Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: NSW Mobile Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Max Mobile and Detailing Pty Ltd [2023] NSWSC 140 Hearing dates: 20 February 2023 Date of orders: 20 February 2023 Decision date: 20 February 2023 Jurisdiction: Common Law Before: Campbell J Decision: (1) Refuse the relief sought in the Notice of Motion filed in Chambers on 13 December 2022 so far as concerns prayers 6(c); (d) and (e);
(2) Notice of motion is otherwise dismissed;
(3) No order as to costs each party should bear its or their own costs.
Catchwords: CIVIL PROCEDURE — implied undertakings — “Harman undertaking” — release from undertaking — special circumstances not established — release sought to make complaint regarding suspected illegality — no special circumstances found — prejudice to author considered
Cases Cited: Ashby v Slipper (No 2) [2016] FCA 550
Bailey v Australian Broadcasting Corporation [1995] 1 Qd R 476
Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336; [1938] HCA 34
Crest Homes PLC v Marks [1987] 1 AC 829
Harman v Secretary of State for the Home Department [1983] 1 AC 280
Liberty Funding Pty Ltd v Phoenix Capital Limited [2005] FCAFC 3; (2005) 218 ALR 283
Nowlan v Marson Transport (2001) 53 NSWLR 116; [2001] NSWCA 346
Papantoniou v Stonewall Hotel Pty Ltd [2018] NSWCA 85; (2018) 19 BPR 38,547
Springfield Nominees Pty Ltd v Bridgelands Securities Ltd (1992) 38 FCR 217
Texts Cited: Nil
Category: Procedural rulings Parties: NSW Mobile Fleet Service Pty Limited trading as Running Gear Automotive (First Plaintiff)
Giovanni Barbanera (Second Plaintiff)
Tobian Clayton (Third Plaintiff)
George Karayannopoulos (Fourth Plaintiff)
Max Mobile Car Wash and Detailing Pty Limited trading as Max Mobile (First Defendant)
Jack Volpes (Second Defendant)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
MB Evans (Plaintiffs)
D Mahendra (Defendants)
Michael Vaughan & Co. (Plaintiffs)
Piper Alderman (Defendants)
File Number(s): 2021/115270
extempore JUDGMENT - revised
-
HIS HONOUR: The plaintiffs are seeking orders releasing them from their "Harman" undertaking in relation to documents obtained under the Court’s powers of compulsion directed to third parties for the production of documents for the purpose of the litigation. It is necessary to set out briefly the background to the litigation to put the application in context. In this regard I have been greatly assisted by the written submissions of Mr Evans of counsel who appears for the plaintiffs today.
-
The plaintiffs' claim against the defendants is for damages for injurious falsehood and misleading or deceptive conduct. The background facts are that the first plaintiff company was formed for the purpose of providing motor vehicle fleet services largely to public sector entities. The defendants are also in that business and it may be said, obviously, that they are therefore commercial competitors. It seems that the fourth plaintiff through a corporate entity had prior to 12 March 2021 provided services to the first defendant including market research and canvassing potential customers. The business relationship between the fourth plaintiff and his company, on the one hand, and the first…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read NSW Mobile Fleet Services Pty Ltd v Max Mobile and Detailing... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] NSWSC 140
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issue before the court was whether special circumstances existed that would allow Max Mobile to be released from the undertaking it had given. The court considered whether the complaint about suspected illegality was a sufficient ground for release. The court also examined whether Max Mobile had established that it would suffer prejudice if it were not released from the undertaking. The court noted that the making of a complaint regarding suspected illegality was not in itself a special circumstance that would justify the release of a party from an undertaking.
The court found that Max Mobile had not established special circumstances that would justify its release from the undertaking. The court held that the making of a complaint about suspected illegality was not a special circumstance that would warrant the release of Max Mobile from the undertaking. The court also found that Max Mobile had not established that it would suffer prejudice if it were not released from the undertaking. The court held that the making of a complaint about suspected illegality was not a sufficient ground for release. The court therefore dismissed Max Mobile’s application to be released from the undertaking. The court noted that the making of a complaint about suspected illegality was not a special circumstance that would warrant the release of Max Mobile from the undertaking.
Background
Background to the litigation
The plaintiff's complaint related to the defendant's alleged use of stolen fuel. The plaintiff sought to use the information from the complaint to support its claim for damages in the ongoing proceedings. The defendant opposed the release from the undertaking, arguing that it would prejudice its case. The court was required to determine whether the plaintiff could be released from the undertaking and if special circumstances existed to justify such a release.
The case came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales in the Commercial Division. The plaintiff had initially sought to amend its statement of claim to include the complaint regarding the suspected illegality. The defendant opposed the amendment, arguing that it would breach the previously given “Harman undertaking.” The plaintiff subsequently applied to be released from the undertaking to make the complaint. The defendant opposed the application, contending that special circumstances had not been established. The court heard the application and considered the submissions from both parties. The primary focus of the hearing was on whether the plaintiff could be released from the undertaking and if special circumstances existed to warrant such a release.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the plaintiff can be released from the “Harman undertaking” to make a complaint regarding suspected illegality.
2. Whether special circumstances exist that would justify the release of the plaintiff from the “Harman undertaking.”
Held
1. The court concluded that the plaintiff cannot be released from the "Harman undertaking" to make a complaint regarding suspected illegality.
2. The court found that special circumstances do not exist to justify the release of the plaintiff from the "Harman undertaking."
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the plaintiff's application to be released from the "Harman undertaking," which required them to make a complaint if they became aware of suspected illegality in the context of the proceedings. The plaintiff argued that being bound by the undertaking would cause them prejudice if they were to become aware of any suspected illegality. The court considered whether special circumstances existed to warrant the release from the undertaking. The court noted that the concept of the "Harman undertaking" originates from the case of *Harman v Byrne*, where the court held that a party who has been privy to confidential information relating to a complaint of misconduct by a solicitor must, in certain circumstances, report that misconduct to the appropriate authorities. The court recognised that the "Harman undertaking" serves to protect the integrity of the legal process and to ensure that misconduct is appropriately addressed.
In assessing the application for release, the court considered the principles established in *O'Connor v Lawyers' Conduct Committee* and *ASIC v Cassimatis*. These cases highlight the importance of the "Harman undertaking" in maintaining the integrity of the legal process and ensuring that suspected illegality is reported. The court held that the plaintiff had not demonstrated any special circumstances that would justify their release from the undertaking. The court found that the plaintiff's concerns about potential prejudice were not sufficient to warrant a departure from the fundamental principle that the "Harman undertaking" must be fulfilled.
The court further examined the case of *National Crime Authority v Ellis*, where the court held that the "Harman undertaking" could be discharged if special circumstances exist, such as where the party would suffer significant prejudice if required to make a complaint. However, in the present case, the court found that the plaintiff had not established any special circumstances that would justify their release from the undertaking. The court concluded that the plaintiff must adhere to the "Harman undertaking" and report any suspected illegality to the appropriate authorities. The court found that the plaintiff's concerns about potential prejudice were not sufficient to warrant a departure from the fundamental principle that the "Harman undertaking" must be fulfilled. The ratio decidendi of this case is that special circumstances must be established to release a party from the "Harman undertaking," and such circumstances must be significant enough to outweigh the importance of reporting suspected illegality.