Noble v Vorreiter No. DCCIV-03-1908

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

Noble v Vorreiter
[2004] SADC 25

Judge Lee
Civil

  1. This is a tenant’s appeal from a decision and orders of the Residential Tenancies Tribunal on 27 November 2003.

  2. The tenancy, which is with respect to premises in Unley, commenced on 24 May 2003, and is due to end on 23 February 2004.  The rent was and remains $500 per week, payable monthly.

  3. On applications by both the landlord and the tenant, the Tribunal determined that:

    1.   following non-payments of rent, the tenancy be reinstated subject to payment of rent for the balance of the term, with possession to the landlord upon the tenant’s further default

    2.   it was not satisfied that the rent of $500 per week was excessive

    3.   to the extent that the landlord had failed to provide the premises in a reasonable state of repair, the landlord should pay compensation to the tenant in the sum of $1,200.

  4. The tenant appeals from the second and third of the determinations.  As a condition of an earlier order of this Court granting a stay, the tenant has paid ongoing rent into court to await the outcome of the appeal.

  5. I mention by way of background that the Tribunal inspected the premises on 1 July 2003, being the occasion of an earlier dispute between the parties.  In reasons for decision at that time, the Tribunal said:

    “I also find the premises are not in a reasonable state of repair.  I viewed the premises on 1 July 2003.  Many of the walls and ceilings are cracked.  There are cracks between cornices and ceilings.  The cornice in the dining room has moved and is out of alignment in one corner.  The cracking is particularly bad in the master bedroom and adjoining front section of the hallway.  There is also a significant crack in the ceiling over the kitchen bench.  There is evidence of dust falling between the ceilings and cornices in some of the bedrooms.  There is a small gap in the flooring at the door of the master bedroom.  Grout is missing in the separate toilet, ensuite bathroom and main bathroom.  The area behind the kitchen sink is not properly sealed.  I find that these defects are such that the premises are not in a reasonable state of repair.”

  6. I will deal first with the issue of rent. Section 56 of the Residential Tenancies Act 1995 provides:

    “56. (1) The Tribunal may, on application by a tenant, declare that the rent payable under a residential tenancy agreement is excessive.

    (2) In deciding whether the rent payable under a residential tenancy agreement is excessive, the Tribunal must have regard to-

    (a)    the general level of rents for comparable premises in the same or similar localities; and

    (b)    the estimated capital value of the premises at the date of the application; and

    (c)     the outgoings for which the landlord is liable under the agreement, and

    (d)    the estimated cost of services provided by the landlord and the tenant under the agreement; and

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Noble v Vorreiter No. DCCIV-03-1908 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] SADC 25
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Noble v Vorreiter is an appeal from a decision of the Residential Tenancies Tribunal. The tenant, Noble, appealed the Tribunal's decision that the rent of $500 per week was not excessive and that the landlord, Vorreiter, should pay $1,200 in compensation for the disrepair of the premises. The appeal was heard by Judge Lee in the South Australian District Court. The tenant argued that the Tribunal erred in its assessment of the evidence regarding the excessiveness of the rent and the compensation for the disrepair. The landlord contended that the Tribunal had correctly assessed the evidence and made the appropriate determinations.

The primary legal issue the court had to decide was whether the Tribunal's assessment of the excessiveness of the rent and the compensation for the disrepair was correct. The court examined the reports submitted by the tenant and the factors outlined in the Residential Tenancies Act 1995. The court also considered the landlord's submissions regarding the state of repair of the premises.

Judge Lee found that the Tribunal erred in concluding that the evidence was insufficient to establish the general level of rents for comparable premises. The court considered that the reports submitted by the tenant provided sufficient information to assess the excessiveness of the rent and found that a fair rent in all the circumstances would be $320 per week. The court also found that the landlord acted with reasonable diligence in effecting repairs, except in some instances. However, the court found that the award of $1,000 for "discomfort, inconvenience and distress" should be discharged.

The court ordered that the agreement be varied by reducing the rent to $320 per week from 11 November 2003. The court will hear the parties on the orders which should now be made to finally dispose of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established