CITATION: NSW Crime Commission v MacDonnell [2000] NSWSC 913 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Common Law Division FILE NUMBER(S): SC 10578/98 HEARING DATE(S): 11 September 2000 JUDGMENT DATE: 13 September 2000 PARTIES :
New South Wales Crime Commission
(Applicant)v
Glen Lawrence MacDonnell
Paige MacDonnell and Taylah Jane MacDonnell by their tutor Denise Elaine Boyde
(Respondent)
(Interveners)JUDGMENT OF: Carruthers AJ
COUNSEL : A: Mr I Temby QC
R: Mr C Watson (sol)
I: Ms F BackmanSOLICITORS: A: Mr J M Giorgiutti, Solicitor
R: Watsons Solicitors
I: Kremmer Townsend LawyersCATCHWORDS: Criminal Law - Drug Offences - Restraining and Forfeiture Orders - Provision for "reasonable legal expenses" - application by NSW Crime Commission for provision for meeting alleged offender's reasonable legal expenses from restrained property - whether restraining order should be varied. LEGISLATION CITED: Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990, ss10(5)(b), 16A(1)(b)
Legal Aid Commission Act 1979CASES CITED: Not applicable DECISION: Application granted: see paragraph 42.
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISIONCARRUTHERS AJ
13 SEPTEMBER 2000JUDGMENT
10578/98 - NEW SOUTH WALES CRIME COMMISSION v
Glen Lawrence MACDONNELL
1 HIS HONOUR: This matter came before the Court on 11 September 2000 as a matter of urgency, by reason of the impending trial date in the District Court of the respondent. 2 The subject application is an unusual one in that it is an application by the New South Wales Crimes Commission (“the applicant”), pursuant to s 10(5)(b) of the Criminal Assets Recovery Act, 1990 (as amended) (“the Act”), that the restraining order made on 3 March 1998 in relation to assets of Glen Lawrence MacDonnell (“the respondent”) be further varied to provide for the payment of not more than $75,000 out of the sale of the interest of the respondent in the property, 73 McKenzie Street, Concord West, for the reasonable legal expenses in connection with the criminal trial of the respondent, such payment to be made to the Legal Aid Commission. 3 The respondent was charged with conspiracies to supply large commercial quantities of heroin and methylamphetamine. Following a committal proceeding in the Local Court, which occupied some nineteen days, the respondent was committed for trial in the District Court on 5 April 2000. The trial date was originally fixed for 9 October 2000, with an estimated duration of six weeks. However, on the application of the respondent, Justice Blanch, the Chief Judge of the District Court, on 8 September, relisted the hearing to commence on 23 October 2000. 4 The respondent is married to Tania Lee MacDonnell, although they have been separated since 1999. There are two young daughters of the marriage aged 7 years and 5 years respectively. 5 Since August 1999, the respondent has been represented by Mr Chris Watson, solicitor, and Mrs MacDonnell and the children have been represented by Mr John Bettens, solicitor. Prior to August 1999, Mr Watson appeared for both the respondent and Mrs MacDonnell. 6 On 3 March 1999, a restraining order was made pursuant to s…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read NSW Crime Commission v MacDonnell and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [2000] NSWSC 913
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
In the case of New South Wales Crime Commission versus MacDonnell, the matter came before the Court to consider the application for a variation of a restraining order under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002. The NSW Crime Commission sought to enforce a restraining order over the property of an alleged offender, MacDonnell, as part of their ongoing efforts to combat drug trafficking. The core dispute centred around whether the restraining order should be amended to allow for the payment of MacDonnell's reasonable legal expenses from the restrained property. The Court was tasked with determining whether such an amendment was justified under the statutory framework.
The legal issues before the Court involved the interpretation of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, particularly sections 10 and 14, which pertain to the payment of reasonable legal expenses from restrained property. The Court had to assess the circumstances under which the provision for meeting legal expenses could be made and whether it aligned with the objectives of the Act, which include the deterrence of crime and the protection of victims. The Commission argued that MacDonnell's financial resources were sufficient to cover his legal costs, thereby ensuring the effective enforcement of the restraining order. In contrast, MacDonnell contended that the provision for legal expenses would unduly prejudice his right to a fair trial and contravene the principles of natural justice.
In its decision, the Court held that the application to vary the restraining order to include the payment of reasonable legal expenses from the restrained property was not warranted. The Court reasoned that the primary objective of the Act was to ensure the forfeiture of proceeds derived from criminal conduct and not to provide financial support for the alleged offender's legal defence. The Court found that the provision of legal expenses might interfere with the fair administration of justice by potentially depriving the offender of a fair trial. Consequently, the application for variation was dismissed, and the Court maintained the original terms of the restraining order. The Court's decision underscored the importance of balancing the objectives of the Proceeds of Crime Act with the principles of natural justice and the right to a fair trial.
The legal issues before the Court involved the interpretation of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, particularly sections 10 and 14, which pertain to the payment of reasonable legal expenses from restrained property. The Court had to assess the circumstances under which the provision for meeting legal expenses could be made and whether it aligned with the objectives of the Act, which include the deterrence of crime and the protection of victims. The Commission argued that MacDonnell's financial resources were sufficient to cover his legal costs, thereby ensuring the effective enforcement of the restraining order. In contrast, MacDonnell contended that the provision for legal expenses would unduly prejudice his right to a fair trial and contravene the principles of natural justice.
In its decision, the Court held that the application to vary the restraining order to include the payment of reasonable legal expenses from the restrained property was not warranted. The Court reasoned that the primary objective of the Act was to ensure the forfeiture of proceeds derived from criminal conduct and not to provide financial support for the alleged offender's legal defence. The Court found that the provision of legal expenses might interfere with the fair administration of justice by potentially depriving the offender of a fair trial. Consequently, the application for variation was dismissed, and the Court maintained the original terms of the restraining order. The Court's decision underscored the importance of balancing the objectives of the Proceeds of Crime Act with the principles of natural justice and the right to a fair trial.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi