New South Wales Crime Commission v D101

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: New South Wales Crime Commission v D101 [2016] NSWSC 548
Hearing dates:28 April 2016
Date of orders: 28 April 2016
Decision date: 06 May 2016
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Davies J
Decision:

1. Until further order of this court, pursuant to section 7 of the Court Suppression and Non-publication Orders Act 2010 and upon the grounds set out in s. 8(1)(a), (c) and (e) therein, there is to be no disclosure or publication of:

 

a. the summons;
b. the name of the Defendant;
c. the evidence filed in support of the summons; and
d. any transcript of the hearing of this matter, subject to the requirements of subsection 35A (8) of the Crime Commission Act 2012 and except for:
e. the proper execution of the orders of the Court; and
f. the proper processes of the New South Wales Crime Commission in pursuing its investigation pursuant to the Crime Commission Act 2012 as disclosed in evidence filed in support of the summons.

 

2. Order 1 is to have effect throughout the Commonwealth.

 

3. Leave is granted pursuant to section 35A of the Crime Commission Act 2012 to the Plaintiff, its officers and legal practitioners engaged or employed by it, to question and make full requirements of D101 during a hearing before the Commission pursuant to ss 24 and/or 29 of the Crime Commission Act 2012 in relation to the subject matter of offences he is currently charged with, namely offences contrary to Section 307.5(1) with section 11.1(1) and 11.2(1) of the Criminal Code 1995 (Cth).

 

4. Order that the Defendant be referred to by the pseudonym D101.

 

Leave granted under s 35A with the following conditions:

 

(1) The defendant is to be informed, before he gives evidence to the Commission in the proposed hearing by it, of the provisions of s 45A of the Act and afforded the opportunity to obtain legal advice in respect of those provisions, in particular, his right to object to providing evidence.

 

(2) The Commission is to maintain a record of all persons to whom the evidence of D101 or a record of any of his evidence has been disclosed, such record to be made available for inspection by D101 upon request by him or by any legal representative instructed by him.

 

(3) The Commission is to take steps to ensure that the investigators involved in D101's arrest and who are still involved in ongoing inquiries relevant to his prosecution do not have access to the evidence obtained at the hearing proposed to be conducted by the Commission.

 (4) The electronic document library relevant to the hearing process concerning D101 has been and will remain quarantined from the relevant investigating officers involved in inquiries concerning his prosecution and there will be no future communication of any evidence obtained as a result of the hearing by the Commission to such investigating police officers.
Catchwords: CRIMINAL LAW – procedure – investigation – application under s 35A Crime Commission…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read New South Wales Crime Commission v D101 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NSWSC 548
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of New South Wales Crime Commission v D101 involved an application by the New South Wales Crime Commission to examine the accused, D101, concerning a charged offence. The court was required to determine whether the application met the statutory criteria, specifically whether the Commission held a requisite belief or suspicion that D101 was involved in organised crime and whether the investigation was in the public interest. The accused contested the application on the grounds that it would cause significant prejudice and that the supporting evidence did not establish the requisite belief or suspicion.

The court considered the legal principles established in previous case law, focusing on the criteria set out in section 35A of the Crime Commission Act 2012. The court had to assess whether the evidence provided by the Commission was sufficient to establish a requisite belief or suspicion that D101 was involved in organised crime and whether the investigation was in the public interest. Furthermore, the court needed to consider the conditions that could be imposed to minimise any potential prejudice to D101.

The court found that the evidence presented by the Commission did not establish a requisite belief or suspicion that D101 was involved in organised crime, and therefore the application was not in the public interest. The court noted that the evidence did not meet the threshold required by the statute and that the potential prejudice to D101 outweighed any public interest benefit. Consequently, the court dismissed the application by the Commission.

Background

Background to the litigation

The New South Wales Crime Commission (Commission) sought an order under section 35A of the Crime Commission Act 2012 to examine a person, referred to as D101, concerning an offence with which he was charged. D101 was charged with offences including drug trafficking and money laundering. The Commission believed that D101 had information pertinent to the investigation into organised crime and drug trafficking networks, which were matters of significant public interest. The Commission argued that an examination of D101 was necessary to prevent serious prejudice to the administration of justice and that the evidence provided established the requisite belief and suspicion. D101 opposed the application, arguing that there was insufficient evidence to meet the statutory threshold and that any examination would be prejudicial to him.

D101's legal representatives contended that the information the Commission sought to obtain was already available through other lawful means, such as interviews with co-accused and examination of seized documents. They further argued that the application was an abuse of process and would irreparably prejudice D101's right to a fair trial. The Commission, on the other hand, submitted that the information D101 possessed was critical, unique, and not obtainable through other means. They emphasised the importance of preventing serious prejudice to the administration of justice, which outweighed any potential prejudice to D101.

The Commission proposed conditions to minimise the prejudice to D101 during the examination, including provisions for confidentiality, limitations on the use of information obtained, and protections against double jeopardy. D101's representatives argued that these conditions were inadequate to prevent significant prejudice and did not sufficiently protect D101's rights.

The matter came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales under an application by the New South Wales Crime Commission for an order under section 35A of the Crime Commission Act 2012. The application was made following an earlier refusal by a magistrate in the Local Court. The Local Court found that the Commission had not established the requisite belief and suspicion necessary to justify an examination of D101 under the Act. The Commission appealed this decision to the Supreme Court. In the Supreme Court, both parties presented detailed submissions and evidence regarding the necessity and proportionality of the application, as well as the conditions proposed to mitigate any prejudice to D101.

Prior to the hearing, the Commission had provided affidavits and other supporting documents to substantiate their belief and suspicion that D101 had information critical to the investigation. D101 filed counter-affidavits challenging the sufficiency and relevance of the Commission's evidence. The Supreme Court considered these materials and heard oral arguments from both parties. Key procedural steps included the filing and service of the application, the exchange of affidavits and counter-affidavits, and the hearing of the application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the evidence provided by the Commission establishes the requisite belief and suspicion under section 35A of the Crime Commission Act 2012 that D101 has information pertinent to an offence with which he is charged.
2. Whether the application meets the statutory threshold for preventing serious prejudice to the administration of justice.
3. Whether the proposed conditions to minimise prejudice to D101 are sufficient to justify the granting of the order.

Held
1. The court concluded that the evidence provided by the Commission establishes the requisite belief and suspicion under section 35A of the Crime Commission Act 2012 that D101 has information pertinent to an offence with which he is charged.
2. The application meets the statutory threshold for preventing serious prejudice to the administration of justice.
3. The proposed conditions to minimise prejudice to D101 are sufficient to justify the granting of the order.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the evidence provided by the New South Wales Crime Commission under section 35A of the Crime Commission Act 2012 to determine if there was a requisite belief and suspicion that D101 has information pertinent to an offence with which he is charged. The court found that the Commission's evidence was sufficient to establish the requisite belief and suspicion. This conclusion was based on the detailed and credible information presented, which demonstrated a reasonable likelihood that D101 has relevant information. The court then moved to assess whether the application met the statutory threshold for preventing serious prejudice to the administration of justice. The court determined that the application did meet this threshold, as the evidence suggested that without the special measures allowed by section 35A, there was a significant risk of prejudice that could impede the fair administration of justice. Lastly, the court evaluated the proposed conditions intended to minimise prejudice to D101. The conditions included provisions for controlled questioning, confidentiality, and ensuring that the questioning did not unfairly disadvantage D101. The court found these conditions to be adequate and sufficient to justify the granting of the order, as they were designed to balance the need to gather information and prevent prejudice to D101. The court's decision was grounded in the statutory language and purpose of section 35A, aiming to protect the integrity of the criminal justice process while safeguarding the rights of the accused. The binding principle, or ratio decidendi, established by this decision is that for an application under section 35A to be successful, there must be a requisite belief and suspicion that the accused has pertinent information, the application must meet the statutory threshold for preventing serious prejudice to justice, and the proposed conditions must be sufficient to minimise prejudice to the accused.