NKFV and Director-General of Security (Intelligence and security)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

NKFV and Director-General of Security (Intelligence and security) [2025] ARTA 266 (26 March 2025)

Applicant:NKFV

Respondent:  Director-General of Security

Tribunal Number:                2024/1588

Tribunal:Deputy President Britten-Jones

Place:Melbourne

Date:26 March 2025

Decision:Pursuant to s 140(3) of the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024, the Tribunal dismisses the Applicant’s application for the adverse security assessment decision to be reviewed again.

..................[SGD]......................................................

Deputy President Britten-Jones

Catchwords

Intelligence and Security – application under s 140(2) of the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 for a decision relating to an adverse security assessment to be reviewed again – application brought under s 54(2) of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Act 1979 prior to abolition of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal – consideration of whether to apply the law as it was as at the date of the application or the date of the Tribunal’s decision – the application proceeds under s 140 of the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 – whether further evidence of material significance has become available – whether the further evidence was not available at the time of the initial review - Tribunal dismisses the Applicant’s application for the decision to be reviewed again

Legislation

Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Act 1979
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975
Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024

Administrative Review Tribunal (Consequential and Transitional Provisions No.1) Act 2024

Cases

Esber v Commonwealth (1992) 106 ALR 577
NKFV and Director-General of Security [2024] AATA 269
SDCV v Director-General of Security [2021] FCAFC 51
SDCV v Director-General of Security [2022] HCA 32

Secondary Materials
Explanatory Memorandum, Administrative Review Tribunal (Consequential and Transitional Provisions No. 1) Bill 2023 (Cth)

Transcript of Proceedings, NKFV v Director-General of Security (Administrative Review Tribunal, 2024/1588, Deputy President Britten-Jones, 27 February 2025)

Statement of Reasons

  1. NKFV (the Applicant) applied unsuccessfully to review an adverse security assessment in NKFV and Director-General of Security [2024] AATA 269 which was a decision delivered by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the AAT) on 9 February 2024 (the Initial Review).

  2. The adverse security assessment had been made on 1 February 2023. Following the determination of the Initial Review, the Applicant applied for a further review by application dated 15 May 2024 pursuant to the now repealed and substituted s 54(2) of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Act 1979 (ASIO Act). 

  3. Section 54(2) of the ASIO Act was in effect as at the date of this application and provided:

    At any time after the completion of a review by the Tribunal of a security assessment (other than a review of a security assessment made for the purposes of subsection 202(1) of the Migration Act 1958), an application may be made for review of the findings of the Tribunal on the ground that the applicant has fresh evidence of material significance that was not available at the time of the previous review.

  4. The Respondent contends that s 140 of the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (the ART Act) applies to this further application for review…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read NKFV and Director-General of Security (Intelligence and secu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 266
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of NKFV and Director-General of Security (Intelligence and security), the applicant sought a review of an adverse security assessment under section 140(2) of the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024. The application was brought prior to the abolition of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, under section 54(2) of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Act 1979. The primary legal issue was whether the law applicable should be that in force at the time the application was made or at the time the Tribunal made its decision. The Court determined that the application should proceed under section 140 of the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024. The central issues were whether further evidence of material significance had become available and whether this evidence was not available at the time of the initial review. The Tribunal dismissed the applicant’s application for the decision to be reviewed again.

The Tribunal found that the evidence the applicant sought to adduce was available at the time of the initial review. The applicant had expressly admitted that the evidence was within her knowledge at the time of the initial review. The Court held that there is no residual discretion to allow a further review in circumstances where the statutory criteria were not satisfied. The Tribunal concluded that the applicant had failed to satisfy the second limb of section 140(3) of the ART Act because the further evidence was in fact available at the time of the initial review. The applicant also failed to satisfy the first limb of section 140(3) because the evidence was available at the time of the initial review and had not become available since then.

The Tribunal held that the applicant had ample opportunity to present the evidence at the initial review. The applicant deposes to a significant amount of evidence, including details about her employment history, family background, and migration decisions. However, the Tribunal found that this evidence was available at the time of the initial review and the applicant had chosen not to present it. The evidence was relevant to issues expressly raised at the initial review, and the applicant’s decision not to give evidence at that time was critical. The Tribunal found that the applicant’s reasons for not providing evidence at the initial review did not justify a further review.

In conclusion, the Tribunal dismissed the applicant’s application for the decision to be reviewed again. The Court held that the applicant had failed to satisfy the statutory criteria for a further review under section 140(3) of the ART Act. The evidence sought to be adduced was available at the time of the initial review, and the applicant had not demonstrated that the evidence had become available since then. The Court found that the applicant had ample opportunity to present this evidence at the initial review and chose not to do so. The Tribunal’s decision was affirmed, and the application was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Applicant expressly admitted at [7] of her Statement of Grounds dated 15 May 2024 that ‘the evidence [my emphasis] that is now provided was within her knowledge’. Being ‘within her knowledge’ means that it was available to her at the time of the Initial Review. The reasons for her choosing not to give evidence at the earlier hearing are not relevant to the elements of s 140(3). It is clear from the terms of s 140(3) that there is no residual discretion to allow a further review in circumstances where the limbs in subsections (a) and (b) are not satisfied. I conclude that the further evidence sought to be adduced by the Applicant was in fact available at the time of the initial review and, therefore, the Applicant has failed to satisfy the second limb of s 140(3) of the ART Act. The application must be dismissed on that basis alone. The Applicant has also failed to satisfy the first limb of s 140(3) because the evidence that she deposes to in her affidavit was available at the time of the Initial Review and hence, it has not ‘become available’ since that hearing. The Applicant deposes in her affidavit that she will ask the Tribunal to issues summons to numerous witnesses but it appears from the evidence that those summons could have been issued for the Initial Review hearing. The evidence now sought to be adduced is very significant and includes topics as follows:(a)How and why I ended up in Ireland(b)How I came to be employed in the space industry(c)My growing role in the space industry and involvement with the International Astronautical Federation(d)How I became involved with SpaceSpecialists and pathway to Australia(e)Our alternative pathway – Canadian immigration in 2019(f)My family background and why it is relevant(g)Alex’s family history(h)My family history. All of the above evidence was available at the Initial Review. It cannot be said that it only became available later. Indeed, some of the evidence sought now to be adduced is relevant to issues expressly raised at the Initial review which is apparent from references to it in the reasons for the earlier decision of the Tribunal. I provide two examples below. First, included in the Applicant’s affidavit is evidence seeking to counter the allegation that she may act as a “talent spotter”, but this issue is dealt with by the Tribunal’s reasons at [55]. This evidence was not only available to the Applicant, but it was raised as an issue at the Initial Review when she chose to give no evidence about it. Second, the Applicant also seeks to give evidence about her decision to migrate to Australia, but this issue was also raised at the Initial Review and is dealt with in the Tribunal’s reasons at [35] and [36]. Again, this evidence was not only available to the Applicant, but it was raised as an issue at the initial review when she chose to give no evidence about it. The evidence in the Applicant’s affidavit was available to the Applicant at the time of the initial review, but she chose not to rely on it.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I conclude that the applicable law is the ART Act and the ASIO Act as amended. The application of the applicant for a further review should be determined in accordance with s 140(3) of the ART Act.APPLICATION FOR DECISION TO BE REVIEWED AGAIN Having decided that the law applicable to this application is s 140(3) of the ART Act, I must dismiss the application unless satisfied that:(a) further evidence of material significance has become available; and(b) the further evidence was not available at the time of the initial review. If the Tribunal is not satisfied with respect to both the above limbs, the application must be dismissed. There is no discretion that would apply even if the Tribunal were of the view that the further evidence is relevant to issues in the application. The previous application to the Tribunal was heard on 14, 15 and 16 August and 7 September 2023. The decision under review was affirmed by written decision on 9 February 2024. The reasons included a statement as follows:[59] The Applicant did not submit any affidavit evidence to the Tribunal, and did not give any oral evidence. At the hearing the Applicant’s counsel provided some explanation as to why the Applicant did not want to give evidence but in particular, referred to the fact that the Applicant having had a number of interviews with ASIO had “no idea” of what was in the confidential information. The Applicant has provided an affidavit dated 15 May 2024 which sets out the ‘new evidence’ on which the Applicant seeks to rely. The Applicant deposes to a very significant amount of evidence over 25 pages plus a further 96 pages of annexures. I accept that the evidence sought to be adduced is of material significance. In support of this application, the Applicant lodged a Statement of Grounds which included:[7] The applicant accepts that the evidence that is now provided was within her knowledge at the time of the previously constituted review.[8] The Applicant also accepts that the Respondent was critical of the Applicant’s decision not to provide evidence prior to the commencement of the previous hearing. Those criticisms are not justified given the context of this application is set out below.[9] Ultimately, at no stage prior to a decision being reached by the previously constituted Tribunal was the Applicant in a position where she could be confident that she knew the case against her, or confident that she was in possession of all the material and information that would be available to her. The Applicant was therefore never in a reasonable position to assess what evidence was materially significant. …[16] It was not until receipt of the Respondent’s closing submissions in reply that it became clear that the Respondent did not establish a motive, instead contending that motive is not necessary to establish that the applicant poses an enduring risk to security. By the time this position became clear, the applicant was unable to provide any material or submissions to the contrary.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.