Nutrifield Pty Ltd v Smart Garden Products Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Nutrifield Pty Ltd to application under section 92 of the Act by Smart Garden Products Limited for removal of trade mark number 1165046 (1, 5, 7, 11, 16, 31, 44) – SMART GARDEN and Device- in the name of Nutrifield Pty Ltd

Delegate: Nicholas Smith
Representation: Opponent: Self-Represented
Applicant: Adrian M Trioli, Registered Patent and Trade Mark Attorney
Decision: 2018 ATMO 178
Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) - section 96 opposition to s 92(4)(b) application for removal - Removal Opponent’s evidence does not show use of the Trade Mark during the relevant period or obstacle to use – exercise of Registrar’s discretion not appropriate – Trade Mark to be removed from the Register

Background

  1. This decision is pursuant to an application made on 31 August 2016 under s 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘Act’) by Smart Garden Products Limited (‘Applicant’) for removal of the trade mark detailed below from the Register of Trade Marks.  The application is made in respect of all of the good and services for which the trade mark is registered, that is, the application is for complete removal of the trade mark.

Registration No. 1165046
Lodgement date 8 March 2007
Goods and Services Class 1: Chemicals used in industry agriculture, horticulture and forestry to aid plant growth
Class 5: Preparations for destroying vermin, fungicides
Class 7: Machines and machine tools; motors and engines (except for land vehicles); machine coupling and transmission component (except for land vehicles); agricultural implements other than hand operated; incubators for eggs
Class 11: Apparatus for lighting, heating, steam generating, cooking, refrigerating, drying, ventilating, water supply and sanitary purposes
Class 16: Paper cardboard and goods made from these materials, not included in other classes; printed matter; book binding material; photographs; stationery; adhesives for stationery or house hold purposes; artist materials; paint brushes; typewriters and office requisites (except furniture); instructional and teaching material (except apparatus); plastic material for packaging (not included in other classes); printers' type; printing blocks
Class 31 Agricultural, horticultural and forestry products and grains not included in other classes; live animals; fresh fruit and vegetables; seeds, natural plants and flowers; food stuffs for animals, malt
Class 44: Agriculture, horticulture and forestry services
(‘Registered Goods and Services)
Owner Nutrifield Pty Ltd
Trade Mark  
(‘Trade Mark’)
  1. Nutrifield Pty Ltd (‘Opponent’) has opposed the application to remove the Trade Mark, filing a Notice of Intention to Oppose removal on 13 September 2016 and a Statement of Grounds and Particulars (‘SGP’) on 23 September 2016.  The Applicant filed a Notice of Intention to Defend on 24 November 2016.

  2. The Opponent subsequently filed evidence in support of its opposition to removal (‘EIS’).  The Applicant filed evidence in answer (‘EIA’) and the Opponent chose not to file any evidence in reply.  The parties’ evidence…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nutrifield Pty Ltd v Smart Garden Products Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] ATMO 178
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an opposition to the removal of a trade mark from the Register, brought by Nutrifield Pty Ltd (the Applicant) against Smart Garden Products Limited (the Opponent). The dispute arose from an application to remove the Opponent's trade mark, "Smart Garden," from the Register due to non-use. The decision was made by Hearing Officer Nicholas Smith.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Opponent had established use of the trade mark in Australia during the relevant period, or if there were circumstances that constituted an obstacle to use, to prevent the removal of the trade mark from the Register. Alternatively, the court had to consider whether it was reasonable to exercise discretion under s 101(3) of the Act to retain the registration despite a lack of use.

The Hearing Officer found that the Opponent's evidence of use was insufficient. While a 2014 catalogue from Dome Garden Supplies was presented as evidence of use, there was no proof that this catalogue was ever printed or displayed in Australia, nor was its timing or target audience established. The burden of proof rested on the Opponent, who was best placed to provide evidence of use. The lack of invoices, receipts, or product guides showing use during the relevant period, especially when such evidence was available for an earlier period, weighed against the Opponent. The Hearing Officer concluded that the Opponent's limited commercial interest in maintaining the registration did not outweigh the Applicant's commercial interest and the public interest in the integrity of the Register.

Consequently, the Hearing Officer decided that the Opponent had not established its opposition to the removal. The trade mark was directed to be removed from the Register in respect of all goods and services for which it was registered, one month from the date of the decision, subject to any appeal. The Opponent was also ordered to pay the Applicant's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Abdelmalek Declaration does not provide any context surrounding either the 2013 or 2014 Dome Garden Supplies catalogues including when they were produced or if and how they were used. Equally the Opponent does not identify whether any of the products listed on the 11 November 2014 invoice featured the Trade Mark. I note that none of the products containing the acronym ‘SG’ in their description are products featured in the Dome Garden Supplies catalogue. Equally it is unclear why they are referred to as ‘labels’ if the invoice is for ‘cash sales’.Applicant’s Evidence17. The Applicant’s evidence in answer consists of a declaration made on 24 July 2017 by Jonathan Stobart, Managing Director of the Applicant with Exhibit JS-1 (‘Stobart Declaration’). 18. The Stobart Declaration indicates that the Applicant has applied to register a trade mark containing the words ‘Smart Garden’ surrounded by two curved stripes in an ellipse in respect of goods in classes 6, 9, 11, 14, 19, 20, 21, 22, 26, 27 and 31 (application number 1737964). The Applicant holds applications for, or registrations of, similar marks in the United States, United Kingdom, China and in the European Union. Discussion To successfully oppose the removal application the Opponent must establish that it has used the Trade Mark (or a substantially identical mark) for the Registered Goods and Services during the relevant period (or per s100 of the Act that there were relevant circumstances that were an obstacle to use), failing which the Opponent would need to satisfy the Registrar that it was nevertheless ‘reasonable’ to exercise her discretion under s 101(3) to decide that the Trade Mark should not be removed from the Register.Use of the Trade Mark in the relevant period Having reviewed the EIS, the only dated material that could amount to use of the Trade Mark in the relevant period is the 2014 catalogue from Dome Garden Supplies that, at page 57 and 60 (or page 490 and 493 of the Abdelmalek Declaration) shows products bearing the Trade Mark. However there is no evidence that this catalogue was ever actually printed or displayed. Nor is there any evidence of whether this catalogue was targeted in Australia or elsewhere. In essence, the Opponent relies on a single use of the Trade Mark in the Relevant Period (the catalogue), but the evidence supplied does not satisfy the requirement of ‘if not conclusive proof, overwhelmingly convincing proof’[5] of use since there is no evidence that the catalogue was ever printed or displayed in Australia and when. [5] Nodoz Trade Mark (1962) RPC 1, 7. I note that the burden of proof is placed on the Opponent pursuant to s100(3)(a) for the simple reason that if the Trade Mark was used in the relevant period, the Opponent would be in the best position to provide evidence to substantiate such use. The fact that the Opponent has not been able to put on any evidence of invoices, receipts or product guides showing use of the Trade Mark in the relevant period (when it was able to do so in respect of the period between 2007 and 2010), is a factor that tells against the Opponent in this case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

While the Opponent may have a limited private commercial interest in maintaining the registration of the Trade Mark as it stands, given the very limited to negligible reputation of the Trade Mark in Australia apparent from its evidence, the Opponent’s private commercial interest is insufficient to outweigh the private commercial interest of the Applicant and the public interest in the integrity of the Register. In those circumstances I do not consider it reasonable to exercise the Registrar’s discretion in the Opponent’s favour.Decision29. I decide that the Opponent has not established its opposition to removal and the Trade Mark should be removed from the Register in respect of all of the goods and services for which it is registered. Accordingly, I direct that registration 1165046 be removed from the Register one month from the date of this decision. If the Registrar is served with a notice of appeal before then I direct that removal shall not occur until the appeal has either been discontinued or, in the event of a decision from the Court, that the registration be dealt with as the Court sees fit.Costs31. The Applicant has been successful in relation to the application for removal of the Trade Mark and has requested its costs. I direct that costs in relation to trade mark registration no. 1165046 be awarded against the Opponent in accordance with Schedule 8 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995.Nicholas SmithHearing OfficerHearings and Oppositions 1 November 2018

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Opponent’s evidence in this matter consists of a declaration made on 27 February 2018 by Mina Abdelmalek, Operations Manager of the Opponent. This declaration annexes approximately 550 pages of material that is described generally in the declaration as evidence but is not marked, paginated or identified in any way (‘Abdelmalek Declaration’). The Abdelmalek Declaration is difficult to follow given that it contains much material that is undated, is dated outside the relevant date or is irrelevant, including tax returns of various corporate entities. Much of the marketing material displaying the Trade Mark included in the Abdelmalek Declaration is either undated or in draft form and no context is provided about when or whether such material was used. I limit my summary of the Opponent’s evidence below to material that could be relevant to this decision. The Abdelmalek Declaration contains the following information:·The Opponent was founded in 2002. In 2007 the Opponent developed the Smart Garden range of organically certified products. In 2009 this range was promoted to the Big W, Bunnings and Dahlsens retail chains. The Opponent produced product guides in 2009 and 2011 that feature the Smart Garden range. ·An entity known as Dome Garden Supplies produced a 2013 catalogue that refers to the Smart Garden range. ·At page 486 of the Abdelmalek Declaration there is a catalogue, again from Dome Garden Supplies, that although undated, refers to itself as the 2014 catalogue in which the Trade Mark appears in respect of certain gardening materials such as compost tea and plant starter, as well as a product described as water cleaner. ·At page 521 of the Abdelmalek Declaration there is an invoice dated 11 November 2014 to Cash Sales. These sales include a lengthy list of products including certain products that contain the acronym ‘SG’ in their description, i.e. ‘SG Alaska Pure Label’, ‘SG Cargo Boost Label’. There are other invoices dated before the relevant period to Dome Garden Supplies. The Abdelmalek Declaration does not provide any context surrounding either the 2013 or 2014 Dome Garden Supplies catalogues including when they were produced or if and how they were used. Equally the Opponent does not identify whether any of the products listed on the 11 November 2014 invoice featured the Trade Mark. I note that none of the products containing the acronym ‘SG’ in their description are products featured in the Dome Garden Supplies catalogue. Equally it is unclear why they are referred to as ‘labels’ if the invoice is for ‘cash sales’.Applicant’s Evidence17. The Applicant’s evidence in answer consists of a declaration made on 24 July 2017 by Jonathan Stobart, Managing Director of the Applicant with Exhibit JS-1 (‘Stobart Declaration’). 18. The Stobart Declaration indicates that the Applicant has applied to register a trade mark containing the words ‘Smart Garden’ surrounded by two curved stripes in an ellipse in respect of goods in classes 6, 9, 11, 14, 19, 20, 21, 22, 26, 27 and 31 (application number 1737964). The Applicant holds applications for, or registrations of, similar marks in the United States, United Kingdom, China and in the European Union. Discussion