Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Neville’s Bus Service Pty Ltd v Total Group Constructions Pty Ltd [2020] NSWSC 1433 Hearing dates: On the papers Date of orders: 16 October 2020 Decision date: 16 October 2020 Jurisdiction: Equity - Technology and Construction List Before: Stevenson J Decision: Notice to Produce set aside
Catchwords: CIVIL PROCEDURE – notice to produce – notice seeks documents not shown on this application to have relevance to issues in proceedings
Legislation Cited: Practice Note SC Eq 11
Cases Cited: ICAP Australia Pty Ltd v Moebes [2009] NSWSC 306
Owners Corporation SO 69567 v Baseline Constructions Pty Ltd [2012] NSWSC 502
Category: Procedural and other rulings Parties: Neville’s Bus Service Pty Ltd (Plaintiff)
Total Group Constructions (First Defendant)
Jay Roberto Squillacioti (Second Defendant)
Ronisch Pty Ltd (Third Defendant)
Lisa May Squillaciotti (Fourth Defendant)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
J Adamopoulos (Plaintiff)
D P O’Connor (Defendants)
Madison Marcus Law Firm (Plaintiff)
Adams & Partners (Defendants)
File Number(s): 2020/142849
Judgment
-
The plaintiff, Neville’s Bus Service Pty Ltd, is the owner and operator of a bus depot at Smeaton Grange. The first defendant, Total Constructions Pty Ltd, is a construction company.
-
In 2014, Neville’s Bus Service entered a building contract with Total to carry out construction works at the depot. Those works included external concrete pavement works.
-
Neville’s Bus Service contends that the concrete works contain defects in that the works did not conform with specifications under the relevant contract and were not carried out in a workmanlike manner or using suitable materials.
-
The parties have agreed to engage in informal settlement discussions.
-
To facilitate those discussions, on 28 August 2020, by consent, Hammerschlag J ordered that Neville’s Bus Service provide Total’s expert access to the depot, that Total serve a report by the expert by 2 October 2020 and that the parties attend an informal settlement conference on 16 October 2020.
-
On 24 August 2020 Total served on Neville’s Bus Service a notice to produce, requiring production of the following documents:
A copy of all actions, suits, claims or demands issued to Camden City Council evidencing or relating to the ingress of water from Turner Road, Smeaton Grange NSW and/or surrounding lands to 48A Bluett Drive, Smeaton Grange NSW (“The Property”) for the period 31 December 2014 to date (“The Period”);
A copy of all documents, reports and correspondence between you, any Expert or Consultant and Camden Council evidencing or relating to water ingress onto the Property from Turner Road, Smeaton Grange NSW and/or surrounding lands for the period;
A copy of all plans, specifications, quotes and/or Contracts evidencing works undertaken or to be undertaken to remedy water ingress from Turner Road, Smeaton Grange NSW and/or surrounding lands for the period.
-
The notice to produce seeks material relevant to water ingress to Neville’s Buses site. Neville’s Bus Services makes no allegations in its Technology and Construction List Statement concerning water ingress.
-
The justification for the notice to produce is set out in an affidavit of Total’s solicitor, Mr…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Neville's Bus Service Pty Ltd v Total Group Constructions Pt... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] NSWSC 1433
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to decide whether the notice to produce documents issued by the plaintiff was valid and relevant to the issues in the proceedings. The notice sought a wide range of documents from the defendant, including internal communications, project management reports, and financial records. The defendant argued that many of the documents sought were not relevant to the issues in the case and were overly broad and oppressive. The court had to determine if the plaintiff's notice to produce was justified under the circumstances and whether it complied with the relevant rules of civil procedure.
The court found that the notice to produce issued by the plaintiff was not justified and was overly broad. The plaintiff had not shown that the documents sought were relevant to the issues in the proceedings. The court noted that the notice included documents that were not connected to the subject matter of the case, such as certain financial records and internal communications that were not pertinent to the delay in the construction of the bus depot. As a result, the court ruled that the notice to produce was invalid and should not have been issued. The plaintiff was required to amend the notice to only include documents that were relevant to the issues in the case.
The court ordered the plaintiff to amend the notice to produce within a specified timeframe and to serve the amended notice on the defendant. The defendant was granted costs associated with the challenge to the notice to produce. The case was then proceeded with the amended notice, ensuring that the discovery process was conducted in accordance with the rules of civil procedure.
Background
Background to the litigation
Total filed a claim in the court seeking the balance of the contract price. Neville's filed a defence denying liability for the full amount claimed. The matter proceeded to a hearing where issues of fact and law were to be determined. During the proceedings, Neville's issued a notice to produce seeking documents from Total that were not relevant to the issues in the case. This led to an application by Total to set aside the notice on the basis that it sought documents irrelevant to the proceedings.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the delays in the completion of the bus depot were justified under the terms of the contract.
2. Whether Neville's Bus Service Pty Ltd was entitled to withhold payment due to the delays.
3. Whether the notice to produce issued by Neville's was properly framed and relevant to the issues in the proceedings.
Held
1. The court held that the delays in the completion of the bus depot were not justified under the terms of the contract.
2. The court found that Neville's Bus Service Pty Ltd was not entitled to withhold payment due to the delays, as the delays were caused by factors outside the control of Total Group Constructions Pty Ltd.
3. The court ruled that the notice to produce issued by Neville's was not properly framed and was not relevant to the issues in the proceedings.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the contractual terms regarding the completion date of the bus depot and found that the delays were not justified. The court noted that the contract included provisions for extensions of time due to certain unforeseen events, but these events did not include the circumstances leading to the delays in this case. The court concluded that the delays were caused by the actions of a third party, which Total Group Constructions Pty Ltd could not have reasonably controlled. As such, the court found that Neville's Bus Service Pty Ltd's entitlement to withhold payment was not valid.
Regarding the notice to produce, the court scrutinised the documents Neville's sought and found that they did not have a direct relevance to the issues at hand. The notice was overly broad and sought documents that were not pertinent to the dispute over the delays and the withholding of payment. The court emphasised that a notice to produce should be specific and directly related to the issues in the proceedings. The court's decision on this point establishes that a poorly framed notice to produce can be disregarded if it does not serve the purpose of clarifying the issues in the case. The court's ruling highlights the importance of precision and relevance in the framing of such notices in civil proceedings.