Newstart Homes Australia Pty Ltd v Kodiak Concrete Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Newstart Homes Australia Pty Ltd v Kodiak Concrete Pty Ltd [2024] QSC 129

PARTIES:

NEWSTART HOMES AUSTRALIA PTY LTD ACN 616 573 463

(applicant)

v
KODIAK CONCRETE PTY LTD ACN 636 336 322

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS 14327 of 2023

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Originating Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

19 June 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

16 May 2024

JUDGE:

Cooper J

ORDER:

Application dismissed

CATCHWORDS:

CORPORATIONS – WINDING UP – OTHER GROUNDS FOR WINDING UP – ABUSE OF PROCESS – where the respondent performed works pursuant to a subcontract for the applicant – where the works performed by the respondent were allegedly defective and not rectified by the respondent as required by the subcontract – where the applicant sought to recover the rectification costs of the allegedly defective works by serving a statutory demand on the respondent – where the respondent disputed the debt which was the subject of the statutory demand – where, in the present proceedings, the applicant applied to wind up the respondent for insolvency as the debt which was the subject of the statutory demand was not paid – where the respondent argues that the application for winding up is an abuse of process – where, in arguing that it is solvent, the respondent sought to argue that there is a genuine dispute as to the existence of the debt contained in the statutory demand – where the respondent did not apply to set aside the statutory demand – where, in circumstances where the respondent disputed that its work was defective, the amount due and payable under the subcontract could not be ascertained until the applicant had established in a proceeding for breach of the subcontract that the respondent’s work was defective – whether service of the statutory demand by the applicant constituted an abuse of process

CORPORATIONS – WINDING UP – WINDING UP IN INSOLVENCY – STATUTORY DEMAND – where two accounting reports were provided addressing the issue of the respondent’s solvency – where the first report undertook a cash flow, profit and loss statement, and balance sheet analysis to demonstrate that the respondent was solvent – where the second report’s purpose was to review and comment on the conclusions in the first report – where the second report stated that there were numerous faults in the financial information available on which the first report was based and that the methodology used in the first report was not a proper basis upon which to assess the solvency of the respondent – where the second report opined that the respondent was insolvent at 31 December 2023 and remains insolvent – where the expert who prepared the first report prepared another report responding to the comments in the second report confirming that the respondent was solvent – where it was disputed that a director’s loan was owed by the respondent’s director to the respondent and repayable on demand by the respondent – where it was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Newstart Homes Australia Pty Ltd v Kodiak Concrete Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QSC 129
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Newstart Homes Australia Pty Ltd sought to wind up Kodiak Concrete Pty Ltd for insolvency, arguing that Kodiak had failed to rectify defective works as required by their subcontract. Kodiak disputed the debt and claimed the winding up application was an abuse of process. The court had to decide whether the statutory demand was an abuse of process and whether Kodiak was solvent. The court found that Kodiak had established its solvency through a cash flow forecast, adjusted for errors and omissions, and that the dispute over the director's loan did not alter this conclusion. The court also found that the statutory demand did not constitute an abuse of process.

The court considered the financial reports and evidence presented by both parties. The first report by David Johnstone, a partner at KordaMentha, concluded that Kodiak was solvent based on an adjusted cash flow forecast. This was challenged by a second report by Matthew Hudson, who disputed the reliability of Kodiak's financial records. However, the court accepted Johnstone's analysis as a sufficient basis for finding that Kodiak was solvent, despite the criticisms of its financial records. The dispute over the director's loan was also considered, but the court found that it did not affect the solvency analysis.

Orders

Orders of the court

Application dismissed

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As will become apparent, Newstart criticises the quality of the financial records which Kodiak has provided for the purpose of seeking to establish that it is insolvent. This submission relies on the observation by Hayne J in Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Begonia[26] that, ordinarily, it would be expected that a company would provide “the fullest and best” material in support of its case in opposition to the application that it be wound up in insolvency. However, Newstart acknowledges that there is no inflexible rule that a company may only prove insolvency by producing audited accounts.[27][26](1993) 11 ACSR 609, 617. See also Expile Pty Ltd v Jabb’s Excavations Pty Ltd (2003) 45 ACSR 711, 719 [16].[27]Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v De Simone Consulting Pty Ltd [2007] FCA 548, [11]-[14]; Coates Hire Operations Pty Ltd v D-Link Homes Pty Ltd [2011] NSWSC 1279, [60]-[61]; Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Bayconnection Property Developments Pty Ltd (2012) 127 ALD 64, 74–75 [60]-[61]; Xu v Megaward Pty Ltd (2018) 130 ACSR 412, 417–418 [30]-[32].Evidence of Kodiak’s financial position In submitting that it has displaced the presumption of insolvency, Kodiak relies principally on two reports prepared by David Johnstone, a partner at KordaMentha. Newstart relies on a report prepared by Matthew Hudson, an associate director at SV Partners. Mr Brittain and Mrs Brittain also provided affidavits which went to the issue of solvency.First report of Mr Johnstone Mr Johnstone provided his first report on 8 February 2024. Having regard to various indicators, Mr Johnstone concluded in his first report that Kodiak was solvent at 30 June 2023 (being the date of the last full statutory account available to him) and at 8 February 2024. The primary analysis undertaken by Mr Johnstone in his first report involved his consideration and adjustment of a monthly cash flow forecast for Kodiak’s business for the period February 2024 to January 2025 prepared by the company’s external accountant. The cash flow forecast prepared by Kodiak’s accountant projected that the company’s cash balance would increase from $126,244.34 at the end of February 2024 to $501,043.05 at the end of January 2025. Mr Johnstone identified that this cash flow forecast omitted some expenditure items and failed to include provision for repayment of a payroll tax debt. Mr Johnstone prepared an adjusted cash flow forecast which took account of these items. That adjusted cashflow forecast projected that the company’s cash balance would increase from $28,292.19 at the end of February 2024 to $279,753.57 at the end of January 2025. A significant difference between the original cash flow forecast and Mr Johnstone’s adjusted cash flow forecast is Mr Johnstone’s assumption that, in the absence of a current payment arrangement with the Queensland Revenue Office, Kodiak would be required to pay its outstanding payroll tax debt of $68,493.17 in February 2024. In April 2024, after Mr Johnstone’s first report had been completed, Kodiak entered into a payment arrangement with the Queensland Revenue Office which requires it to pay weekly instalments of $1,000. Even without that payment arrangement in place, Mr Johnstone described the adjusted cash flow forecast as being conservative. He further concluded that this cash flow analysis indicated that Kodiak is solvent.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the reasons given above, I am satisfied that Kodiak has established to the requisite standard that it is solvent: that is, it can pay its debts as and when they fall due. Having regard to the availability of repayment by Mr Brittain of the director’s loan as a source of funds to pay Kodiak’s debts, that is a conclusion I have reached even if the debt claimed to be owing to Newstart was to be included in the solvency analysis. It is therefore unnecessary for Kodiak to seek leave under s 459S of the Act to rely upon a ground which it could have raised in seeking to have the statutory demand set aside (its dispute about the existence and amount of the debt claimed by Newstart).Conclusion Kodiak has succeeded on both grounds it relied upon to resist the winding up application. The application is dismissed. I cannot presently see any reason why costs should not follow the event but will hear from the parties on that issue before making any order as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mrs Brittain was not required for cross-examination.Consideration of Kodiak’s solvency Based on Kodiak’s financial records, I am satisfied that the company traded profitably in the 2022 and 2023 financial years and that it continued to trade profitably in the 2024 financial year up to the date of the hearing of the winding up application. I am also satisfied that no creditor other than Newstart has made any demand on Kodiak for repayment of a debt owed by the company, issued any notice of default to Kodiak or taken any enforcement action against Kodiak in respect of any outstanding debt. In addition to these considerations, the question whether Kodiak has displaced the presumption of insolvency requires a determination whether:(a)the issues Mr Johnstone raised about errors in Kodiak’s management accounts, or criticisms Newstart makes about the quality of the evidence led by Kodiak to demonstrate its solvency, would preclude the Court from relying upon that evidence to make a finding that Kodiak is solvent;(b)the director’s loan is in fact owed by Mr Brittain to Kodiak such that it should be considered an asset of the company to which recourse could be had, by demanding repayment from Mr Brittain, to increase the funds available to pay debts as and when they fall due;(c)Kodiak’s failure to comply with the statutory demand and the filing of Newstart’s winding up application has the result that Kodiak’s secured debts should be treated as having become immediately due and payable;(d)any further adjustments to Mr Johnstone’s adjusted cash flow forecast would alter the outcome of that cash flow analysis to the extent that it could not be concluded that Kodiak is able to pay its debts as and when they fall due.The accuracy and reliability of Kodiak’s financial records Although Mr Johnstone found errors in Kodiak’s management accounts, his evidence was that he did not have regard to those accounts and instead sought and was provided with further information which he found to be a sufficient basis for his conclusion that the company was solvent. I accept that evidence. I do not accept that, in the circumstances of this case, Newstart’s criticisms of the reliability of Kodiak’s financial records diminishes the probity of Mr Johnstone’s cash flow forecast to such an extent that I should disregard that analysis as a basis for finding that Kodiak is solvent. In my view, taking account of the conclusions I have reached on the matters to which I now turn, Kodiak’s financial records and the adjusted cash flow forecast which Mr Johnstone prepared having regard to those records are a sufficient basis to find that Kodiak has established that it is able to pay its debts as and when they fall due.The director’s loan The inclusion of Mr Brittain’s address in Nerang on a loan agreement purportedly signed in September 2020, some nine months before he and Mrs Brittain purchased the land at Nerang on which the family home was eventually constructed, raises doubt as to whether that document was signed on the date it bears, or at some later time.