Noble v Whitelock

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Noble v Whitelock & Ors [2020] QIRC 069

PARTIES:

Noble, Charlotte
(Complainant)

v

Whitelock, Rod
(First Respondent)

&

Motton, Brett
(Second Respondent)

&

Toowoomba Motors Pty Ltd
(Third Respondent)

CASE NO:

AD/2019/119

PROCEEDING:

Referral of a complaint

DELIVERED ON:

8 May 2020

HEARING DATE: 

11 March 2020

MEMBER:

HEARD AT:

O'Connor VP

Brisbane

ORDERS:

1. Pursuant to s 175(2) of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld) I permit the matters predating May 2018 to be included within the claim.

CATCHWORDS:

ANTI-DISCRIMINATION–DISCRIMINATION IN THE WORKPLACE – time limits on referred complaints – discretion to accept complaints outside time limits – where some complaints were made more than 1 year after the alleged contravention – whether on the balance of fairness it is reasonable to include complaints – relevant considerations

LEGISLATION:

CASES:

Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld) s15, s119, s129, s175
Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 372

Buderim Ginger v Booth (2003) Qd R 147; [2002] QCA 177
Campbell v United Pacific Transport Pty Ltd [1966] Qd R 465
Donchi v Broadhead & AMP Shopping Centres Pty Ltd [2001] QADT 14
Hopper v Mount Isa Mines Ltd and others [1997] QADT 3
Lucic v Nolan [1982] FCA 232; 45 ALR 411
Marijanovic v Chalmers Industries Pty Ltd and Davis [2008] QADT 4
Singh v State of Queensland [2015] QCAT 318
Wong v Medical Board of Queensland & Ors [2006] QADT 41

APPEARANCES:

Ms K Khamsone of Holding Redlich

Mr W Ash of Mills Oakley

Reasons for Decision

  1. Charlotte Noble commenced as a Used Vehicle Sales Supervisor at Toowoomba Motors Pty Ltd on 13 February 2017. She reported to Rod Whitelock, the Used Vehicle Sales Manager and Brett Motton, the Dealer Principal.

  2. On 23 May 2019 a complaint was filed with the Anti-Discrimination Commission (the pre-cursor to the Queensland Human Rights Commission) setting out details of her sexual harassment complaint for the period March 2017 to 26 February 2019.

  3. The complaint referred by the QHRC are as follows:

    (a) the Complainant was subject to sexual harassment by her manager, Mr Whitelock, while employed by Toowoomba Motors Pty Ltd ("Toowoomba Motors") in contravention of s119 of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld)("the Act");

    (b) the Complainant was discriminated against in the work area on the basis of her sex in contravention of s15 of the Act;

    (c) the Complainant has been victimised in contravention of s129 of the Act.

  4. The question before the Commission is whether the Tribunal should exercise its discretion under s175 of the Act to deal with the out-of-time allegations. Section 175 provides as follows:

(1) [One year after contravention ends] The Tribunal must accept a complaint that is referred to it by the Commissioner, unless the complaint was made to the Commissioner more than one year after the alleged contravention of the Act.

(2) [Tribunal may deal with complaint] If the complaint was made more than one year after the alleged contravention, the Tribunal may deal with the complaint if the Tribunal considers that, on the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Noble v Whitelock and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QIRC 69
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Noble v Whitelock, the Anti-Discrimination Tribunal of Queensland was tasked with determining whether the complainant, Ms Noble, could include complaints made more than one year after the alleged contravention of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld). The dispute centred on Ms Noble's claims of discrimination and harassment by her employer, Toowoomba Motors, and specifically whether the tribunal had the discretion to accept her complaints outside the statutory time limits. The tribunal needed to decide if it was reasonable, on the balance of fairness, to include the out-of-time complaints in the proceedings.

The central legal issue was whether the tribunal had the discretion to accept complaints made beyond the one-year statutory limit, particularly when some elements of the complaint were out-of-time while others were within time. The tribunal examined relevant considerations such as the nature of the alleged discrimination, the explanation for the delay, and whether the respondent had suffered any actual prejudice due to the delay. Ms Noble argued that her delay in lodging the complaint was justified due to her pursuit of other legal remedies and the continuous nature of the alleged discrimination. The tribunal found that the length of the delay was not excessive, given the ongoing nature of the alleged contraventions, and that Ms Noble had provided a reasonable explanation for the delay. Additionally, the respondent did not provide any evidence of actual prejudice resulting from the delay.

The tribunal concluded that it was reasonable, on the balance of fairness, to permit the out-of-time complaints to be included within the claim. The tribunal adopted the reasoning of Atkinson P in Hopper v Mount Isa Mines Ltd, which suggested that the correct approach was to view the behaviour in the context in which it occurred rather than examining each alleged incident in isolation. The tribunal emphasized the importance of allowing Ms Noble the opportunity to have her complaint determined justly. Therefore, the tribunal exercised its discretion under section 175(2) of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld) to permit the matters predating May 2018 to be included within the claim.

ORDER:
1. Pursuant to s 175(2) of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld) I permit the matters predating May 2018 to be included within the claim.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 175(2) of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld) I permit the matters predating May 2018 to be included within the claim.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is difficult, if not impossible in the present circumstances to determine the relative merits or otherwise of the Complainant's case. This is particularly so in the absence of the statement of facts and contentions.Conclusion The Tribunal has the capacity to deal with complaints made more than one year after the alleged contravention of the Act. The Tribunal may deal with the complaint if the Tribunal considers that, on the balance of fairness between the parties, it would be reasonable to do so. What is alleged is a pattern of behaviour which commenced shortly after the Complainant commenced her employment at Toowoomba Motors and continued until she ended her full-time employment. The alleged discrimination and harassment were "continuing in nature". This is not a case where there has been a failure by the Complainant to commence proceedings within time. Rather it is a case where some elements of the complaint are out-of-time while others are within time. The Complainant contends that she made complaints to Brett Motton, the Dealer Principal. That allegation is denied. In explaining the delay, the Complainant sought legal advice as to her options. She pursued other causes of action including a WorkCover claim and an application to the Fair Work Commission pursuant to s372 of the Fair Work Act 2009. The pursuit of other options are not of itself a sufficient basis upon which I should refuse to exercise the discretion in her favour. The length of the delay is not excessive in the context that the matters complained of allegedly occurred throughout the Complainants employment. I am satisfied that the Complainant has provided an explanation for the delay. There is no evidence before the Tribunal that it would not be possible to call relevant witnesses or to adduce evidence to defend the claim. Whilst I accept that the onus of satisfying the Tribunal to exercise the discretion to extend time remains on the Complainant, the Respondents have not advanced any argument or produced any evidence of actual prejudice consequent upon the delay. I respectfully adopt the reasoning of Atkinson P in Hopper v Mount Isa Mines Ltd and others that the correct approach is not to examine each alleged incident or episode in isolation but rather view it in the context in which the behaviour is said to have occurred. To decline to exercise the discretion at such an early stage in the hearing, particularly before the Statements of Facts and Contentions have been filed would deprive the Complainant of the opportunity to have a just determination of her complaint which alleges a contravention of the Act. On the balance of fairness between the parties, it would be reasonable to permit the matters predating May 2018 to be included within the claim. Order1. Pursuant to s 175(2) of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld) I permit the matters predating May 2018 to be included within the claim.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.