Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Nguyen v Hwang [2023] NSWSC 782 Hearing dates: 7 June 2023 Date of orders: 7 July 2023 Decision date: 07 July 2023 Jurisdiction: Common Law Before: Harrison AsJ Decision: (1) The defendants’ notice of motion filed 9 December 2022 is dismissed.
(2) The defendants’ are to pay the plaintiff’s costs.
Catchwords: CIVIL PROCEDURE – Review of Registrar’s decision – subpoenas – to produce documents or things – application to set aside – whether subpoenas were a fishing expedition – whether subpoenas had forensic value
Legislation Cited: Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) rr 33.4 and 49.19
Cases Cited: Groeneveld v Wollongong City Council (2009) 168 LGERA 260; [2009] NSWLEC 149
Commissioner for Railways v Small (1938) 38 SR (NSW) 564
Category: Procedural rulings Parties: Vo Vien Phuong Nguyen (Plaintiff)
Chiao Ling Hwang (First Defendant).
Vaissade Pty Ltd (Second Defendant).Representation: Counsel:
Dr S Baronlevi (Plaintiff)
Mr D Zhao (First and Second Defendants).Solicitors:
Kerrs law (Plaintiff)
Brightstone Legal (First and Second Defendants)
File Number(s): 2019/00392822-1
Judgment
-
This judgment concerns a review of the Registrar’s decision to set aside sixteen subpoenas to produce in accordance with r 49.19 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) (‘UCPR’). On 9 December 2022, the defendants sought to replace the Registrar’s order pursuant to r 33.4 of the UCPR.
-
The plaintiff is Vo Vien Phuong Nguyen. The first defendant is Chiao Ling Hwang. The second defendant is Vaissade Pty Ltd. The second defendant owned the premises on which the pharmacy was operating. S. Baronlevi appeared for the plaintiff. S. Zhao appeared for the defendants. The parties relied upon a joint court book marked Exhibit 1 (‘Ex 1’).
Background
-
The plaintiff and the first defendant are both pharmacists. The first defendant was the previous owner of the pharmacy (‘the Pharmacy’) which operated on the premises owned by the second defendant. Before selling the Pharmacy to the plaintiff in 2015. The second defendant is subject to a lease with the plaintiff.
-
On 25 May 2015, the plaintiff and the first defendant entered a contract for the sale of business (‘the Contract’). Prior to the execution of this contract, the first defendant and/or her agents provided the plaintiff with Dispensing Activity Reports for the 2012, 2013 and 2014 financial years (‘Dispensing Activity Reports’). The Dispensing Activity Reports included the number and breakdown of prescriptions dispensed by the business for those financial years.
-
On 13 December 2019, the plaintiff commenced proceedings on based on allegations that the Dispensing Activity Report provided by the plaintiff in 2014 was untrue, without bases or reasonable bases and either recklessly fraudulent or negligently fraudulent. The first defendant denies these allegations.
-
In 2020, the plaintiff, in her amended statement of claim (‘ASC’), joined the second defendant in order to seek relief in relation to rent paid to it.
-
Paragraph [11] of the plaintiff’s ASC pleads that the Dispensing…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Nguyen v Hwang and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] NSWSC 782
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the criteria for setting aside a subpoena, which included whether the subpoena was a fishing expedition and whether it had forensic value. The court found that the subpoenas were not a fishing expedition as they were not vague or ambiguous, and the documents and items sought were relevant to the proceedings. The court also found that the subpoenas had forensic value as the documents and items sought were necessary for the respondent to establish their case. The court noted that the respondent had provided a detailed affidavit outlining the relevance of the documents and items sought, and the appellant had not provided any evidence to rebut this.
As a result of its findings, the court dismissed the application to set aside the subpoenas. The court held that the subpoenas were not a fishing expedition and had forensic value. The court found that the respondent had made out a prima facie case for the documents and items sought, and the appellant had not shown that the subpoenas were oppressive or an abuse of process. The court noted that the appellant had not provided any evidence to rebut the respondent’s affidavit, and the subpoenas were not vague or ambiguous.
The court ordered that the subpoenas remain in force and that the appellant comply with the subpoenas by producing the documents and items sought. The court also ordered that the costs of the application be paid by the appellant to the respondent.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case came before the court following an application by Ms. Hwang to set aside the subpoenas issued by Mr. Nguyen. This application was brought under the relevant civil procedure rules, which allow for the review of subpoenas to ensure they are not oppressive or an abuse of the court process. The court considered submissions from both parties and relevant authorities on the scope and purpose of subpoenas. The matter was heard by a Registrar who made an initial decision to refuse Ms. Hwang's application to set aside the subpoenas. Ms. Hwang then applied to the court for a review of the Registrar’s decision, leading to the current proceedings.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the subpoenas issued by Mr. Nguyen were a fishing expedition.
2. Whether the subpoenas had forensic value in the context of the litigation.
3. Whether the subpoenas were oppressive or an abuse of the court process.
Held
1. The court concluded that the subpoenas issued by Mr. Nguyen were not a fishing expedition.
2. The court found that the subpoenas did have forensic value in the context of the litigation.
3. The court determined that the subpoenas were not oppressive or an abuse of the court process.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court commenced its analysis by examining the nature of the subpoenas issued by Mr. Nguyen. It found that the subpoenas were targeted and specific, aimed at obtaining documents relevant to the issues in dispute. This specificity indicated that they were not a fishing expedition, which typically involves broad and vague requests without a clear connection to the litigation. The court referred to the established criteria for determining whether a subpoena amounts to a fishing expedition, emphasizing that the requests must be relevant and necessary to the issues at hand. Given the targeted nature of the subpoenas, the court concluded they were not a fishing expedition.
Regarding the forensic value of the subpoenas, the court considered whether the documents sought were likely to contain evidence relevant to the litigation. It held that the subpoenas had forensic value because the documents requested were pertinent to the issues in dispute, and their production could potentially assist in the resolution of the case. The court noted that the relevance of the documents to the litigation was a key factor in determining their forensic value, and in this case, the documents were deemed relevant.
Lastly, the court addressed the question of whether the subpoenas were oppressive or an abuse of the court process. It found that the subpoenas did not meet the threshold for being considered oppressive or an abuse. The court examined the balance between the need for the documents and the potential burden on the respondent. Given that the documents were relevant and necessary for the litigation, the court concluded that the subpoenas were not oppressive or an abuse of the court process. This conclusion was supported by the lack of any evidence suggesting that the subpoenas were issued for an improper purpose or with the intent to cause unnecessary hardship. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that subpoenas must be targeted, relevant, and necessary to the litigation to avoid being considered a fishing expedition and to possess forensic value. The court also reinforced the need for a balance between the parties' rights and the efficient administration of justice in determining whether a subpoena is oppressive or an abuse of process.