Nicholls and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2009] AATA 646

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          2008/5161

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION )
RE BRIAN KENNETH NICHOLLS

Applicant

And

CIVIL AVIATION SAFETY AUTHORITY

Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal Deputy President P E Hack SC

Date28 August 2009  

PlaceBrisbane

Decision The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.  

................Signed................

Deputy President

  1. Late on the evening of 7 June 2008 the applicant, Mr Brian Nicholls, was the pilot in command and sole occupant of a Piper Seneca PA34 twin engine aircraft VH-WDP (WDP) on a flight from Coober Pedy to Alice Springs. WDP landed at Alice Springs shortly before midnight. The circumstances of the flight leading up to the landing prompted the respondent, the Civil Aviation Safety Authority, to undertake an investigation into the flight.

  2. As a result of the investigation CASA decided that Mr Nicholls’ Commercial and Private Pilot (Aeroplane) Licences and Student Pilot Licence should be cancelled. In these proceedings Mr Nicholls seeks a review of that decision.

    Factual Background

  3. There is significant factual controversy but I will start by recording some matters that are not in dispute. Mr Nicholls is an experienced pilot who has held a Private Pilot (Aeroplane) licence since December 1971 and a Commercial Pilot (Aeroplane) licence since July 1977. His licences permitted him to fly as pilot in command of the Seneca and to do so at night under the visual flight rules (V.F.R.). He did not hold an instrument rating that would have authorised him to fly under the instrument flight rules (I.F.R.). Mr Nicholls has a total of 3,762 hours of aeronautical experience including 2,613 hours in Piper Seneca aircraft. Prior to this occasion he had landed at Alice Springs aerodrome on approximately 80 occasions, including at least 30 night landings.

  4. On the evening of 7 June 2008 Mr Nicholls was planning to fly WDP to Alice Springs. He telephoned Airservices Australia from Coober Pedy aerodrome and obtained a weather forecast for the route to Alice Springs and a TAF[1] (terminal aerodrome forecast) for Alice Springs. The precise terms of the TAF are considered below. Mr Nicholls took off from Coober Pedy at approximately 2025 Central Standard Time[2]. He estimates that he had about five hours fuel on board the aircraft.

    [1]        In some of the material the term TAFOR is used.

    [2]        There are references in the material to UTC (Coordinated Universal Time) or Zulu. For simplicity and consistency all references will be to Central Standard Time which is the time zone for both Coober Pedy and Alice Springs.

  5. WDP attained a cruising altitude of approximately 6,500 feet and maintained a consistent height and speed for a little over two hours. Mr Nicholls had a portable GPS unit in the cockpit with him, initially in a bracket mounted on the coaming panel. Much of what happened after WDP arrived in the vicinity of Alice Springs is also very much in issue. It is not in doubt that at 2250 Mr Nicholls advised air traffic control…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nicholls and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] AATA 646
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between Mr Nicholls and the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) involved the review of CASA's decision to cancel Mr Nicholls' aeroplane licences following an incident where his aircraft made contact with terrain during a landing attempt at Alice Springs. The Federal Court was tasked with determining whether CASA's decision to cancel Mr Nicholls' Commercial and Private Pilot (Aeroplane) Licences and Student Pilot Licence was justified. The court had to consider whether Mr Nicholls breached his duties as a pilot by not planning his flight in accordance with his obligations, failing to obtain a weather forecast for an alternative aerodrome, and not adhering to safe altitude requirements and cloud clearance rules.

The central legal issues revolved around whether Mr Nicholls' actions demonstrated that he was not a fit and proper person to hold aeroplane licences, and whether CASA's decision to cancel his licences was justified. The court examined the statutory provisions under the Civil Aviation Act 1988 and Civil Aviation Regulations 1988, and considered relevant case law. The court found that Mr Nicholls' failures to comply with flight planning and safety obligations, coupled with a lack of insight into his actions, substantiated the conclusion that he was not a fit and proper person. The court upheld CASA's decision, affirming that the cancellation of Mr Nicholls' licences was appropriate.

The Federal Court's reasoning concluded that Mr Nicholls' breaches of duty, including not planning the flight properly and disregarding safety protocols, demonstrated that he was not fit to hold aeroplane licences. The absence of insight into his errors further supported CASA's decision. The court confirmed that the decision to cancel Mr Nicholls' licences was justified, and there was no basis to suggest a suspension rather than a cancellation.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Background

Background to the litigation

As a result of the investigation CASA decided that Mr Nicholls’ Commercial and Private Pilot (Aeroplane) Licences and Student Pilot Licence should be cancelled. In these proceedings Mr Nicholls seeks a review of that decision.Factual Background There is significant factual controversy but I will start by recording some matters that are not in dispute. Mr Nicholls is an experienced pilot who has held a Private Pilot (Aeroplane) licence since December 1971 and a Commercial Pilot (Aeroplane) licence since July 1977. His licences permitted him to fly as pilot in command of the Seneca and to do so at night under the visual flight rules (V.F.R.). He did not hold an instrument rating that would have authorised him to fly under the instrument flight rules (I.F.R.). Mr Nicholls has a total of 3,762 hours of aeronautical experience including 2,613 hours in Piper Seneca aircraft. Prior to this occasion he had landed at Alice Springs aerodrome on approximately 80 occasions, including at least 30 night landings. On the evening of 7 June 2008 Mr Nicholls was planning to fly WDP to Alice Springs. He telephoned Airservices Australia from Coober Pedy aerodrome and obtained a weather forecast for the route to Alice Springs and a TAF[1] (terminal aerodrome forecast) for Alice Springs. The precise terms of the TAF are considered below. Mr Nicholls took off from Coober Pedy at approximately 2025 Central Standard Time[2]. He estimates that he had about five hours fuel on board the aircraft.[1] In some of the material the term TAFOR is used.[2] There are references in the material to UTC (Coordinated Universal Time) or Zulu. For simplicity and consistency all references will be to Central Standard Time which is the time zone for both Coober Pedy and Alice Springs. WDP attained a cruising altitude of approximately 6,500 feet and maintained a consistent height and speed for a little over two hours. Mr Nicholls had a portable GPS unit in the cockpit with him, initially in a bracket mounted on the coaming panel. Much of what happened after WDP arrived in the vicinity of Alice Springs is also very much in issue. It is not in doubt that at 2250 Mr Nicholls advised air traffic control that he was trying to land at Alice Springs aerodrome and was unable to sight the runway lights and that at 2303 Mr Nicholls advised air traffic control “that he had hit something”. WDP was eventually able to land at Alice Springs at approximately 2343 and taxied to the western General Aviation area. Mr Nicholls was met by Mr Christopher Brand, then a member of the Northern Territory Police Force who had been seconded to the Australian Federal Police in the Joint Airports Intelligence Group. Mr Brand was, coincidentally, an experienced pilot. Mr Brand had a brief conversation with Mr Nicholls in which Mr Nicholls acknowledged that he had made contact, possibly, with “the top of one of the ranges”. Mr Brand arranged for other police to take possession of the GPS unit. There is a dispute about the location of the GPS unit when Mr Nicholls landed in Alice Springs. Shortly after midnight, Mr Brand took a series of photographs of WDP depicting the damage to it. He took further photographs of the damage after sunrise on 8 June 2008. The steps taken by Mr Brand thereafter are also the subject of controversy and are dealt with at length below.The legislative framework

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I add, that in reaching this conclusion I pay no regard to the matters from 1989. The vintage of these events is such that I regard them as having no bearing on the question of whether Mr Nicholls is now a fit and proper person.The preferable decision In light of my conclusion that both of CAR 269(1)(c) and (d) are satisfied the discretion to vary, suspend or cancel Mr Nicholls’ licences in enlivened. It was not suggested in argument, nor, in my view, is it open to be suggested, that some variation to the terms of Mr Nicholls’ licences would deal adequately with his demonstrated failings. The question is one of either suspension or cancellation. I consider cancellation to be the only conclusion open on the material before me. The lapses by Mr Nicholls satisfy me that he is not a fit and proper person to hold the licences. Once that conclusion is reached it is difficult to see how any decision short of cancellation could be warranted. Certainly this is not such a case. It follows that I would affirm the decision under review.I certify that the 80 preceding paragraphs are a true copy of the reasons for the decision herein of Deputy President P E Hack SCSigned: .........................Signed............................................ Lynne Stalley, Administrative AssistantDates of Hearing 21 - 22 April 2009 and 5 August 2009 Date of Decision 28 August 2009 Solicitor for the Applicant Mr P Clough Solicitor for the Respondent Mr J Rule

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established