| [2017] FWC 3113 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.120 - Application to vary redundancy pay for other employment or incapacity to pay
Norwest Child Care Centre Pty. Limited.
v
Cathy Paul & Others
(C2016/7482), (C2016/7483), (C2016/7484), (C2016/7492), (C2016/7493), (C2016/7494), (C2016/7495), (C2016/7496), (C2016/7501), (C2016/7502), (C2016/7504), (C2016/7506)
Educational services | |
COMMISSIONER JOHNS | SYDNEY, 7 JUNE 2017 |
Redundancy - entitlement under the NES - application to vary redundancy pay due to other employment - alternative position acceptable - whether employer obtained the other employment.
Introduction
[1] Norwest Child Care Centre Pty Ltd (Norwest) has made applications to the Fair Work Commission (Commission) pursuant to s.120 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (FW Act) in relation to redundancy payments otherwise due to its former employees. Norwest is seeking that the redundancy payments that would otherwise be due to its employees be reduced by varying percentages on the basis that, it says, it obtained acceptable alternative employment for each of them.
[2] The employees oppose the applications on the basis that, they each say, they obtained the alternative employment for themselves, rather than Norwest.
[3] The applications were all made by Norwest at the same time. Twenty applications were made. However, by the time final submissions were filed, only 12 applications remained outstanding.
[4] The matters were heard together and a common substratum of facts pertained to all of the applications. However, because some circumstances differ in respect of each individual, I have decided to issue this decision with 12 separate schedules. Accordingly, this decision should read as though it is 12 separate decisions each comprising of the substantive body of the decision paragraphs [1] – [48] with the schedule applying to each individual respondent.
[
5] Twelve individual Orders will be issued with this decision.
Hearing
Permission to be represented
[6] The Commission, as presently constituted, granted permission to be represented to those parties who made an application to be represented. Having regard to the nature of various applications that were heard jointly I was satisfied that the matter was invested with sufficient complexity such that I would be assisted in the efficient conduct of the matter if parties were allowed to be represented pursuant to s.596(2)(a) of the FW Act. Consequently, permission was granted to each party who sought to be represented.
The hearing
[7] At the hearings on 10 February 2017, 17 February 2017 and 17 March 2017:
a) the applicant was represented by Mr Mark Hanna, a solicitor,
b) the following respondents were represented by Mr Sam Lavery and Mr James Clifford, solicitors from Laxon Lex Lawyers:
i. Emily Grinter (2016/7483),
ii. Matthew Summons (2016/7493),
iii. Tamara Carter (2016/7496),
iv. Dannielle Johansen (2016/7501),
v. Fernanda Batista (2016/7502), and
vi. Bryn Williams (2016/7506),
(Represented Six)
c) Emma Talbot (2016/7484) represented herself,
d) the following respondents were unrepresented:
i. Cathy Paul (2016/7482),
ii. Jessica Whipps (2016/7492),
iii. Kalesita Kalhau (2016/7494),
iv. Siobhan Robinson (2016/7495), and
v. Naoko Hisada (2016/7504).
Submissions and evidence
[8]
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Norwest Child Care Centre Pty. Limited. v Cathy Paul and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] FWC 3113
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Commission was whether the employer had legitimately obtained the alternative employment and if this employment could be taken into account when calculating the redundancy pay under the NES. The court needed to assess the circumstances surrounding the alternative employment and determine if it was obtained in a manner consistent with the statutory requirements. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the alternative employment could be deemed acceptable for the purposes of varying the redundancy pay.
In its decision, the Commission found that the employer had indeed obtained the alternative employment in a legitimate manner. The court held that the employer's efforts to secure this employment were reasonable and aligned with the statutory provisions. Consequently, the Commission ruled that the alternative employment could be considered in determining the variation of the redundancy pay. The court concluded that the employer's acquisition of the alternative employment was valid and that it could be factored into the calculation of the redundancy pay due to Cathy Paul. The Commission varied the redundancy pay accordingly, taking into account the alternative employment.
The Fair Work Commission ordered that the redundancy pay to Cathy Paul be varied to reflect the alternative employment obtained by the employer. The decision emphasised the importance of the employer's legitimate efforts in securing alternative employment and its relevance in calculating the variation of redundancy pay under the NES. The outcome underscores the need for employers to ensure that any alternative employment is obtained in a manner that complies with statutory requirements, as this can have significant implications for redundancy pay entitlements.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi