NOEL CARROLL and DAVID CHRISTOPHER HARPER

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

IN THE MATTER of the Patents Act 1952

‑ and ‑

IN THE MATTER of Patent Applications No. 12421/83 and No. PF5180 in the name of NOEL CARROLL and DAVID CHRISTOPHER HARPER

‑ and ‑

IN THE MATTER of Determination under Section 63

DECISION OF AN ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS
     In the period from 4 March 1982 to 10 August 1982 six applications, each accompanied by a provisional specification, were lodged in the name of Noel Carroll and David Christopher Harper by their patent attorneys, Davies & Collison, Melbourne.  One of these is application No. PF5180, the others were cognated by a complete specification lodged on 3 March 1983, also in the name of Mr Carroll and Mr Harper, and treated as application No. 12421/83.
     On 26 April 1983, Davies & Collison on behalf of Noel Carroll lodged a letter in the Patent Office requesting that the Commissioner determine, under the provisions of Section 63 of the Patents Act, the manner in which the above applications are to proceed.  It was stated in the letter that "in consequence of cessation at least by 15 February 1983 of arrangements as to joint ownership of the inventions the subject of the applications, and of the applications themselves, Noel Carroll then became solely entitled to the benefit of the said inventions and applications, and the applications are to proceed solely in the name of Noel Carroll".  An affidavit by Noel Carroll and dated 18 April 1983 accompanied the letter.
     A request for determination under Section 63 (Form 15), as prescribed

by Regulation 24(1), was lodged on 31 May 1983.  Copies of the request, the letter by Davies & Collison and the affidavit were served on Mr Harper in United Kingdom on 18 July 1983, thus satisfying the requirements of Regulation 24(2)(a).  The request was advertized in the Official Journal on 25 August 1983 as prescribed by Regulation 24(4).  Consequently, the period within which a person interested in the application could give a notice if he desires to be heard, as prescribed under Regulation  24(5), expired on 6 October 1983.
         Since no notice was received in the Office within the above period, and because Mr Carroll wanted to finalize the matter as soon as possible in order to secure the earliest priority date to his related applications in other countries, the matter was set down for hearing in Canberra on 28 October 1983, the earliest practical date.
         At the hearing Noel Carroll was represented by Mr Keith Leslie, a patent attorney of Davies & Collison, Melbourne and Mr G. Browne, Mr Carroll's solicitor.
         At the outset of the hearing Mr Browne pointed out that the Patents Act and Regulations lack procedural requirements relating to a hearing of this type.  However, he submitted that his client, Mr Carroll, had satisfied all the requirements having complied with Section 63 and Regulations 24 and that it is proper to proceed with this hearing based on the material available.
         He made an observation, before discussing the Mr Carroll's…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read NOEL CARROLL and DAVID CHRISTOPHER HARPER and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1983] APO 47
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves a dispute between Noel Carroll and David Christopher Harper over patent applications for inventions related to hydrocyclones and oil recovery systems. The matter was brought before the Assistant Commissioner of Patents to determine how the applications should proceed, as per the Patents Act 1990 and relevant regulations. The central issue was whether Harper was entitled to remain as a co-applicant on the patent applications, given the breakdown of their joint venture agreement.

The court examined the evidence presented, including affidavits and correspondence, to assess whether an agreement existed between the parties and if it was subsequently breached by Harper. Carroll argued that Harper failed to fulfill his obligations under the agreement, such as paying for shares in a jointly owned company and securing a license for the hydrocyclone invention. Harper did not participate in the hearing, nor did he provide any evidence or submissions to counter Carroll's claims. The Assistant Commissioner concluded that an agreement did exist and that Harper had breached it by not fulfilling his part. As a result, the Commissioner directed that the patent applications should proceed solely in the name of Noel Carroll.

The final orders of the court were that the patent applications No. PF5180 and No. 12421/83 should proceed exclusively in the name of Noel Carroll, effective immediately. This decision was based on the breach of the joint venture agreement by David Christopher Harper, who failed to meet his obligations under the terms agreed upon with Noel Carroll.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established