Nichols v Earth Spirit Homes Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read
CITATION: Nichols v Earth Spirit Homes Pty Ltd [2014] QCATA 260
PARTIES: George Nichols
(Applicant/Appellant)
v
Earth Spirit Homes Pty Ltd
(Respondent)
APPLICATION NUMBER: APL236-13
MATTER TYPE: Appeals
HEARING DATE: 9 December 2013
HEARD AT: Brisbane
DECISION OF: Justice Thomas, President
Member Roney
DELIVERED ON: 17 September 2014
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
ORDERS MADE:

1.    In relation to appeal grounds 1 – 3, the appeal is dismissed.

2.    In relation to appeal grounds 4 – 12, leave to appeal is refused.

3.    Consistent with the reasons in APL235-13:

a)    Leave to appeal is granted;

b)   The appeal is allowed;

c)    The issue of costs in the proceeding below is remitted to the tribunal for determination in accordance with those reasons.

4.    Subject to any application with respect to costs within 14 days by either party, the appellant pay the respondent’s costs on the appeal on a standard basis, by reference to the District Court scale, to be assessed, or agreed.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEALS – QUESTIONS OF LAW AND MIXED LAW AND FACT – LEAVE TO APPEAL – BUILDING DISPUTE – where tribunal found funds in Master Builders Association should be paid to respondent builder – where dispute about terms of agreement – whether tribunal erred in finding written contracts without effect – whether tribunal erred in concluding three oral contracts – whether appeal should be allowed – where tribunal Member found evidence of respondent’s witnesses more credible than that of appellant – whether cause to upset findings of fact by tribunal Member – whether grounds for leave to appeal

Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld), 14B
Domestic Building Contracts Act 2000 (Qld), s 55
Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld), s 42, s 67AAA, s 67G, s 67 J
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 142, s 146, s 147

Air Great Lakes Pty Ltd v KS Easter (Holdings) Pty Ltd  [1985] NSWLR 309, applied
Builders Licensing Board v Sperway Constructions (Syd) Pty Ltd (1976) 135 CLR 616, applied
Canada (Director of Investigation and Research) v Southern Inc [1997] 1 SCR 748, cited
Ash Industries Pty Ltd v Plumb [2010] QCATA 53, cited
Cant Contracting Pty Ltd v Casella & Anor [2007] 2 Qd R 13; [2006] QSC 242, considered
Chambers v Jobling (1986) 7 NSWLR 1, cited
Dearman v Dearman (1908) 7 CLR 549, cited
Equuscorp Pty Ltd v Haxton & Ors (2012) 246 CLR 498, cited
Flegg v CMC and Assistant Commissioner O’Regan [2013] QCA 376, cited
Freedom Homes Pty Ltd v Botros [2000] 2 Qd R 377, considered
Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118, cited
Gemini Nominees Pty Ltd v Queensland Property Partners Pty Ltd [2008] 1 Qd R 137, considered
Gino v D’Alessandro [1987] 2 Qd R 40, cited
Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298, considered
Miller v Miller (2011) 242 CLR 446, considered
Pavey & Matthews Pty Ltd v Paul (1987) 162 CLR 221, cited
Pickering v McArthur [2005]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nichols v Earth Spirit Homes Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] QCATA 260
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Nichols v Earth Spirit Homes Pty Ltd was an appeal concerning a building dispute where the tribunal found that funds held by the Master Builders Association should be paid to the respondent builder. The central issues were whether the tribunal had erred in finding that the written contracts were without effect, whether the tribunal had correctly concluded the existence of three oral contracts, and whether there were grounds for allowing the appeal. The appellant also questioned the tribunal's assessment of witness credibility, arguing that the tribunal Member should have been persuaded by the appellant's evidence rather than that of the respondent.

The court examined the Queensland Building Services Authority Act 2000, particularly section 67E, which states that a building contract is not void or voidable even if inconsistent with the Act. The court interpreted section 67E(1) as making clear that the contract remains valid, despite any inconsistency, and section 67E(2) as ensuring that contractual provisions are void only to the extent of inconsistency with the Act. The explanatory memoranda and second reading speech of the Bill supported the interpretation that unwritten contracts are not rendered void by the legislation. The court concluded that the tribunal's findings on the existence of the oral contracts were not unreasonable, and the tribunal Member's assessment of credibility was not a basis for overturning the decision.

The appeal was dismissed in relation to the first three grounds, and leave to appeal was refused for the remaining grounds. However, leave to appeal was granted and the appeal was allowed regarding the issue of costs, remitting the matter to the tribunal for determination according to previous reasons. The appellant was ordered to pay the respondent's costs on the appeal, subject to any applications within 14 days.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. In relation to appeal grounds 1 – 3, the appeal is dismissed.

2. In relation to appeal grounds 4 – 12, leave to appeal is refused.

3. Consistent with the reasons in APL235-13:

a) Leave to appeal is granted;

b) The appeal is allowed;

c) The issue of costs in the proceeding below is remitted to the tribunal for determination in accordance with those reasons.

4. Subject to any application with respect to costs within 14 days by either party, the appellant pay the respondent’s costs on the appeal on a standard basis, by reference to the District Court scale, to be assessed, or agreed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Nichols, the appellant, engaged Earth Spirit Homes Pty Ltd, the respondent, to construct a residential property. The agreement between the parties was initially oral but later formalised in writing. Disputes arose regarding the terms of the agreement, particularly about the inclusion of additional work and the cost. Funds held in the Master Builders Association were ordered by the tribunal to be paid to the respondent. The appellant contested the decision, arguing that the written contracts were ineffective and that there were no binding oral contracts.

The matter was initially heard by a tribunal under the Queensland Building Services Authority Act (QBSA Act). The tribunal found in favour of the respondent, ordering the payment of funds held in the Master Builders Association to the respondent. Dissatisfied with the tribunal's decision, the appellant applied for leave to appeal to a higher court. The appeal process involved multiple stages, including the consideration of grounds for appeal and the granting or refusal of leave to appeal. The appeal was heard on specific grounds, some of which were dismissed while others were refused leave to appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the tribunal erred in finding that the written contracts between the parties were without effect.
2. Whether the tribunal erred in concluding that there were three valid oral contracts between the parties.
3. Whether the appeal should be allowed based on the tribunal's findings of fact and credibility of witnesses.
4. Whether there are grounds for leave to appeal the tribunal's decision.

Held
1. The court held that the tribunal did not err in finding that the written contracts between the parties were without effect. The appeal against this finding was dismissed.
2. The court held that the tribunal did not err in concluding that there were three valid oral contracts between the parties. The appeal against this finding was dismissed.
3. The court held that the appeal should not be allowed based on the tribunal's findings of fact and credibility of witnesses. The appeal was dismissed on these grounds.
4. The court held that there were grounds for leave to appeal the tribunal's decision on certain issues. Leave to appeal was granted on these grounds, the appeal was allowed, and the issue of costs was remitted to the tribunal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The QBSA Act, however, also contains s 67E, which relevantly provides:67E Operation of pt 4A(1) …this part (which includes s 67G) does not have effect to make void or voidable a building contract, or a provision of the building contract, even:(a)in entering into the building contract, or the building contract containing the provision, a party to the building contract commits an offence against this part.(2) However, if a building contract, or a provision of a building contract, is inconsistent with a provision (the Act provision) of this part applying to the building contract, the building contract, or the provision of the building contract, has effect only to the extent it is not inconsistent with the Act provision. The meaning of the words in s 67E(1) is clear: the contract is not void or voidable. However, as has been pointed out by the appellant, a verbal contract is, in its entirety, inconsistent with the Act provision (that the contract be in writing). In that circumstance, the relevant question is: would s 67E(2) override the result which flows from s 67E(1) on the basis that, in the case of a verbal contract, the inconsistency is essentially the entire contract? In seeking to answer that question, assistance may be found in the explanatory notes to the Queensland Building Services Authority Amendment Bill 1999 (Qld), (that relevantly introduced Part 4A to the QBSA Act), which says that “section 67E removes doubt that this part only makes void any conditions of the contract expressly made void by this part and that it applies to all contracts even if, in entering into the contract, an offence is committed or the contract is entered into outside Queensland.” The Honourable Judy Spence, in the second reading speech for the Bill, said on 21 July 1999:Provisions are structured so that where inconsistencies arise between the legislation and contractual provisions, contractual provisions are void only to the extent of the inconsistency. All other existing contractual rights are preserved (s 67E(2)).Injustices occur where contracts are not committed to writing. The legislation therefore makes it mandatory to put contracts in writing and set out basic contract terms. Failure to do so constitutes an offence for all parties to the contract who are building contractors. However, the unwritten contract is not rendered void by the legislation.[37][37]Hansard page 2771 (21 July 1999). The wording used in s 67E(2) is possibly confusing and ambiguous. However, in our view, s 67E(1) makes it clear that the contract will not be void or voidable in the event that the contract is inconsistent with the legislation. It is not ambiguous. Section 67E(2) should not be read so as to defeat that operation of s 67E(1) which is clear in its effect. To the extent that these statutory provisions are ambiguous or obscure it is open to take extrinsic material into account to assist in the interpretation. Such material includes the explanatory memoranda and the second reading speech of the Bill,[38] both of which support the way in which, in our view, the two sections should be understood.[38]Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld) s 14B.