Newell and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

Newell and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 4140 (13 December 2023)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number:2021/4728          

Re:Mandy   Newell

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member K. Parker

Date:13 December 2023

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the Decision Under Review not to grant the Applicant access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme, because the Applicant does not meet the access criteria under s 21 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (NDIS Act). The Tribunal is not satisfied that she meets either the “disability requirements” under s 24 or the “early intervention requirements” under s 25 of the NDIS Act.

.................................[sgd].......................................

Senior Member K. Parker

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – access request – whether access criteria under s 21 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) are met – “disability requirements” under s 24 – “early intervention requirements” under s 25 – Applicant has disability arising from various physical and psychosocial impairments – bipolar affective disorder type II – anxiety and depression – hand conditions – back, neck and shoulder issues – osteoarthritis – whether impairments are, or likely to be, permanent – whether impairments have resulted in substantially reduced functional capacity in any one of the six prescribed activities – decision under review affirmed

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Home and Community Care Act 1985 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Becoming a Participant) Rules 2016 (Cth)

Cases

Mulligan v National Disability Insurance Agency (2015) 233 FCR 201
National Disability Insurance Agency v Davis [2022] FCA 1002
National Disability Insurance Agency v Foster [2023] FCAFC 11

Secondary Materials

Explanatory Memorandum, National Disability Insurance Bill 2012 (Cth)

National Disability Insurance Agency, NDIS Operational Guidelines: Applying to the NDIS (Guidelines, 28 September 2023) < FOR DECISION

Senior Member K. Parker

13 December 2023

INTRODUCTION

  1. This application is about whether the Applicant, Ms Mandy Newell, should be granted access as a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). Ms Newell seeks review of a decision made on 26 June 2021 by a “reviewer” under sub-s 100(6) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (NDIS Act) (Decision Under Review).[1] This decision confirmed an earlier decision by the Respondent, the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA), not to grant access to Ms Newell as a participant in the NDIS. 

    [1] The NDIA lodged a set of documents with the Tribunal pursuant to its obligations under s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (AAT Act) (T-Documents). Refer T-Documents, T2/12.

  2. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal’s (Tribunal) jurisdiction arises under sub-s 25(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (AAT Act), operating in conjunction with s 103 of the NDIS Act.

  3. For the reasons set out below, the Tribunal affirms the Decision Under Review because it…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Newell and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 4140
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review by Ms Newell of a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) to refuse her access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). The NDIA's original decision, and the subsequent internal review decision, were both based on the applicant not meeting the access criteria under section 21 of the *National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013* (Cth). Specifically, Ms Newell was found not to satisfy the "disability requirements" under section 24, which necessitates an impairment that is permanent or likely to be permanent, nor the "early intervention" requirements under section 25. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was required to determine whether Ms Newell met these access criteria.

The Tribunal affirmed the NDIA's decision, finding that Ms Newell had not satisfied the requirements for access to the NDIS. The Tribunal considered the evidence presented, including reports from medical professionals and occupational therapists, as well as the testimony of Ms Newell and her former treating occupational therapist. The core of the Tribunal's reasoning focused on the permanence requirement for disability under section 24(1)(b) of the Act. While acknowledging Ms Newell's various physical and psychosocial impairments, including bipolar affective disorder, anxiety, depression, hand conditions, back, neck, and shoulder issues, and osteoarthritis, the Tribunal was not satisfied that these impairments were permanent or likely to be permanent. Furthermore, the Tribunal found that the evidence did not establish that Ms Newell's impairments resulted in a substantially reduced functional capacity in any of the six prescribed activities as required by the legislation.

Consequently, the Tribunal was not satisfied that Ms Newell met the disability requirements under section 24 of the NDIS Act, nor the early intervention requirements under section 25. Therefore, the Tribunal affirmed the NDIA's decision not to grant Ms Newell access to the NDIS.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons set out below, the Tribunal affirms the Decision Under Review because it is not satisfied that Ms Newell meets the access requirements under s 21 of the NDIS Act. BACKGROUNDFamily, education, and employment background Ms Newell is a single woman in her mid-50s. Ms Newell has seven adult children (aged between 22 and 37), and 18 grandchildren. Ms Newell has several bodily conditions and mental health issues. Ms Newell reported that she has dyslexia and, consequently, struggled at school. She said she was required to repeat either grade 4 or 5. She left school at the beginning of Year 10.[2][2] Report by Dr Anthony Cidoni, consultant psychiatrist, dated 3 July 2022 (Dr Cidoni’s Report), [25] – see Ms Newell’s Hearing Tender Bundle (HTB), 18-26. After leaving school, Ms Newell worked in a clothing company for one year, a laminating company for two years, and in retail, for several years. She said she used to work as a painter and decorator but had to cease this work, due to pain in her hands and upper body. She said she cannot hold paint brushes anymore. In 2022, Ms Newell informed Dr Anthony Cidoni, consultant psychiatrist, that she last worked 24 years ago.[3] Ms Newell is presently unemployed and has been in receipt of the disability support pension since 2005.[3] Dr Cidoni’s Report, [25]. Since November 2021, Ms Newell has been living alone in a public housing, two-bedroom, one-bathroom unit in a coastal Victorian town. Ms Newell said the bathroom is quite large and designed to be wheelchair accessible. She said the doors are wider than usual and the toilet is “quite high”.[4] She described her back yard as being a “good size” but “not massive”. The back yard surface area comprises mainly of concrete.[5] The front yard has some grassed areas and requires maintenance.[6] Ms Newell said she had removed the shrubs alongside the driveway because she was unable to get down to do the weeding. She said that the “Housing Commission” was supposed to send somebody out to do the weeding. She said she had agreed to an offer by one of her neighbours for him to do it.[7][4] See also Supplementary HTB, 40-79.[5] Transcript of Proceedings, Newell and National Disability Insurance Agency (Administrative Appeals Tribunal, 2021/4728, SM Parker, 26-27 June 2023 and 19-20 July 2023), 29.[6] See also Supplementary HTB, 40-79.[7] Transcript of Proceedings, Newell and National Disability Insurance Agency (Administrative Appeals Tribunal, 2021/4728, SM Parker, 26-27 June 2023 and 19-20 July 2023), 30. Ms Newell’s adult children live in various locations. Her two eldest sons and her second youngest daughter live in Queensland. Her eldest daughter lives about a one and half hour’s drive from her home and has five children/stepchildren. Ms Newell’s second eldest daughter has three children and Ms Newell said she is about to relocate to far Northwest regional Victoria. Ms Newell’s youngest son lives one-hour’s drive from her, and her youngest daughter lives a 30-minute drive from her and has a set of two-year-old twins. Ms Newell says four of her grandchildren are living in Queensland and the other 14 grandchildren live in Victoria.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 15 July 2021, Ms Newell sought review of this the Decision Under Review by the National Disability Insurance Scheme Division of the Tribunal under s 103 of the NDIS Act.[19][19] Ibid, T1-T1A/1-11.EVIDENCE AND SUBMISSIONS On 6 August 2021, the NDIA lodged with the Tribunal a set of documents pursuant to s 37 of the AAT Act (T-Documents) comprising 179 pages. On 8 May 2023, Ms Newell lodged a Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (Ms Newell’s SFIC). On 20 June 2023, Ms Newell lodged a supplementary SFIC (Ms Newell’s Supplementary SFIC). On 22 June 2023, the NDIA lodged a SFIC (NDIA’s SFIC). The following hearing tender bundles (HTBs), comprising the parties’ respective submissions and evidence, were lodged with the Tribunal:(a)Ms Newell’s HTB, lodged on 8 May 2023 (Ms Newell’s HTB), comprising 76 pages;(b)the NDIA’s HTB, lodged on 13 June 2023 (NDIA’s HTB), comprising 607 pages; and(c)a Joint Supplementary HTB lodged on 20 July 2023 (Supplementary HTB), comprising 440 pages. The Tribunal received the exhibits contained in these three HTBs into evidence in this proceeding. The Tribunal conducted a substantive hearing over four days on 26 and 27 June 2023 and 19 and 20 July 2023. Ms Newell was represented by Victoria Legal Aid (VLA) and Mr Bryn Overend of counsel. Ms Tegan Weir of HWL Ebsworth Lawyers appeared as Solicitor Advocate on behalf of the NDIA. At the hearing, the following witnesses were called to give evidence:(a)Ms Newell;(b)Ms Newell’s former treating OT, Mr Tom Chapman. Mr Chapman graduated with a master’s degree in OT in about 2016 and has worked as an OT at South West Healthcare for about seven years treating patients in wards and out-patients. Mr Chapman said he has been working in his current role “in hand therapy” since February 2022 with previous “stints” doing so, during rotations in previous years.[20] Ms Newell was treated by three different OTs at South West Healthcare, first, Leanne Jackson, then, Lucinda Watson, and then, Mr Chapman as from 3 February 2022. Mr Chapman saw Ms Newell weekly for about two months, following which he saw her fortnightly. Mr Chapman has issued three reports in relation to Ms Newell as follows:(i)report dated 4 April 2022 (Mr Chapman’s First Report);[21] (ii)report dated 12 December 2022 (Mr Chapman’s Second Report);[22] and(iii)report dated 21 March 2023 (Mr Chapman’s Third Report);[23] (c)a further treating OT and an Australian Hand Therapy Association (AHTA) accredited hand therapist, Mrs Josephine Gibbs. Mrs Gibbs has issued several reports in relation to Ms Newell. The paperwork maintained by Mrs Gibbs relating to Ms Newell was difficult to follow and needed to be revised half way through the hearing.[20] Transcript of Proceedings, Newell and National Disability Insurance Agency (Administrative Appeals Tribunal, 2021/4728, SM Parker, 26-27 June 2023 and 19-20 July 2023), 51.[21] Ms Newell’s HTB, 3-7.[22] Ibid, 27-31.[23] Ibid, 32-36. Specifically, on the second day of the hearing, on 27 June 2023, it became apparent that Mrs Gibbs had prepared other documents regarding the functional assessment she undertook of Ms Newell which had not been lodged with the Tribunal. Mrs Gibbs told the Tribunal she had sent them to a former solicitor of VLA who previously had carriage of Ms Newell’s matter and has since departed the organisation. Ms Newell’s current solicitor said he was unable to locate those documents. The Tribunal considered it appropriate to adjourn the matter to allow for those documents to be forwarded by Mrs Gibbs to Ms Newell’s current VLA lawyer, so that they could be lodged with the Tribunal and given to the NDIA.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 30 April 2021, a delegate of the Chief Executive Officer of the NDIA (CEO) decided not to grant Ms Newell access to the NDIS (Original Access Decision), on the basis that she did not meet the access criteria set out in s 21 of the NDIS Act, because she did not satisfy:(a)the “disability requirements” under s 24 (specifically, para 24(1)(b), which requires Ms Newell to have an impairment that is permanent, or likely to be permanent); or(b)the “early intervention” requirements under s 25 of the NDIS Act.[16] [16] Ibid, T11/61-65. On 3 May 2021, Ms Newell sought internal review of this decision by a “reviewer” of the NDIA under sub-s 100(6) of the NDIS Act.[17][17] Ibid, T12/66. On 26 June 2021, the reviewer confirmed the Original Access Decision, being the Decision Under Review.[18] [18] Ibid, T2/12. On 15 July 2021, Ms Newell sought review of this the Decision Under Review by the National Disability Insurance Scheme Division of the Tribunal under s 103 of the NDIS Act.[19][19] Ibid, T1-T1A/1-11.EVIDENCE AND SUBMISSIONS On 6 August 2021, the NDIA lodged with the Tribunal a set of documents pursuant to s 37 of the AAT Act (T-Documents) comprising 179 pages. On 8 May 2023, Ms Newell lodged a Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (Ms Newell’s SFIC). On 20 June 2023, Ms Newell lodged a supplementary SFIC (Ms Newell’s Supplementary SFIC). On 22 June 2023, the NDIA lodged a SFIC (NDIA’s SFIC). The following hearing tender bundles (HTBs), comprising the parties’ respective submissions and evidence, were lodged with the Tribunal:(a)Ms Newell’s HTB, lodged on 8 May 2023 (Ms Newell’s HTB), comprising 76 pages;(b)the NDIA’s HTB, lodged on 13 June 2023 (NDIA’s HTB), comprising 607 pages; and(c)a Joint Supplementary HTB lodged on 20 July 2023 (Supplementary HTB), comprising 440 pages. The Tribunal received the exhibits contained in these three HTBs into evidence in this proceeding. The Tribunal conducted a substantive hearing over four days on 26 and 27 June 2023 and 19 and 20 July 2023. Ms Newell was represented by Victoria Legal Aid (VLA) and Mr Bryn Overend of counsel. Ms Tegan Weir of HWL Ebsworth Lawyers appeared as Solicitor Advocate on behalf of the NDIA. At the hearing, the following witnesses were called to give evidence:(a)Ms Newell;(b)Ms Newell’s former treating OT, Mr Tom Chapman. Mr Chapman graduated with a master’s degree in OT in about 2016 and has worked as an OT at South West Healthcare for about seven years treating patients in wards and out-patients. Mr Chapman said he has been working in his current role “in hand therapy” since February 2022 with previous “stints” doing so, during rotations in previous years.[20] Ms Newell was treated by three different OTs at South West Healthcare, first, Leanne Jackson, then, Lucinda Watson, and then, Mr Chapman as from 3 February 2022. Mr Chapman saw Ms Newell weekly for about two months, following which he saw her fortnightly. Mr Chapman has issued three reports in relation to Ms Newell as follows:(i)report dated 4 April 2022 (Mr Chapman’s First Report);[21] (ii)report dated 12 December 2022 (Mr Chapman’s Second Report);[22] and(iii)report dated 21 March 2023 (Mr Chapman’s Third Report);[23] (c)a further treating OT and an Australian Hand Therapy Association (AHTA) accredited hand therapist, Mrs Josephine Gibbs. Mrs Gibbs has issued several reports in relation to Ms Newell. The paperwork maintained by Mrs Gibbs relating to Ms Newell was difficult to follow and needed to be revised half way through the hearing.[20] Transcript of Proceedings, Newell and National Disability Insurance Agency (Administrative Appeals Tribunal, 2021/4728, SM Parker, 26-27 June 2023 and 19-20 July 2023), 51.[21] Ms Newell’s HTB, 3-7.[22] Ibid, 27-31.[23] Ibid, 32-36.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established