Newcombe v Medical Board of SA

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

NEWCOMBE v MEDICAL BOARD OF SA & ANOR

[2007] SASC 69

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Duggan

1 March 2007

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - MEDICAL AND RELATED PROFESSIONS - MEDICAL PRACTITIONERS - DISCIPLINE, AND REMOVAL FROM AND RESTORATION TO REGISTER - PROCEDURE EVIDENCE AND APPEAL

Application for permanent stay of proceedings – claim of abuse of process by reason of delay – complaint against medical practitioner laid before Medical Practitioners Professional Conduct Tribunal – allegations of sexual misconduct with patient and other conduct arising from treatment of the patient – consideration of principles relevant to abuse of process by reason of delay – application for permanent stay of proceedings refused.

Herron v McGregor (1986) 6 NSWLR 246; Walton v Gardiner (1993) 177 CLR 378; Hunter v Chief Constable of the West Midlands Police [1982] AC 529; Jago v District Court of New South Wales (1989) 168 CLR 23; G v Medical Board of the Australian Capital Territory [1994] ACTSC 42, discussed.

NEWCOMBE v MEDICAL BOARD OF SA & ANOR
[2007] SASC 69

Civil

  1. Duggan J.              A complaint against the plaintiff dated 22 June 2004 has been lodged with the Medical Practitioners Professional Conduct Tribunal (“the tribunal”) by the Medical Board of South Australia (“the Board”).  There are four grounds of complaint, all of which allege that the plaintiff is guilty of unprofessional conduct.

  2. The first ground states that, during the period from 7 November 1984 to 21 August 1985 (the consultation period), the plaintiff, a psychiatrist, entered into a sexual relationship with D, a patient.  It is alleged that during this period he failed to refer D to another psychiatrist or other medical practitioner.  It is also alleged that, during the period from 22 August 1985 to 1 March 2000 (the post-consultation period), the plaintiff continued to participate in a sexual relationship with D and prescribed medication for her, including Serepax.

  3. The second ground in the complaint alleges that, during the period from 7 November 1984 to 31 October 1985, the plaintiff failed to refer D to a psychiatrist or other medical practitioner for the management and treatment of D’s weight loss.

  4. The third ground in the complaint alleges that, between 9 July 1985 and 19 July 1985 the plaintiff dishonestly claimed a Medicare payment in the sum of $96.00 in respect of the attendance by D at the plaintiff’s consulting rooms on 9 July 1995, an occasion on which the plaintiff is alleged to have had sexual intercourse with D.

  5. The fourth ground of complaint alleges that, during the period from 9 July 1985 to 21 August 1985, the plaintiff failed to record in D’s patient case notes the changed nature of the relationship between the plaintiff and D, namely, the sexual and emotional relationship which had developed between them.

  6. At a hearing before the tribunal on 6 June 2005, the plaintiff gave notice of an application to have the proceedings stayed as an abuse of process…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Newcombe v Medical Board of SA and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] SASC 69
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Newcombe v Medical Board of SA was a case brought before the court involving a medical practitioner, Newcombe, and the Medical Board of South Australia. The dispute centred on a complaint against Newcombe for alleged sexual misconduct with a patient, as well as other conduct related to the treatment of the patient. The Medical Practitioners Professional Conduct Tribunal had received the complaint and the matter was now before the court on the grounds of an application for a permanent stay of proceedings, with the applicant alleging an abuse of process due to the delay in making the complaint.

The court was required to determine the principles relevant to an abuse of process by reason of delay in the context of a complaint against a medical practitioner. The court had to consider the extent of the delay, the potential prejudice caused by the delay, and the community's interest in investigating such complaints. The court also needed to assess whether the delay was so significant that it would render the proceedings an abuse of process.

In examining the case, the court found that while the delay in making the complaint was considerable, the potential prejudice caused by the delay was not of a particularly high order. The court acknowledged that the delay could be attributed to the vulnerable position of the complainant as a patient seeking help for emotional problems and the subsequent development of a more permanent relationship between the complainant and the plaintiff. However, the court held that the delay and any motives the complainant may have had for reporting the matter eventually were relevant in assessing the reliability of the evidence. After weighing the delay and the extent of prejudice against the interest of the community in investigating complaints of this nature, the court concluded that the application for a permanent stay of proceedings should be refused.

The court's decision ultimately resulted in the refusal of the application for a permanent stay of proceedings, allowing the complaint against Newcombe to proceed before the Medical Practitioners Professional Conduct Tribunal. The court's reasoning emphasised the importance of considering the delay and potential prejudice caused by it, as well as the community's interest in investigating complaints of misconduct against medical practitioners.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

As I have said, D’s affidavit makes no reference to the sexual relationship between the complainant and the plaintiff. It is difficult to understand why D would have said anything to the solicitor which would be exculpatory of the plaintiff in the present proceedings or of assistance to him in these proceedings. In any event, the suggestion that there would have been such material is nothing more than speculation.Conclusion The delay in the making of the complaint in the present case is considerable. Initially, the vulnerable position of D as a patient seeking help for emotional problems may explain why she did not report the matter shortly after the consultations. From that time onwards, a more permanent relationship developed between D and the plaintiff. During this relationship it is understandable that she did not make an official complaint. The delay and any motive D may have had for reporting the matter eventually may be relevant in assessing the reliability of the evidence. However, for the reasons which I have given, the level of potential prejudice is not of a particularly high order. After weighing the delay and the extent of prejudice against the interest of the community in investigating complaints of this nature, I have reached the conclusion that the application for a permanent stay of proceedings should be refused.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established