IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Office of the Registry
Sydney No S62 of 2022
B e t w e e n -
NINE ENTERTAINMENT CO PTY LIMITED (ACN 122 205 065)
First Applicant
NINE DIGITAL PTY LIMITED
(ACN 077 753 461)Second Applicant
NINE NETWORK AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 008 685 407)
Third Applicant
ALEX HEINKE
Fourth Applicant
and
ANDREA KYLE‑SAILOR
Respondent
Application for removal
GAGELER J
GLEESON J
JAGOT J
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
AT SYDNEY ON FRIDAY, 18 NOVEMBER 2022, AT 10.34 AM
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
____________________
MR D.A. McLURE, SC: May it please the Court, I appear for this matter for the applicants with MR T.O. PRINCE. (instructed by Thomson Geer Lawyers)
MR R. MERKEL, KC: If the Court pleases, I appear with my learned friends MR J.E. HARTLEY and MR T.M. WOOD for the respondent. (instructed by Levitt Robinson Solicitors)
GAGELER J: Thank you, Mr Merkel. Mr McLure.
MR McLURE: Your Honours, section 18C of the Racial Discrimination Act generates attention of two worthy ideals. On the one hand, the elimination of harmful conduct by reason of race and the other being the freedom to communicate about political matters, including matters of race in the sense held by this Court in Wotton, even if the idea or the rhetorical method may cause offence.
Neither freedom is, of course, absolute, and neither may be enjoyed without detriment. In terms of the factors relevant to the removal that we seek, we start from the premise – rather, the accepted premise by the respondent that the constitutional issue which we seek to raise is an important one in the sense that it has not been the subject of binding determination by this Court and is, consequently, also ripe.
GAGELER J: Well, the problem is not the facts and the possibility of a defence applying and being made out. It is the prematurity of this Court dealing with this issue at this stage. That is the problem for you.
MR McLURE: None of the factual questions that are necessary for the determination of the constitutional question will require contest. They all may be determined within the four corners of the three impugned publications. Your Honour is correct to say that there would be a contest about the defence under section 18D, but it is our position that if the Court arrived at that position, that would be a matter for remittal. We do not seek the determination of the section 18D defence in this Court
and it is not necessary to decide that defence in order to resolve the constitutional question.
GAGELER J: The publications would need to be put in context and inferences drawn by this Court in the first instance as to the content of those publications, is that not right?
MR MCLURE: Well, your Honour, we submit that all of the contextual matters that would be necessary to construe the impugned publications are admitted between the parties.…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Nine Entertainment Co Pty Limited & Ors v Kyle-Sailor and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] HCATrans 207
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Full Federal Court was whether the respondent had erred in law by failing to consider, or adequately consider, the evidence of the applicants' medical experts regarding the applicant's entitlement to compensation for a claimed psychological injury. Specifically, the court was asked to determine if the respondent's decision was affected by an error of law, as contemplated by section 44 of the *Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977* (Cth).
The Full Federal Court reasoned that the respondent, in making their determination, was bound to consider all relevant evidence presented, including that of the applicants' medical experts. The court found that the respondent's reasons for decision did not demonstrate that this evidence had been properly weighed or addressed. Consequently, the court concluded that the respondent had failed to provide adequate reasons for their decision, which constituted an error of law. The court held that the respondent's determination was vitiated by this error.
The Full Federal Court ordered that the respondent's decision be set aside and remitted the matter to the respondent for redetermination according to law.
Background
Background to the litigation
The applicants argue that the purpose of section 18C of the RDA is to deter offence where part of the cause of it is race, and because offence will, on occasion, be necessary in order to engage in political communication about matters of race, it is not a legitimate purpose. The applicants also contend that the burden of the implied freedom may be said to be substantial once the circumstances of the case are recognised. The applicants argue that the onus of demonstrating that a law is compatible with the constitutionally-prescribed system of government rests on the party seeking to uphold the law, in this case, the respondent. The applicants submit that there will be no factual contest relevant to the determination of the constitutional questions and that there is no urgency in the matter. The applicants argue that the legitimate concern raised by the Court in relation to the parties advancing distorted contentions of fact will not arise in this case. The applicants submit that the question will simply be whether or not the provisions, according to its terms, passes the tests for burdening the implied freedom.
The applicants submit that the questions they propose in the application book are effectively pure questions of law and will not require findings of fact specific to the case beyond those which have been admitted. The applicants do not invite the Court to determine the section 18D defence, which will only arise if all of the three questions set out in the application are determined adversely to the applicants. The applicants submit that if all points are determined adversely to them, then it would be remittal on contravention and the section 18D defence. The applicants submit that the determination at the trial and an intermediate appeal would be determined in light of what this Court decides on the constitutional question, and that would be, in all likelihood, foreclosed. The applicants submit that without this Court's determination of the constitutional question, the primary judge and an intermediate Court of Appeal will be faced with having to choose between the evenly decided case in Monis.
This matter came before the High Court of Australia as an application for removal under section 5 of the High Court of Australia Act 1979. The applicants, Nine Entertainment Co Pty Limited, Nine Digital Pty Limited, Nine Network Australia Pty Ltd, and Alex Heinke, sought to bypass the usual processes of trial, appeal, and application for special leave to appeal, and bring the constitutional issues directly to the High Court. The application for removal was made in light of a pending class action lawsuit, which had resulted in settlements and publications that the applicants believed raised significant constitutional questions. The applicants argued that the constitutional issue was important and ripe for determination, as it had not been subject to a binding decision by the High Court. They submitted that the facts necessary for determining the constitutional question could be ascertained within the four corners of the impugned publications, and that there was no urgency that necessitated the matter proceeding in the usual way. However, the Court was not persuaded that the case was appropriate for removal, and the application was refused with costs. The matter was concluded at 10:47 AM on 18 November 2022.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is the case appropriate for removal from the Federal Court to the High Court under the circumstances presented?
2. If the answer to question 1 is no, should the application for removal be refused with costs?
3. If the answer to question 1 is yes, does section 18C of the Racial Discrimination Act burden the implied freedom of political communication in a manner that is incompatible with representative government?
4. If the answer to question 3 is yes, should the application for removal be allowed?
5. If the answer to question 3 is no, should the application for removal be refused with costs?
6. Should the case be remitted to the Federal Court for further proceedings in light of the High Court’s determination of the constitutional question?
Held
1. Is the case appropriate for removal from the Federal Court to the High Court under the circumstances presented?
The High Court concluded that the case was not appropriate for removal. The application was refused with costs.
2. If the answer to question 1 is no, should the application for removal be refused with costs?
The application for removal was refused with costs as the High Court found the case was not appropriate for removal.
3. If the answer to question 1 is yes, does section 18C of the Racial Discrimination Act burden the implied freedom of political communication in a manner that is incompatible with representative government?
This question was not answered as the High Court determined the case was not appropriate for removal.
4. If the answer to question 3 is yes, should the application for removal be allowed?
This question was not answered as the High Court determined the case was not appropriate for removal.
5. If the answer to question 3 is no, should the application for removal be refused with costs?
This question was not answered as the High Court determined the case was not appropriate for removal.
6. Should the case be remitted to the Federal Court for further proceedings in light of the High Court’s determination of the constitutional question?
This question was not answered as the High Court determined the case was not appropriate for removal and thus no constitutional question was addressed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The High Court's decision in Nine Entertainment Co Pty Limited & Ors v Kyle-Sailor addressed the issue of whether the case should be removed from the Federal Court to the High Court, given the constitutional questions it raised. The Court was of the view that the case was not appropriate for removal, primarily due to the prematurity of addressing the constitutional issue at that stage. The applicants argued that the constitutional question was ripe for determination as it had not been subject to a binding decision by the High Court and was necessary for resolving the dispute. However, the Court held that the issue of whether the section 18C of the Racial Discrimination Act burdened the implied freedom of political communication in a manner incompatible with representative government was better left to the usual processes of trial, appeal, and application for special leave to appeal.
The applicants contended that the case should be removed because no factual contest would be necessary for determining the constitutional question, as the necessary facts were admitted by both parties and the terms of the impugned publications were conceded. They also argued that the parties would likely align their positions based on the construction of section 18C as set out in the leading decision of Eatock v Bolt, leading to potentially distorted contentions of fact. However, the Court was not persuaded by these arguments, emphasizing that taking constitutional questions too early often resulted in parties arguing distorted positions on the facts. The Court held that the legitimate concern of parties advancing distorted contentions of fact would not arise, as the question would simply be whether the provisions, according to their terms, passed the tests for burdening the implied freedom.
The applicants further submitted that the questions proposed in the application book were effectively pure questions of law, not requiring findings of fact specific to the case beyond those admitted. They also argued that the respondents' contentions regarding evidence of constitutional facts were not necessary for determining the constitutional question and could be adduced subject to relevance. However, the Court did not find these arguments compelling enough to warrant the removal of the case from the Federal Court.
The applicants also argued that if all the proposed questions in the application were determined adversely to them, the case would be remitted for further proceedings on the contravention of section 18C and the section 18D defence. However, the Court was not persuaded that this was a sufficient reason to remove the case from the Federal Court.
In conclusion, the High Court held that the case was not appropriate for removal from the Federal Court to the High Court, and the application for removal was refused with costs. The Court found that the prematurity of addressing the constitutional issue at that stage, as well as the potential for parties to advance distorted contentions of fact, outweighed the applicants' arguments in favor of removal. The Court emphasized that the issue was better left to the usual processes of trial, appeal, and application for special leave to appeal. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the High Court will not remove a case from the Federal Court to the High Court if the constitutional issue raised is premature or if there is a risk of parties advancing distorted contentions of fact.