Nobel House Group Pty Ltd v Medisystems Technology Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

patents act 1990

decision of a delegate of the commissioner of patents

Re:Application for extension of time by MEDISYSTEMS TECHNOLOGY CORPORATION under section 223 to file statement of grounds and particulars.

background

Patent Application 683541 by Nobel House Group Pty Ltd (Nobel House) was advertised accepted on 13 November 1997. Medisystems Technology Corporation (Medisystems) filed a notice of opposition on 6 February 1998.  No statement of grounds and particulars was filed in the prescribed period (that ended 6 May 1998).  Medisystems applied on 12 May 1998 for an extension of time of one month under section 223 in order to file a statement of grounds and particulars.  Nobel House objected on 5 June 1998 to the application for an extension of time.

The hearing on the extension of time took place in Canberra on 15 July 1998.  Representing Medisystems was Peter Maxwell (patent attorney of Peter Maxwell and Associates).  Representing Nobel House was Paul A Grant (patent attorney).

The application for an extension of time

"The circumstances in which, and the grounds upon which, this application is made are as follows:

Due to an error on the part of our Patent Attorney, the Statement of Grounds and Particulars was not lodged by the due date of 6 May 1998.  The particulars of that error will be set forth in a declaration of Peter Francis Maxwell to be lodged as soon as it is received from America."

Evidence

The evidence supplied by Peter Maxwell and Associates in support of their application comprises two declarations by Peter Maxwell filed on 19 May 1998 and 13 July 1998.  The later declaration was accompanied by exhibits identified as:

(i)  PFM1 Copy of  the general diary for 6 May 1998.
(ii) PFM2  Copy  of the general diary for 13 May 1998.

The declaration and associated exhibits suggest to me that the following chronology of events took place:

  1. Mr Maxwell's firm had lodged a Notice of Opposition on 6 February 1998 on behalf of Medisystems Technology Corporation against Patent Application 683541 of Nobel House Group Pty Ltd.

  2. Mr Maxwell made the following diary entries in the general diary used by the firm for Oppositions, Opinions, Searches and the like:

6 May 1998                98-7-005 Nobel House finalise G&P due 13/5

13 May 1998              98-7-005 Nobel House LODGE S.G+P.

  1. On the morning of the 7 May 1998 while checking the files prior to catching a flight to the United States of America Peter Maxwell found that the due date for filing the statement of grounds and particulars was in fact 6 May 1998.

  1. Mr Maxwell phoned the Patent Office on 7 May 1998 advising that he would be seeking an extension of time in the following week.

  1. Mr Maxwell filed the application for the extension of time to file the statement of grounds and particulars on 12 May 1998.

  1. Mr Maxwell filed the statement of grounds and particulars on 13 May 1998.

SUBMISSIONS

I will refer to the submissions of both parties where relevant in the decision.

Decision

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nobel House Group Pty Ltd v Medisystems Technology Corporati... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] APO 56
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Medisystems Technology Corporation's application for an extension of time to file a statement of grounds and particulars in opposition to Patent Application 683541 by Nobel House Group Pty Ltd, the delegate of the Commissioner of Patents was required to decide whether the application should be granted. The decision hinged on whether Medisystems could demonstrate an error or omission by their patent attorney, Peter Maxwell, that led to the late filing of the statement of grounds and particulars. Nobel House argued that the late filing was due to a deliberate decision by Medisystems rather than an error, and that the application form was improperly filed.

The court examined the evidence provided, including diary entries and declarations from Peter Maxwell, to determine if there was an error or omission that warranted an extension under section 223 of the Patents Act 1990. It found that Maxwell's mistake in calculating the due date for filing the statement of grounds and particulars constituted an error within the meaning of section 223(2)(a). The court also concluded that the form, despite its initial inconsistency, was intended as an application for an extension of time and could be considered as such. The delegate found no procedural lapses by either party that would invalidate the application. Considering the interests of all parties and the public, the delegate decided to grant the extension of time to Medisystems, allowing them to file their statement of grounds and particulars within one month from the date of the decision. No costs were awarded to either party.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established