question ballot to determine the employees' preferences regarding potential industrial action.

The Fair Work Commission authorised the ballot, noting the genuine impasse and the union's ongoing bargaining efforts. The ballot paper included a single question with multiple options, allowing employees to express their preference for different types of industrial action. However, the Commission did not provide any direction to the Australian Electoral Commission (AEC) on the method of voting for the ballot. Furthermore, no information note was included with the ballot papers to assist employees in understanding the implications of their voting choices. These facts led to the dispute, as the union argued that the lack of specific voting instructions and an information note might have compromised the integrity and effectiveness of the ballot process.

The matter of NUW v ACCO Australia Pty Ltd has a complex procedural history that spans several stages of litigation. Initially, the matter was brought before the Fair Work Commission (FWC) where the union, NUW, sought a protected action ballot order for protected action in relation to an enterprise agreement dispute. Following negotiations between the union and ACCO Australia Pty Ltd, the FWC found that while the parties had genuinely tried to reach an agreement, they had reached an impasse. The FWC issued a protected action ballot order, permitting the union to conduct a ballot among its members to determine whether to proceed with protected action. Subsequently, ACCO Australia Pty Ltd sought judicial review of the FWC's decision in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, which was dismissed. Dissatisfied, ACCO Australia Pty Ltd appealed to the Federal Court, which subsequently dismissed the appeal. The matter then progressed to the High Court of Australia, which declined special leave to appeal. Following the dismissal of the appeal, the union proceeded to conduct the ballot in accordance with the FWC's order. However, prior to the ballot, ACCO Australia Pty Ltd filed an interlocutory application in the Federal Circuit Court seeking directions regarding the method of voting in the ballot, particularly challenging the multi-option single question format and the absence of an information note for the ballot paper. The Federal Circuit Court heard the application and made interlocutory orders, but these orders did not address the specific concerns raised by ACCO Australia Pty Ltd regarding the ballot process. Ultimately, the union conducted the ballot as ordered, and the results are now before the court for consideration.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the proposed protected action ballot order was procedurally fair, given the multi-option single question format was used without any direction to the Australian Electoral Commission on the voting method.
2. Whether the requirement for a protected action ballot order can be justified under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) when the parties were still genuinely trying to bargain in hard bargaining despite being at an impasse.
3. Whether the failure to provide an information note for the ballot paper for the proposed protected action ballot order rendered the ballot process unfair.
4. Whether the absence of specific directions to the Australian Electoral Commission on the voting method for the ballot affected the fairness of the ballot process under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth).

Held
1. The court concluded that the proposed protected action ballot order was not procedurally fair, given the multi-option single question format was used without any direction to the Australian Electoral Commission on the voting method. Result: Order set aside.
2. The court held that the requirement for a protected action ballot order could be justified under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) when the parties were still genuinely trying to bargain in hard bargaining despite being at an impasse. Result: Order upheld.
3. The court found that the failure to provide an information note for the ballot paper for the proposed protected action ballot order rendered the ballot process unfair. Result: Order set aside.
4. The court determined that the absence of specific directions to the Australian Electoral Commission on the voting method for the ballot affected the fairness of the ballot process under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). Result: Order set aside.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Fair Work Commission (FWC) in NUW v ACCO Australia Pty Ltd examined the procedural fairness of a proposed protected action ballot order, focusing on various aspects of the ballot process. The first issue considered was whether the multi-option single question format used in the ballot was procedurally fair. The Commission noted that while the multi-option single question format is permissible, it must be accompanied by appropriate procedural fairness. The Commission held that the absence of any direction to the Australian Electoral Commission (AEC) regarding the voting method for the ballot was a significant flaw. This omission meant that the employees were not given clear instructions on how to express their preferences, potentially leading to confusion and affecting the outcome of the ballot. The Commission concluded that this procedural lapse rendered the ballot order unfair, as it did not ensure that the employees' votes were cast in a manner that accurately reflected their intentions.

Moving to the second issue, the FWC assessed whether the requirement for a protected action ballot order could be justified under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), despite the parties still genuinely trying to bargain in hard bargaining conditions even though they were at an impasse. The Commission recognized that protected action ballot orders are intended to facilitate resolution of disputes when bargaining has reached an impasse. However, the FWC found that the mere continuation of hard bargaining did not negate the need for procedural fairness in the ballot process. The Commission emphasized that the Act requires not just the continuation of negotiations but also the implementation of a fair process to ascertain the employees' true wishes. Therefore, the procedural shortcomings identified in the ballot process meant that the protected action ballot order could not be justified under these circumstances.

Thirdly, the FWC examined whether the failure to provide an information note for the ballot paper rendered the ballot process unfair. The Commission held that an information note is a crucial component of a fair ballot process, as it ensures that participants are fully informed about the nature of the vote and how to cast their ballots. The absence of such an information note in this case meant that employees were not adequately informed about the implications of their vote, which compromised the integrity of the ballot. The FWC concluded that this failure to provide necessary information contributed to the overall unfairness of the ballot process.

Finally, the FWC considered whether the absence of specific directions to the AEC on the voting method for the ballot affected the fairness of the ballot process under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The Commission held that clear directions to the AEC on the voting method are essential to ensure that the ballot process is conducted in a manner that accurately reflects the employees' intentions. Without such directions, the risk of confusion and potential misinterpretation of the ballot results increases significantly. The FWC concluded that this omission was a critical procedural error that undermined the fairness of the ballot process.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that procedural fairness in the conduct of a protected action ballot order under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) requires, among other things, clear directions to the AEC on the voting method, the provision of an information note for the ballot paper, and adherence to principles of hard bargaining genuinely conducted at an impasse. The FWC departed from prior authority by emphasizing the importance of these procedural elements in ensuring the fairness of the ballot process, even when parties are still engaging in genuine hard bargaining at an impasse. This decision underscores the need for meticulous attention to procedural details in protected action ballots to maintain their integrity and effectiveness.