NKDL and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

NKDL and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2024] AATA 3148 (4 September 2024)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2022/6987

Re:NKDL

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndPWSR

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Member L M Gallagher

Date:4 September 2024

Place:Perth

The Tribunal affirms the decision of the AAT1 dated 16 August 2022 that:

(i)The Other Party provides 100% care of the Child from 1 November 2020, with effect from 24 January 2022; and

(ii)The Applicant provides 0% care of the Child from 1 November 2020, with effect from that date.

...............[Sgd].........................................................

Member L M Gallagher

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

CATCHWORDS

CHILD SUPPORT – percentage of care – whether there was a change in care – actual care – date of effect – evidence – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) ss 49, 49(1)(a), 49(1)(b), 50, 50(1)(a), 50(1)(b), 50(3), 51, 54A(1), 54A(3), 54F, 54F(1)(c), 54F(3)(b)(i), 54F(3)(b)(ii), 54G, 54G(2)(b), 54H, 54H(1)(c), 54H(3)(b)(i), 54H(3)(b)(ii) and 55C

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) ss 6(2AC)16(2AB), 87AA(1)

Family Assistance and Child Support Legislation Amendment (Protecting Children) Act 2018 (Cth)

CASES

Minister for Home Affairs v G and Another [2019] FCAFC 79

Polec & Staker & Anor [2011] FMCAfam 959
P v Child Support Registrar [2013] FCA 1312
P v Child Support Registrar [2014] FCAFC 98

Parent 1 and Child Support Registrar and Parent 2 [2013] AATA 562

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Guides to Social Policy Law: Child Support Guide

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member L M Gallagher

4 September 2024

THE APPLICATION

  1. The Applicant seeks review of a decision of the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT1) dated 16 August 2022 (the Reviewable Decision).[1]  The Reviewable Decision:[2]

    (a)Set aside the decision under review;[3] and in substitution, decided that:

    (i)The Other Party provides 100% care of the Child from 1 November 2020, with effect from 24 January 2022; and

    (ii)The Applicant provides 0% care of the Child from 1 November 2020, with effect from 1 November 2020.

    [1] R1, T2.

    [2] R1, T2.

    [3] Being the Respondent’s objection decision dated 22 April 2022.  See R1, T24 and [10] below.

    ISSUE

  2. The issue for determination by this Tribunal, being the General Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal), is the Applicant’s and the Other Party’s respective percentages of care of the Child from the relevant commencement date.[4] 

    [4] The relevant commencement date, being the date on which the change of care occurred (if indeed the Tribunal finds a change in care did occur), are findings of fact addressed by the Tribunal below.  As the care period is now in the past, these percentages must correspond to the actual care that took place…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read NKDL and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 3148
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review by the Tribunal of a child support decision. The dispute was between the Applicant and the Other Party, the separated parents of two children, concerning the percentage of care for their older child. The core of the dispute was whether there had been a change in the actual care arrangements for the child from 1 November 2020, and if so, from what date any new determination of care percentages should take effect.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the existing percentage of care determination, which reflected the Other Party having 51% care and the Applicant having 49% care from 16 March 2019, should be revoked and replaced. If revocation was warranted, the Tribunal also needed to determine the new percentage of care and the date from which this new determination should have effect. The relevant legislative framework included provisions for the revocation of care percentages and the commencement dates for new determinations, particularly considering whether notification of a change in care occurred within 28 days of the change.

The Tribunal considered the evidence presented by both parties regarding the child's living arrangements and financial contributions. While the Applicant did not participate in the initial Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) hearing, his previous statements indicated the child chose to move between parents' houses. However, the AAT was satisfied that the existing care percentage determination did not reflect the actual care taking place. Consequently, the AAT revoked the existing determination and made new ones, finding the Other Party provided 100% care and the Applicant 0% care from 1 November 2020. The AAT determined that the Other Party's increased care percentage took effect from 24 January 2022, as the change was notified more than 28 days after it occurred, while the Applicant's decreased percentage took effect from 1 November 2020. The Applicant subsequently applied for a review of this decision.

The Tribunal affirmed the AAT's decision, finding that the existing care percentage determination did not reflect the actual care of the child. It was determined that the Other Party provided 100% care and the Applicant 0% care from 1 November 2020. The Tribunal upheld the commencement date of 24 January 2022 for the Other Party's increased care percentage, as the change was notified outside the 28-day period. The Applicant's decreased care percentage was confirmed to have effect from 1 November 2020.

Background

Background to the litigation

If the Tribunal finds that there was a change in the percentage of care from the relevant commencement date, the percentage of care determined by the AAT1 on 16 August 2022 should be revoked and replaced. If, and only if, this is the case, the following remaining issues fall for consideration:(a)What is the new percentage of care determination?(b)What is the date from which the new percentage of care determination should have effect for the purposes of child support? Generally speaking,[5] this date would be either:[5] However, see further discussion at paras [22]–[23] below. ·From the date the objection was lodged,[6] which was on 21 February 2022;[7] or·From the date that the change in care was notified, being 24 January 2022.[8] [6] Section 87AA(1) of the Collection Act provides that where an objection is not lodged within 28 days of a percentage of care determination, and the objection is allowed in a way that has the effect of varying the percentage of care determination or substituting a new care percentage determination, the objection decision will have effect from the date the objection was lodged.[7] R1, T17, p 166.[8] R1, T13, p 145.BACKGROUND The Applicant and the Other Party are the separated parents of two children. The present application relates only to the care of one of those children, being the older child of the two (the Child). A child support case was first registered in relation to the Child on 1 August 2020.[9][9] R1, T31, p 260. For completeness, the child support case for the child ended in 2021 as a result of the child reaching 18 years of age. With effect from 1 May 2019, the assessment of child support for the Child reflected that, from 16 March 2019, the Other Party had 51% care of the Child and the Applicant had 49% care of the Child (existing care percentage determination).[10][10] R1, T31, p 254 On 24 January 2022, the Other Party notified a delegate of the Respondent that from [11] R1, T13, p 145..1 November 2020, she had 100% care of the Child and the Other Party had 0% care of the Child.[11] On 15 February 2022, a delegate of the Respondent decided that there was insufficient evidence from both parties regarding their respective percentages of care of the Child and rejected the change in care reported by the Other Party (original decision).[12][12] R1, T15, pp 151-152. On 21 February 2022, the Other Party objected to the original decision.[13][13] R1, T30, p 226. On 22 April 2022, a delegate of the Registrar disallowed the Other Party’s objection (objection decision).[14][14] R1, T24, pp 184-186. On 13 May 2022, the Other Party applied to the AAT1 for a first review of the objection decision.[15][15] R1, T2, p 5. On 16 August 2022, the AAT1 made the Reviewable Decision.[16] In its decision, the AAT1:(a)Noted the Other Party’s contention that the Child had lived with her full-time since November 2020, while their other child lived full-time with the Applicant.[17](b)Noted that, while the Applicant did not participate in the AAT1 hearing, the evidence showed that, in a conversation with a delegate of the Respondent, the Applicant had stated that the Child chose to move between the parents’ houses.[18](c)Was satisfied that the existing care percentage determination did not reflect the care of the Child that was actually taking place, and decided to revoke the existing care percentage determination and make new determinations that the Other Party was providing 100% care to the Child and the Applicant was providing 0% care to the Child from 1 November 2020.(d)Determined that:(i)the Other Party’s increased care percentage of 100% from 1 November 2020 had effect from 24 January 2022,[19] because the Other Party had notified the change in care more than 28 days after the change in care occurred; and(ii)the Applicant’s decreased care percentage of 0% from 1 November 2020 had effect from 1 November 2020.[20][16] R1, T2.[17] R1, T2, p 6.[18] R1, T2, p 7.[19] R1, T2, p 8.The Tribunal considers this date was incorrectly recorded and should read 23 January 2024, being the day before the notification of the change in care in accordance with s54F(3)(b)(i) of the Assessment Act.[20] R1, T2, p 8.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal is satisfied that all the relevant evidence was before the Tribunal and that the parties were provided an opportunity to address it, either orally or in writing. The Parties’ evidence The Applicant and the Other Party gave evidence and made submissions in support of their respective positions, in writing and orally at hearing.[38][38] See A1 to A7, OP1 and OP2 and transcript, pp 12 to 31.The Applicant The Applicant gave evidence that he got a car for the Child when she was about [39] See A1, for example, and Transcript pp 12-13.16 or 17 years old so that she could do her driving lessons in it. The Applicant said that he paid all the car expenses such as registration, insurance, fuel, servicing and parts as well as for the driving lessons the Child took at the time.[39] The Applicant said that the Child has had the use of the car since she obtained her licence to the present day, and that he still pays for the related expenses. As to the private health insurance membership he previously maintained for the Child, the Applicant said that this has been cancelled and he cannot recall the exact years during which he held the policy.[40][40] Transcript, p 13. Regarding the statement from his Father that the Applicant had been responsible for the full time care of the Child since she was born,[41] the Applicant added that his Father ‘sees[41] A2.[42] Transcript, p 15.[the Child] a lot,’[42] so it is on this basis that his Father knows this to be the case. When asked to give context to his evidence of having purchased camera equipment and a laptop for the Child in August 2022,[43] as well as art equipment in the past, the Applicant said his purchases served as replacement items from when the Child’s items were stolen from the car in June 2022. The Applicant said that the camera equipment was for the Child’s personal use.[44][43] This being outside the relevant period for present purposes.[44] Transcript, p 16. As to the invoice for the Child’s school fees for 2019 issued to the Applicant,[45] the Applicant said he paid the Child’s school fees for the 2019 school years as well as the fees for some of the other school years. The Applicant said the Child had won a school scholarship in [45] A5.[46] Transcript, p 16.year 11, and so, he believes, the Child paid her own school fees for year 12.[46] When asked about the bundle of documents provided that included bank statements and telephone bills,[47] the Applicant said some of the bank records are for items he has paid for and that he has also sent money to the Child for other things. The Applicant said that the Child first got a mobile phone in high school and that he usually paid $100 per month for the Child’s phone expenses, which he currently still pays.[48][47] A6.[48] Transcript, p 18. In addition, the Applicant emphasised that he helped the Child get a job at her local IGA, where she worked on Thursday nights and Saturday mornings while she was in year 11 and part of year 12. The Applicant said he would drop the Child off and pick her up from her job, reflecting that the Child stayed with him at those times, that is, on those days of the week that the Child worked at the IGA. The Applicant said that these weren’t the only nights that the Child would stay with him because they were doing a lot of driving lessons together in the evenings at that time.[49][49] Transcript, pp 20-21.The Other Party

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 22 April 2022, a delegate of the Registrar disallowed the Other Party’s objection (objection decision).[14][14] R1, T24, pp 184-186. On 13 May 2022, the Other Party applied to the AAT1 for a first review of the objection decision.[15][15] R1, T2, p 5. On 16 August 2022, the AAT1 made the Reviewable Decision.[16] In its decision, the AAT1:(a)Noted the Other Party’s contention that the Child had lived with her full-time since November 2020, while their other child lived full-time with the Applicant.[17](b)Noted that, while the Applicant did not participate in the AAT1 hearing, the evidence showed that, in a conversation with a delegate of the Respondent, the Applicant had stated that the Child chose to move between the parents’ houses.[18](c)Was satisfied that the existing care percentage determination did not reflect the care of the Child that was actually taking place, and decided to revoke the existing care percentage determination and make new determinations that the Other Party was providing 100% care to the Child and the Applicant was providing 0% care to the Child from 1 November 2020.(d)Determined that:(i)the Other Party’s increased care percentage of 100% from 1 November 2020 had effect from 24 January 2022,[19] because the Other Party had notified the change in care more than 28 days after the change in care occurred; and(ii)the Applicant’s decreased care percentage of 0% from 1 November 2020 had effect from 1 November 2020.[20][16] R1, T2.[17] R1, T2, p 6.[18] R1, T2, p 7.[19] R1, T2, p 8.The Tribunal considers this date was incorrectly recorded and should read 23 January 2024, being the day before the notification of the change in care in accordance with s54F(3)(b)(i) of the Assessment Act.[20] R1, T2, p 8. On 27 August 2022, the Applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of the Reviewable Decision.[21][21] R1, T1.LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK The relevant legislation is contained within the:(a)Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) (the Assessment Act); the (b)Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) (the Collection Act); and the(c)Family Assistance and Child Support Legislation Amendment (Protecting Children) Act 2018 (Cth) (the Amendment Act).[22] If there has been a change in the pattern of care subsequent to a percentage of care determination, a new percentage of care determination can be made only if the existing percentage determination that was made under ss 49 or 50 of the Assessment Act in respect of a particular care period is revoked, under Subdivision C of Division 4 of Part 5 of the Assessment Act (ss 49(1)(b) and 50(1)(b) of the Assessment Act).[28] For completeness, s 51 of the Assessment Act may apply in circumstances where a care arrangement, such as a Court order, applies in relation to a child or children, but actual care does not or did not comply with the relevant care arrangement.Revocation of existing care percentages The revocation of care percentages is dealt with in Subdivision C of Division 4 of Part 5 of the Assessment Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Other Party responded to the Applicant’s evidence regarding the Child’s school fees, health insurance for the Child and other expenses, as follows:[52][52] Transcript, pp 24 to 29.(a)The Child received a scholarship in the amount of what might have been $1,000, for outstanding school work. The money went towards a MacBook computer, which she and the Child went ‘halves in’.[53](b)Regarding the Child’s school fees, she believes that after her separation from the Applicant, he did go in and pay for half of one year’s school fees for the Child. She was in charge of paying for the majority of the Child’s schooling. She was given money from her stepfather for doing so, given their low-income situation.[54](c)Regarding the theft of the contents of the car, this occurred around March or April 2022,[55] when the Child and her partner were on their way on holiday. The camera belonged to the Child’s partner, not her, and the laptop, iPad, and art equipment that were stolen belonged to the Child. She understood the Applicant had an insurance claim for those items.[56](d)As to the Child’s health insurance policy, while the Other Party and the Applicant were in partnership she ‘always maintained a family policy for essentials cover’. Just prior to their separation, the Applicant opened his own health insurance fund because his needs were beyond the essentials cover. After their separation, the Applicant added the Child (and their younger daughter) to his policy and paid for a family policy without her knowledge. At that time, she was continuing to pay the existing family policy, so the Child (and her younger sister) were being insured twice. She understands though, that the Applicant took ownership of the additional policy to cover the Child’s (and her younger sister’s) orthodontic care. She has since reinstated essential cover for herself, the Child and her younger sister.(e)The Child’s mobile phone was purchased when the Child started high school and was billed to the Applicant’s business account. The Applicant continues to pay for the Child’s phone although the Child has the financial capability to meet this expense herself.[57](f)The same applied to the Child’s car. The Applicant executed all the driving lessons with the Child, paid for the car in full, paid for registration and fuel even though the Child could take responsibility for this herself. The Other Party recognised that it is an extremely generous gesture from the Applicant, and a way that he feels he can care for his daughter.[58][53] Transcript, p 24.[54] Transcript, p 25.[55] Again, this is outside the relevant period for present purposes.[56] Transcript, p 26.[57] Transcript, p 27.[58] Transcript, p 28.CONSIDERATION The Reviewable Decision concerns the care of the Child in the period 1 November 2020 (the date of the claimed change in care)[59] to 26 November 2021 (being the day before the child turned 18 years of age) (the care period).[59] The Other Party contends that the Child was 100% in her care from 1 November 2020 onwards. See [7] above.Whether the existing care percentage determination should be revoked and replaced