Newett and Newett & Anor (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEWETT & NEWETT AND ANOR (NO. 3) [2020] FamCA 822
FAMILY LAW – PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – applications filed by the mother and the Independent Children’s Lawyer – where the Court does not require the father to obtain updated evidence in respect of his health issues – where the Court finds the parties are entitled to know what documents the mother provided to single expert – where although there is no previous order for the appointment of the expert, the Court regards the expert as an expert witness retained jointly by the parties – where the Independent Children’s Lawyer is permitted to ask the expert a question to clarify his report – where the Court is not prepared to make an order in respect of a motor vehicle on the basis that the final hearing is less than three months away – where the mother is permitted to file contravention applications she previously sought to file that had not been accepted for filing by the Registry – where earlier documents relating to the estate of the father’s relative have no relevance to the financial proceedings.
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) ss 75(2)(o), 102NA
De Angelis & De Angelis [1999] FamCA 1609
White & Tulloch & White [1995] FamCA 127
APPLICANT: Mr Newett
FIRST RESPONDENT: Ms Newett
SECOND RESPONDENT: Ms Adlam
FILE NUMBER: BRC 2179 of 2018
DATE DELIVERED: 3 September 2020
PLACE DELIVERED: Brisbane
PLACE HEARD: Brisbane
JUDGMENT OF: Baumann J
HEARING DATE: 3 September 2020

REPRESENTATION

SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT:

Mr S Richardson

Damien Greer Lawyers

THE FIRST RESPONDENT: Self-represented
THE SECOND RESPONDENT: Self-represented
INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER:

Mr D Carter

Carter Farquar Lawyers

Orders

  1. That Orders 1 to 4 and 9 sought in the amended Application in a Case filed by the Independent Children’s Lawyer on 26 August 2020 be dismissed.

  2. That the Court declares that the documents provided under tab “(12) Dr A Materials” saved to the USB delivered by the mother to the Court pursuant to Order 3 made 12 May 2020 are the documents that the mother presented to Dr A at interview on 17 August 2018.

  3. That the Independent Children’s Lawyer and the parties have leave to copy the documents produced by the mother under the tab “(12) Dr A materials”.

  4. That the Independent Children’s Lawyer and the parties have leave to copy the material produced by Dr A pursuant to the subpoena of the mother filed on 20 December 2019.

  5. That the Court, having heard argument, takes the view that Dr A, although not formally appointed as a Court Expert/Single Expert under the Family Court Rules 2004, has nonetheless undertaken the role as an independent expert and the Independent Children’s Lawyer intends to rely on the evidence at trial, the Court deems Dr A to be an expert called by the Independent Children’s Lawyer and both parties shall have, to the extent Dr A’s reports are relied upon, the opportunity to cross-examine Dr A.

  6. That the Court gives…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Newett and Newett & Anor (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FamCA 822
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Family Court of Australia, before Baumann J, this matter concerned parenting arrangements and property proceedings between the parties, identified as Newett and Newett, with the Independent Children’s Lawyer also participating. The proceedings involved various applications and counter-applications by the mother, as well as the role and evidence of a Dr A.

The court was required to determine several key issues, including the admissibility and treatment of documents provided by the mother to Dr A, the status of Dr A as an expert witness, and the extent to which Dr A's evidence could be relied upon and cross-examined. Additionally, the court considered applications to dismiss various orders sought by the mother and the Independent Children’s Lawyer, the discharge of an order bifurcating property and parenting proceedings, and the timing and nature of future hearings and trials. The mother also sought specific discovery from the father regarding alleged non-disclosure.

Baumann J reasoned that while Dr A was not formally appointed as a single expert under the Family Court Rules, he had acted in an independent expert capacity. Consequently, the court deemed Dr A to be an expert called by the Independent Children’s Lawyer, granting both parties the opportunity to cross-examine him to the extent his reports were relied upon. The court also made declarations regarding the authenticity of documents provided by the mother to Dr A and granted leave for the parties and the Independent Children’s Lawyer to copy relevant materials. Numerous applications by the mother to dismiss orders were dismissed.

The court ordered that the property and parenting proceedings would proceed to trial commencing on 30 November 2020, discharging the previous order that bifurcated these proceedings. An interim hearing regarding parenting arrangements was scheduled for 2 October 2020, with provisions for parties to appear by telephone. The mother was granted leave to file an application for specific discovery from the father concerning alleged non-disclosure, which would also be listed for the interim hearing. Judgment was reserved on the mother's application to discharge the Independent Children's Lawyer.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

That Orders 1 to 4 and 9 sought in the amended Application in a Case filed by the Independent Children’s Lawyer on 26 August 2020 be dismissed.

2.

That the Court declares that the documents provided under tab “(12) Dr A Materials” saved to the USB delivered by the mother to the Court pursuant to Order 3 made 12 May 2020 are the documents that the mother presented to Dr A at interview on 17 August 2018.

3.

That the Independent Children’s Lawyer and the parties have leave to copy the documents produced by the mother under the tab “(12) Dr A materials”.

4.

That the Independent Children’s Lawyer and the parties have leave to copy the material produced by Dr A pursuant to the subpoena of the mother filed on 20 December 2019.

5.

That the Court, having heard argument, takes the view that Dr A, although not formally appointed as a Court Expert/Single Expert under the Family Court Rules 2004, has nonetheless undertaken the role as an independent expert and the Independent Children’s Lawyer intends to rely on the evidence at trial, the Court deems Dr A to be an expert called by the Independent Children’s Lawyer and both parties shall have, to the extent Dr A’s reports are relied upon, the opportunity to cross-examine Dr A.

6.

That the Court gives leave to the Independent Children’s Lawyer to forward a question to Dr A in the following terms:

Dear Doctor

The Court has made orders allowing the delivery of certain questions to you in respect of your report and the documents you delivered to the court pursuant to the subpoena of the mother.

They are these:

(i) In reference to the words “but not included them in this report” in the last paragraph on page 20 of your report dated 16 October 2018, please clarify if those words mean that you did not list or describe the documents in your report or that you did not consider the documents?

(ii) You delivered documents in response to a subpoena of the mother filed 20 December 2019. Did those documents contain all of the documents delivered to you by the mother at interview on 17 August 2018?

Thanks

7.

That Orders 4, 5 and 8 sought in the amended Application in a Case filed by the mother at 2.05am on 19 August 2020 be dismissed.

8.

That any applications for contravention the mother sought to file in February 2020 be filed and be returnable before a Registrar on the same date as the other contravention applications that have been filed.

9.

That Orders 5, 6, 7, 8A, 8B, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15 and 16 sought in the amended Application in a Case filed by the mother at 1.44am on 19 August 2020 be dismissed.

10.

That Order 1 sought in the Application in a Case filed by the mother on 18 August 2020 be dismissed.

11.

That these proceedings be adjourned for Interim Hearing regarding the parenting arrangements, noting that Orders made on 17 June 2020 (in anticipation of a trial commencing 28 September 2020) do not make provision for time after 27 September 2020, at 2.30pm on 2 October 2020 in the Family Court of Australia at Brisbane.

12.

That the parties have leave to appear by telephone on 2 October 2020 by using the “AAPT GlobalMeet” telephone conferencing system as follows:

(a) They shall each telephone 1800 132 423 (within Australia only) (toll free) by 2.25pm on 2 October 2020;

(b) Any party dialling in from outside of Australia shall telephone +61 (0) 7 … (with the necessary international dialling codes);

(c) They shall each then enter the pass code…; and

(d) Hold the line until the Court is ready to connect and proceed with the matter.

13.

That each party shall file and serve on each other by no later than 4.00pm on 23 September 2020 one (1) short affidavit of evidence in relation to:

(a) how the interim Orders made on 17 June 2020 have progressed; and

(b) proposals for further interim orders including for the Christmas school holidays and Christmas Day/Boxing Day.

14.

That judgment be reserved on the mother’s application to discharge the Independent Children’s Lawyer to a date to be advised.

15.

That Order 17 of Orders made 12 May 2020 which bifurcated the property and parenting proceedings be discharged.

16.

That both the property and parenting proceedings shall proceed to trial commencing 30 November 2020.

17.

That noting that the unrepresented mother asserts that the father has not made full and complete disclosure, she is given leave to file, and if she chooses to do so, must file by no later than 4.00pm on 25 September 2020 an Application in a Case seeking specific discovery that she says the father has been requested to make but has refused to make. If the mother files such an application as directed it shall also be listed for Interim Hearing at 2.30pm on 2 October 2020 in the Family Court of Australia at Brisbane.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry of the order in the Court’s records.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case concerns the ongoing dispute between the mother and father of a child regarding parenting arrangements and property settlement following their separation. The Independent Children’s Lawyer has been involved in the case, acting in the best interests of the child. The factual background begins with the parents separating, leading to the filing of various applications and counter-applications by both parties. The mother and father have been engaged in a contentious dispute, with each party accusing the other of failing to comply with court orders and make full disclosure of relevant information. The mother has alleged that the father has not made full and complete disclosure, while the father has accused the mother of failing to comply with court orders.

The case has involved multiple hearings and applications, with the Court making various orders to manage the proceedings. One of the key issues in the case has been the role and evidence of Dr A, an expert who has been involved in assessing the child’s best interests. The Independent Children’s Lawyer intends to rely on Dr A’s evidence at trial, and the Court has deemed Dr A to be an expert called by the Independent Children’s Lawyer. The Court has also ordered that both parties have the opportunity to cross-examine Dr A to the extent that Dr A’s reports are relied upon.

Another significant aspect of the case has been the mother’s allegations of non-compliance with court orders and failure to make full disclosure by the father. The Court has ordered that the mother be given leave to file an application seeking specific discovery if she chooses to do so, and if she files such an application, it will be listed for an Interim Hearing. The Court has also ordered that the property and parenting proceedings proceed to trial, with the trial commencing on 30 November 2020. The Court has further ordered that the parties file and serve short affidavits of evidence regarding the progress of the interim Orders made on 17 June 2020 and proposals for further interim orders, including for the Christmas school holidays and Christmas Day/Boxing Day.

The matter of Newett and Newett & Anor (No 3) arose out of a complex family law dispute concerning parenting and property matters, with the Independent Children’s Lawyer involved in the proceedings. The case began with multiple applications filed by the Independent Children’s Lawyer, the mother, and the father, leading to various orders and directions from the Family Court of Australia. Notably, the court had previously made interim orders on 17 June 2020 in anticipation of a trial, and had bifurcated property and parenting proceedings by an order made on 12 May 2020. The latest round of applications, filed between 18 and 19 August 2020, sought various orders relating to the disclosure of documents, the status of an expert, and contraventions, among other things. The court dismissed most of these applications but made several rulings on document disclosure, the status of the expert, and the admissibility of certain materials. The proceedings were adjourned for an interim hearing to address parenting arrangements and to allow the mother an opportunity to seek specific discovery if she chose to do so. The trial for both property and parenting matters was set to commence on 30 November 2020.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the documents provided under tab "(12) Dr A Materials" are the ones presented to Dr A by the mother.
2. Whether Dr A, despite not being formally appointed as a Court Expert, should be considered an expert called by the Independent Children’s Lawyer.
3. Whether the Independent Children’s Lawyer and the parties should be granted leave to copy the documents produced by the mother and Dr A.
4. Whether the Court should deem Dr A to be an expert called by the Independent Children’s Lawyer and provide the parties with the opportunity to cross-examine Dr A.
5. Whether the Independent Children’s Lawyer should be granted leave to forward specific questions to Dr A.
6. Whether certain orders sought in the amended Application in a Case filed by the Independent Children’s Lawyer should be dismissed.
7. Whether the mother’s applications for contravention should be filed and returnable before a Registrar on the same date as other contravention applications.
8. Whether specific orders sought in the amended Application in a Case filed by the mother should be dismissed.
9. Whether the mother’s application to discharge the Independent Children’s Lawyer should be granted.
10. Whether the bifurcation of the property and parenting proceedings should be discharged.
11. Whether the mother should be granted leave to file an Application in a Case seeking specific discovery from the father.

Held
1. The Court declares that the documents provided under tab “(12) Dr A Materials” are the ones presented to Dr A by the mother.
2. Dr A, despite not being formally appointed as a Court Expert, is deemed an expert called by the Independent Children’s Lawyer.
3. The Independent Children’s Lawyer and the parties are granted leave to copy the documents produced by the mother and Dr A.
4. The Court deems Dr A to be an expert called by the Independent Children’s Lawyer and provides the parties with the opportunity to cross-examine Dr A.
5. The Independent Children’s Lawyer is granted leave to forward specific questions to Dr A.
6. Certain orders sought in the amended Application in a Case filed by the Independent Children’s Lawyer are dismissed.
7. The mother’s applications for contravention are to be filed and returnable before a Registrar on the same date as other contravention applications.
8. Specific orders sought in the amended Application in a Case filed by the mother are dismissed.
9. The mother’s application to discharge the Independent Children’s Lawyer is reserved for a later date.
10. The bifurcation of the property and parenting proceedings is discharged.
11. The mother is granted leave to file an Application in a Case seeking specific discovery from the father.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Newett and Newett & Anor (No 3), the Family Court of Australia addressed a multitude of issues that revolved around the handling of documents, the status of experts, and procedural matters in family law proceedings. The Court began by affirming the authenticity of documents presented to Dr A by the mother. It was determined that the documents provided under tab "(12) Dr A Materials" were indeed the ones presented to Dr A by the mother during the interview on 17 August 2018. This conclusion was based on the court's assessment of the materials saved on the USB drive delivered by the mother to the Court. The decision was straightforward, given the evidential chain of custody and the alignment of the materials with the date of the interview.

Next, the Court addressed the issue of whether Dr A, despite not being formally appointed as a Court Expert, should be considered an expert called by the Independent Children’s Lawyer (ICL). The Court found that Dr A had effectively undertaken the role of an independent expert, and given the ICL's intention to rely on Dr A's evidence at trial, the Court deemed Dr A to be an expert called by the ICL. The decision was grounded in the principle that the designation of an expert is more about the function and reliance on the expert's evidence than the formal appointment under the Family Court Rules 2004. The Court emphasized that both parties should have the opportunity to cross-examine Dr A to the extent his reports were relied upon.

In considering whether the ICL and the parties should be granted leave to copy the documents produced by the mother and Dr A, the Court granted leave. This decision was in line with the need for transparency and fairness in proceedings, ensuring that all parties had access to the materials that would be pivotal at trial. The Court also allowed the ICL to forward specific questions to Dr A, focusing on clarifications regarding the inclusion and consideration of certain documents in Dr A's report. This was to ensure that the evidence was clear and that any ambiguities were resolved before trial.

The Court dismissed several orders sought in the amended applications filed by the ICL and the mother, finding that they were either redundant or not warranted by the circumstances of the case. It also ruled that any contravention applications by the mother should be filed and returnable before a Registrar on the same date as other contravention applications, ensuring procedural consistency. The Court denied the mother's application to discharge the ICL, deeming it premature without further evidence or justification.

Furthermore, the Court discharged the bifurcation of the property and parenting proceedings, deciding that both should proceed to trial together. This decision was based on the interrelation of the issues and the efficiency of addressing them concurrently. Lastly, the Court granted the mother leave to file an Application in a Case seeking specific discovery from the father, if she chose to do so, but stipulated that it must be filed by a specified date and would be listed for an Interim Hearing. This decision aimed to ensure that all relevant evidence was on the table for the upcoming trial.

In summary, the Court's decisions in Newett and Newett & Anor (No 3) were meticulously crafted to balance the need for procedural fairness, the relevance and authenticity of evidence, and the efficient progression of the case towards trial. The Court's reasoning was grounded in ensuring transparency, fairness, and the proper administration of justice in the complex landscape of family law proceedings.