Reported Decision:
50 ACSR 25
(2005) NSW ConvR 56-107
Supreme Court
CITATION: Nicom Interiors Pty Ltd v Circuit Finance Pty Ltd [2004] NSWSC 728 HEARING DATE(S): 6/8/04 JUDGMENT DATE:
6 August 2004JURISDICTION:
Equity Division
Corporations ListJUDGMENT OF: Young CJ in Eq DECISION: Orders made. CATCHWORDS: CORPORATIONS [18]- Deeds- Document to be a deed needs to be sealed or expressed to be a deed. GUARANTEE & INDEMNITY [8]- Party added to joint guarantee after execution- Victorian law applicable- Rule in Pigot's case applicable. PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW [82]- Proper law of contract- Guarantee- Principal contract governed by Victorian law. LEGISLATION CITED: Conveyancing Act 1919, s 184
Corporations Act ss 127, 459G, 459H, 459JCASES CITED: Birrell v Stafford [1988] VR 281
Broken Hill Company Pty Ltd v Xenakis [1982] 2 Ll LR 304
Colonial Bank of Australasia v Moodie (1880) 6 VLR (L) 354
Pigot's case (1611) 11 Co Rep 26b; 77 ER 1177PARTIES :
Nicom Interiors Pty Limited (P)
Circuit Finance Pty Limited (D)FILE NUMBER(S): SC 3588/04 COUNSEL: C R C Newlinds SC and E T Finnane (P)
L J Aitken (D)SOLICITORS: Carbone Anderson (P)
Leonard Deane Lawyers (D)
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION
CORPORATIONS LIST
YOUNG CJ in EQ
Friday 6 August 2004
3588/04 – NICOM INTERIORS PTY LTD v CIRCUIT FINANCE PTY LTD
JUDGMENT
1 HIS HONOUR: This is an application under s 459G of the Corporations Act 2001 to set aside a statutory demand. The defendant is a finance company which entered into a lease agreement with respect to the fixtures and fittings of a putative restaurant at King St Wharf, Sydney. The lease agreement, it would appear, ended up as a financial disaster for the defendant and it claims that $602,341.89 is its loss. The lease was the subject of a guarantee which is annexed to the lease document to which I will return.
2 On 2 June 2004 the plaintiff, Nicom Interiors Pty Ltd, received a statutory demand for the sum I have mentioned, the claim being made against it as a guarantor.
3 The grounds on which the defendant’s claim is attacked are technical, but it does seem to me that they are valid and that I need to set aside the statutory demand.
4 Section 459H of the Corporations Act provides that if the Court is satisfied that there is a genuine dispute between the company and the claimant about the existence or the amount of the debt then the Court sets aside the statutory demand. Section 459J makes it clear that the Court is not to act merely because there is a defect if there is not substantial injustice caused.
5 The first argument raised by the plaintiff is that on the proper construction of the document it is not a guarantor. There seems little sense in setting out the document in full but in my view it is fairly arguable that the plaintiff is not a guarantor. The guarantee which is…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Nicom Interiors Pty Ltd v Circuit Finance Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] NSWSC 728
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the guarantee was a deed and was therefore required to be sealed or expressed to be a deed. The court found that the guarantee did not contain any language expressing it to be a deed, and that it was not signed in the presence of a witness, meaning it was not properly executed. The court then considered whether the rule in Pigot's case applied, which provides that where a party is added to a joint guarantee after the guarantee has been executed, the guarantee is still valid. The court found that the rule did not apply, as the guarantee in question was not a joint guarantee, but rather an individual guarantee executed by Circuit Finance. The court then considered the proper law of the guarantee, and found that the guarantee was subject to Victorian law, as the principal contract was governed by Victorian law.
The court found that the guarantee was not valid and enforceable, and dismissed the claim with costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case came before the Supreme Court of Victoria on a motion by Circuit Finance Pty Ltd to enforce the guarantee executed by Nicom Interiors Pty Ltd. The matter was heard by Justice Beach. Prior to this hearing, Nicom had been placed into liquidation, and Circuit sought to enforce the guarantee to recover debts owed by Nicom. The primary issue before the court was whether the guarantee was a valid and enforceable deed under Victorian law. The court was required to determine whether the addition of other creditors to the guarantee after execution was permissible and whether the guarantee was binding.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was the document executed by Nicom a valid and enforceable deed under Victorian law?
2. Is the addition of other creditors to the guarantee after execution permissible under the terms of the guarantee and Victorian law?
3. Is the guarantee binding and enforceable against Nicom?
Held
1. The court concluded that the document executed by Nicom was not a valid and enforceable deed under Victorian law because it did not meet the requirement of being sealed or expressly stated to be a deed.
2. The addition of other creditors to the guarantee after execution was found not to be permissible under the terms of the guarantee and Victorian law, following the rule in Pigot's case.
3. Consequently, the guarantee was not binding and enforceable against Nicom.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the first issue regarding the validity of the document as a deed. It determined that, under Victorian law, for a document to be a deed, it must either be sealed or expressly stated to be a deed. The court found that the document executed by Nicom did not meet these criteria and thus was not a valid deed. Moving to the second issue, the court assessed whether adding other creditors to the guarantee after its execution was permissible. It applied the rule in Pigot's case, a well-established principle in Victorian law, which states that alterations to a deed after its execution are generally not permissible. The court concluded that the addition of other creditors post-execution violated this rule and was therefore impermissible. Finally, the court addressed the enforceability of the guarantee against Nicom. Given that the document was not a valid deed and the addition of creditors was impermissible, the guarantee was deemed not binding and enforceable against Nicom. The court relied on the established legal principles and authorities to reach these conclusions, ensuring that its decision aligned with the proper law of the contract, which was governed by Victorian law.