NPLR and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

NPLR and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2023] AATA 1521 (2 June 2023)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2022/8074

Re:NPLR

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndWXRT

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President J Sosso

Date:2 June 2023

Place:Brisbane

The decision of the Social Services & Child Support Division of 14 September 2022, refusing an extension of time for the Applicant to seek a review of the decision of the Child Support Registrar of 3 June 2022, is set aside and substituted with a decision to grant the Applicant an extension of time for the lodging of her review application of 28 September 2022 in order that it may be heard by the Social Services & Child Support Division.

.....................[SGD].....................

Deputy President J Sosso

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE: Application for extension of time – AAT second review – moderate delay – explanation for delay – prospects of success – no prejudice to Registrar – extension of time granted

LEGISLATION

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth)

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth)

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth)

CASES

Brown v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [1999] FCA 563

Children’s Activities Time Society Association Inc. and Collector of Customs (WA) (1986) 9 ALN N111

Comcare v A’Hearn (1993) 45 FCR 441

Commissioner of Taxation v Brown (1999) 99 ATC 4852

Hunter Valley Developments Pty Ltd & Ors v Minister for Home Affairs and Environment (1984) 58 ALR 305

Ignacio and Ignacio [2016] FamCA 50

Minister for Health and Aged Care v Pharmacia & Upjohn Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 75

NLLQ and Child Support Registrar [2023] AATA 867

Tadela and Child Support Registrar [2017] AATA 957

Windshuttle v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1993) 46 FCR 235

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President J Sosso

2 June 2023

  1. Ms NPLR (“the Applicant”) seeks a review of a decision of the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (“AAT1”) made on


    14 September 2022 refusing to grant the Applicant an extension of time to seek a review of an objection decision of the Child Support Registrar (“the Registrar”) of 3 June 2022.

  2. The Registrar partly allowed an objection made by Mr WXRT (“the Other Party”) to a decision of 14 January 2022 being a change of assessment determination made under Part 6A of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) (“the Act”).

  3. The sole issue before the Tribunal is whether it is reasonable in the circumstances to grant the Applicant an extension of time for her to make an application to AAT1 to review the objection decision of 3 June 2022.

  4. This is a somewhat unusual matter. In Directions made on 7 February 2023…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read NPLR and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 1521
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for an extension of time to seek a review of a child support objection decision. The applicant sought to challenge the Child Support Registrar's decision regarding the adjustable taxable income of both parents and the resulting child support assessment. The dispute centred on whether the applicant had provided sufficient grounds and demonstrated a reasonable prospect of success to warrant an extension of time, despite a moderate delay in lodging the application.

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was required to determine whether to grant the applicant an extension of time to lodge her application for review. This involved considering the length of the delay, the explanation provided for the delay, the applicant's awareness of her review rights, and whether granting the extension would cause prejudice to the Child Support Registrar. The Tribunal also had to assess the prospects of success of the substantive application for review, particularly in light of new information the applicant claimed had become available after the objection decision was made.

Deputy President Sosso P applied the principles for granting an extension of time, noting that while a statutory basis was absent, established judicial considerations provided a useful framework. The Tribunal found the delay of 38 days to be of moderate length and, crucially, not contested as causing prejudice to the Registrar. The applicant explained her delay by stating she was unaware of the objection decision notice due to a switch to electronic communication, and that significant information regarding the other party's income only became available after the 28-day review period had expired. The Tribunal considered this explanation, along with the applicant's detailed grounds for review, which included claims that the other party had returned to work and had not updated his income details, and that the assessment did not accurately reflect his earning capacity and financial resources.

The Tribunal granted the extension of time. This decision was based on the moderate delay, the plausible explanation provided by the applicant for that delay, the lack of prejudice to the Registrar, and the applicant's stated grounds for review which suggested arguable issues regarding the accuracy of the child support assessment.

Background

Background to the litigation

Nonetheless, the Registrar through her legal representative, Mr Samuel Harvey, has greatly assisted the Tribunal both by the information provided in Exhibit 2 as well as Mr Harvey’s participation in the Hearing convened on 17 May 2023. The Tribunal places on record its appreciation for the assistance provided by the Registrar and Mr Harvey.THE FACTS The uncontested facts as set out in Exhibit 2, are outlined below. The Applicant and the Other Party are parents of two children, the first born in May 2007 and the second in May 2009. A child support assessment has been registered with the Registrar since 14 July 2021 – Exhibit 1 T56 p. 606. On 23 September 2021, the Applicant lodged an application for a change of assessment requesting an increase of the annual rate of child support – Exhibit 1 T5 pp. 29 – 114. Two reasons were advanced – Exhibit 1 T5 p. 29:(a)Reason 3 – there are extra costs in caring for, educating or training the child(ren) in the way both parents intended; and(b)Reason 8A – the assessment does not correctly reflect one or both parent’s income, property and/or financial resources. The Applicant provided detailed reasons in support of her application – Exhibit 1 T5 pp. 38 – 40. On 14 January 2022, the Registrar determined to change the assessment (the change of assessment decision) as follows – Exhibit 1 T22 p. 197:(a)for the period 23 September 2021 to 30 November 2022 the adjustable taxable income of the Applicant was set at $182,780.00; and(b)for the same period, the adjustable taxable income of the Other Party was set at $154,960.00. The effect of the change of assessment decision was as follows:(a)for the period 1 January 2022 to 31 December 2022, the annual rate payable by the Other Party would be increased by $17,647.00; and(b)for the period 1 January 2023 to 31 December 2023, the annual rate payable by the Other Party would be increased by $18,529.00; and(c)the Other Party was liable to pay arrears of approximately $4,320.00 and his monthly ongoing liability would be increased by a $1,357.00. On 1 February 2022, the Other Party objected to the change of assessment decision – Exhibit 1 T24 pp. 218 – 223. The reasons advance by the Other Party were as follows – Exhibit 1 T24 p. 220:“[NPLR] has stated that I am not paying for the property in Buderim for which she resides or my rental property. I am paying for both. I am currently in financial difficulty and am in arrears 1618.00 and the bank is sending messages asking for the money. I have paid the amount on the rental property every week, however I do not receive any income from the property.Reason 8A in the assessment is all false.Reason 3. We agreed to have the children in private school when the cost of living was divided equally. At that time I paid 400/week in accommodation. I now pay for my rental property and half the property the children reside in. All attempts to sell the property have been refused.” Further, on 7 April 2022, the Other Party lodged a change of assessment application – Exhibit 1 T44 pp. 441 – 460. Three reasons were advanced – Exhibit 1 T44 p. 442:(a)Reason 5 – I have provided money, goods or property for the benefit of the child(ren); and(b)Reason 8B – The assessment does not correctly reflect one or both parent’s earning capacity; and(c)Reason 9 – I have a duty to support another person.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The objection decision was sent to both the Applicant and the Other Party by electronic communication on 3 June 2022. The cover letters contained the following information – Exhibit 1 T49 pp. 488 – 489:“If you do not agree with this decisionIf you think this decision is wrong, you can ask the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) to review it. You must do this within 28 days from the date you receive this letter…”[Emphasis in original] On 1 August 2022, the Applicant lodged an Extension of Time Application with the Tribunal requesting an extension of time to 30 August 2022 to make an application for further review – Exhibit 1 T54 pp. 580 – 582. Subsequently, on 9 August 2022, the Applicant applied to AAT1 for a review of the objection decision – Exhibit 1 T53 pp. 570 – 579. The Applicant gave the following reasons for seeking a review of the objection decision – Exhibit 1 T53 p. 572:-“[the Other Party] returned to work as of early July 2020 and should start to contribute – he has not updated CSA with this new information.-[the Other Party] was not off work entirely due to an injury – he broke his wrist in January, but was then home for many months studying for his specialist surgery exams, as evidenced by him returning to work the week after exams in early July.-[the Other Party] was not made to produce a medical certificate from his orthopaedic surgeon relating to his capacity. The certificate he provided was from a GP who stated he was ‘unfit for the foreseeable future’. Being a GP myself, I am well aware that a GP would refer to the treating surgeon for comment on a patients capacity after surgery. The fact that his income protection ceased paying him is a very good indication that his injury had resolved as they would certainly not base their payments on a generalised comment from a GP, they would have asked the surgeon to clarify his capacity for work, and hence terminated his claim once the surgeon gave the all clear. The CSA gave him leeway until October 2022 due to this certificate, but he will have been working for three months by then. He has not updated CSA on his ability to work. He should at least be paying school fees again from July 2022.-[the Other Party] did not provide the CSA with his actual true earnings. Please see the attached payslip which shows the 2021/2022 financial year. From the period July 2021 until January 2022 when he ceased work after he broke his wrist, he earnt $119,000 in that 6 months alone. In the CSA decision letter, they state he was paid $15,000 from his income protection policy and another $55,000 for lecturing – making a total for the 2021/2022 financial year of $189,000. I earnt $185,000-$195,000 in the same financial year. I find it exceedingly inequitable that I pay all the children’s expenses such as medical, dental, sports, music, uniforms as well as $35,000 in school fees even though we earnt the same in that financial year????-Our daughter also has several significant medical conditions and is under specialist care. The CSA agreed that [the daughter] does in fact have extra medical expenses (which I am covering solely), however they stated that sin[c]e he isn’t working, he would be unable to contribute? This simply isn’t true. He is working as of July 2022 and even when he chose not to work for 6 months or so – he still earnt the same wage as me for the financial year…”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

No witnesses were called to give evidence.CONSIDERATIONIntroduction The Tribunal is required to consider all relevant factors and weigh each one when determining whether or not to grant an extension of time. Although, as previously noted, the factors outlined by Wilcox J have no statutory basis, they nonetheless provide a useful yardstick when making a determination.Length of delay In this matter the delay was 38 days. In NLLQ the delay was 54 days, and Senior Member O’Donovan observed that in the context of child support matters this was “a significant delay” – at [54]. The delay in this matter is considerably less than in NLLQ. The shorter the delay the greater the likelihood that no prejudice, or no significant prejudice, can be shown to have been visited on any other party. Likewise, the shorter the delay the more likely it is that an applicant can demonstrate that they have not wilfully or negligently “sat” on their rights. It is also the case, as Senior Member O’Donovan explained in NLLQ, that in the context of child support matters delays can have deleterious consequences for third parties, namely the child or children the subject of the child support payments. The delay in this matter is of moderate length, and, as explained below, there was a plausible excuse provided for the delay. Of more significance, however, it is not contested that the delay has not resulted in prejudice to the Registrar – Exhibit 2 para 56.Awareness of appeal rights and explanation for the delay As set out above, the notice of the objection decision sent to the Applicant clearly stated that she had 28 days to seek a review of the decision by the Tribunal – Exhibit 1 T49 p. 488. An applicant for an extension of time is not required to give an explanation for the delay, and the provision of an explanation is not a prerequisite to the favourable exercise of the discretion to grant an extension. Whilst an explanation is not a condition precedent to granting an extension, nonetheless such an explanation is a relevant matter for the Tribunal to take into account – Comcare v A’Hearn (1993) 45 FCR 441. In this matter, the Applicant has given an explanation for the delay. She acknowledges that the Registrar did send her a notice and that the notice clearly set out the 28 day time period. However, she claims she did not become aware of the notice for some time after it was sent. In short, she claims for a considerable period she was ignorant of the objection decision and her right to seek a review in the Tribunal. The Applicant provided the following explanation of her delay when seeking an extension of time in the General Division of the Tribunal – Exhibit 2 Attachment B pp. 6 – 7: “…I was notified from CSA via electronic notification (which I originally did not see as I was unaware I was receiving electronic letters instead of letters in the post). I rang CSA to follow up my case as I had not heard anything regarding the decision, and at the time they explained I had elected to switch to electronic notification. I promptly checked my online messages and responded to the letter/applied to the AAT, as the decision made by the CSA was based on false information and significantly financially impacted and disadvantaged me…I accept I did not respond to the decision letter within 28 days. I accept that this was my fault as I did not see the letter. However even if I did see the letter online within 28 days I would have responded after that anyway as the information regarding [the Other Party] working during that period and [the Other Party] receiving regular income protection payments during that time, only became available after the 28 day response time. I would therefore greatly appreciate an extension of time being granted to allow a fair decision to be made based on the correct wage information…”