NRND and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

NRND and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration) [2018] AATA 3601 (21 September 2018)

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL               )
  )         No: 2017/7742
GENERAL DIVISION  )

Re: NRND
Applicant

And: Minister for Immigration and Border Protection
Respondent

DIRECTION

TRIBUNAL:  Deputy President J W Constance

DATE OF CORRIGENDUM: 26 September 2018

PLACE:            Sydney           

IT IS DIRECTED that, in accordance with subsection 43AA(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the text of the decision in this application is to be altered such that:

  1. the wording of the decision is changed to:

The decision under review, being the decision made 25 October 2017
to exercise the discretion to refuse the visa applicant’s application for a Partner visa, is set aside
;
The matter is remitted to the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection for reconsideration with a direction that the visa applicant should not be refused a Partner (Provisional)(Class UF) visa under s 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

  1. the wording in paragraph [5] of the reasons for the decision is changed to:

For the reasons which follow, the matter will be remitted to the
Minister for reconsideration with a direction that Mr G should not be refused a Partner (Provisional)(Class UF) visa under s 501(1) of the
Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

  1. the wording in paragraph [103] of the reasons for the decision is changed to:

It will be decided that the matter will be remitted to the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection for reconsideration with a direction that Mr G should not be refused a Partner (Provisional)(Class UF) visa under s 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

...................[sgd]................................................

J W Constance
Deputy President

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2017/7742

Re:NRND  

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Immigration and Border Protection

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President J W Constance 

Date:21 September 2018  

Place:Sydney

The decision under review, being the decision made 25 October 2017 to exercise the discretion to refuse the visa applicant’s application for a Partner visa, is set aside.

In substitution, it is decided that the matter will be remitted to the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection for reconsideration with a direction that the visa applicant be granted a Partner (Provisional)(Class UF) visa.

..................[sgd]......................................................

J W Constance
Deputy President

CATCHWORDS

MIGRATION - discretion to refuse the application for a visa - Partner visa - whether the visa applicant is of good character - substantial criminal record - people smuggling - transportation of refugees - humanitarian crisis - Ministerial Direction No. 65 - protection of the Australian community - seriousness and nature of conduct - expectations of the Australian community - risk to community should conduct be repeated - decision set aside and remitted to the Minister

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

CASES

Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Daniele [1981] FCA 212

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Cth), Direction [No 65] – Visa refusal and cancellation under s501 and revocation of a mandatory…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read NRND and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Mig... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 3601
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Court of Australia considered an appeal by Mr G against a decision by the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection to refuse his application for a Partner visa. The refusal was based on Mr G’s character, specifically a prior conviction for people smuggling in Hungary. Mr G had been convicted in 2015 for assisting in the transportation of refugees across the Hungarian border and received a suspended 18-month prison sentence.

The central legal issue before the Court was whether the Minister had properly exercised the discretion to refuse the visa application, having regard to Ministerial Direction No. 65, which outlines considerations for assessing the character of visa applicants. Specifically, the Court had to determine if Mr G’s past conduct, namely the people smuggling offence, posed a risk to the Australian community, and whether the seriousness and nature of his conduct, along with community expectations, warranted the refusal of the visa.

Deputy J W Constance P reasoned that while people smuggling is a serious offence, Mr G’s conduct was at the lower end of the scale. This conclusion was based on the circumstances of the offence, including that Mr G did not attempt to evade authorities and that the refugees crossed the border on foot before re-entering his vehicle. Furthermore, the Hungarian court imposed a suspended sentence, indicating that the period of pre-trial detention was considered sufficient punishment, provided no further offences were committed. The Court found that the Minister had not given sufficient weight to these mitigating factors and the fact that Mr G had not re-offended since the incident.

Consequently, the Court set aside the decision to refuse Mr G’s Partner visa application. The matter was remitted to the Minister for reconsideration with a direction that Mr G be granted a Partner (Provisional)(Class UF) visa.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons which follow, the decision under review will be set aside and the matter will be remitted to the Minister for reconsideration with a direction that Mr G be granted a Partner (Provisional)(Class UF) visa.2. BACKGROUND Unless stated otherwise, findings of fact in these reasons are based on the evidence of Mr G. I am satisfied of the facts found on the balance of probabilities. Mr G is 39 years old. Conviction by a Court in Hungary in 2015 On 11 September 2015, Mr G was convicted in a Hungarian Court of the offence of “smuggling of people, helping more people at the border crossing, one-time”[3] and sentenced to imprisonment for 18 months. The sentence was immediately suspended on the basis that he could be required to serve the sentence within two years of the conviction. He was held in custody from the time he committed the offence (13 August 2015) until he pleaded guilty and was sentenced on 11 September 2015.[3] Exhibit R1 at 79. In a statement filed in these proceedings and verified at the hearing, Mr G described the circumstances of his conviction and imprisonment:In August of 2015, a friend of mine asked me if i would help him to give a ride to these people to Austria and in return he would pay me. He told me that we wont [sic] do any illegal offence as this would be classed as a taxi ride, because we will not take them over the border, as they will pass the border alone. As the agreement was that i should only wait for them in Hungary, and drive them to Austria. On the 13th of August 2015, we went on the road. When they crossed the Hungarian border, i was waiting for them and soon as they entered the car, the police had stopped us. They then arrested me, and I had been in prison until the 11th of September 2015. When i had the court trial at Baja city, they gave me paroled sentence of two years, and one year and six months of prison if i repeat any offence in Hungary. They banned me to enter Hungary and Schengen zone country’s [sic] for two years (until 11th September 2017). They also give me a fine of 51,950 forints (167 euros) to pay for court costs.That was my first time that i ever had issues with the law. I’ve always tried to live honestly and to avoid trouble. In custody in which i was almost for one month, I thought a lot of everything and I decided to never let something similar happen. I just want to have a peaceful family life. I am saying this in order to convince you that I have no intention to never do something that’s illegal, and I have learnt a lot from this bad experience that I had. I honestly feel a shamed [sic] that i have allowed this to happen to me.[4][4] Exhibit A2.Mr G’s evidence as to the circumstances of the offence The Solicitor for the Minister questioned Mr G at length as to how he came to commit the offence. When Mr G was asked by his friend to drive a group of refugees from Belgrade to Austria, he was offered the equivalent of AUD 1000.00 to do so. This was a significant amount of money for Mr G, as it was about the same as he could earn over 2-3 months if he got casual work. He did not believe he was exploiting the refugees as they had offered the amount to his friend who conveyed this to him. He did not ask for the sum offered. He was not paid in advance and he never received the sum offered.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In a statement filed in these proceedings and verified at the hearing, Mr G described the circumstances of his conviction and imprisonment:In August of 2015, a friend of mine asked me if i would help him to give a ride to these people to Austria and in return he would pay me. He told me that we wont [sic] do any illegal offence as this would be classed as a taxi ride, because we will not take them over the border, as they will pass the border alone. As the agreement was that i should only wait for them in Hungary, and drive them to Austria. On the 13th of August 2015, we went on the road. When they crossed the Hungarian border, i was waiting for them and soon as they entered the car, the police had stopped us. They then arrested me, and I had been in prison until the 11th of September 2015. When i had the court trial at Baja city, they gave me paroled sentence of two years, and one year and six months of prison if i repeat any offence in Hungary. They banned me to enter Hungary and Schengen zone country’s [sic] for two years (until 11th September 2017). They also give me a fine of 51,950 forints (167 euros) to pay for court costs.That was my first time that i ever had issues with the law. I’ve always tried to live honestly and to avoid trouble. In custody in which i was almost for one month, I thought a lot of everything and I decided to never let something similar happen. I just want to have a peaceful family life. I am saying this in order to convince you that I have no intention to never do something that’s illegal, and I have learnt a lot from this bad experience that I had. I honestly feel a shamed [sic] that i have allowed this to happen to me.[4][4] Exhibit A2.Mr G’s evidence as to the circumstances of the offence The Solicitor for the Minister questioned Mr G at length as to how he came to commit the offence. When Mr G was asked by his friend to drive a group of refugees from Belgrade to Austria, he was offered the equivalent of AUD 1000.00 to do so. This was a significant amount of money for Mr G, as it was about the same as he could earn over 2-3 months if he got casual work. He did not believe he was exploiting the refugees as they had offered the amount to his friend who conveyed this to him. He did not ask for the sum offered. He was not paid in advance and he never received the sum offered. Mr G felt that he was doing a good deed for the family, which included children, as Belgrade “was full of people like them, wanting to go to Germany or Austria.” He was aware that the family was escaping from the war in Syria. He believed that they had been robbed on occasions and feared for their safety. Mr G was unaware that he was acting illegally in assisting the refugees in the manner in which he did. The family alighted from his vehicle before the Hungarian border and Mr G then drove through the check point and waited for them about one kilometre beyond the Hungarian side of the border. The refugees crossed the border on foot. When they got into Mr G’s vehicle again, he was arrested by the Hungarian Police.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For these reasons, the discretion to refuse Mr G’s application for a Partner visa should not be exercised.7. CONCLUSION The decision under review, being the decision made 25 October 2017 to exercise the discretion to refuse Mr G’s application for a Partner visa, will be set aside. In substitution, it will be decided that the matter will be remitted to the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection for reconsideration with a direction that Mr G be granted a Partner (Provisional)(Class UF) visa.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Primary considerations are set out in Paragraph 11 of Part B. They are:(a)protection of the Australian community from criminal or other serious conduct;(b)the best interests of minor children in Australia;(c)expectations of the Australian Community.5.1.1 Primary consideration (a): Protection of the Australian community from criminal or other serious conduct. Paragraph 11.1 of the Direction provides that “decision-makers should have regard to the principle that the Government is committed to protecting the Australian community from harm as a result of criminal activity or other serious conduct by non-citizens.” Consideration is also to be given to the nature and seriousness of the visa applicant’s conduct to date and the risk to the community should the visa applicant commit further offences or engage in other serious conduct.5.1.1.1 The nature and seriousness of Mr G’s conduct to date Subparagraph 11.1.1 sets out further principles to which regard is to be had in considering the nature and seriousness of the non-citizen’s criminal offending. These are set out in full in the schedule (Schedule 1) to these reasons. The crime committed by Mr G was neither violent nor sexual in nature. It was not committed against the refugees. Rather, it was a crime against the State of Hungary in the exercise of its rights as a sovereign State. Nevertheless, there can be no doubt that the offence of people smuggling is a serious offence with serious consequences for Australia if this country is the subject of the illegal activity. In this regard, I have taken into account material provided on behalf of the Minister.[9] [9] Exhibit R2: Khalid Koser and Marie McAuliffe, “Establishing an Evidence-Base for Future Policy Development on Irregular Migration to Australia”, Irregular Migration Research Program Occasional Paper Series, June 2013.Exhibit R3 Australian Federal Police web page 31/08/2018, Why People Smuggling threatens all Australians. Several matters cause me to conclude that Mr G’s offence was to the lower end of the scale of similar offences. First, the circumstances of his offending. He did not attempt to evade the law enforcement authorities in either country by concealing the refugees or attempting to convey them across the border. On the contrary, he caused them to approach the crossing point on foot to ascertain what, if any, action would be taken against them. They were permitted to enter Hungary under circumstances unknown. They were then required to proceed on foot about one kilometre past the check point before again entering the vehicle being driven by Mr G. Secondly, Mr G was not imprisoned after he was convicted. On the limited evidence available as to the Court proceedings in Hungary, I am satisfied that the Court considered that the 30 days during which Mr G was held in custody prior to his court appearance was an appropriate period of detention provided he did not commit any further offences. This was significantly less than the term of actual imprisonment which could have been imposed.