FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| NG v YANJIAN GROUP (AUSTRALIA) PTY LIMITED | [2013] FCCA 2349 |
| Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – Practice & Procedure – stay of proceedings – multiple proceedings – related proceedings in Supreme Court of Queensland – abuse of process. |
| Legislation: Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Regulations 2009 (Cth), reg.1.03 Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), s.32 |
| Blair v Curran (1939) 62 CLR 464 |
| Applicant: | MARCUS NG |
| Respondent: | YANJIAN GROUP (AUSTRALIA) PTY LIMITED T/A YANJIAN GROUP |
| File Number: | BRG 1063 of 2012 |
| Judgment of: | Judge Burnett |
| Hearing date: | 15 May 2013 |
| Date of Last Submission: | 15 May 2013 |
| Delivered at: | Brisbane |
| Delivered on: | 17 May 2013 |
REPRESENTATION
| Counsel for the Applicant: | Mr P. Hastie |
| Solicitors for the Applicant: | Clarke Kann Lawyers |
| Senior counsel for the Respondent: Junior counsel for the Respondent: | Mr K. Barlow SC Mr M. Amerena |
| Solicitors for the Respondent: | MacDonnells Law |
ORDERS
That the Applicant has leave to amend these proceedings to incorporate into these proceedings claims made in proceeding BS10108 of 2012 in the Supreme Court of Queensland.
That the Applicant file an amended claim and statement of claim on or before 4pm 1 June 2013.
Alternatively the Applicant make application for cross-vesting of the Supreme Court proceeding BS10108 of 2012 to the Federal Court of Australia on or before 4pm 1 June 2013.
That upon the Applicant either filing an amended claim and statement of claim in these proceedings or making application for an order for cross-vesting following the application in terms of paragraph 2 or 3 herein (respectively), these proceedings be transferred to the Federal Court of Australia.
That in default of the Applicant filing an amended claim and statement of claim or making application for an order for cross-vesting, these proceedings be stayed pending the outcome of the proceedings BS10108 of 2012 in the Supreme Court of Queensland.
That costs of the interim application filed on 6 May 2013 be reserved.
| FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT BRISBANE |
BRG 1063 of 2012
| MARCUS NG |
Applicant
And
| YANJIAN GROUP (AUSTRALIA) PTY LIMITED T/A YANJIAN GROUP |
Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
(Ex tempore)
This case illustrates the difficulties that can arise when tactical decisions concerning the forum in which litigation is to be conducted are undertaken without first embarking upon the necessary strategic overview to inform the tactical decisions. There are two proceedings on foot; both concern the same parties, and in each they have the same role. The separate proceedings are inextricably related. They arose out of an employment relationship that existed between Mr Marcus Ng (“the employee”) and Yanjian Group (Australia) Pty Ltd trading as Yanjian Group (“the employer”).
That relationship between them commenced on 1 November 2009 and concluded on 13 September 2012 when…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Ng v Yanjian Group (Australia) Pty Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] FCCA 2349
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine the appropriate forum for the resolution of Mr Ng's claims, given the existence of parallel proceedings in different jurisdictions. Specifically, the court considered how to manage the two inextricably related sets of claims, one concerning statutory rights under the *Fair Work Act* and the other concerning alleged common law contractual entitlements, including a significant claim for a share of project profits. The court also had to address the applicant's request to amend his Federal Circuit Court proceedings to incorporate claims from the Supreme Court action.
Judge Burnett reasoned that the tactical decision to pursue litigation in separate forums without a comprehensive strategic overview had created difficulties. The court acknowledged the applicant's desire to litigate his statutory and common law claims separately but recognised the inherent connection between them. The court's approach was to facilitate the consolidation of these related claims, either by allowing the applicant to amend his Federal Circuit Court claim to include the Supreme Court claims or by requiring an application for cross-vesting of the Supreme Court proceeding to the Federal Court.
The court ordered that the applicant be granted leave to amend his proceedings to incorporate the claims made in the Supreme Court of Queensland. The applicant was directed to file an amended claim and statement of claim by a specified date, or alternatively, to make an application for cross-vesting of the Supreme Court proceeding to the Federal Court. Upon the applicant taking either of these steps, the Federal Circuit Court proceedings were to be transferred to the Federal Court of Australia. In default of the applicant complying with these orders, the proceedings were to be stayed pending the outcome of the Supreme Court action. The costs of an interim application were reserved.
Orders
Orders of the court
1.
That the Applicant has leave to amend these proceedings to incorporate into these proceedings claims made in proceeding BS10108 of 2012 in the Supreme Court of Queensland.
2.
That the Applicant file an amended claim and statement of claim on or before 4pm 1 June 2013.
3.
Alternatively the Applicant make application for cross-vesting of the Supreme Court proceeding BS10108 of 2012 to the Federal Court of Australia on or before 4pm 1 June 2013.
4.
That upon the Applicant either filing an amended claim and statement of claim in these proceedings or making application for an order for cross-vesting following the application in terms of paragraph 2 or 3 herein (respectively), these proceedings be transferred to the Federal Court of Australia.
5.
That in default of the Applicant filing an amended claim and statement of claim or making application for an order for cross-vesting, these proceedings be stayed pending the outcome of the proceedings BS10108 of 2012 in the Supreme Court of Queensland.
6.
That costs of the interim application filed on 6 May 2013 be reserved.
FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
AT BRISBANE
BRG 1063 of 2012
MARCUS NG
Applicant
And
YANJIAN GROUP (AUSTRALIA) PTY LIMITED T/A YANJIAN GROUP
Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
(Ex tempore)
1.
This case illustrates the difficulties that can arise when tactical decisions concerning the forum in which litigation is to be conducted are undertaken without first embarking upon the necessary strategic overview to inform the tactical decisions. There are two proceedings on foot; both concern the same parties, and in each they have the same role. The separate proceedings are inextricably related. They arose out of an employment relationship that existed between Mr Marcus Ng (“the employee”) and Yanjian Group (Australia) Pty Ltd trading as Yanjian Group (“the employer”).
2.
That relationship between them commenced on 1 November 2009 and concluded on 13 September 2012 when Mr Ng was made redundant. I will detail the proceedings in a moment. The employee seeks to litigate in this court in respect of rights he claims pursuant to the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (“FW Act”). He separately seeks to litigate in the Supreme Court of Queensland common law rights that he alleges arise from the contract of employment. The Fair Work claim is for a sum of approximately $210,000, and the common law claim is for a sum of approximately $1.2 million.
3.
The Supreme Court proceedings were commenced first by filing on 30 October 2012. Presumably the employee was concurrently engaged in the conciliation process at the Fair Work Commission in respect of his rights under the FW Act, for he only received his s.370 certificate on 3 December 2012. He was unable to commence proceedings here until that time. Accepting that the processes involved before the Fair Work Commission would have taken a little time, it is not unreasonable to infer that at the same time as he was instituting proceedings in the Supreme Court he was also before the Commission.
4.
As I have noted, on 3 December he received his certificate and was then able to commence proceedings in this court. In broad terms, the respective proceedings are these. In this court the claim comprises three elements:
a) An adverse action claim. Mr Ng alleges that his employment was terminated because he sought to assert a workplace right, namely, to make a complaint or inquiry in relation to his employment. He thereby seeks compensation, a pecuniary penalty and interest. The compensation is particularised as comprising 12 months’ salary, superannuation and allowances in lieu of notice of termination, totalling about $143,000, as well as a bonus of $40,000.
b) Untaken but accrued annual leave quantified in an amount of approximately $18,600.
c) Redundancy pay in a sum of about $10,000. I note the employer’s contention that that claim sits uncomfortably with the adverse action claim.
5.
In the Supreme Court claim, Mr Ng agitates for a declaration for an account of profits, an order for payment of amounts due and/or damages for breach of contract.
6.
At the heart of that proceeding is an alleged oral agreement said to comprise Mr Ng’s contract of employment between Yanjian Group and himself. That contract was allegedly made in or about November 2012 between him and Mr Bo Tang, a director of Yanjian’s Chinese holding company, on behalf of Yanjian, which was not then incorporated. The terms of the alleged oral agreement are the foundation of both the expressed and implied terms in Mr Ng’s alleged contract of employment and of his purported entitlement to a share of 15 per cent of the after-tax profits of Yanjian’s ‘Midtown’ project, quantified by Mr Ng at $1.2 million.
7.
Background
Background to the litigation
Mr Ng commenced the Supreme Court proceedings on 30 October 2012, shortly before receiving his section 370 certificate from the Fair Work Commission on 3 December 2012, which allowed him to initiate proceedings in the Federal Circuit Court. In the Federal Circuit Court, Mr Ng's claim includes three elements: an adverse action claim, untaken but accrued annual leave, and redundancy pay. Specifically, he alleges that his employment was terminated for seeking to assert a workplace right, entitling him to 12 months’ salary, superannuation, allowances in lieu of notice of termination, and a bonus, totalling about $183,000. Additionally, he claims approximately $18,600 for untaken annual leave and about $10,000 for redundancy pay. The employer contends that the redundancy pay claim is inconsistent with the adverse action claim.
The crux of the Supreme Court claim is an alleged oral agreement made between Mr Ng and Mr Bo Tang, a director of Yanjian’s Chinese holding company, in or about November 2012. This alleged agreement is the basis for Mr Ng’s entitlement to a 15 per cent share of the after-tax profits of Yanjian’s 'Midtown' project, which he quantifies at $1.2 million. Mr Ng seeks a declaration for an account of profits, an order for payment of amounts due, and/or damages for breach of contract. The proceedings in both courts are inextricably linked, as they concern the same parties and the same employment relationship, leading to the court's orders regarding the procedural steps Mr Ng must take to consolidate these claims.
The procedural history of the case Ng v Yanjian Group (Australia) Pty Limited commenced when the applicant, Marcus Ng, initiated proceedings in the Supreme Court of Queensland on 30 October 2012, seeking a declaration for an account of profits, an order for payment of amounts due, and/or damages for breach of contract. This was done before Ng received his section 370 certificate from the Fair Work Commission, which he obtained on 3 December 2012, allowing him to proceed in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. Following the receipt of the certificate, Ng commenced proceedings in this court on 12 December 2012, asserting claims for adverse action, untaken but accrued annual leave, and redundancy pay. The proceedings in the Supreme Court and the Federal Circuit Court were inextricably related as they both concerned the same parties and the same employment relationship. The court was tasked with managing the concurrent proceedings and ensuring that the claims were appropriately addressed in the right forum.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Applicant has leave to amend these proceedings to incorporate claims made in the Supreme Court proceeding BS10108 of 2012.
2. Whether the Applicant must file an amended claim and statement of claim by 4pm on 1 June 2013.
3. Whether the Applicant must make an application for cross-vesting of the Supreme Court proceeding BS10108 of 2012 to the Federal Court of Australia by 4pm on 1 June 2013.
4. Whether these proceedings should be transferred to the Federal Court of Australia upon the Applicant filing an amended claim and statement of claim or making an application for an order for cross-vesting.
5. Whether these proceedings should be stayed pending the outcome of the proceedings BS10108 of 2012 in the Supreme Court of Queensland if the Applicant fails to file an amended claim and statement of claim or make an application for an order for cross-vesting.
6. Whether the costs of the interim application filed on 6 May 2013 should be reserved.
Held
1. The Applicant has leave to amend these proceedings to incorporate claims made in the Supreme Court proceeding BS10108 of 2012.
2. The Applicant must file an amended claim and statement of claim by 4pm on 1 June 2013.
3. Alternatively, the Applicant must make an application for cross-vesting of the Supreme Court proceeding BS10108 of 2012 to the Federal Court of Australia by 4pm on 1 June 2013.
4. Upon the Applicant filing an amended claim and statement of claim or making an application for an order for cross-vesting, these proceedings should be transferred to the Federal Court of Australia.
5. If the Applicant fails to file an amended claim and statement of claim or make an application for an order for cross-vesting, these proceedings should be stayed pending the outcome of the proceedings BS10108 of 2012 in the Supreme Court of Queensland.
6. The costs of the interim application filed on 6 May 2013 should be reserved.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court's reasoning in this case revolves around the complexities arising from the strategic oversight in choosing the appropriate forum for litigation. The employee, Mr. Marcus Ng, initiated proceedings in two separate courts, the Federal Circuit Court of Australia and the Supreme Court of Queensland, for claims arising from the same employment relationship with Yanjian Group (Australia) Pty Ltd. The decision addresses whether Mr. Ng should be allowed to amend the proceedings to incorporate claims from the Supreme Court, the timeline for filing amended claims, and the implications of cross-vesting, transfer, and stay of proceedings.
In granting leave for Mr. Ng to amend these proceedings, the court examined the inextricable connection between the two sets of proceedings and the necessity for a strategic overview before initiating litigation. The Federal Circuit Court recognized that the claims under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and common law rights in the Supreme Court are fundamentally related and involve the same parties. The court applied the principle that when proceedings are closely connected and involve overlapping issues, it is preferable to consolidate them in one forum to avoid multiplicity of litigation and ensure judicial efficiency. This decision aligns with the judicial approach to managing related proceedings and preventing piecemeal litigation.
The court set a deadline for Mr. Ng to file an amended claim and statement of claim by 4pm on 1 June 2013, or alternatively to apply for cross-vesting of the Supreme Court proceeding to the Federal Court of Australia by the same date. The rationale behind this timeline is to provide Mr. Ng with a clear and specific deadline to either integrate the claims or pursue the appropriate legal process for transferring jurisdiction. This decision underscores the importance of timely action to avoid unnecessary delays and to facilitate the expeditious resolution of the litigation. The court relied on precedents that emphasize the necessity for litigants to act promptly and decisively when faced with overlapping claims in different jurisdictions.
Upon Mr. Ng either filing an amended claim or applying for cross-vesting, the court ordered the transfer of the proceedings to the Federal Court of Australia. This order was grounded in the principle of judicial economy and the desire to avoid duplication of effort. By transferring the proceedings, the court aimed to streamline the litigation process and ensure that all related claims are adjudicated in one forum. The decision reflects a commitment to consolidating related matters to enhance efficiency and reduce the burden on the judicial system.
The court also considered the possibility of staying the proceedings if Mr. Ng failed to meet the deadlines. This decision was based on the court’s discretion to manage its caseload effectively and to prevent the proceedings from proceeding without clarity on the jurisdictional issues. Staying the proceedings pending the outcome of the Supreme Court litigation allows the court to avoid potential conflicts and ensure that all related claims are resolved in a coordinated manner.
Lastly, the court reserved the costs of the interim application filed on 6 May 2013. This decision reflects the court’s discretion to manage costs associated with interim applications, particularly when the outcome of the main proceedings may influence the final costs order. The reservation of costs allows the court to make a comprehensive assessment once the substantive issues are resolved.
In summary, the court’s decisions in Ng v Yanjian Group (Australia) Pty Limited illustrate a balanced approach to managing related litigation in different forums. The key legal principles applied include the consolidation of related claims, the necessity for timely action by litigants, and the importance of judicial efficiency. The court’s reasoning and the orders issued reflect a commitment to resolving overlapping claims in a manner that avoids duplication and promotes the effective administration of justice.