NRJT and Australian Offshore Solutions Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

NRJT and Australian Offshore Solutions Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2015] AATA 588 (13 August 2015)

Division GENERAL DIVISION

File Number

2015/1016

Re

NRJT

APPLICANT

And

Australian Offshore Solutions Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President, Dr Christopher Kendall

Date 13 August 2015
Place Perth

The Tribunal finds that the Applicant did not provide any reasonable excuse for his failure to attend three medical examinations requested by the Respondent on 15 July 2014, 5 August 2014 and 15 December 2014. That portion of the Reconsideration Determination which found that the Applicant’s failure to attend these three medical appointments constitutes an obstruction in accordance with section 66(2) of the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1991 (Cth) is affirmed.   

..........................[sgd].............................................

Deputy President, Dr Christopher Kendall

CATCHWORDS

Seafarers - compensation - request for medical examination - refusal to attend – claim compensation suspended – whether refusal to attend reasonable – reconsideration determination affirmed in relation to failure to attend medical appointments

LEGISLATION

Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1991 (Cth) – s 66(2)

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) – s 35(3)

CASES

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Administrative Appeals Tribunal and Anor (2009) 181 FCR 130 at [149]

Australian Postal Corporation v Forgie (2003) 130 FCR 279
Fazlic v Milinginbi Community Inc (1980) 38 ALR 424
McKinnon v Commonwealth [1999] FCA 717
Pascoe v Australian Postal Corporation (2004) 77 ALD 464
Re Twaddell and Comcare (2001) 65 ALD 794

Taikato v The Queen [1996] HCA 28; (1996) 186

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Peter Sutherland and John Oman Ballard, Annotated Safety and Compensation Act 1988 (Leichhardt: The Federation Press, 2014) at 455-457.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President, Dr C Kendall

14 August 2015

BACKGROUND

  1. Pursuant to section 35(3) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the Tribunal can restrict the publication of the names of parties to proceedings and allocate a pseudonym to parties to proceedings: Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Administrative Appeals Tribunal and Anor (2009) 181 FCR 130 at [149].

  2. The Applicant in these proceedings asked that his personal history not be publically disclosed.  The Tribunal agreed and made orders restricting the publication of the name of, and any information that might identify, the Applicant in this written decision.

  3. In these reasons the Applicant will simply be referred to as “the Applicant”.

  4. Failure to attend a medical examination when required to do so pursuant to section 66 the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1991 (Cth) (the “Act”) results in a claim for compensation being suspended until the medical examination takes place.  Compensation is not payable in respect of the period of suspension.  If an employee subsequently proves that a “reasonable excuse” existed for not attending the medical examination, the suspension is not justified and compensation is payable for the period of suspension: Peter Sutherland and John Oman Ballard, Annotated Safety and Compensation Act 1988 (Leichhardt: The Federation Press, 2014) at 455.

  5. The Applicant in these proceedings was employed by the respondent, Australian Offshore Solutions Pty Ltd (“Offshore Solutions”).

  6. The Applicant applied…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read NRJT and Australian Offshore Solutions Pty Ltd (Compensation... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 588
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties involved in this case are the Applicant, identified as NRJT, and the Respondent, Australian Offshore Solutions Pty Ltd. The dispute revolves around the Applicant's refusal to attend three medical examinations requested by the Respondent, which led to a suspension of his compensation claims under the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992. The matter was heard and decided by the Australian Tribunal.

The key legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the Applicant had provided a reasonable excuse for his non-attendance at the medical examinations and whether his failure to attend constituted an obstruction as defined by section 66(2) of the Act. Specifically, the Tribunal had to determine if the Applicant's reasons for not attending the appointments were reasonable and justified under the circumstances, and if his actions amounted to an obstruction of the examination process.

The Tribunal considered the evidence presented, which included the Applicant's email communications expressing his inability to attend due to health issues and dissatisfaction with the claim process. Despite the Applicant's claims of ill health, the Tribunal found that his reasons for non-attendance were not reasonable, particularly since he had not raised concerns about his health or medication in a timely manner. The Tribunal noted that the Applicant's last-minute notification about potential medication-related issues did not constitute a reasonable excuse. Additionally, the Tribunal highlighted that the Applicant's insistence on attending with his own doctor and a witness at a company-paid doctor's appointment suggested a lack of trust, which further undermined his position. Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the Reconsideration Determination that the Applicant's failure to attend the medical appointments constituted an obstruction under section 66(2) of the Act.

The Tribunal's decision was that the Applicant did not provide a reasonable excuse for his non-attendance at the medical examinations and that his failure to attend constituted an obstruction. The Tribunal upheld the Reconsideration Determination that the Applicant's non-attendance at the three medical examinations on 15 July 2014, 5 August 2014, and 15 December 2014 amounted to an obstruction in accordance with section 66(2) of the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal finds that the Applicant did not provide any reasonable excuse for his failure to attend three medical examinations requested by the Respondent on 15 July 2014, 5 August 2014 and 15 December 2014. That portion of the Reconsideration Determination which found that the Applicant’s failure to attend these three medical appointments constitutes an obstruction in accordance with section 66(2) of the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1991 (Cth) is affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

At the Tribunal hearing on 8 July 2015, the evidence included:·Oral evidence from the Applicant.·A Statement of Findings on Material Questions of Fact dated 16 April 2015 tendered as Exhibit R1.·T-Documents filed by Offshore Solutions (T1 to T56 comprising with 191 pages), dated 16 April 2015 tendered as Exhibit R2. The T documents included the Reconsideration Determination of 23 February 2015 (T2) and extensive email correspondence between the Applicant and Offshore Solutions. ·A timeline of events and relevant documents received by the Tribunal on 7 July 2015 and tendered as R5. These documents, comprising 149 pages, were not numbered or placed in chronological order. They were filed on the day of the hearing. All were reviewed and, where relevant, referred to below. FACTS AND EVIDENCE There are three medical appointments relevant to the determination of the issue before the Tribunal. These occurred on 15 July, 2014, 5 August, 2014, and 15 December, 2014. Medical Examination scheduled for 15 July 2014 On 8 July 2014, a letter was sent to the Applicant from Liberty International Underwriters requesting that he attend a medical review with psychiatrist Lawrence Terace on 15 July 2014 in accordance with section 66 of the Act (R5). That letter stated:In accordance with the Act, should you, without reasonable excuse fail to attend the examination or in any way obstruct the examination, any rights to compensation under the Act you may have, and to institute or continue any proceedings under this Act in relation to compensation, are suspended until the examination takes place. On 8 July 2014 at 1:13 pm, the Applicant replied via email to this letter (R5):Probably can’t make that date not feeling well.whats the piont youve allready denied the claim.you take it up the aat.or the company sponsored seacare talk to chris kerwin .and then give me transcipts of any conversationbunder the sec 68.seafarers rehabilition and compensation act refer to claim.is this part of your injury mangement.scheam.plus ibeen giving sepration certificate .still trying to get it ring labour gary grays office. They told them they were going to send itunder section 68 I request all your paticulars your address. Your ph number dste of birth .all that you know X my personal details I want all the poeple working on my claims details under section 68 srca. 1992 Ill back it up .with post. (sic) On 8 July 2014 at 5:53pm, the Applicant wrote again in response to this letter and stated, via email (R5):Like siad before its making sick im not well at the moment all this stress. Fighting for my ditnity and integrity how would you feel somebody forging your nane and what would you do. Ask yourself that .. … I dont sleep at night. Havent sleapt since the signature. Incerdent causeing me P.T.S..D…Ad. (sic) On 9 July 2014 at 11:29am, the Applicant wrote again, stating, via email (R5):Dont go making appointments without my knowlege.as ive said im not well wembely is too far away from where I live take your concerns to aat. Dont bother me no more you make me sick . And make appointments if I ever go to company paid doctor I will make sure my dr is there as well. And a witness.because last time I went to company dr he called police .I cant trust them and company dr s make me sick just like you did yesterday way out of time in the limit .let s charge you a penalty under the act. Ok don't send me any emails go through seacare or aat .im allready sick . (sic)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 66 of the Act provides:Power to require medical examination (1) If: (a)a notice has been given under section 62 in relation to an injury to an employee; or (b)an employee has made a claim for compensation under section 63; the employer to whom the notice of claim is given may require the employee to undergo an examination by a legally qualified medical practitioner nominated by the employer. (1A)An employee must not be required to be examined by more than one legally qualified medical practitioner in any examination that the employee is required to undergo under subsection (1). (2)If an employee, without reasonable excuse, does not undergo an examination, or in any way obstructs an examination, the employee's rights to compensation under this Act, and to institute or continue any proceedings under this Act in relation to compensation, are suspended until the examination takes place. (3)If an employee's right to compensation is suspended under subsection (2), compensation is not payable in respect of the period of the suspension. (4)Subject to subsection (4D), an employer who requires an employee to undergo an examination under this section must pay the cost of the examination and is liable to pay to the employee: (a)an amount equal to the expenditure reasonably incurred by the employee in making a journey, necessary in connection with the examination, from the place in Australia where the employee is residing to the place where the examination is to be made; and (b)an amount equal to the expenditure reasonably incurred by the employee in remaining (if necessary), for the purpose of the examination, at a place to which the employee has made a journey for that purpose. (4A)If the journey referred to in paragraph (4)(a) is made by means of public transport or ambulance services, the expenditure referred to in that paragraph is taken to be an amount equal to the expenditure reasonably incurred in undertaking the journey. EVIDENCE At the Tribunal hearing on 8 July 2015, the evidence included:·Oral evidence from the Applicant.·A Statement of Findings on Material Questions of Fact dated 16 April 2015 tendered as Exhibit R1.·T-Documents filed by Offshore Solutions (T1 to T56 comprising with 191 pages), dated 16 April 2015 tendered as Exhibit R2. The T documents included the Reconsideration Determination of 23 February 2015 (T2) and extensive email correspondence between the Applicant and Offshore Solutions. ·A timeline of events and relevant documents received by the Tribunal on 7 July 2015 and tendered as R5. These documents, comprising 149 pages, were not numbered or placed in chronological order. They were filed on the day of the hearing. All were reviewed and, where relevant, referred to below. FACTS AND EVIDENCE There are three medical appointments relevant to the determination of the issue before the Tribunal. These occurred on 15 July, 2014, 5 August, 2014, and 15 December, 2014. Medical Examination scheduled for 15 July 2014 On 8 July 2014, a letter was sent to the Applicant from Liberty International Underwriters requesting that he attend a medical review with psychiatrist Lawrence Terace on 15 July 2014 in accordance with section 66 of the Act (R5). That letter stated:In accordance with the Act, should you, without reasonable excuse fail to attend the examination or in any way obstruct the examination, any rights to compensation under the Act you may have, and to institute or continue any proceedings under this Act in relation to compensation, are suspended until the examination takes place.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Further, it is unclear to the Tribunal why the Applicant waited until the last minute to advise Offshore Solutions that his medication had made it impossible for him to attend at Dr Tay’s offices. It is clear on the evidence that he had envisaged being tired if medication were required. Had Offshore Solutions been advised that there was a possibility of non-attendance due to medication concerns, other options could have been examined, the appointment could have been delayed if necessary and Offshore would not have been financially penalised for a third time for non-attendance. For the Applicant to advise at a very late stage that he could not attend a third appointment cannot, taking into account all of the evidence before the Tribunal, be seen to be reasonable in the circumstances. DECISION For the reasons outlined above, the Tribunal finds that the Applicant did not, pursuant to section 66(2) of the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992, provide any reasonable excuse for his failure to attend three medical examinations requested by Australian Offshore Solutions on 15 July 2014, 5 August 2014 and 15 December 2014. That portion of the Reconsideration Determination which found that the Applicant’s failure to attend these three medical appointments constitutes an obstruction in accordance with section 66(2) of the Act is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.