New Price Retail Services Pty Limited v David Hanna

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: New Price Retail Services Pty Limited and Anor v David Hanna [2014] NSWSC 1546
Hearing dates:31 October 2014
Decision date: 05 November 2014
Jurisdiction:Equity Division
Before: Sackar J
Decision:

See paragraph [67]

Catchwords:

EQUITY - application by defendant to re-open case after judgment pronounced but before final orders entered - material relied on in support of application available but not tendered at any point - whether appropriate to order money be paid into Court or enter judgment

COSTS - where plaintiffs successful on motion to adopt report of referee - where order for joint and several liability made at time of reference without affecting power of Court as to costs - where significant period of time taken up by referee coming to a proper understanding of plaintiff's records - whether basis for ordering otherwise than costs following the event - whether the cross-claim of the defendant should be stayed pending quantification and payment of amount owed to referee
Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005
Supreme Court Rules 1970
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005
Cases Cited: ACD Tridon Inc v Tridon Australia Pty Ltd [2003] NSWSC 357
Chocolate Factory Apartments v Westpoint Finance and Others [2005] NSWSC 784
Hastings Point Progress Association v Tweed Council [2010] NSWCA 39
James v Surf Nominees Pty Ltd (No 2) [2005] NSWCA 296
Madden v Madden [2014] NSWSC 1098
McLaughlin v Dungowan Manly Pty Ltd [2010] NSWSC 306
New Price Retail Services Pty Limited and Anor v David Hanna [2014] NSWSC 553
New Price Retail Services Pty Limited and Anor v David Hanna [2014] NSWSC 1051
Roads and Traffic Authority of New South Wales v Welling and Comerford [2000] NSWCA 360
State of New South Wales v Plaintiff A [2012] NSWCA 248
Texts Cited: n/a
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: New Price Retail Services Pty Limited - first plaintiff
Priceline Pty Limited - second plaintiff
David Hanna - defendant
Brian Raymond Silvia - referee
Representation: Counsel:
Plaintiffs - M Condon SC
Defendant - self represented
Referee - J Baird
Solicitors:
Holman Webb - plaintiffs
Self represented - defendant
Somerset Ryckmans - referee
File Number(s):2010/356948

Judgment

Proceedings

  1. These proceedings concern a notice of motion filed by the plaintiffs on 6 September 2013, seeking a number of orders in relation to the reports of a referee. There is also before me a motion filed 17 October 2014 by the defendant.

  1. The plaintiffs by their motion seek the adoption of the reports of the referee dated 24 July 2013 and 16 August 2013, an order that the defendant pay the sum of $732,799.44 into court, an order pursuant to UCPR rule 20.18 that the defendant pay the whole of the costs of the referee of and incidental to the reference and provide security for those costs pending their final determination. The plaintiffs also seek an order that the sum of $9,000 paid to the referee be released and costs.

  1. I previously gave judgment in this matter on 9…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read New Price Retail Services Pty Limited v David Hanna and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NSWSC 1546
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of New Price Retail Services Pty Limited v David Hanna, the defendant, Mr Hanna, sought to re-open the case after the judgment had been pronounced but before final orders were entered. The legal issues involved whether it was appropriate to order that money be paid into court or enter judgment, considering that the material relied on in support of the application was available but not tendered at any point. Additionally, the court had to decide on the costs, particularly whether the plaintiffs were successful on the motion to adopt the report of the referee and if the order for joint and several liability made at the time of the reference affected the court's power as to costs. The court also needed to determine whether the significant time taken by the referee to come to a proper understanding of the plaintiff's records provided a basis for ordering otherwise than costs following the event. Furthermore, the court had to consider whether the cross-claim of the defendant should be stayed pending quantification and payment of the amount owed to the referee.

The court reasoned that the application to re-open the case was not appropriate because the material that Mr Hanna sought to rely on was available but had not been tendered at any point in the proceedings. The court held that it was not appropriate to order money to be paid into court or enter judgment. Regarding costs, the court noted that the plaintiffs were successful on the motion to adopt the report of the referee, and the order for joint and several liability did not affect the court's power as to costs. The court found that the significant time taken by the referee did not provide a basis for ordering otherwise than costs following the event. Lastly, the court decided that the cross-claim of the defendant should not be stayed pending quantification and payment of the amount owed to the referee.

The final orders of the court were that Mr Hanna's application to re-open the case was dismissed, and no order was made for money to be paid into court or for judgment to be entered. The court ordered that the plaintiffs' costs of the motion to adopt the report of the referee be paid by Mr Hanna, and the costs of the proceedings were to follow the event. The cross-claim of Mr Hanna was not stayed, and the matter proceeded with quantification and payment of the amount owed to the referee.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I also heard the parties on 31 July and gave judgment on 4 August in relation to the application by the plaintiffs to join the former solicitor of the defendant, Mr George Hanna, for the purpose of making him liable for all or part of the referee's fees. I dismissed that application for the reasons set out in New Price Retail Services Pty Limited and Anor v David Hanna [2014] NSWSC 1051 (joinder judgment). As noted in those reasons, the defendant appeared by telephone at the hearing on 31 July and made an application for an adjournment. Although I proceeded to hear the application for joinder, I adjourned the motion of the referee in relation to the fixing of his fees, and the balance of the plaintiff's motion of 6 September 2013. I also indicated that I was minded to direct that the remuneration of the referee be determined by a Registrar. That has been done by orders made in chambers on 14 August. On 10 October, with Mr Hanna again appearing by telephone, I adjourned the matter which was listed for 13 October, despite the opposition of counsel for the plaintiffs, to 31 October. It was made clear that the hearing on 31 October would only be in relation to the motion of the plaintiffs and would not cover the fee issue concerning the referee (transcript of 10 October, T4/18; T5/16). It was also made clear that the plaintiffs sought costs thrown away and the costs of 10 October, and that would be dealt with on 31 October (T4/33). On 31 October, after receiving written submissions and hearing oral argument, I announced my decision and indicated that I would provide reasons at a later point. These are those reasons. In the principal judgment, I proposed to adopt the reports in their entirety: see [196]. However, as I have said, a formal order to that effect has not yet been made. Subsequent to 10 October, Mr Hanna filed a notice of motion dated 17 October 2014 in which he sought that the sum determined by the referee be "adjusted after consideration of the proof of delivery documentation obtained from Linfox", the liability of the Referee's fees be finalised after such an adjustment, and an order that the plaintiffs provide security for his costs. Mr Hanna filed an affidavit which described and exhibited an email from an employee of Linfox, Mr Steve Goltz, in relation to proof of delivery documentation, although that documentation is not before me and does not appear to have been provided to the defendant, let alone the plaintiffs. Mr Hanna also provided some short written submissions in support of his notice of motion. The effect of acceding to Mr Hanna's motion would be to permit him, in my view, to re-open a matter which was central to the referee's investigation and analysis. The email to which I referred responded to an earlier email from Mr Hanna to Mr Goltz dated 10 October 2014 at 5.21pm. It provided relevantly as follows: Mr Goltz replied at 5.35pm on the same day in the following terms: In response to my questioning, Mr Hanna confirmed that the attachment referred to in his email to Mr Goltz was the same as the documents provided to the referee by Mr Hanna on 15 August 2013 and found in the court book prepared for the hearing the subject of the principal judgment. Although the attachment was tendered by the plaintiffs as Exhibit P1, it was merely a copy of the version found in that earlier court book at CB2/523 (T4/27-T5/4).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established