IP AUSTRALIA
AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE
Norwood Immunology Ltd v Regeneus Pt Ltd [2012] APO 132
Patent Application: 2009201915
Title:Therapeutic methods
Patent Applicant: Regeneus Pty Ltd
Opponent: Norwood Immunology Ltd
Delegate: Dr S.D.Barker
Decision Date: 14 December 2012
Hearing Date: Written submissions completed on 19 October 2012
Catchwords: PATENTS – application to serve further evidence – nature of the evidence suggests it could be of significance – other factors of less weight – further evidence allowed
Representation: Patent applicant: Spruson & Ferguson
Opponent:FB Rice & Co
IP AUSTRALIA
AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE
Patent Application: 2009201915
Title:Therapeutic methods
Patent Applicant: Regeneus Pty Ltd
Date of Decision: 14 December 2012
DECISION
I allow the service of further evidence.
The applicant has three (3) months from the date of this decision to serve responding evidence.
I award costs in accordance with Schedule 8 against the opponent.
REASONS FOR DECISION
Regeneus Pty Ltd is the applicant for patent application 2009201915. Norwood Immunology Ltd is the opponent. Evidence in reply to the opposition has been completed. The applicant has applied to serve further evidence, and the opponent has objected. The parties have been heard by way of written submissions on whether the applicant should be allowed to serve further evidence.
The law
Applications for further evidence are governed by regulation 5.10. The relevant subregulations state:
(4) The Commissioner may:
(a) on the application of a party; and
(b) on such reasonable terms (if any) as the Commissioner specifies;
permit the party to serve further evidence on the other party.(5) The Commissioner must not give a direction under subregulation (1) or grant an application under subregulation (2) or (4) unless the Commissioner:
(a)if he or she proposes to grant an application by a party - is reasonably satisfied that the other party has been notified of the application; and
(b)if he or she proposes to act on his or her own motion - ensures that the parties are notified of the proposed action; and
(c)in either case:
(i)gives the parties a reasonable opportunity to make representations concerning the application or proposed action; and
(ii)is reasonably satisfied that a direction, an extension of time or the serving of further evidence is appropriate in all the circumstances.
In the present case I am satisfied that the parties have been notified, and have had an opportunity to make representations (and in fact did make representations). The question that must be considered is whether I am satisfied that it is appropriate to allow the service of the further evidence. In exercising this discretion I am guided by the decisions of Burchett J in Ferocem Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Patents [1994] FCA 981; 28 IPR 243, Sackville J in A Goninan & Co Ltd v Commissioner of Patents [1997] FCA 424; 38 IPR 213 and Goldberg J in National Starch & Chemical Co v Commissioner of Patents [2001] FCA 33; 50 IPR 398 on the operation of regulation 5.10(5) in relation to extensions of time. The general…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Norwood Immunology Ltd v Regeneus Pt Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] APO 132
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the nature of the proposed evidence, its potential significance, and the impact on the interests of both parties. The applicant sought to introduce four statutory declarations addressing experiments, animal data requirements, and document IJR-4, which were issues first introduced in the opponent's evidence in reply. The opponent argued that some of this evidence was available earlier and questioned the necessity and relevance of the proposed new evidence. The court considered that while there was an explanation for the delay in submitting the evidence, the key factor was its potential significance. The evidence, particularly regarding the efficacy of the treatment and the TetraQ study, appeared to be relevant to a dispute in the opposition proceedings. Therefore, the court concluded that the evidence could be of significance and allowed the service of further evidence, while also awarding costs to the opponent.
In allowing the service of further evidence, the court balanced the potential benefits of the new evidence against the delay and the interests of both parties. Given the dispute regarding the efficacy of the treatment, the court found that the new evidence could be relevant, even if it was not conclusive. The court also noted that the opponent would have an opportunity to respond to the new evidence, and granted the applicant three months to serve the responding evidence, considering the Christmas period. The final order was that further evidence could be served, and costs were awarded to the opponent in accordance with Schedule 8.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the Australian Patent Office as an application for permission to serve further evidence in opposition proceedings. The applicant filed the application for further evidence in August 2012, after the opponent completed its evidence in reply in April 2012. Both parties made written submissions on the application. The decision on the application was issued by Dr S.D. Barker, Delegate of the Commissioner of Patents, on 14 December 2012.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the nature and significance of the proposed further evidence suggests it could be of relevance in the opposition proceedings.
2. Whether the delay in serving the further evidence can be sufficiently explained.
3. Whether the interests of the parties and the public interest weigh in favour of or against the service of further evidence.
Held
1. The court held that the nature and significance of the proposed further evidence suggests it could be of relevance in the opposition proceedings.
2. The court held that the delay in serving the further evidence can be sufficiently explained.
3. The court held that the interests of the parties and the public interest weigh in favour of the service of further evidence.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In deciding whether to allow the service of further evidence in opposition proceedings, the court applied the principles set out in the relevant regulations and previous decisions. The court noted that the power to allow further evidence is discretionary and that while a satisfactory explanation for the delay in serving the evidence is relevant, it is not mandatory. The court also considered the nature and significance of the evidence, the interests of the parties, and the public interest in determining the opposition on its merits.
The applicant sought to introduce evidence related to experiments and clinical trial results that were directly relevant to the dispute over the efficacy of the treatment. The court concluded that while the evidence may not be conclusive, it could be of relevance in resolving the dispute. The opponent's objections to the relevance of the evidence were noted, but the court found that the nature and significance of the evidence suggested that it should be allowed.
Regarding the delay in serving the evidence, the court found that there was an explanation for the delay as the new evidence responded to experiments first introduced in the evidence in reply. While the explanation did not cover each specific part of the new evidence, the court accepted that there was an explanation for the delay on the whole.
The interests of the parties were considered, with both parties arguing for either allowing or refusing the further evidence. The court balanced these interests against the potential significance of the evidence and concluded that the evidence should be allowed. The public interest in determining the opposition on its merits was also considered, and the court found that it weighed in favour of allowing the further evidence.
The court ordered the applicant to serve the further evidence within three months and awarded costs in accordance with Schedule 8 against the opponent. The decision followed the principle that costs normally follow the event, but the court saw no reason to depart from this rule in this case.