JUDGMENT No. 6?.2./.%?-.,.
CATCHWORDS
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - whether member of the Australian Broadcast~ng Tribunal who made
original decision should conduct a rehearing - principles of apprehended bias discussed.
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - costs - discretion
. 3 . . . 1977 (Cth)
NSW PM PTY L- v. m A U S T R A V T I N G TRlBUNAI, RIV-
Davies, Burchett & Foster JJ.
12 November 1990
Sydney
No. G421 of 1990
m THE E U R T Q u u I M u )
) No. G421 of 1990
- )
from a judgment of
a single judge of the Federal Court
BETWEEN:
Appellant
m:
TRIBUNAL
First Respondent
S FM BBPLQ
LIMITED
Second Respondent
ALSO
N R IV-
LIMITED
Cross Appellant
IW AUSTRAUAN TRIBUNAL
First Cross Respondent
Second Cross Respondent
G?lUl: Davies, Burchett & Foster JJ. &&C: 12 November 1990 uiiss: Sydney
The appeal be dism~ssed.
The cross-appeal be dismissed.
Each party abide its own costs.
m: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
)
) No. G421 of 1990
v
) )
- )
Qn from a judgment of a single judge of the Federal Court
lslzw3u: NSW PM PTY LI- Appellant
m:
TRIBUNAL
First Respondent
LIMITED
Second Respondent
ALSO
FM RAPLQ
LIMITED
Cross Appellant
First Cross Respondent Second Cross Respondent
G!UUl: Davies, Burchett & Foster JJ. M: 12 November 1990 &LCG: Sydney
7: This is an appeal from a judgment of a single judge of the Court.
, . . .
Proceedings had been brought in the Court under t - h
1977 ( C t h ) ( " t h e A D J R ) . Northern Rivers PM Radio Limited was the applicant and the Auatralmn Broadcasting Tribunal was the respondent. The learned trial Judge by consent ordered that a report of an inquiry by the Australian Broadcasting Tribunal into the grant of an FM radio licence to serve the Lismore area be set aside and that the matter be referred back to the Tribunal
to be dealt with in accordance with law. The trial Judge was also asked to add the present appellant, Northern NSW PM Pty Limited, as a second respondent in the proceedings. All parties then joined in seeking an order that leave be granted to the applicant, Northern Rivers FM Radio Limited, to amend its application to seek an order that Mr Bruce Allen, the member const~tuting
the Australian Broadcasting Tribunal for the purpose of the report, not sit to hear and determtne the matter again. On that amendment being made, the trial Judge heard counsel for the partles on the question whether or not a direction to that effect should be given. After hearing counsel, the trial Judge directed that Mr Allen not conduct the rehearing.
Tbe trial Judge expressed the issue as fol lows
"Prior to the hearing the parties agreed to the order of review, but the applicant sought an additional order that the member…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Northern NSW FM Pty Ltd v Australian Broadcasting Tribunal and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1990] FCA 642
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Full Bench of the Federal Court held that the trial judge had correctly exercised his discretion in directing that the matter be reheard by a differently constituted tribunal. The principles of natural justice require that a decision-maker should not have already formed a view on the matter to be decided, and that a rehearing by a differently constituted tribunal generally seems fairer to the parties. The Full Bench noted that there was no evidence before the trial judge to show that the ordinary practice should not apply. The Full Bench also held that the costs orders proposed by the trial judge were appropriate, and that the Australian Broadcasting Tribunal, as an intervenor, should abide its own costs.
The appeal and cross-appeal were dismissed, and each party was ordered to bear its own costs. The Full Bench's decision affirms the importance of maintaining public confidence in the administration of justice, and the need to ensure that justice is seen to be done.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter originated as an application for judicial review brought by Northern Rivers FM Radio Limited in the Federal Court. The application was successful, and the trial judge set aside the report of the ABT and remitted the matter back for reconsideration. Northern NSW FM Pty Limited was added as a second respondent, and all parties sought an order that Mr Allen not conduct the rehearing on the ground of apprehended bias. The trial judge agreed and directed that Mr Allen not conduct the rehearing. Both Northern NSW FM Pty Limited and Northern Rivers FM Radio Limited appealed the decision of the trial judge, and the Australian Broadcasting Tribunal intervened as a first cross-respondent. The case was heard by Davies, Burchett, and Foster JJ in the Federal Court of Australia.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the discretion conferred upon the court by s.16(1)(b) of the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 should be exercised so as to give a direction that the rehearing take place before a differently constituted tribunal.
2. Whether the costs orders proposed by the trial judge were appropriate.
Held
1. The appeal against the order directing that the rehearing take place before a differently constituted tribunal should be dismissed.
2. The cross-appeal against the costs order should be dismissed.
3. Each party should bear their own costs.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the discretion conferred by s.16(1)(b) of the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 to determine whether the rehearing should take place before a differently constituted tribunal. The court reviewed the principles of apprehended bias and the circumstances under which it is appropriate to reconstitute a tribunal for a rehearing. The court found that the trial judge correctly exercised his discretion by directing that the rehearing should be conducted by a differently constituted tribunal, as it was in the interests of justice to do so given the extensive and lengthy consideration of the matter by the original tribunal member and the strong views expressed. This decision aligns with the general principle that when a decision is set aside and remitted for rehearing, it is fairer for the matter to be heard by a differently constituted tribunal to maintain public confidence in the administration of justice.
Regarding the costs, the court held that the trial judge's discretion was properly exercised. The court noted that since the appeal and cross-appeal failed, no order as to costs should be made between the appellant and the cross-appellant. Additionally, as the Australian Broadcasting Tribunal intervened as an intervenor, it should bear its own costs. The court concluded that the trial judge's order for each party to bear their own costs was appropriate given the nature of the proceedings and the fact that the issue of tribunal constitution was arguable on both sides.