Nnadi (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

Nnadi (Migration) [2019] AATA 6329 (7 November 2019)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

APPLICANTS:  Mrs Grace Nneka Nnadi
Mr Anthony Okechukwu Maduike

CASE NUMBER:  1725040

HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE:                BCC2017/2968942

MEMBER:Rosa Gagliardi

DATE:7 November 2019

PLACE OF DECISION:  Melbourne

DECISION:The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and substitutes a decision not to cancel the first named applicant’s Subclass 500 (Student) visa.

The Tribunal has no jurisdiction with respect to the second named applicant.

Statement made on 07 November 2019 at 2:30pm

CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION – Cancellation –Student (Temporary) (Class TU) visa – Subclass 500 visa – visas were granted as a result of suspected fraudulent conduct – strong performance in her education – genuine temporary entrant requirements met– no direct link between the allegedly corrupt Departmental officer and the grant of the visa to applicant– decision under review set aside

LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958, ss116, 140, 189, 348
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), r 2.43

CASES
Tien & Ors v MIMA (1998) 89 FCR 80
Patel v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCA 165
Rani & Ors v MIMA (1997) 80 FCR 379
Zhao v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 1235

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision dated 12 October 2017 made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection to cancel the first named applicant’s (the applicant) Subclass 500 (Student) visa under s.116 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

  2. The delegate cancelled the visa under s.116(1)(g) of the Act on 12 October 2017 on the basis that the applicant had enlivened regulation 2.43(1)(o) because the delegate reasonably suspected that the visa had been “obtained as a result of the fraudulent conduct of any person”. The issue in the present case is whether that ground for cancellation is made out, and if so, whether the visa should be cancelled.

  3. For the purposes of the Tribunal’s jurisdiction under s.348 of the Act, the only decision that is before the Tribunal is the decision with respect to the first named applicant. The second named applicant’s visa was automatically cancelled as a consequence of that cancellation, not by a decision but by force of the operation of s.140(1) of the Act which made the cancellation of the second named applicant’s visa self-executing on the cancellation of the first named applicant’s visa: see Rani & Ors v MIMA (1997) 80 FCR 379 at 385, 393, 400; Tien & Ors v MIMA (1998) 89 FCR 80 at 96. As no decision was involved in the visa cancellation under s.140(1), the Tribunal has no jurisdiction with respect to the second named applicant.

  4. The first-named visa holder, Ms Nnadi, appeared before the Tribunal on 21 August 2019 to give evidence and present arguments. Unfortunately, the primary visa holder’s spouse,


    Mr Anthony Okechukwu Maduike, has since passed away in Australia.  The Tribunal also took evidence from a relative of Ms Nnadi over the phone.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nnadi (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 6329
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal reviewed the decision to cancel the Student (Temporary) (Class TU) Subclass 500 visa held by Ms Nnadi, a Nigerian national. The visa had been granted to Ms Nnadi and her late husband, who was a dependent on her application. The cancellation was based on a suspicion that the visas were obtained as a result of fraudulent conduct by a Departmental officer.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the ground for cancellation under regulation 2.43(1)(o) of the Migration Regulations 1994 was established. This regulation permits visa cancellation if the decision-maker reasonably suspects that the visa was obtained as a result of fraudulent conduct by any person, not necessarily the visa holder. The Tribunal was required to determine if there was a causal connection between the alleged fraudulent conduct and the grant of Ms Nnadi's visa.

The Tribunal reasoned that regulation 2.43(1)(o) requires a reasonable suspicion that the visa would not have been granted "but for" the fraudulent conduct. Applying the "but for" test, the Tribunal found insufficient evidence to establish a direct link between the alleged misconduct of a Departmental officer and the grant of Ms Nnadi's visa. While acknowledging that a cohort of visas granted by a particular officer were under investigation for suspected fraud, the Tribunal noted that the investigative reports did not directly implicate Ms Nnadi or her husband in facilitating any fraudulent conduct. The Tribunal concluded that the delegate had not provided credible evidence demonstrating that the visa would not have been granted had the application been processed without the alleged fraudulent conduct, particularly as Ms Nnadi met the substantive criteria for the visa.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the decision to cancel Ms Nnadi's visa.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision to cancel the applicant’s visa should be set aside.Background The visa holder is a 30 year old National Nigerian, from Imo State, who is a widow and had been married to the second named visa applicant who died in Australia. Ms Nnadi’s first and only arrival in Australia was on 26 March 2017 holding a Student (Temporary) (Class TU) Subclass 500 visa. This student visa was granted to Ms Nnadi on her enrolment in a Diploma of Leadership and Management and Advanced Diploma of Leadership and Management. This student visa was valid until 4 August 2021. Ms Nnadi included her husband, Mr Anthony Maduike, in her student visa application and he was also granted a dependent student visa. He too arrived in Australia on 26 March 2017. Alerts in relation to Ms Nnadi’s application were raised by the departmental investigations into the circumstances leading to the grant of Ms Nnadi and her dependent’s student visas. It was considered by the delegate that a Departmentally employed officer may have acted improperly to grant the visas and it appeared that the visas were granted as a result of suspected fraudulent conduct. Accordingly, Ms Nnadi’s visa was cancelled and that of her husband’s was cancelled consequentially under section 140 of the Act. This resulted in Ms Nnadi and Mr Maduike’s being Unlawful Non-Citizens in the community and they were detained pursuant to section 189 of the Act before being granted a Bridging visa to remain in the community while Ms Nnadi was seeking review of the cancellations at the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. At that time a delegate was satisfied that Ms Nnadi and her spouse would abide by their Bridging visa conditions and accepted Ms Nnadi’s reassurances that they would return to Nigeria were they to be unsuccessful on review. It was after Ms Nnadi and Mr Maduike were released from detention on the Bridging visas that Mr Maduike passed away.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE Under s.116 of the Act, the Minister may cancel a visa if he or she is satisfied that certain grounds specified in that provision are made out. Relevantly, to this case, these include the ground set out in s.116(1)(g). If satisfied that the ground for cancellation is made out, the decision maker must proceed to consider whether the visa should be cancelled, having regard to all the relevant circumstances, which may include matters of government policy.Does the ground for cancellation exist?s.116(1)(g) - prescribed ground A visa may be cancelled under s.116(1)(g) if the Minister is satisfied a prescribed ground for cancelling the visa applies to the applicant. The prescribed grounds for cancellation are set out in r.2.43 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (the Regulations). In the present case, the ground in r.2.43(1)(o) is relevant. Regulation 2.43(1)(o) allows the Minister or his delegate to cancel a visa if he reasonably suspects that the visa has been obtained as a result of fraudulent conduct of any person. The fraudulent conduct does not have to be confined to the visa holder.Evidence and reasoning for the cancellation by the delegate

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

A visa may be cancelled under s.116(1)(g) if the Minister is satisfied a prescribed ground for cancelling the visa applies to the applicant. The prescribed grounds for cancellation are set out in r.2.43 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (the Regulations). In the present case, the ground in r.2.43(1)(o) is relevant. Regulation 2.43(1)(o) allows the Minister or his delegate to cancel a visa if he reasonably suspects that the visa has been obtained as a result of fraudulent conduct of any person. The fraudulent conduct does not have to be confined to the visa holder.Evidence and reasoning for the cancellation by the delegate On 13 February 2017, Ms Nnadi lodged a student visa application electronically via the Department’s online processing system. Mrs Nnadi was granted a Class TU subclass 500 Student – Vocational Education visa on 23 February 2017 by an officer of the Department’s post in Pretoria, South Africa. Departmental records indicate that Ms Nnadi arrived in Australia as the holder of the Class TU subclass 500 Student – Vocational Education visa on 26 March 2017. Broadly, Departmental investigations into the circumstances surrounding the grant of Ms Nnadi’s Class TU subclass 500 Student – Vocational Education visa led the Department to conclude that a Departmental officer ‘may’ have acted improperly to grant the visa and that the visa was granted as a result of reasonably suspected fraudulent conduct [Tribunal emphasis]. The Tribunal is unable to provide the detailed nature of the fraud conducted by an immigration official/s in the Australian High Commission in Pretoria, partly because it has not been provided with the entirety of the investigative reports, however, the delegate relied on a number of reports in relation to an investigation undertaken by the Department about alleged misconduct by such officials. It is important to note that none of these reports refer in anyway directly to Ms Nnadi and her late husband. According to a document provided to the Tribunal “Visa Cancellation Referral Report” dated 10 August 2017, from Australian Border Force, the Department identified a link between offshore nationals engaging in criminal activity and visas granted by a Departmental officer working at the Australian High Commission in Pretoria. This led to a joint investigation with the Australian Commission for Law Enforcement Integrity (ACLEI). Again, the Tribunal has found little evidence in these reports that would link Ms Nnadi and her husband facilitating any fraudulent conduct by the relevant Departmental officer. Some of the allegations involved officials possibly knowingly granting visas for personal financial gain. The features of this caseload, including that of the applicant which attracted suspicion, involved cases being decided expeditiously without the required scrutiny and verification. Specifically, the alleged conduct by the officials in the Australian High Commission in Pretoria involved Department officers ‘bypassing’ the mandatory allocation of the grant of visas to Nigerian applicants, who were identified as high risk on the basis of their nationality, and without following the ‘otherwise rigorous assessment’ process that would have been applied to Nigerian applicants as part of the Department’s risk profiling. The processes involved more in depth assessments which included a direction to ‘check employment and education documents for any evidence of fraud’ as specified in ‘Student Visa Assessment Methodology’, attached to the Visa Cancellation Referral Report. It is alleged that funds were paid to these Departmental officers by third parties who were associated with Nigerian students at the Australian colleges referred to in the report.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Regulation 2.43(1)(o) requires the decision-maker to reasonably suspect that the visa was obtained as a result of fraudulent conduct, suggesting a causal connection is required. The task for the Tribunal is therefore to assess whether Ms Nnadi’s visa was granted as a direct result of fraudulent conduct by any person.The but for test and the decision in Odinkaeze The Tribunal notes that it has been unable to find evidence of why the delegate had a reasonable suspicion that fraudulent conduct had occurred with respect to the grant of Ms Nnadi’s visa specifically, except the vague reasons that her application was caught up with a batch being dealt with by a Departmental officer alleged to have engaged in misconduct over a cohort of cases generally. The delegate in cancelling the visa did not dispute that Ms Nnadi met the criteria for the visa but considered that even though she did meet the criteria, this did not mean that the grounds for cancellation were not enlivened. In its decision in Odinkaeze, the Tribunal found that “to have a reasonable suspicion that a visa was granted ‘as a result of the fraudulent conduct’, there would need to be some evidence the visa would not have been granted but for the fraud”.[5][5] See decision by Deputy President and Division Head Jan Redfern and Dr Colin Huntly, 17 May 2018, Ms Ogochukwu Concilia Odinkaeze – Decision no: 1725482. This approach was expounded in another decision of the Tribunal in Mbelu (Decision: 1725196):In Odinkaeze the Tribunal was not satisfied there was sufficient evidence to found a reasonable suspicion that the applicant’s visa was obtained as a result of the fraud of the allegedly corrupt Departmental officer. While there was evidence of the fraudulent conduct by the Department officer in respect of the grant of student visas to Nigerian nationals more generally, the Tribunal was not satisfied on the basis of the evidence that there was a link between the fraudulent conduct as described more generally in the Investigation Reports LES Misconduct and the granting of the visa of Ms Odinkaeze. The ‘but for’ approach indicates that the grounds for cancellation do not arise if it cannot be shown through probative evidence that the visa was granted as a direct result of fraudulent conduct by anybody. Departmental policy PAM3 also provides that “[I]t is not enough to reasonably suspect that there was fraudulent conduct by a person – the delegate must reasonably suspect that if it were not for the fraudulent conduct the visa would not have been granted”. The Tribunal has, therefore, examined whether had Ms Nnadi’s application been processed by an officer who was not tainted with maladministration, she would have been granted the visa on the basis of the information provided by her regarding her education and work experience, which is the only basis upon which the visa was cancelled. Whether a lack of verification of employment and education is enough to make a factual finding that the visa was granted to Ms Nnadi as a result of fraudulent conduct is questionable. The Department has not submitted any credible evidence to demonstrate that the verification had not occurred and what such verification might have entailed. The decision in Odinkaeze states:Information that a Department Officer did not verify employment or educational records would not be sufficient if there is evidence to suggest those records are genuine and can be verified. If the records are genuine and the application has been processed in accordance with the Student visa methodology, her application would have been granted.Requirements for the grant of a Student (Temporary) (Class TU) Subclass 500 visa

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established