Newcastle City Council v Lindsay

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      Newcastle City Council v Lindsay [2004]  NSWCA 198

FILE NUMBER(S):
40693/03

HEARING DATE(S):               3 June 2004

JUDGMENT DATE: 22/06/2004

PARTIES:
Newcastle City Council
Colleen Lindsay

JUDGMENT OF:       Giles JA Tobias JA McClellan AJA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          DC 1190/01

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Sidis DCJ

COUNSEL:
A: L King SC / A Ventura
R: D Nock SC / R Montgomery

SOLICITORS:
A: Phillips Fox
R: King Street Lawyers

CATCHWORDS:
TORTS - NEGLIGENCE - Reasonable foreseeability - Obvious danger - Warning - Uneven footpath - Dangerous situation - Creation of - Distraction
JUDGES - BIAS - Application to disqualify for bias - Reasonable apprehension bias - Prejudgment - Extra-judicial publications - Published article

LEGISLATION CITED:
N/A

DECISION:
(a) Appeal allowed
(b) Set aside the orders made by Sidis DCJ on 6 August 2003 and in lieu thereof enter a verdict and judgment for the appellant
(c) Order that the respondent repay to the appellant all moneys paid to her pursuant to the orders made by Sidis DCJ on 6 August 2003, together with interest thereon from the date of payment to the date of repayment at the rate prescribed pursuant to Pt 40 r 7(2) of Schedule J of the Supreme Court Rules 1970
(d) Order that the respondent pay the appellant's costs of the proceedings in the court below and of the appeal but in respect of the latter, to have a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act 1951, if otherwise qualified

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40693/03
DC 1190/01

GILES JA
TOBIAS JA
McCLELLAN AJA

Tuesday 22 June 2004

NEWCASTLE CITY COUNCIL v COLLEEN LINDSAY

Judgment

  1. GILES JA: I agree with Tobias JA.

  2. TOBIAS JA: The respondent, Mrs Colleen Lindsay, claimed damages in the District Court of New South Wales from the appellant, Newcastle City Council, with respect to injuries sustained by her when she tripped on an uneven section of the footpath in Darby Street, Newcastle on 26 May 1999.

  3. On 6 August 2003, the primary judge, Sidis DCJ, found that the appellant had breached its duty of care to the respondent entitling her to a verdict.  Her Honour considered that the respondent was guilty of contributory negligence and that the damages awarded to her should be reduced by 15%.  She then assessed damages in the sum of $109,508.11 and entered judgment for the respondent against the appellant accordingly.  The appellant now appeals to this Court from her Honour's decision. 

    The facts

  4. At approximately 1pm on 26 May 1999, the respondent, then aged 71, was walking in a southerly direction along the eastern footpath of Darby Street in the vicinity of No. 47 Darby Street.  It was a bright and sunny autumn day.  The respondent had just enjoyed lunch with her daughter and at the time of her fall she was proceeding to her daughter's workplace with a surprise gift to mark the latter's wedding anniversary.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Newcastle City Council v Lindsay and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWCA 198
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal by Newcastle City Council from a decision of Sidis DCJ in the District Court of New South Wales. The primary judge had found the Council liable for negligence after the respondent, a 71-year-old woman, tripped and fell on an uneven footpath in Darby Street, sustaining injuries. The primary judge had awarded the respondent damages, reduced by 15% for contributory negligence.

The legal issues before the Court of Appeal included whether the Council had breached its duty of care to the respondent by creating or failing to warn of a dangerous situation on the footpath, and whether the respondent's own conduct constituted contributory negligence. The Court was required to determine if the unevenness of the footpath, caused by tree roots displacing a concrete slab by approximately 75mm, constituted an obvious danger that the Council ought to have addressed. A further consideration was whether the presence of pedestrian barriers in an adjacent garden bed, which the respondent observed shortly before her fall, constituted a distraction that contributed to her not seeing the displaced slab.

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, finding that the primary judge had erred in concluding that the appellant had breached its duty of care. The Court reasoned that the unevenness of the footpath, while present, did not amount to a danger that the Council was negligent in failing to prevent or warn against. The Court noted that the respondent was distracted by pedestrian barriers placed in a garden bed, and that her failure to see the displaced slab was due to this distraction rather than an inherent, unforeseeable danger on the footpath itself. Consequently, it was unnecessary for the Court to consider the issues of contributory negligence or the quantum of damages.

The Court ordered that the appeal be allowed, the orders of the District Court be set aside, and a verdict and judgment be entered for the appellant. The respondent was ordered to repay all moneys received under the District Court's orders, with interest, and to pay the appellant's costs of both the proceedings below and the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

(a) Appeal allowed

(b) Set aside the orders made by Sidis DCJ on 6 August 2003 and in lieu thereof enter a verdict and judgment for the appellant

(c) Order that the respondent repay to the appellant all moneys paid to her pursuant to the orders made by Sidis DCJ on 6 August 2003, together with interest thereon from the date of payment to the date of repayment at the rate prescribed pursuant to Pt 40 r 7(2) of Schedule J of the Supreme Court Rules 1970

(d) Order that the respondent pay the appellant's costs of the proceedings in the court below and of the appeal but in respect of the latter, to have a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act 1951, if otherwise qualified

Background

Background to the litigation

On 6 August 2003, the primary judge, Sidis DCJ, found that the appellant had breached its duty of care to the respondent entitling her to a verdict. Her Honour considered that the respondent was guilty of contributory negligence and that the damages awarded to her should be reduced by 15%. She then assessed damages in the sum of $109,508.11 and entered judgment for the respondent against the appellant accordingly. The appellant now appeals to this Court from her Honour's decision. The facts At approximately 1pm on 26 May 1999, the respondent, then aged 71, was walking in a southerly direction along the eastern footpath of Darby Street in the vicinity of No. 47 Darby Street. It was a bright and sunny autumn day. The respondent had just enjoyed lunch with her daughter and at the time of her fall she was proceeding to her daughter's workplace with a surprise gift to mark the latter's wedding anniversary. The incident occurred on a section of Darby Street where the footpath was approximately 3.6m wide. Approximately 1m back from the kerb there was a line of liquid amber trees planted within the footpath at intervals of approximately 10m. On other side of the footpath was a garden bed retained by a concrete kerb. On the other side of the garden bed was a disabled persons ramp leading to the entrance of No. 47. The accident occurred on a stretch of the footpath between one of the trees and the garden bed. The footpath comprised concrete slabs laid in line, each having a width of approximately 1.2m. The width of the footpath was, therefore, comprised of three slabs. The respondent's evidence as accepted by the primary judge was that she was walking on the left-hand side of the footpath when she tripped over the inside slab which had been displaced due to the roots of the adjacent tree. She said that one foot collided with the edge of the slab and she then fell forward, sustaining her injuries. Photographs of the offending slab taken immediately after the accident reveal that the outside edge of the slab had been pushed upwards so that it was approximately 75mm above its immediate neighbours. The inside edge of the slab where it met the concrete kerb retaining the garden bed appears to be level with its neighbours. Accordingly, the slab appears to have been displaced and raised above its neighbours from 0mm to approximately 75mm. The respondent's evidence was that she was watching where she was going although she was not walking along looking at the ground. However, immediately prior to falling, she had noticed two plastic red and white water-filled pedestrian barriers, which had been placed by the appellant's workers in the garden bed adjacent to the location where the respondent fell. It would appear that the presence of these barriers distracted the respondent: although she did not expressly say she was distracted, her evidence was that she was wondering to herself what these objects were doing in the garden bed. Accordingly, she did not see the displaced slab for, as she said, "otherwise I wouldn't have fallen if I had noticed it".

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Accordingly, in my opinion the primary judge erred in finding that the appellant had breached its duty of care to the respondent. In these circumstances, it is unnecessary for me to deal with the submissions of the appellant challenging her Honour's assessment of a 15% reduction in the respondent's damages due to her contributory negligence or its challenge to her assessment of those damages.Conclusion For the foregoing reasons, I would propose the following orders:(a) Appeal allowed.(b)Set aside the orders made by Sidis DCJ on 6 August 2003 and in lieu thereof enter a verdict and judgment for the appellant.(c)Order that the respondent repay to the appellant all moneys paid to her pursuant to the orders made by Sidis DCJ on 6 August 2003, together with interest thereon from the date of payment to the date of repayment at the rate prescribed pursuant to Pt 40 r 7(2) of Schedule J of the Supreme Court Rules 1970.(d)Order that the respondent pay the appellant's costs of the proceedings in the court below and of the appeal but in respect of the latter, to have a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act 1951, if otherwise qualified. McCLELLAN A-JA: I agree with Tobias JA.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.