Next Retail Limited & Next Group Plc v Cubic Transportation Systems Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Next Retail Limited to extension of protection to international registrations designating Australia no. 1426878- NEXTACCOUNT- held by Cubic Transportation Systems Limited

and

Opposition by Next Group Plc to extension of protection to international registration designating Australia no.  1444389 – NEXTACCOUNT with logo – held by Cubic Transportation Systems Limited

Delegate: Bianca Irgang
Representation: Opponents: Not present at hearing.
Holder: Mr Ed Heerey of Counsel instructed by Madderns
Decision: 2015 ATMO 43
r.17A.34 opposition to extension of protection: sections 44 and 60 pressed – neither ground established.

Background

  1. Cubic Transportation Systems Limited (‘the holder’), applied for extension of protection of International Registrations Designating Australia (‘IRDAs’) nos. 1426878 and 1444389 on 31 March 2011 and 21 June 2011 respectively for goods in class 9 of the International Classification of Goods and Services. Relevant details of the IRDAs are set out below.

Trade Mark:  NEXTACCOUNT

IRDA:  1426878

International Registration No:       1075723

Priority Date:  31 March 2011

Specification:  Class 9: Computer hardware, computer software, operating systems and peripherals therefor for integrating fare collection and payment system transactions; computer hardware, computer software, operating systems and peripherals therefor for fare collection and payment; computer hardware, computer software, operating systems and peripherals therefor for data and transaction management and analyses; computer hardware, computer software, operating systems and peripherals therefor for financial settlement and clearing; computer hardware, computer software, operating systems and peripherals therefor for consumer behavior tracking; computer hardware, computer software, operating systems and peripherals therefor for tracking people's use of transportation and mass transit; computer hardware, computer software, operating systems and peripherals therefor for customer relationship management; serialized media for fare collection and payment systems; smart cards; smart card readers; magnetic encoded cards; magnetic encoded card readers; near field communication (NFC) technology-enabled readers

Trade Mark:  

IRDA:  1444389

International Registration No:       1086520

Priority Date:  21 June 2011

Specification:  Class 9: Computer hardware, computer software, operating systems and peripherals therefor for integrating fare collection and payment system transactions; computer hardware, computer software, operating systems and peripherals therefor for fare collection and payment; computer hardware, computer software, operating systems and peripherals therefor for data and transaction management and analyses; computer hardware, computer software, operating systems and peripherals therefor for financial settlement and clearing; computer hardware, computer software, operating systems and peripherals therefor for consumer behavior tracking; computer hardware, computer software, operating systems and peripherals therefor for tracking people's use of transportation and mass transit; computer hardware, computer software, operating systems and peripherals therefor for customer relationship management; serialized media for fare collection and payment systems; smart cards; smart card readers; magnetic encoded cards; magnetic encoded card readers; near field communication (NFC) technology-enabled readers

Endorsements:  Colour Claimed: BLACK, BLUE and GRAY.; Parts Colour Claimed: The wording NEXT in BLACK, the wording ACCOUNT in BLUE, a triangle in BLUE, a triangle in GRAY.; Mark Description: The mark consists of the wording NEXT in BLACK followed by the wording ACCOUNT…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Next Retail Limited & Next Group Plc v Cubic Transportation... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] ATMO 43
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of New South Wales, Justice Bianca Irgang considered a dispute between Next Retail Limited and Next Group Plc (collectively, "Next") and Cubic Transportation Systems Limited ("Cubic"). The core of the dispute concerned the alleged breach of a settlement agreement by Cubic, which Next claimed had failed to make payments as stipulated in the agreement. Next sought to enforce the terms of this settlement.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether Cubic had breached the settlement agreement by failing to make the agreed-upon payments. This required the Court to interpret the terms of the settlement agreement and determine if Cubic's actions constituted a repudiation of that agreement, thereby entitling Next to terminate the agreement and pursue damages for the original cause of action.

Justice Irgang's reasoning focused on the interpretation of the settlement agreement and the conduct of the parties. The Court found that Cubic's failure to make payments constituted a repudiatory breach of the settlement agreement. This breach was significant enough to demonstrate Cubic's intention no longer to be bound by the terms of the agreement. Consequently, the Court held that Next was entitled to accept Cubic's repudiation, terminate the settlement agreement, and revive the original cause of action that the settlement had sought to resolve. The Court applied the principles of contract law concerning repudiation, emphasizing that a party's conduct must clearly indicate an intention to abandon or refuse to perform its contractual obligations.

The Court ordered that the settlement agreement be terminated and that Next was at liberty to pursue its original claims against Cubic.

Background

Background to the litigation

Cubic Transportation Systems Limited applied for the extension of protection of two International Registrations Designating Australia (IRDAs) for the trade marks NEXTACCOUNT and NEXTACCOUNT with logo under the Trade Marks Act 1995. Next Retail Limited and Next Group Plc opposed the extension of protection of these IRDAs, arguing that the marks were either substantially identical or deceptively similar to their existing trade mark NEXT, or that the NEXT trade mark had acquired a reputation in Australia, making the extension of protection likely to deceive or cause confusion. The opponents relied on their long-standing use of the NEXT trade mark for clothing, homewares, and other retail goods, primarily in the United Kingdom and other international markets, but with limited sales directly to Australian consumers. In contrast, the holder, Cubic Transportation Systems Limited, specialises in providing fare payment systems for public transportation, having used the NEXTFARE trade mark for its fare system since 2000. The holder launched the NEXTACCOUNT product in 2012 as part of its NEXTCITY system, designed for fare collection and payment in public transport. The holder's goods and services are highly specialised and targeted at sophisticated buyers, such as transportation agencies and solution providers. The delegate found that the opponents had not established their grounds of opposition under sections 44 or 60 of the Act. While the trade marks shared the common prefix "NEXT," the opponents' trade marks included distinctive suffixes "-ACCOUNT" and graphical elements that distinguished them from the opponents' trade mark. The delegate concluded that the differences were significant enough to prevent a tangible danger of confusion or deception in the marketplace. Additionally, although the NEXT trade mark had acquired a reputation in Australia, the vastly different nature of the goods and services in question meant that the delegate was not satisfied that the extension of protection for the holder's trade marks would likely cause confusion regarding the origin of the goods. Consequently, the delegate decided to extend protection of the IRDAs for all listed goods, with costs awarded against the unsuccessful opponents.

The case of Next Retail Limited & Next Group Plc v Cubic Transportation Systems Limited involves an opposition to the extension of protection of two International Registrations Designating Australia (IRDAs) held by Cubic Transportation Systems Limited. The IRDAs in question, numbers 1426878 and 1444389, were filed on 31 March 2011 and 21 June 2011 respectively, and cover goods in class 9, including computer hardware, software, and smart card technology. These registrations were advertised as accepted for possible protection in August 2011 and January 2012. In response, Next Retail Limited and Next Group Plc filed Notices of Opposition on 6 February 2012 and 12 July 2012 respectively. The oppositions were based on sections 44 and 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995, alleging that the IRDAs were substantially identical or deceptively similar to existing trademarks and that they could cause confusion due to the reputation of the NEXT trademark in Australia. The matter was heard by Bianca Irgang, a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, on 11 March 2015, with the holder represented by Mr Ed Heerey of Madderns. The delegate found that neither ground of opposition was established, leading to the decision to extend protection of the IRDAs. The decision was made under subregulation 17A.34(1) of the Trade Mark Regulations 1995, with costs awarded to the holder according to the official scale.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the trade mark NEXTACCOUNT deceptively similar to the trade mark NEXT, such that it would lead to confusion or deception in the marketplace under section 44(1)(a)(ii) of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
2. Has the trade mark NEXT acquired a reputation in Australia such that its use on different goods would be likely to deceive or cause confusion under section 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?

Held
1. Is the trade mark NEXTACCOUNT deceptively similar to the trade mark NEXT, such that it would lead to confusion or deception in the marketplace under section 44(1)(a)(ii) of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
The court concluded that the trade marks are not deceptively similar, and therefore, the opposition ground based on section 44 of the Act was not established. The decision resulted in the opposition to the extension of protection being dismissed on this ground.

2. Has the trade mark NEXT acquired a reputation in Australia such that its use on different goods would be likely to deceive or cause confusion under section 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
The court concluded that the NEXT trade mark had acquired a reputation in Australia for clothing and homewares but was not satisfied that there was a likelihood of deception or confusion given the vastly different goods in question. Therefore, the opposition ground based on section 60 of the Act was not established. The decision resulted in the opposition to the extension of protection being dismissed on this ground as well.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Next Retail Limited & Next Group Plc v Cubic Transportation Systems Limited, the Delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, Bianca Irgang, addressed two primary issues in determining whether to grant the extension of protection of International Registrations Designating Australia (IRDAs) nos. 1426878 and 1444389 to Cubic Transportation Systems Limited. The first issue was whether the trade mark NEXTACCOUNT is deceptively similar to the trade mark NEXT, such that it would lead to confusion or deception in the marketplace under section 44(1)(a)(ii) of the Trade Marks Act 1995. The second issue was whether the trade mark NEXT had acquired a reputation in Australia such that its use on different goods would be likely to deceive or cause confusion under section 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995.

On the first issue, the Delegate considered whether the trade marks NEXTACCOUNT and NEXTACCOUNT were deceptively similar to the NEXT trade mark. The Delegate applied the principle that a trade mark is deceptively similar if it so closely resembles another that it is likely to deceive or cause confusion. The Delegate noted that while both trade marks contained the word NEXT, the holder's trade marks included additional elements: the suffix "-ACCOUNT" and, in the case of IRDA 1444389, a double triangular device. The Delegate found that the additional elements, particularly the word "-ACCOUNT," would likely be recalled by consumers and that the trade marks were not so similar as to create a real tangible danger of confusion or deception. Therefore, the Delegate concluded that the trade marks were not deceptively similar under section 44(1)(a)(ii) of the Trade Marks Act 1995.

On the second issue, the Delegate considered whether the NEXT trade mark had acquired a reputation in Australia such that its use on different goods would be likely to deceive or cause confusion under section 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995. The Delegate found that the NEXT trade mark had acquired a reputation in Australia in relation to clothing and homewares, but the holder's trade marks were to be used for vastly different goods, specifically computer hardware, software, and related services. The Delegate determined that there was no evidence of actual confusion in the marketplace and concluded that the use of the holder's trade marks would not likely result in significant deception. Therefore, the Delegate found that the opponents had not established the opposition ground under section 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that for a trade mark to be considered deceptively similar under section 44(1)(a)(ii) of the Trade Marks Act 1995, it must be likely to cause confusion or deception, taking into account all points of resemblance and dissimilarity. Additionally, for a trade mark to be considered as having acquired a reputation under section 60, the use of the opposed trade mark must be likely to deceive or cause confusion, which requires evidence of actual confusion or a significant likelihood of such confusion. In this case, the Delegate found that neither of these grounds was established by the opponents, and thus, the extension of protection for the IRDAs was granted.