Nolan v Owners Units Corporation No 369 (Unit Titles)

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL



NOLAN & ANOR v OWNERS UNITS CORPORATION NO 369

(Unit Titles) [2014] ACAT 32

UT 14/6

Catchwords:    Units Titles – proposal to replace carpet flooring with bamboo floating floor in unit – whether change of flooring is a structural alteration – whether floor covering change needs an unopposed resolution at a general meeting of owners corporation – addressing noise problem in installation of timber floor – whether concern of adjoining unit owner could be a reason for not calling an owners corporation meeting – a meeting would be an opportunity to present information to unit owners about proposed replacement of carpet with wooden floor

Legislation:Owners Corporations Act 2006 (Vic), s 132

Unit Titles Act 2001, s 34
Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011, s 24 and Schedule 4 (default rules 4 and 8)

Subordinate
Legislation:   
Building (General) Regulations 2008, regulation 23

Strata Schemes Management Regulation 2010, regulations 14 and 15

Cases:            Owners SP 10701 v Segelov & Ors [1999] NSWSSB 61

Smith v Hoopman [2005] NSWCTTT 291
United Petroleum v Skorpos and Anor [2012] SASC 151

Tribunal:                  Ms E. Symons – Presidential Member

Date of Orders:  26 May 2014  
Date of Reasons for Decision:         26 May 2014

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY              )
CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL          )  UT 14/6

BETWEEN:

LUKE NOLAN &

MARIA CLAIR VICTORIA

Applicant

AND: THE OWNERS UNITS

CORPORATION NO. 369

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:             Ms E Symons – Presidential Member

DATE:26 May 2014

ORDER

The Tribunal determines that the removal of carpets and the installation of a floating bamboo floor is not an erection or alteration to the structure as provided in default rule 4(i)(a) in Schedule 4 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 and the removal and installation does not require the approval of the owners corporation.

………………………………..

Ms E. Symons – Presidential Member

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

  1. In November 2013, the applicants purchased unit 10 in The Quadrant, 8 Howitt Street, Kingston. The relevant Units Corporation is No. 369. The Quadrant does not have specific Body Corporate Rules; it is governed by the default rules in Schedule 4 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 (UTMA).

  2. Prior to the settlement of the purchase of unit 10, the applicants sought, in writing,  permission from the owners corporation to change the flooring in their unit after settlement, by replacing carpet in the living areas, the kitchen and the hallway to the bedrooms with a bamboo floating floor with noise minimising underlay which meets the Building Code of Australia.

  3. Mr Darren Walton, from ACT Strata Management Services, on behalf of the owners corporation, informed the applicants in writing on 16 September 2013 that the approval process for alterations and erections is by Special Resolution at a General Meeting or Annual General Meeting of Owners. He also informed the applicants that if the process is to be held outside of the Annual General Meeting, a Special General Meeting can be requested with approval from the requesting unit’s adjoining properties.

  4. On 14…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nolan v Owners Units Corporation No 369 (Unit Titles) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] ACAT 32
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Nolan, sought a determination from the ACAT regarding the legality of replacing carpet flooring with a bamboo floating floor in their unit. The dispute arose because the owners corporation, Owners Units Corporation No 369, had refused to approve the change, claiming it required unanimous consent under the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011. Nolan argued that the change was merely a replacement of floor covering and did not constitute a structural alteration.

The court was required to determine whether the proposed replacement of the flooring constituted a structural alteration that needed approval from the owners corporation. The court had to examine the definition of a structural alteration under the Act and consider whether the change of floor covering required the unanimous consent of all unit owners as per the Act's default rules. Additionally, the court needed to address whether the concern of an adjoining unit owner could be a reason for not convening a general meeting of the owners corporation.

The ACAT found that the replacement of the carpet with a bamboo floating floor did not constitute an erection or alteration to the structure as defined in the Act. The Tribunal held that the change was merely a replacement of floor covering and did not require the approval of the owners corporation. The ACAT emphasised that the concern of an adjoining unit owner should not be a reason for not calling a general meeting, as such meetings provide an opportunity to present information to all unit owners. The Tribunal determined that the replacement of the flooring did not require the approval of the owners corporation.

The Tribunal ordered that the removal of carpets and the installation of a floating bamboo floor did not constitute an erection or alteration to the structure under the Act and did not require the approval of the owners corporation.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal determines that the removal of carpets and the installation of a floating bamboo floor is not an erection or alteration to the structure as provided in default rule 4(i)(a) in Schedule 4 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 and the removal and installation does not require the approval of the owners corporation.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Disputes involving the owners corporation—generally(1)This section applies to a dispute relating to an owners corporation for a units plan between the corporation and any 1 of the following:(a)an owner or occupier of a unit in the units plan;(b)the manager (if any) for the owners corporation;(c)a service contractor for the owners corporation;(d)an executive member.(2)A party to the dispute may apply to the ACAT for an order in relation to the other party if the application relates to the dispute. Disputes between unit owners(1)This section applies to a dispute relating to an owners corporation for a units plan between 2 or more unit owners. (2)A party to the dispute may apply to the ACAT for an order in relation to the other party if the application relates to the dispute. Kinds of ACAT orders(1)The ACAT may make the following orders:(a)an order requiring a party to do, or refrain from doing, a stated thing;(b)an order requiring a party to exercise a function under this Act;(c)an order requiring an owners corporation to do a stated thing that is ancillary to a function of the corporation under this Act;(d)an order requiring a person to pay to the Territory or someone else an amount of not more than $1 000;(e)a declaration—(i)that a general meeting or executive committee meeting is void for irregularity; or(ii)that a resolution of a general meeting or executive committee meeting is void for irregularity; or(iii)that a rule of the owners corporation is invalid for irregularity;(f)an order repealing or amending a resolution of a general meeting or executive committee based on a merits review of the resolution by the ACAT;(g)an order giving effect to an unsuccessful motion for a resolution of a general meeting (either as originally proposed or as amended by the ACAT) if the ACAT is satisfied after a merits review of the motion that opposition to the motion was unreasonable;(h)an order requiring stated accounts of an owners corporation to be audited, whether by a stated person or a person of a stated kind;(i)an order allowing an applicant to examine records of the owners corporation;(j)an order requiring an owners corporation to make or repeal a rule and register a copy of the resolution making or repealing the rule;(k)an order appointing an administrator to exercise all or stated functions of the owners corporation, the executive committee or an office-holder in the committee;(l)if the dispute relates to a matter mentioned in section 126 (1) (a)—an order to remove the animal from the unit if—(i)a condition requiring the owners corporation’s consent to keeping the animal is not complied with; or(ii)the animal is causing a nuisance.(2)The ACAT may make any other order it considers reasonably necessary or convenient to resolve a dispute under this part.(3)This section does not limit the orders the ACAT may make in relation to a dispute under this part. Definitions—default rules(1)In these rules:executive committee representative means a person authorised in writing by the executive committee under rule 10 (4).owner, occupier or user, of a unit, includes an invitee or licensee of an owner, occupier or user of a unit.(2)A word or expression in the Act has the same meaning in these rules.