New South Wales
Court of Appeal
CITATION: Newcastle City Council v Wieland (No 2) [2009] NSWCA 246 HEARING DATE(S): On the papers.
JUDGMENT DATE:
18 August 2009JUDGMENT OF: Beazley JA at 1; Hodgson JA at 18; Ipp JA at 24 DECISION: Application for indemnity costs dismissed with costs. CATCHWORDS: PROCEDURE - costs - departing from the general rule - unsuccessful appellant - whether costs should be paid on an indemnity basis - where respondents made Calderbank offer prior to hearing of the application for leave to appeal - where respondents made second Calderbank offer after leave to appeal was granted - where leave to appeal granted subject to the condition that the appellants pay the costs of both sides of the appeal in any event - where issue raised by appeal was of general public interest. CATEGORY: Procedural and other rulings CASES CITED: Baulkham Hills Shire Council v Hahn [2008] NSWLEC 184
Charlick Trading Pty Ltd v Australian National Railways Commission [2001] FCA 629
Commonwealth of Australia v Gretton [2008] NSWCA 117
Evans Shire Council v Richardson (No 2) [2006] NSWCA 61
Higgins v Nicol (No 2) (1972) 21 FLR 34
Innovative Agricultural Products Pty Ltd & Ors v Crawshaw & Ors [1966] FCA 758
Jones v Bradley (No 2) [2003] NSWCA 258
Mead & Anor v Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd [2007] NSWSC 500
Newcastle City Council v Paul Wieland [2009] NSWCA 113
SMEC Testing Services Pty Ltd v Campbelltown City Council [2000] NSWCA 323PARTIES: Newcastle City Council (First Appellant)
HP Planning Services Pty Ltd (Second Appellant)
Paul Wieland (First Respondent)
Janine Wieland (Second Respondent)FILE NUMBER(S): CA 40082/08 COUNSEL: P R Cummings (Appellants)
T A Alexis SC; D H Mitchell (Respondents)SOLICITORS: Rockliffs (Appellants)
Moray & Agnew Solicitirs (First Respondent)
Colin Biggers & Paisley (Second Respondent)LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): 1510/06 LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER: Sidis DCJ LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION: 5 February 2008 LOWER COURT MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: Wieland v Newcastle City Council & Anor [2008] NSWDC 4
CA 40082/08
DC 1510/0618 AUGUST 2009BEAZLEY JA
HODGSON JA
IPP JA
1 BEAZLEY JA: I have had the opportunity of reading in draft the reasons of Ipp JA in respect of the respondents’ application for an order for indemnity costs of the summons for leave to appeal and of the appeal. With respect to his Honour, there are two aspects of his reasons with which I do not agree, as I explain below. My reasons on the application for an order for an indemnity costs then follow.
2 Ipp JA has raised four reasons why an application for indemnity costs should not be ordered: (1) leave to appeal was granted on condition the appellants pay the costs of both sides of the appeal in any event; (2) the trial judge had erred in finding that the parties had entered into an agreement whereby the appellants had…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Newcastle City Council v Wieland (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] NSWCA 246
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court was whether to depart from the general rule that costs follow the event and order the unsuccessful appellant to pay the respondents' costs on an indemnity basis. This required the Court to assess the reasonableness of the Council's conduct in refusing the Calderbank offers, taking into account the circumstances of the case, including the offers themselves, the stage at which they were made, and the nature of the appeal. The Court also had to consider the impact of the condition imposed when leave to appeal was granted.
The Court reasoned that while the respondents had made Calderbank offers, the condition imposed by the Court when granting leave to appeal – that the appellant pay the costs of the appeal in any event – was a significant factor. This condition effectively meant that the Council was already liable for the costs of the appeal, regardless of the outcome. The Court found that the respondents had not demonstrated that the Council's refusal of the Calderbank offers was so unreasonable as to warrant a departure from the standard costs order and the imposition of indemnity costs. The fact that the appeal raised an issue of general public interest did not, in itself, justify an order for indemnity costs.
Consequently, the Court of Appeal dismissed the respondents' application for indemnity costs and ordered that the costs of that application be paid by the respondents.
Orders
Orders of the court
Application for indemnity costs dismissed with costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
The initial factual events leading to the legal dispute began when the respondents, Wieland, challenged a decision made by the Newcastle City Council regarding a development application. The respondents took their case to the Land and Environment Court, which ruled in their favour. The Newcastle City Council then sought leave to appeal this decision to a higher court. During the proceedings for leave to appeal, the respondents made a Calderbank offer, which was declined by the appellants. Following the granting of leave to appeal, the respondents made a second Calderbank offer, stipulating that the appellants would pay the costs of both parties if the appeal failed. The appeal was subsequently heard, and the appellants were unsuccessful in their bid to overturn the original decision.
The factual circumstances during the appeal process were marked by the continuous engagement between the parties regarding the costs associated with the proceedings. The second Calderbank offer made by the respondents included an explicit condition that the appellants would bear the costs of both parties if the appeal was unsuccessful. This condition was a significant factor in the court's consideration of the costs issue. The appellants' unsuccessful appeal and the prior Calderbank offers formed the core of the factual matrix that the court had to evaluate in determining the appropriate costs order.
The proceedings in Newcastle City Council v Wieland (No 2) commenced with an initial decision by a tribunal, which was subsequently appealed to a lower court. The lower court's decision was then appealed to the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The appellants, Newcastle City Council, sought leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal, which was granted subject to the condition that the appellants pay the costs of both sides of the appeal in any event. Prior to the hearing of the application for leave to appeal, the respondents made a Calderbank offer. After the leave to appeal was granted, the respondents made a second Calderbank offer. The appellants ultimately filed an application for indemnity costs, arguing that the issue raised by the appeal was of general public interest and thus departed from the general rule of costs following an unsuccessful appeal. This application was subsequently dismissed by the Court of Appeal, which ordered that the costs be paid on a standard basis.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the court should depart from the general rule of costs in favour of the unsuccessful appellant in this case.
2. Whether the unsuccessful appellant should be required to pay the respondents' costs on an indemnity basis.
3. Whether the respondents' Calderbank offer made prior to the hearing of the application for leave to appeal should be taken into account in determining the costs order.
4. Whether the respondents' second Calderbank offer, made after leave to appeal was granted, should be considered in the context of the costs order.
5. Whether the general public interest in the issue raised by the appeal affects the costs order to be made.
Held
1. Whether the court should depart from the general rule of costs in favour of the unsuccessful appellant in this case. The court concluded that there were no exceptional circumstances to justify departing from the general rule of costs in favour of the unsuccessful appellant. Result: Departure from the general rule of costs was not allowed.
2. Whether the unsuccessful appellant should be required to pay the respondents' costs on an indemnity basis. The court concluded that the unsuccessful appellant should not be required to pay the respondents' costs on an indemnity basis. Result: Application for indemnity costs dismissed.
3. Whether the respondents' Calderbank offer made prior to the hearing of the application for leave to appeal should be taken into account in determining the costs order. The court concluded that the respondents' Calderbank offer made prior to the hearing of the application for leave to appeal should not be taken into account in determining the costs order. Result: The offer was not considered.
4. Whether the respondents' second Calderbank offer, made after leave to appeal was granted, should be considered in the context of the costs order. The court concluded that the respondents' second Calderbank offer made after leave to appeal was granted should be considered in the context of the costs order. Result: The offer was considered.
5. Whether the general public interest in the issue raised by the appeal affects the costs order to be made. The court concluded that the general public interest in the issue raised by the appeal does not affect the costs order to be made. Result: Public interest did not impact the costs order.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Newcastle City Council v Wieland (No 2), the court undertook a detailed examination of the principles governing costs orders in the context of an unsuccessful appeal. The general rule in Australian law is that the unsuccessful party in litigation must bear the costs of the successful party. However, the court has the discretion to depart from this rule if there are special circumstances justifying such a deviation. The Court of Appeal in this case considered whether it should depart from the general rule in favour of the unsuccessful appellant, the Newcastle City Council.
The court acknowledged that the issue raised by the appeal was of significant general public interest, potentially impacting the rights of the public in relation to land and planning laws. The court held that while the public interest was a relevant consideration, it did not, in and of itself, constitute a special circumstance warranting a departure from the general rule of costs. The court found that the general public interest did not alter the outcome of the costs order, which remained in line with the general rule.
A further matter for consideration was whether the unsuccessful appellant should be required to pay the respondents' costs on an indemnity basis. The court noted that indemnity costs are awarded in cases of bad faith or where the unsuccessful party’s litigation conduct was unreasonable. The court found no evidence of bad faith or unreasonable litigation conduct on the part of the appellant and therefore rejected the claim for indemnity costs.
The court also assessed the relevance of the respondents' Calderbank offers in determining the costs order. A Calderbank offer is a formal offer to settle made after proceedings have commenced but before judgment. The court considered the respondents' initial Calderbank offer, made before the hearing of the application for leave to appeal. While the offer was not accepted, the court found that it did not possess the qualities of an exceptional case warranting a costs order on an indemnity basis or a departure from the general rule of costs.
Additionally, the court examined the respondents' second Calderbank offer, made after leave to appeal had been granted. The court held that this offer was not relevant to the costs order as it came after the appeal had been allowed in principle. The court reasoned that the timing of the offer made it irrelevant to the costs order, as the substantive merits of the appeal had already been determined.
Finally, the court considered the condition attached to the grant of leave to appeal, which required the appellants to pay the costs of both sides of the appeal in any event. This condition did not alter the court's assessment of the costs order, as it did not affect the general rule or the specific circumstances of the case. The court concluded that the appellants should bear their own costs and the costs of the respondents up to the point of the granting of leave to appeal, but not on an indemnity basis.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that while general public interest in the issues raised by an appeal can be a factor in the court’s consideration, it does not constitute a special circumstance warranting a departure from the general rule of costs. Furthermore, the court must carefully consider the nature and timing of Calderbank offers when determining the appropriate costs order, and conditions attached to the grant of leave to appeal do not automatically alter the usual approach to costs. The unsuccessful appellant in this case was not entitled to indemnity costs, and the respondents' Calderbank offers, particularly the second one, were not relevant to the final costs order.