Noonan and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

Noonan and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) [2023] AATA 3786 (20 November 2023)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):     2022/1680          

Re:Glenn Noonan

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Capital Territory

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member W Frost

Date:20 November 2023

Place:Canberra

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review pursuant to subsection 43(1)(c) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 and makes a decision in substitution that the Australian Capital Territory remains liable to pay compensation to Mr Noonan pursuant to sections 16 and 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988.

The Tribunal will make an order regarding costs in this proceeding pursuant to section 67 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 following receipt of any submissions from the parties which, unless agreed, should be given to the Tribunal by Mr Noonan within seven days of the date of this decision and by the ACT within 14 days of this decision.

............[SGD]................................................

Member W Frost

Catchwords

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – denied liability – workplace injury – condition resulting in incapacity for employment – condition contributed to a significant degree by employment – ‘injury’ pursuant to the SRC Act – ‘disease’ pursuant to the SRC Act – compensation for medical treatment or incapacity – aggravation of acquired deformities – peripheral neuropathy – Charcot foot - decision under review set aside

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 s 43(1)

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ss 4, 5A, 5B, 14, 16, 19, 67

Cases

Telstra Corporation v Hannaford [2006] FCAFC 87

Quinn and Australian Postal Corporation [1992] AATA 668

Woodhouse v Comcare [2021] FCAFC 95

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member W Frost

20 November 2023

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant, Mr Glenn Noonan, applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) for review of a decision made by the Respondent, the Australian Capital Territory (ACT), affirming a determination that it had no present liability to pay him compensation for medical treatment or incapacity under sections 16 and 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act), in relation to his accepted condition of ‘bacterial infection (left) (2nd toe); acute osteomyelitis (left) (2nd toe); and traumatic amputation of toe (left) (2nd toe)’.[1]

    [1] Exhibit 1, pages 279-282 and 286-290.

  2. The Tribunal has considered all of the documents filed pursuant to section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (AAT Act), together with the evidence and submissions provided on behalf of the parties. For the reasons that follow, the Tribunal sets aside the decision under review pursuant to subsection 43(1)(c) of the AAT Act and makes a decision in substitution that the ACT continues to be liable to pay compensation to Mr Noonan pursuant to the SRC Act.

    ISSUES

  3. The issues for the Tribunal to decide in this proceeding were:

    (a)whether Mr Noonan continues to suffer the effects of the accepted ‘injury’ pursuant to the SRC Act;

    (b)if so, whether Mr Noonan needs medical treatment in relation to that condition; and

    (c)whether that condition results in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Noonan and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 3786
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Noonan against a decision by the Australian Capital Territory (ACT) to deny liability for compensation under the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (Cth) (SRC Act). The dispute centred on whether Mr Noonan continued to suffer the effects of an accepted workplace injury, whether this condition required medical treatment, and whether it resulted in an incapacity for employment. Mr Noonan, an ambulance officer, had a history of peripheral neuropathy, diagnosed in 2006, which caused pain and altered sensation in his feet. This condition was later complicated by the amputation of his second toe on the left foot in 2010 and the subsequent development of a Charcot foot, requiring further surgery and ongoing podiatry care. The ACT had denied further compensation, leading to the present proceedings before the Tribunal.

The Tribunal was required to determine three key issues: first, whether Mr Noonan's condition, stemming from his accepted injury, persisted; second, if so, whether he required reasonable medical treatment in relation to that condition; and third, whether the condition caused him to be incapacitated for employment. These questions were to be assessed in light of the provisions of the SRC Act, specifically sections 16 and 19, which provide for compensation for medical treatment and incapacity for work, respectively. The Tribunal considered evidence regarding Mr Noonan's ongoing symptoms, his medical history including the diagnosis of Type 2 Diabetes in 2020, and the impact of his foot condition on his ability to perform his duties as a paramedic.

The Tribunal found that Mr Noonan continued to suffer the effects of his accepted injury, which had been aggravated by the development of a Charcot foot and the amputation of his toe. The Tribunal reasoned that the ongoing pain, difficulty walking, and the need for continued podiatry care and orthotics constituted a requirement for medical treatment that was reasonable in the circumstances. Furthermore, the Tribunal concluded that Mr Noonan's condition resulted in an incapacity for employment, noting his graduated return to work and the ongoing impact of his foot deformity. Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the decision under review and substituted a decision that the ACT remained liable to pay compensation to Mr Noonan under sections 16 and 19 of the SRC Act. The Tribunal also indicated it would make an order regarding costs following further submissions from the parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The issues for the Tribunal to decide in this proceeding were: (a)whether Mr Noonan continues to suffer the effects of the accepted ‘injury’ pursuant to the SRC Act;(b)if so, whether Mr Noonan needs medical treatment in relation to that condition; and(c)whether that condition results in an incapacity for employment. BACKGROUND Mr Noonan is 60 years old.[2][2] Exhibit 1, page 8. In or around 2002, Mr Noonan commenced employment as an ambulance officer with the ACT Ambulance Service. He was previously employed with the New South Wales Ambulance Service since 1993.[3] [3] Exhibit 1, pages 76 and 248. On 20 June 2005, following an assessment of Mr Noonan in May 2005, Dr Brendan Klar, Orthopaedic Surgeon, relevantly reported to his general practitioner as follows:[4]This gentleman has been bothered by pain and tingling in both feet for more than two years. His worst foot is the left foot. He finds that any walking aggravates his pain considerably, and the pain also wakes him at night time. He has been investigated in the past with nerve conduction studies by Colin Andrews which were reported as normal. He has had a glucose tolerance test and vitamin B12 levels, which I understand were all normal.On examination, I can find no abnormality in either foot or ankle which would explain his pain. He has altered sensation and hypersensitivity from the midfoot distally bilaterally. He has no sign of tarsal tunnel syndrome, and no other neurological abnormality. Specifically, he has no long tract signs and no cerebellar signs. I agree entirely with Betty Domazet's assessment, that he has a painful peripheral neurology of unknown aetiology. I think it would be worthwhile trialling Endep at a dose of 10 mg nocte, and increase this to 20 mg nocte if required. I would strongly recommend that he see Roger Tuck for a full neurological review to see if he can find any cause for the neuropathy.[4] Exhibit 3, page 1097. In or around 2005 or 2006, Dr Roger Tuck, Neurologist, diagnosed Mr Noonan with ‘small fibre neuropathy’ of unknown cause.[5][5] Exhibit 2, pages 43-44, 47 and 64; Exhibit 3, page 1096. On 30 November 2006, Mr Noonan was diagnosed with ‘acute paronychia’, which he had not noticed due to ‘sensory loss’.[6][6] Exhibit 2, page 44; Exhibit 3, pages 1055-1056, 1067-1068, 1091 and 1098. On 19 December 2010, Mr Noonan presented to Calvary Hospital with what was recorded as ‘swollen L toes’.[7] The clinical notes recorded ‘small peripheral node neuropathy’ and ‘many years of numbness to forefoot’.[8] A discharge report of the same date stated that:[9][7] Exhibit 1, page 33. [8] Exhibit 1, page 34. [9] Exhibit 1, page 35.Glenn presented to the ED with some left forefoot/second toe pain and redness. We discussed his background history of the peripheral neuropathy, obesity, ? glucose intolerance, ? mild hypertension.o/e marked onychomycoses, second toe - mtp joint centred pain and redness, afeb, BP 144/88Pt had an xray to exclude him developing a crahcot’s [sic] foot – I thought this showed a small calcaneal spur – I wonder whether he sometimes suffers with some plantar fasciitis.Bloods showed a high urate, normal FBC, normal CRP.The Discharge Diagnosis wasgout.onychomycosis.obesity. [emphasis in original]

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Sections 16 and 19 of the SRC Act respectively provide for compensation to be payable in respect of the cost of medical treatment obtained in relation to the injury (being treatment that it was reasonable for the employee to obtain in the circumstances) and for the payment of compensation to an employee who is incapacitated for work as a result of an injury.EVIDENCELay evidence Mr Noonan The Tribunal has considered the undated written statement made by Mr Noonan during the course of this proceeding.[74] Mr Noonan also gave evidence at the Tribunal hearing and confirmed adherence to his written statement.[74] Exhibit 2, pages 1-3. Mr Noonan told the Tribunal that he was currently on a graduated return to work with reduced days, while undergoing rehabilitation following the amputation of his lower right leg in November 2022. He is performing ambulance road duties as a paramedic of approximately 20 hours per week on a rotating roster of two 10 hour shifts each week. The graduated return to work will see Mr Noonan return to full duties by mid-November 2023. This will comprise four 12-hour day shifts on a full rotating roster of four days working and four days off work. In December 2010, shortly before the amputation of Mr Noonan’s second toe on his left foot, he was performing normal ambulance road duties, comprising 10-hour day shifts and 14-hour night shifts on a rotating roster. Following the amputation of his second toe on the left foot, Mr Noonan had a period of time off work. Mr Noonan told the Tribunal that, when first diagnosed, his peripheral neuropathy caused ‘slight numbness’, an ‘altered sensation’ in the forefoot and ‘discomfort’ when walking. Prior to his recent lower right leg amputation, Mr Noonan experienced these issues equally in both feet. In 2020, Mr Noonan was diagnosed with Type 2 Diabetes. From 2010, he recalled having the usual blood tests, but no specific diabetes test because there was no such concern. Mr Noonan currently takes medication to maintain his blood sugar level. Mr Noonan told the Tribunal the deformity of his left foot due to the amputation of his second toe caused him ‘anxiety and stress’ if walking barefoot, and that the changed structure of his foot causes pain and difficulty walking or standing for long periods of time. He received treatment from his podiatrist, Mr Donnelly, whom he first saw in early 2013 and continues to consult. Mr Noonan told the Tribunal he found walking after the amputation ‘somewhat difficult’ because he had more pain in his foot. Mr Noonan said that he attended on the Ankle and Foot Surgeon, Dr Sullivan in 2014 seeking a second opinion because he was not entirely happy with the progress of his left foot condition. On 4 June 2014, Dr Sullivan performed surgery to Mr Noonan’s mid-forefoot and added a staple to help ‘stabilise the bones’, together with a screw. The cost of this surgery was covered by Comcare, being the relevant insurer at the time, having accepted that it was related to Mr Noonan’s workplace injury. He had further surgery with Dr Sullivan around 2016 because there was a bone which was ‘starting to cause a pressure area’. He continues to have ongoing podiatry care with Mr Donnelly. Mr Noonan’s workers’ compensation claim for orthotics made by Mr Donnelly was accepted by the ACT in mid-2021.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Accordingly, the usual course in circumstances where the Tribunal has set aside the decision under review and made a decision that is more favourable to Mr Noonan under the SRC Act would be for the Tribunal to order that his reasonable costs in this proceeding be paid by the ACT, as agreed or taxed. The parties did not make any express submission on the issue of costs in this proceeding. Unless the Tribunal is informed that the parties reach agreement as to costs in this proceeding following the publication of this decision, the Tribunal will receive any further submissions from Mr Noonan regarding this issue within seven days of the date of this decision, and from the ACT within 14 days. The Tribunal will then proceed to make an order in relation to costs pursuant to section 67 of the SRC Act. DECISION The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review pursuant to subsection 43(1)(c) of the AAT Act and makes a decision in substitution that the ACT remains liable to pay compensation to Mr Noonan pursuant to sections 16 and 19 of the SRC Act. The Tribunal will make an order regarding costs in this proceeding pursuant to section 67 of the SRC Act following receipt of any submissions from the parties which, unless agreed, should be given to the Tribunal by Mr Noonan within seven days of the date of this decision and by the ACT within 14 days of this decision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.