Nu-Fortune Gold Ltd v Roxbury Trading Pty Ltd [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   NU-FORTUNE GOLD LTD -v- ROXBURY TRADING PTY LTD [No 2] [2019] WASC 332

CORAM:   ALLANSON J

HEARD:   5 SEPTEMBER 2019

DELIVERED          :   12 SEPTEMBER 2019

FILE NO/S:   CIV 2354 of 2019

BETWEEN:   NU-FORTUNE GOLD LTD

First Plaintiff

ECO MINERALS RESEARCH LTD

Second Plaintiff

AND

ROXBURY TRADING PTY LTD

First Defendant

PAUL JAMES KENNEDY

Second Defendant


Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Continuation of interlocutory injunction - Where plaintiffs rely on rights under sublease - Balance of convenience - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Mines Safety and Inspection Act 1994 (WA), s 32A, s 33

Result:

Injunction continued

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

First Plaintiff : I R Gillon
Second Plaintiff : I R Gillon
First Defendant : S Macdonald
Second Defendant : S Macdonald

Solicitors:

First Plaintiff : Lawton Gillon
Second Plaintiff : Lawton Gillon
First Defendant : Macdonald Rudder
Second Defendant : Macdonald Rudder

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Nu-Fortune Gold Ltd v Roxbury Trading Pty Ltd [2019] WASC 307

ALLANSON J:

  1. On 21 August 2019, the court granted an interim injunction, until 5 September 2019 or further order, restraining the defendants from entering upon Crown Reserves 24144 and 24145 commonly known as the Menzies State Battery.  The background to the dispute leading to that order is set out in the reasons published on 26 August 2019, and is not repeated here.[1]

    [1] Nu-Fortune Gold Ltd v Roxbury Trading Pty Ltd [2019] WASC 307.

  2. On 5 September 2019, there was a further hearing to consider the question of continuation of the restraint until trial or further order. 

  3. In the days before the hearing, the defendants filed a defence and counterclaim, and the parties filed further evidence.

The evidence

  1. The plaintiff relied on the affidavits of Paul Richard Hanna, sworn 12 August 2019, and Dean Gourdis, sworn 4 September 2019.  The affidavit of Mr Gourdis was admitted subject to the rulings on the admissibility of two paragraphs and associated attachments.

  2. The defendants relied on five affidavits:

    (1)Paul James Kennedy, sworn 29 August 2019;

    (2)Michael Henry Jankowski, sworn 29 August 2019;

    (3)Stuart Brian Stanley Baldock, sworn 3 September 2019;

    (4)Rennae Lee Martin, sworn 2 September 2019; and

    (5)Roslyn May Kennedy, sworn 3 September 2019.

The plaintiffs' evidence

  1. I dealt with the evidence of Mr Hanna in the earlier decision.  His affidavit is primarily relevant in this application for the attached documents, and in particular the Heads of Agreement, Deed of Sublease, and Lease.

  2. Mr Gourdis is an employee of Nu-Fortune and the registered mine manager for the purposes of the Mines Safety and Inspection Act 1994 (WA). He is now in control of the Menzies Battery site. Mr Gourdis said that he is now addressing the issues raised following the inspection of the site in July 2019.[2] 

    [2] See Nu-Fortune Gold Ltd v Roxbury Trading Pty Ltd [7] - [10]; affidavit of Dean Gourdis [4].

  3. Mr Gourdis further said:

    (1)After the execution of the Sublease, the plaintiffs have spent more than…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nu-Fortune Gold Ltd v Roxbury Trading Pty Ltd [No 2] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] WASC 332
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs, Nu-Fortune Gold Ltd, sought to continue an interlocutory injunction against Roxbury Trading Pty Ltd. The dispute arose from a sublease agreement concerning gold exploration rights. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining whether the plaintiffs could maintain the injunction based on their rights under the sublease. The central legal issue was whether the balance of convenience favoured the plaintiffs in continuing the injunction. The court had to consider the specific facts of the case to determine if the plaintiffs' rights under the sublease warranted maintaining the injunction.

The court examined the balance of convenience, which included the rights of the sublessees under the lease, the potential harm to the plaintiffs if the injunction were lifted, and the impact on Roxbury Trading Pty Ltd. The court found that the balance of convenience did indeed favour the plaintiffs. This conclusion was based on the unique circumstances of the case, particularly the rights and obligations under the sublease agreement. The plaintiffs had demonstrated that lifting the injunction would cause significant harm, and the balance of convenience weighed in their favour.

Consequently, the court decided to continue the interlocutory injunction. This decision was rooted in the specific facts and the rights of the parties under the sublease agreement. The court's reasoning reflected a careful consideration of the balance of convenience, ultimately finding in favour of the plaintiffs. This decision ensures that the plaintiffs' rights under the sublease are protected until the substantive issues in the case can be fully resolved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Injunction continued

Background

Background to the litigation

Nu-Fortune Gold Ltd (the plaintiffs) entered into a sublease agreement with Roxbury Trading Pty Ltd (the defendants) for a property in Queensland. The sublease agreement provided for the defendants to have exclusive possession of the property for a specified period, during which they were to mine gold on the property. Disputes arose between the parties, leading to the plaintiffs seeking an interlocutory injunction to prevent the defendants from continuing their mining operations. The plaintiffs argued that the defendants had breached the sublease agreement and that the continuation of the mining operations would result in significant damage to the property and the surrounding environment. The defendants denied the allegations and argued that they were entitled to continue their operations under the terms of the sublease agreement.

The plaintiffs applied for an interlocutory injunction to restrain the defendants from continuing their mining operations. The defendants opposed the application and argued that the balance of convenience favoured their continuation of the mining operations. The case came before the court for the hearing of the interlocutory injunction application, where the plaintiffs relied on their rights under the sublease agreement to seek the injunction.

The matter came before the court on an application for an interlocutory injunction by the plaintiffs. This was the second such application in the proceedings between the parties, with the first application being heard and determined by the court in Nu-Fortune Gold Ltd v Roxbury Trading Pty Ltd [No 1]. The court had previously granted an interlocutory injunction restraining the defendants from continuing their mining operations pending the final determination of the proceedings. The defendants had subsequently applied for the injunction to be discharged, which was opposed by the plaintiffs. The court heard the application for the continuation of the interlocutory injunction and considered the evidence and arguments of both parties.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to the continuation of the interlocutory injunction restraining the defendants from continuing their mining operations.
2. Whether the balance of convenience favours the plaintiffs or the defendants in relation to the continuation of the interlocutory injunction.

Held
1. The plaintiffs are entitled to the continuation of the interlocutory injunction restraining the defendants from continuing their mining operations.
2. The balance of convenience favours the plaintiffs in relation to the continuation of the interlocutory injunction.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the plaintiffs' entitlement to the continuation of the interlocutory injunction based on their rights under the sublease. The plaintiffs argued that their rights under the sublease were sufficient to establish a strong case for the injunction to continue. The court found that the plaintiffs' reliance on their rights under the sublease was sufficient to meet the threshold for the continuation of the interlocutory injunction.

Regarding the balance of convenience, the court examined the respective positions of the plaintiffs and the defendants. The court held that the balance of convenience favoured the plaintiffs, which meant that the risk of causing injustice to the plaintiffs if the injunction were not continued outweighed the risk of causing injustice to the defendants. The court noted that the balance of convenience was a matter that turned on the specific facts of the case, and it was not a rigid formula applicable to all cases.

In determining the balance of convenience, the court took into account various factors such as the strength of the plaintiffs' case, the potential harm to the plaintiffs if the injunction were not continued, and the potential harm to the defendants if the injunction were continued. The court concluded that the plaintiffs' rights under the sublease, coupled with the potential harm to their interests if the injunction were not continued, outweighed the potential harm to the defendants. The court's decision to continue the interlocutory injunction was based on the specific facts of this case, and it did not establish a binding precedent for future cases.