Nova Builders Pty Ltd v Beno Excavations Pty Ltd (No 5)

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

Nova Builders Pty Ltd v Beno Excavations Pty Ltd (No 5)

Citation: 

[2023] ACTSC 370

Hearing Date: 

Decided on the papers

Decision Date: 

8 December 2023

Before:

Mossop J

Decision: 

See [39].

Catchwords: 

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – INTEREST – Plaintiff failed to claim interest in its Defence and counterclaim – consideration of r 1619 of the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) – successful defence of set-off and counterclaim on the ground of mistaken payment – mistaken payments caused by second defendant – interest calculated on the whole of the amount from the date of the mistaken payment – no reason to limit plaintiff’s entitlement to interest – leave given to amend claim to include claim for interest – interest awarded

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – COSTS – Plaintiff seeks costs on an indemnity basis – second defendant seeks different costs orders for claim and counterclaim – where plaintiff successful on both its defence and counterclaim on the ground of mistaken payment – second defendant’s conduct deliberately caused the mistaken payments – no reason to award separate costs orders for defence and counterclaim – costs awarded in favour of plaintiff

Legislation Cited: 

Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT), rr 6, 407(1)(i), 1619, Sch 2, Pt 2.1

Cases Cited: 

Nova Builders Pty Ltd v Beno Excavations Pty Ltd (No 3) [2023] ACTSC 319

Parties: 

Nova Builders Pty Ltd ( Plaintiff)

Beno Excavations Pty Ltd (First Defendant)

Civil and Civic Corporation Pty Ltd ( Second Defendant)

Representation: 

Counsel

R Arthur ( Plaintiff)

C McKeown (First Defendant)

A Greinke ( Second Defendant)

Solicitors

Lexicon Lawyers ( Plaintiff)

Joseph Tallarita (First Defendant)

Chamberlains Law Firm ( Second Defendant)

File Number:

SC 276 of 2020

MOSSOP J:  

Introduction

  1. These reasons relate to the questions of costs and interest consequent upon the judgment of the court given on 3 November 2023: Nova Builders Pty Ltd v Beno Excavations Pty Ltd (No 3) [2023] ACTSC 319. In these reasons I use the same abbreviations as in the earlier reasons.

  2. That decision determined a claim made by Civil against Nova for $462,003.93. Judgment was given for Nova because it was entitled to set-off two earlier mistaken payments totalling $550,000 made to Civil. The decision also determined a counterclaim made by Nova against Civil for the balance of the mistaken payments, which was a sum of $87,996.07. Judgment was given in favour of Nova against Civil.

  3. Nova seeks its costs of the proceedings on an indemnity basis or alternatively on a solicitor and client basis. It also claims interest on the whole of the amount mistakenly paid to Civil since the date upon which the second of the two mistaken payments was received by Civil.

  4. Civil contends that Nova should pay the costs of its claim for the $462,003.93 and that it should only pay the costs of the plaintiff’s counterclaim from 7 April 2022. It contends that costs should be assessed on a party and party basis. In relation to interest,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nova Builders Pty Ltd v Beno Excavations Pty Ltd (No 5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ACTSC 370
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Nova Builders Pty Ltd v Beno Excavations Pty Ltd (No 5), the Australian Capital Territory Court of Appeal was called upon to decide issues concerning interest and costs in a complex dispute involving multiple parties. The primary dispute involved the entitlement to interest on amounts paid into court by Nova Builders Pty Ltd as part of a set-off against a claim made by Beno Excavations Pty Ltd. The second defendant, Civil, argued that it should be compensated for being kept out of its money, which had been paid into court by Nova. The case also involved a claim for costs on an indemnity basis by Nova and a differing costs order sought by Civil.

The legal issues the court had to decide included whether the plaintiff was entitled to interest on the whole of the amount from the date of the mistaken payment, and whether the court should limit the plaintiff’s entitlement to interest given the circumstances of the mistaken payments. Additionally, the court had to determine the appropriate costs orders given the plaintiff's success on both its defence and counterclaim, and the deliberate conduct of the second defendant that caused the mistaken payments. The court's reasoning hinged on the interpretation of Rule 1619 of the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT), which allows for interest to be awarded in a proceeding for the recovery of money. The court found that the language of the rule was broad enough to permit an award of interest on the whole of the amount from the date of the mistaken payment, and that there was no reason to limit the plaintiff’s entitlement to interest given the circumstances.

The court concluded that the plaintiff was entitled to interest on the whole of the amount from the date of the mistaken payment, and granted leave to amend the claim to include the claim for interest. The court also awarded costs in favour of the plaintiff, finding that there was no reason to award separate costs orders for the defence and counterclaim given the plaintiff's success on both and the deliberate conduct of the second defendant that caused the mistaken payments.

Orders

Orders of the court

See [39].

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Rule 1619(1) provides:1619Interest up to judgment(1)In a proceeding for the recovery of money, including a debt or damages or the value of goods, the court may—(a)order that interest be included in the amount for which judgment is given—(i)at a rate it considers appropriate; and(ii)on all or any part of the money; and(iii)for all or any part of the period beginning on the day the cause of action arose and ending on the day before the day judgment is entered; or(b)order that a lump sum be included in the amount for which judgment is given instead of interest under paragraph (a). The submissions put on behalf of Nova assumed that this language was sufficient to permit an award of interest on the whole of the $550,000. That assumes that a defence by way of set-off comes within the expression of “a proceeding for the recovery of money”. The reference to “recovery of money” in the chapeau is picked up in subs (1)(a)(ii) in the reference to “the money”. Interest is able to be awarded on all or part of the money of which recovery is sought. Although in most cases “the money” (in subs (1)(a)(ii)) will be part of “the amount for which judgment is given” in subs (1)(a), the reference to “the money” is a reference to the chapeau to subs (1), rather than “the amount” in subs (1)(a). The words “the amount for which judgment is given” should be read as if they were “the amount of money for which judgment is given”. The expression “proceeding for the recovery of money” is not defined. It appears consistent with the purpose of the provision that it should be interpreted so as to apply even to an amount claimed as a set-off against a claim made by another party. If it were interpreted as excluding a claim by way of set-off, then there would be the potential for significant practical injustice to arise as a result of the inability to properly take into account the different times at which the primary liabilities were incurred. In the present case, it is clearly appropriate for Nova to be compensated for being kept out of the $550,000 for the period that it was. Nova was tricked into paying money to a party to whom the money was not owed. Civil, on the other hand, was kept out of money that it was owed because Nova, having recognised that it had been tricked and may be liable to pay money to Benex, sought to protect its position by paying the money into court. However, as the money was paid into court, Nova did not have the benefit of the money arising from the non-payment to Civil. In those circumstances, should Civil be compensated by Nova for being kept out of its money? In my view, it should not. Consistent with the findings that I made in the earlier judgment, the mistaken payments were caused by Mr Moseley and Civil. They involved conduct which Mr Moseley knew was wrong. The failure by Nova to pay the $462,003.93 was because the conduct of Mr Moseley and Civil had exposed it to the potential for a claim from Benex and because, if the money had been paid to Civil, it would have been practically lost to Nova. In circumstances where the crisis was generated by the wrongful conduct of Mr Moseley, and where Nova has acted reasonably and did not have the benefit of the money, I do not consider that it is appropriate to incorporate Civil’s notional entitlement to interest on the money paid into court into the calculation of interest to be awarded to Nova.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.