Nick Scali Limited v Super A-Mart Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Nick Scali Limited v Super A-Mart Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 751

Citation: Nick Scali Limited v Super A-Mart Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 751
Parties: NICK SCALI LIMITED (ACN 000 403 896) v SUPER A-MART PTY LTD (ACN 009 810 324)
File number(s): NSD 1142 of 2010
Judge: YATES J
Date of judgment: 6 July 2011
Catchwords: TRADE PRACTICES – consumer protection – comparative advertising – misleading or deceptive conduct – false representations – television commercial – point of sale material – relevant approach discussed – whether price-compared products represented to be of the same or equivalent standard, quality, grade or composition – oral representations – whether products represented to be the same or to have come from same factory or place – sufficiency of evidence – whether certification of product misrepresented
Legislation: Australian Consumer Law s 232
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 140(2)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 52, 53, 82
Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No 2) 2010 (Cth) Sch 7, items 7(1) and (2)
Cases cited:

Campomar Sociedad, Limitada v Nike International Limited (2000) 202 CLR 45
Country Road Clothing Pty Ltd v Najee Nominees Pty Ltd (1991) 20 IPR 419
Doolan v Waltons Ltd (1981) 39 ALR 408
Ducret v Chaudhary’s Oriental Carpet Palace Pty Ltd (1987) 16 FCR 562
Elna Australia Pty Ltd v International Computers (Aust) Pty Ltd (No 2) (1987) 16 FCR 410
Gillette Australia Pty Ltd v Energizer Australia Pty Ltd (2002) 193 ALR 629
Given v CV Holland (Holdings) Pty Ltd (1977) 29 FLR 212
JLW (Vic) Pty Ltd v Tsiloglou [1994] 1 VR 237
Morgan v Odhams Press Ltd [1971] 1 WLR 1239
Nick Scali Ltd v Super A-Mart Pty Ltd (2010) 189 FCR 550
Parkdale Custom Built Furniture Proprietary Limited v Puxu Proprietary Limited (1982) 149 CLR 191
Siddons Pty Ltd v The Stanley Works Pty Ltd (1991) 29 FCR 14
Thompson v Riley McKay Pty Ltd (No 2) (1980) 31 ALR 507

Wardley Australia Limited v The State of Western Australia (1992) 175 CLR 514

Date of hearing: 12, 13, 14, 15, 19 October, 10 November 2010
Date of last submissions: 25 November 2010
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 195
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr S Burley SC with Mr H Bevan
Solicitor for the Applicant: DLA Phillips Fox
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr R Cobden SC with Mr N Murray
Solicitor for the Respondent: Clayton Utz

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1142 of 2010

BETWEEN:

NICK SCALI LIMITED (ACN 000 403 896)
Applicant

AND:

SUPER A-MART PTY LTD (ACN 009 810 324)
Respondent

JUDGE:

YATES J

DATE OF ORDER:

6 JULY 2011

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The proceeding stand over to 18 July 2011 at 9.30 am for the purpose of making directions as to the further hearing of the matter on the question of relief and costs.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nick Scali Limited v Super A-Mart Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 751
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Nick Scali Limited took action against Super A-Mart Pty Ltd in court over allegations of misleading or deceptive conduct, specifically in the context of comparative advertising, under sections 52 and 53 of the Trade Practices Act. The applicant claimed that the respondent's advertisements falsely suggested that their products were of the same or equivalent standard, quality, grade, or composition, which is prohibited by the statute. The court was required to determine whether the respondent's advertisements indeed made false representations about the quality and standard of the products and whether these representations contravened the Trade Practices Act.

The court examined the content and context of the advertisements, including the commercial, point of sale material, and oral representations made by the respondent. It considered whether the products compared in the advertisements were represented to be of the same or equivalent standard, quality, grade, or composition. The court also reviewed the sufficiency of the evidence provided by both parties to establish the nature and scope of the alleged representations. The court found significant differences in the construction, design, and quality between the products advertised by the respondent and those of the applicant. The court concluded that the respondent's advertisements made false representations about the quality and standard of the products, thereby contravening the Trade Practices Act.

The court ordered that the proceeding be stood over to allow for further directions regarding the hearing of the matter on the question of relief and costs. This decision highlights the importance of accurately representing product quality and standards in comparative advertising to avoid misleading consumers.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceeding stand over to 18 July 2011 at 9.30 am for the purpose of making directions as to the further hearing of the matter on the question of relief and costs.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

On 14 September 2010 I made an order, at the request of the parties, that all issues concerning liability in this proceeding (including liability for damages or an account of profits) be heard and determined before any hearing in relation to the quantification of damages or profits. The form of that order reflects the fact that, at that time, the applicant had also claimed that the respondent had engaged in passing-off. This claim was subsequently abandoned by the applicant in the course of closing submissions. Thus, the only matter that arises for present determination is the question of liability in relation to the claims made under the Trade Practices Act, including liability for damages.BACKGROUND MATTERSComparative advertising This case concerns a particular factual application of ss 52 and 53 of the Trade Practices Act in the context of comparative advertising. There was no real dispute between the parties about the relevant principles of law. Neither party has suggested that there are special principles involved in the application of ss 52 and 53 to cases of comparative advertising. Both parties have placed reliance on the discussion of relevant principles in Gillette Australia Pty Ltd v Energizer Australia Pty Ltd (2002) 193 ALR 629. The respondent has also drawn particular attention to the decision in Country Road Clothing Pty Ltd v Najee Nominees Pty Ltd (1991) 20 IPR 419 which involved the use of a similar slogan to the one that features in the present case. The nature and scope of the alleged representations As I have noted, the applicant alleges that the respondent has falsely represented that the products it has compared are of the same or an equivalent “standard, quality, grade or composition”. In the context of allegations of resulting contravention of s 53(a) of the Trade Practices Act, the choice of the words “standard, quality, grade or composition”, as characterising the nature and scope of the representations, is no accident. Those words are plainly borrowed from s 53(a) which provides that:A corporation shall not, in trade or commerce, in connexion with the supply or possible supply of goods or services or in connexion with the promotion by any means of the supply or use of goods or services:(a)falsely represent that goods are of a particular standard, quality, value, grade, composition, style or model or have had a particular history or particular previous use;… The word “quality” in this statutory context bears the dictionary meaning of an attribute, property or special feature: Given v CV Holland (Holdings) Pty Ltd (1977) 29 FLR 212 at 216; Thompson v Riley McKay Pty Ltd (No 2) (1980) 31 ALR 507 at 509. In Doolan v Waltons Ltd (1981) 39 ALR 408, Lockhart J observed (at 411) that to construe “quality” in this way was to give it a generally understood and accepted meaning. His Honour noted that the words used in s 53(a) were “components” that “are not mutually exclusive”, and that there may be an overlap between them. His Honour instanced the possibility of overlap between “composition” and “quality”.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Rajah suite is also fitted with tension springs to ensure that the recliner returns to its correct position. This feature is absent in the Excellence suite.Conclusions In my view there are significant differences in construction, design and workmanship between the Rajah suite and the Excellence suite. Overall, the Rajah suite is larger in size and is upholstered in significantly more top grain leather than the Excellence suite, particularly in high-wear areas where top grain leather is better suited than split grain leather. The evidence establishes that the use of top grain leather is more costly than the use of split leather. I am satisfied that, overall, the quality of both the top grain leather and the split leather used in the Rajah suite is superior to the quality of the corresponding leather used in the Excellence suite, based principally on the expert assessments of Mr Bennett and Ms Lees. My own observation confirms that, in respect of sheen, the top grain and split leather used on the Rajah suite is better matched, as compared to the corresponding leather used in the Excellence suite. In my view the Rajah suite is, overall, of sturdier construction than the Excellence suite, particularly in relation to their respective wooden and metal frames and footrests. However, this is not to say that, in these respects, the construction of the Excellence suite is inadequate for its intended purpose. The Rajah suite is also sturdier in relation to its use of double stitching and reinforced stitching (compared to the use of single stitching in the Excellence suite in comparable areas) and in some aspects of design, such as the wing areas, where, in the Rajah suite, the wings are likely to have better performance and greater ability to flex with the back of the lounge, compared to the corresponding areas in the Excellence suite. The Rajah suite has other design features which distinguish it from the Excellence suite in significant ways. These features include: the gutter in the top of the inside back cushions and the use of webbing in the lumbar support areas, to prevent wrinkling or “puddling” in those areas; the use of significantly more foam in the seat areas; the inclusion of tension springs to ensure that the recliners return to their correct positions after use; electrical reclining mechanisms in both the single recliner chairs and the three seat lounge (compared to the manual reclining mechanism in the Excellence three seat lounge); and the provision, advantageously, of holders for transformers for the electrical reclining mechanisms, to enable the transformers and associated wiring to be secured to the inside frames of the chairs/lounge and thus diminish the possibility of the entanglement of electrical wires with other componentry. Apart from these features, the Rajah suite also reflects a significantly greater degree of workmanship in the use of double and reinforced stitching generally, and in the consistent use of curved stitching in the seat and lumbar areas. With the exception of the limited use of curved stitching, the Excellence suite does not exhibit these features of workmanship.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

For its part, the respondent submits that it would be an error to undertake a painstaking deconstruction of the commercial and that, in considering the factual assertions made in it, “there is no substitute for simply watching [the commercial] in real time, without pausing or undue repetition”. When this is done, the respondent submits, the commercial conveys no more than the following message: “Don’t pay more elsewhere for a leather recliner suite with a three seat sofa and two armchairs”. The respondent submits that the commercial makes no express or implied comparison of quality with the applicant’s lounge suite. It submits that the only matter being compared is price and that the commercial lawfully discriminates between the applicant’s and the respondent’s furniture on that basis, and on that basis alone.Consideration I accept the general thrust of the respondent’s submission that, for the purposes of the present case, one should not engage in a painstaking analysis of the commercial for fear of losing sight of what it is likely to convey in the medium and in the settings in which it is intended to be viewed. My description of the commercial is no more than an attempt to record, for the purposes of these reasons, the major stages of the commercial and the more significant elements of those stages. I have not attempted to record all the visual details of the commercial that are capable of being discerned from a close and abstract study of it. Indeed, I do not believe that a number of those details would be perceptible to viewers of the commercial exercising reasonable, but undirected, attention in a domestic setting. The cases speak of the need to take account of the fact that the in-court presentation of television commercials in cases such as the present provides a fundamentally different setting from the domestic setting in which they are intended to be viewed. In Gillette at [47] Lindgren J referred to some of those differences. His Honour said: … apart from the difference between a one-off viewing and repeated viewings, the circumstances in which a judge attends to a television commercial for the purposes of a case are not those in which members of the public do so. First, members of the public watch a commercial after and before viewing other things, rather than in isolation. Secondly, unlike the judge, they do not carefully view the commercial with a special interest in noting and memorising its features. Thirdly, they view the commercial, not in the calm of chambers, but against a background of distractions, such as domestic activity, or simply a preoccupation with other more interesting or pressing concerns. Fourthly, usually they do not know in advance that the commercial is about to commence. I accept that, when considering what the commercial is likely to convey to ordinary or reasonable members of the public, its true impact can only be appreciated by considering the setting in which the commercial is intended to be viewed. Here, however, the intended setting is not confined to casual television viewing. As I have noted, the respondent has taken steps to ensure that the commercial is also available on the Internet. It can be taken that, in that setting, there will be viewers who will have sought out the commercial for their own educative purposes, and who can be taken, therefore, to have a particular interest in what the commercial is saying. Accordingly, in that setting, those viewers, unlike casual television viewers, will, for example, view the commercial in isolation, without the commonplace domestic distractions of the kind to which Lindgren J alluded in Gillette. In order to fulfil their need, such viewers may also seek to view the commercial a number of times in the one sitting, or over several sittings.