Nguyen v State of South Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Appeal: Civil)

NGUYEN v STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

[2024] SASCA 105

Judgment of the Court of Appeal  

(The Honourable Justice S Doyle and the Honourable Justice Bleby)

29 August 2024

HEALTH LAW - MENTAL HEALTH GENERALLY - GENERAL LAW AFFECTING PERSONS WITH MENTAL ILLNESS OR IMPAIRED CAPACITY - CONDUCTING LEGAL PROCEEDINGS - LITIGATION GUARDIANS AND NEXT FRIENDS

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - PARTIES AND REPRESENTATION - PERSONS UNDER LEGAL INCAPACITY OTHER THAN CHILDREN

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - RIGHT OF APPEAL - WHEN APPEAL LIES - FROM INTERLOCUTORY DECISIONS - LEAVE TO APPEAL

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - EXTENSION OF TIME FOR APPEAL

The applicant seeks leave to appeal from the primary judge’s order that the underlying proceedings be stayed pending the appointment of a litigation guardian for the applicant. The applicant requires an extension of the time within which to seek leave to appeal.

Held, per the Court, granting an extension of time but dismissing the application for leave to appeal:

1.Given the limited period of delay, and the respondent’s acceptance that an extension would not give rise to any prejudice, it is appropriate that the applicant be granted an extension of time; and

2.In circumstances where there is no clear merit in the appeal, the appeal does not raise any issue of principle or general importance, and there is limited scope for any substantial injustice if the primary judge’s decision stands, the interests of justice do not favour a grant of leave to appeal.

Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) rr 2.1(b), 23.8, referred to.
Dalle-Molle v Manos (2004) 88 SASR 193; Manning v Russell (2015) 123 SASR 135; Nguyen v State of South Australia [2024] SASC 32; Slaveski v Victoria (2009) 25 VR 160, considered.

NGUYEN v STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
[2024] SASCA 105

Court of Appeal – Civil:  Doyle and Bleby JJA

  1. THE COURT:   This is an application for leave to appeal from the primary judge’s order that the underlying proceedings be stayed pending the appointment of a litigation guardian for the applicant.[1]

  2. The applicant appeals on two grounds.  In Ground 1, the applicant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the applicant lacked capacity, and in Ground 2 he contends that the primary judge gave insufficient weight to the medical report of an expert relied upon by the applicant, Dr Bryden.

  3. The respondent opposes leave to appeal on the basis that the appeal is not reasonably arguable, the appeal does not raise any issue of principle, and no substantial injustice will arise if the primary judge’s orders stand.

  4. The applicant requires an extension of the time within which to seek leave to appeal. Given the limited period of delay, and the respondent’s acceptance that an extension would not give rise to any prejudice, it is appropriate that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nguyen v State of South Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] SASCA 105
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of South Australia, Doyle and Bleby JJ considered an application for leave to appeal an interlocutory decision made by a primary judge. The underlying proceedings involved a claim in negligence brought by the applicant against the respondent for injuries sustained during a medical procedure. The dispute before the primary judge concerned the applicant's legal capacity to conduct these proceedings, with the respondent seeking an order appointing a litigation guardian or, alternatively, a stay of proceedings.

The legal issues before the Full Court were whether the primary judge erred in concluding that the applicant lacked legal capacity for the purposes of rule 2.1(1) of the Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) and in ordering a stay of proceedings until a litigation guardian was appointed, pursuant to rule 23.8 of the Uniform Civil Rules. The Court was also required to determine whether to grant leave to appeal, considering whether the decision was attended by sufficient doubt, raised an issue of principle or general importance, and whether its refusal would cause substantial injustice to the applicant.

The Court reasoned that the primary judge had properly considered all the evidence, including medical reports assessing the applicant's intellectual and reasoning capacity, and the difficulties faced by the applicant's solicitor in obtaining counsel. The primary judge found that the applicant's impaired cognitive function prevented him from appreciating and weighing the forensic choices required in the proceedings, creating a real risk of disadvantage without a litigation guardian. The Full Court concluded that the applicant's proposed grounds of appeal lacked any reasonably arguable basis to challenge these findings.

Consequently, the Full Court determined that the interests of justice did not favour granting leave to appeal, as there was no clear merit in the appeal, no issue of principle or general importance, and limited scope for substantial injustice. The Court granted an extension of time for the appeal but dismissed the application for leave to appeal, ordering costs in favour of the respondent.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

However, for the reasons which follow, the application for leave to appeal should be dismissed. Background In the underlying proceedings, the applicant brought a claim in negligence against the respondent for injuries arising from a medical procedure at the Royal Adelaide Hospital on 17 September 2014. The proceedings have had a protracted procedural history involving a number of procedural defaults by the applicant and several changes to his legal representation. Ultimately, the applicant has been unable to obtain counsel who are prepared to act in the absence of a litigation guardian. The respondent brought an application before the primary judge for an order appointing a litigation guardian for the applicant, or alternatively, a stay of proceedings pending the appointment of a litigation guardian. In considering this application, the primary judge took into account the procedural history of the matter; reports from two medical practitioners, Dr Bryden and Dr Rothwell, who each assessed the applicant’s legal capacity; notes from medical practitioners who the applicant consulted in October and November 2019; and affidavit evidence from the applicant’s solicitor, Mr Kerin, setting out the difficulties he faced obtaining counsel for the applicant. Dr Bryden and Dr Rothwell were retained by the applicant and respondent respectively to assess the applicant’s intellectual and reasoning capacity in relation to the underlying proceedings. There was no oral evidence. After considering this evidence, the primary judge concluded that the applicant is a person under a legal incapacity for the purposes of r 2.1(1) of the Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA), and ordered a stay of proceedings until a litigation guardian could be appointed, pursuant to r 23.8 of the Uniform Civil Rules. This decision is the subject of the current appeal. In respect of the application for leave to appeal, the respondent filed an affidavit sworn by its solicitor, Ms Cartledge, in which she said that the applicant’s solicitor, Mr Kerin, had told her that the Public Trustee had recently indicated that it is prepared to be appointed the applicant’s litigation guardian in the underlying proceedings, following the determination of this appeal. Mr Kerin subsequently filed an affidavit clarifying that whilst he had had a conversation with a representative of the Public Trustee about the prospect of it acting as litigation guardian, he had not intended to convey it had necessarily committed to doing so.Application for leave to appeal In deciding whether to grant leave to appeal, the Court acts in the interests of justice and by reference to three inter-related questions: whether the decision is attended by sufficient doubt to warrant its reconsideration on appeal; whether the appeal raises an issue of principle or general importance; and whether allowing the decision to stand would work a substantial injustice to the applicant. It is convenient to address the second and third considerations before addressing the merits of the appeal.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The primary judge considered the whole of the evidence before him and determined that the applicant is a person with a legal incapacity. In particular, his Honour found that due to his impaired cognitive function, the applicant is unable to appreciate and weigh the advantages and disadvantages of the competing forensic choices which must be made in the underlying proceedings, and that there is therefore a real risk that, without a litigation guardian, he will be disadvantaged in the conduct of his affairs. For the reasons explained, the applicant’s proposed grounds of appeal do not disclose any reasonably arguable basis for challenging the primary judge’s findings or conclusion.Conclusion In circumstances where there is no clear merit in the appeal, the appeal does not raise any issue of principle or general importance, and there is limited scope for any substantial injustice if the primary judge’s decision stands, the interests of justice do not favour a grant of leave to appeal. For the reasons set out, we grant an extension of time but dismiss the application for leave to appeal. We order costs in favour of the respondent in the amount of $1,000.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established