NightOwl Properties Pty Ltd v Replay Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

NightOwl Properties Pty Ltd v Replay Australia Pty Ltd [2022] QSC 270

PARTIES:

NIGHTOWL PROPERTIES PTY LTD
(plaintiff)
v
REPLAY AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
(defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BS 8260 of 2021

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Claim

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court

DELIVERED ON:

5 December 2022

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

Decided without an oral hearing

JUDGE:

Bradley J

ORDER:

THE ORDER OF THE COURT IS THAT:

1.   The plaintiff pay the defendant’s cost of the proceeding to and including 30 November 2021, to be assessed on the indemnity basis.

2.   The defendant pay the plaintiff’s costs of the proceeding from and including 2 June 2022, to be assessed on the standard basis.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS – GENERAL RULE – COSTS FOLLOW THE EVENT – COSTS OF ISSUES – OFFERS OF COMPROMISE – INFORMAL OFFERS AND CALDERBANK LETTERS – UNREASONABLE REFUSAL OF OFFER – where after a trial the Court made declarations, relieved the plaintiff from the forfeiture of the option and ordered the defendant to specifically perform the lease covenant to grant the plaintiff a further lease for five years within the second five-year option – where the defendant submitted that the plaintiff should pay the defendant’s costs on the indemnity basis to do equity – where the plaintiff concedes that usually a tenant seeking relief would be required to pay the landlord’s costs – where the parties exchanged offers of settlement – where none of the offers was accepted – whether the plaintiff should pay the defendant’s costs of the proceeding on the indemnity basis – whether the defendant should pay the defendant’s costs from its failure to accept the plaintiff’s offer.

Bland v Ingrams Estates Ltd (No 2) [2002] Ch 177, cited.

Egerton v Jones [1939] 2 KB 702, cited.

Howard v Fanshawe [1885] 2 Ch 581, cited.

Icechest Corp Pty Ltd v Quan [2017] WASC 345, cited.

National Building Society v Maybeech Ltd [1985] Ch 190, cited.

Riviera Holdings Pty Ltd v Fingal Glen Pty Ltd (in liq) (No 3) (2013) 120 SASR 515, cited.

COUNSEL:

M Johnsson KC for the plaintiff
R A Quirk for the defendant

SOLICITORS:

Preston Law for the plaintiff
Clinton Mohr Lawyers for the defendant

  1. This is a decision about the costs order to be made after a trial and judgment.  The parties filed written submissions and short affidavit evidence, and agreed that a decision on costs could be made by the court without an oral hearing.

    The judgment, the issues, and the reasons

  2. In January 2020, the plaintiff gave a notice exercising the first of two options to lease the ground floor premises in Albert Street, Brisbane for another five years.  The option clause was in the registered lease.  The plaintiff had been a tenant there for more than nine years of the ten-year lease term.  It operated a convenience shop.  At that time, there was little inkling of the once in a century public health…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read NightOwl Properties Pty Ltd v Replay Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QSC 270
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

NightOwl Properties Pty Ltd v Replay Australia Pty Ltd is a case about the costs order to be made after a trial and judgment. The plaintiff, NightOwl Properties, sought to exercise an option to lease the ground floor premises in Albert Street, Brisbane for another five years, but the defendant, Replay Australia, refused to grant the further lease. NightOwl Properties sought equitable relief against the forfeiture of the property interest associated with the contractual right, and the court found that it was appropriate to grant such relief. The court rejected the defendant’s submissions that the plaintiff could not ask the court to order the defendant to grant a further lease for the first option period, and that a tenant, like the plaintiff, who gave a notice of exercise of an option, and then failed to comply with a post-notice condition, could not seek equitable relief against forfeiture. The court also found that the payment of rent reduced “in line with the reduction of turnover”, during the peak of the pandemic restrictions, was not a wilful forfeiture, a wilful or grave breach, or improper in a legal sense.

The legal issues in this case were whether the plaintiff should pay the defendant’s costs of the proceeding on the indemnity basis to do equity, and whether the defendant should pay the defendant’s costs from its failure to accept the plaintiff’s offer. The plaintiff conceded that usually a tenant seeking relief would be required to pay the landlord’s costs, but argued that the defendant should pay the costs from its failure to accept the plaintiff’s offer. The defendant submitted that the plaintiff should pay the defendant’s costs on the indemnity basis to do equity. The court considered the authorities on offers of compromise, including informal offers and Calderbank letters, and found that the defendant’s failure to accept the plaintiff’s offer was unreasonable. The court also considered the exchange of offers of settlement between the parties, and found that none of the offers was accepted.

The court held that the plaintiff should pay the defendant’s costs of the proceeding to and including 30 November 2021, to be assessed on the indemnity basis. The court held that the defendant should pay the plaintiff’s costs of the proceeding from and including 2 June 2022, to be assessed on the standard basis. The court found that the defendant’s failure to accept the plaintiff’s offer was unreasonable, and that the plaintiff was entitled to costs from that date. The court also found that the plaintiff should pay the defendant’s costs of the proceeding to and including 30 November 2021, to be assessed on the indemnity basis, as the plaintiff was the successful party in the proceeding, and the defendant’s failure to accept the plaintiff’s offer was unreasonable. The orders of the court reflect these findings.

Orders

Orders of the court

THE ORDER OF THE COURT IS THAT:

1. The plaintiff pay the defendant’s cost of the proceeding to and including 30 November 2021, to be assessed on the indemnity basis.

2. The defendant pay the plaintiff’s costs of the proceeding from and including 2 June 2022, to be assessed on the standard basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

This is a decision about the costs order to be made after a trial and judgment. The parties filed written submissions and short affidavit evidence, and agreed that a decision on costs could be made by the court without an oral hearing. The judgment, the issues, and the reasons In January 2020, the plaintiff gave a notice exercising the first of two options to lease the ground floor premises in Albert Street, Brisbane for another five years. The option clause was in the registered lease. The plaintiff had been a tenant there for more than nine years of the ten-year lease term. It operated a convenience shop. At that time, there was little inkling of the once in a century public health crisis about to envelop the globe. About ten months later, in December 2020, the defendant refused to grant the further five-year lease. The defendant did so because, during the first five months of the COVID-19 lockdown, the plaintiff had paid rent reduced in line with the reduction in its turnover. The plaintiff had asked the defendant to reduce the rent in this way. The plaintiff accepted that the defendant had never agreed to do so. The defendant raised the breach for the first time in December 2020. The plaintiff remedied it immediately, by paying the outstanding rent. However, the breach meant that some of the conditions in the option clause were not met, so that the defendant was not obliged to grant the further five-year lease. On 30 September 2022, the court made declarations, relieved the plaintiff from the forfeiture of the option, and ordered the defendant to specifically perform the lease covenant to grant the plaintiff a further lease for five years with the second five-year option. In reasons published on 30 September 2022, the declarations and orders were explained. In short: (a)The court rejected the defendant’s submission that the plaintiff could not ask the court to order the defendant to grant a further lease for the first option period. The court found that the loss of the contractual right to a new lease did not prevent a grant of equitable relief against the forfeiture of the property interest associated with the contractual right. If the plaintiff had not lost the contractual right, it would not need equitable relief. (b)The court also rejected the defendant’s submission that a tenant, like the plaintiff, who gave a notice of exercise of an option, and then failed to comply with a post-notice condition, could not seek equitable relief against forfeiture. The authorities on which the defendant relied did not exclude the availability of equitable relief.[1] They were decisions about the effect on the availability of statutory relief against forfeiture of a landlord’s alleged waiver of post-notice conditions. (c)The court found the payment of rent reduced “in line with the reduction of turnover”, during the peak of the pandemic restrictions, was not a wilful forfeiture,[2] a wilful or grave breach,[3] or improper in a legal sense.[4] The lease provisions, by which the plaintiff would lose the option, served the purpose of securing payment of the rent. There was no evidence that the reduced rent payments affected the value of the premises or otherwise caused any prejudice to the defendant. There was a disparity between the value to the long-term tenant of a lease for the first option period (with a second option available), and the effect on the landlord of the failure to pay the full rent during the first five months of the COVID-19 “lockdown”. The loss of the options was disproportionate to any harm occasioned by the late payment.[5] The supervening events, and the circumstances then prevailing, explained the plaintiff’s breach and justified granting equitable relief.(d)The declarations and orders made by the court were the result of findings that the court could relieve the plaintiff from the loss of the option and that it was appropriate for the court to do so. [1]e.g. Grepo & Anor v Jam-Cal Bundaberg Pty Ltd [2015] 131, [107] (Morrison JA). [2]Thomas v Porter (1668) 1 Chan Cas 95 (Bridgeman LK). [3]Shiloh Spinners v Harding [1973] AC 691, 723-724 (Lord Wilberforce).[4]Dering v Earl of Winchelsea (1787) 1 Cox 318 (Eyre CB). [5]Shiloh Spinners Ltd v Harding op cit, 722-724 (Lord Wilberforce).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established