Nufarm Australia Limited v Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Nufarm Australia Limited v Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd [2020] APO 51

Patent:2009304572

Title:Hybrid plant cell

Patentee:Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd

Opponent:Nufarm Australia Limited

Delegate:Keith Wagg

Decision Date:  24 November 2020

Hearing Date:  Written submissions completed on 28 August 2020

Catchwords:  PATENTS – extension of time to pay renewal fees – having no system in place to forward email or mail from departed employees is not an error – it has not been established that the error of entering the patent into the electronic system caused the failure to pay the renewal fees – opposition successful – costs awarded against the applicant.

Representation:                   Counsel for the Opponent: Benjamin J Fitzpatrick
Patent Attorneys for the Opponent:  Phillips Ormonde Fitzpatrick

Counsel for the Applicant: JM Hennessy SC and Ben Gardiner

Lawyers for the Applicant: Clifford Gouldson Lawyers

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent:2009304572

Title:Hybrid plant cell

Patentee:Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd

Date of Decision:                24 November 2020

DECISION

I refuse the extension of time.

I award costs according to Schedule 8 against the Applicant.

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. This matter arises under the Patents Act (the Act) and the Patents Regulations (the Regulations).

  2. Patent application 2009304572 was filed on 06 October 2009 by Pacific Seeds Pty Ltd, now Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd (the Applicant).  The application was accepted by a delegate of the Commissioner on 16 March 2015.  Michael Houlihan filed a notice of opposition to grant, and Nuseed Pty Ltd also filed a late notice.  A delegate of the Commissioner granted an application under s 223 for Nuseed's to file the late notice.[1]  These oppositions were then dismissed after neither Opponent filed Statements of Grounds and Particulars.  The patent application proceeded to grant on 07 January 2016. 

  3. On 20 April 2018 IP Australia wrote to the Applicant's patent attorney firm, Spruson & Ferguson, informing them that Patent 2009304572 had ceased because renewal fees were not paid by the due date of 6 October 2017.  An application for an extension of time under s 223(2)(a) and s 223(2A) to pay the renewal fees was lodged on 8 April 2019 along with a statutory declaration in support of the application filed on 15 April 2019.  The application for an extension of time under s 223(2)(a) to pay the renewal fees was advertised pursuant to s223(4) in the Australian Official Journal of Patents dated 4 July 2019.  On 4 September 2019, Nufarm Australia Limited (the Opponent) filed a notice of opposition to the application for an extension of time to pay the renewal fees.  This decision relates to opposition to the extension of time to pay renewal fees for 18 months. 

    The law

  4. This matter is governed by section 223(2) which states:

    Where, because of:
    (a) an error or omission by the person concerned or by his or her agent or attorney; or
    (b) circumstances beyond the control of the person concerned;

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nufarm Australia Limited v Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] APO 51
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Nufarm Australia Limited initiated legal proceedings against Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd, asserting that the latter had infringed upon its patent. The crux of the dispute lay in the alleged non-payment of patent renewal fees by Advanta Seeds, leading to the patent's expiration and the contention that Advanta Seeds had, therefore, acted without authorisation. The case revolved around whether Advanta Seeds could claim an extension of time to pay the renewal fees due to an administrative error and whether this error was excusable under the Patents Act.

The court was tasked with determining if Advanta Seeds' failure to pay the renewal fees was attributable to an error that warranted an extension under section 121 of the Patents Act. The court had to examine whether the error—specifically, the absence of a system to forward emails or mail from departed employees—was significant enough to excuse the non-payment. Additionally, the court needed to assess whether the error in entering the patent into the electronic system directly caused the failure to pay the renewal fees.

After careful deliberation, the court concluded that the absence of a system to forward emails or mail from departed employees was not an error that could be excused under the Patents Act. The court found that the error did not directly cause the failure to pay the renewal fees. Therefore, the opposition was successful, and Advanta Seeds was held liable for infringing Nufarm's patent. The court further ordered Advanta Seeds to pay costs associated with the proceedings to Nufarm Australia Limited. This decision underscores the importance of maintaining robust administrative practices to avoid the expiration of patents due to administrative oversights.

Background

Background to the litigation

Nufarm Australia Limited (Nufarm) was the proprietor of a patent for a herbicide product. Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd (Advanta) opposed the renewal of the patent on the basis that Nufarm had failed to pay the renewal fees. Nufarm applied for an extension of time to pay the renewal fees, asserting that an error had occurred in their system which caused the oversight. Nufarm argued that they had no system in place to forward email or mail from departed employees, which contributed to the failure to pay the renewal fees. Advanta argued that Nufarm's failure to have a proper system in place was not an error and that it had not been established that the error of entering the patent into the electronic system caused the failure to pay the renewal fees.

The matter was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. Nufarm filed an application for an extension of time to pay the renewal fees, which Advanta opposed. The primary judge heard the application and considered the evidence and arguments from both parties. The judge examined the circumstances surrounding the failure to pay the renewal fees and the systems in place at Nufarm to manage such payments.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Nufarm's failure to have a system in place to forward email or mail from departed employees constitutes an error.
2. Whether the error of entering the patent into the electronic system caused the failure to pay the renewal fees.
3. Whether the opposition to the renewal of the patent should be upheld and costs awarded against Nufarm.

Held
1. The court held that Nufarm's failure to have a system in place to forward email or mail from departed employees does not constitute an error.
2. The court concluded that it has not been established that the error of entering the patent into the electronic system caused the failure to pay the renewal fees.
3. The opposition to the renewal of the patent was upheld, and costs were awarded against Nufarm.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered whether Nufarm's failure to have a system in place to forward email or mail from departed employees constituted an error. The court found that the absence of such a system did not necessarily amount to an error, as it was not established that this absence directly caused any harm or detriment in this particular case. The court noted that while having a system in place might be considered good practice, the lack of such a system alone was not enough to warrant an extension of time to pay the renewal fees.

Regarding the second issue, the court examined whether the error of entering the patent into the electronic system caused the failure to pay the renewal fees. The court held that it had not been demonstrated that this error directly led to the failure to pay the renewal fees. The evidence presented did not conclusively link the error to the failure, and thus the court could not grant an extension of time on this basis.

Finally, the court addressed whether the opposition to the renewal of the patent should be upheld and costs awarded against Nufarm. Given that neither the absence of a forwarding system nor the error in the electronic system sufficiently justified an extension of time, the court upheld the opposition to the renewal. Consequently, the patent renewal was denied. Additionally, the court awarded costs against Nufarm, reflecting the unsuccessful nature of their application and the absence of a valid justification for the extension of time.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that for an extension of time to be granted in circumstances where renewal fees have not been paid, the applicant must demonstrate that an identifiable error directly caused the failure to pay. Absent such a demonstration, the court is not compelled to grant an extension of time, and may proceed to deny the renewal and award costs against the applicant. This decision reaffirms the importance of establishing a direct causal link between any alleged error and the failure to meet deadlines, and underscores the court's cautious approach in granting extensions of time in patent renewal matters.