DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2000] AATA 930
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) No Q00/638
GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION )
Re SHANE NEPSON
Applicant
And MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
Respondent
DECISION
Tribunal Deputy President DP Breen, Presidential Member
Date25 October 2000
PlaceBrisbane
Decision The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution therefor determines that the applicant SHANE NEPSON be permitted to remain in Australia.
(Sgd) DP BREEN
PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER
CATCHWORDS
IMMIGRATION – deportation – serious offence – best interests of children – sufficiency of warning – parity of treatment.
Migration Act 1958 s 200
Phung and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] AATA 855]
REASONS FOR DECISION
25 October 2000 Deputy President DP Breen, Presidential Member
This is a review of a decision made on 6 June 2000 by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs to deport the applicant SHANE NEPSON under Section 200 of the Migration Act 1958.
The matter was heard by me on 25 September 2000 in Brisbane. Mr Nepson was represented by his fiancee's father, Mr F Snowden. Mr P O'Higgins, Solicitor of Messrs Blake Dawson Waldron represented the respondent Minister.
Oral evidence was given at the hearing by the applicant; Rebecca Kena, the applicant's sister and Kathleen Emma Rawinia Snowden, the applicant's fiancee.
The following documents were taken into evidence:
Exhibit 1 "T" Documents
Exhibit 2 Letter from Centrelink dated 22.9.00 to Department
Exhibit 3 Statement of Raymond Thomas Toi Whare
Exhibit 4 Statement of Hina H Taunoa
Exhibit 5 Statement of Veronica Nepson
Exhibit 6 Statement of Jenny Snowden
Exhibit 7 Statement of Trevor Hall dated 1.8.00
Exhibit 8 Statement of Elsie Wright dated 9.8.00
Exhibit 9 Statement of Kathleen Emma Rawinia Snowden
Exhibit 10 Statement of Rebecca Kena dated 2.8.00
Exhibit 11 Statements of Andrew and Angela Perry dated 2.8.00
Exhibit 12 Statement of Neil Allen, National Polystyrene Systems dated 11.7.00
Exhibit 13 Extracts from Corrective Services File
Mr Nepson is 23 years of age and a New Zealand citizen. He arrived in Australia in January 1996 to join his mother and sister and has not departed since. He has been in a de facto relationship for over 3½ years. He has a son and a step-daughter, both of whom are Australian citizens. In May 1999 he was convicted of assault occasioning bodily harm with a circumstance of aggravation. He was sentenced to 18 months imprisonment to be suspended for 2 years after serving 3 months. It is this conviction which brings him within Section 200 of the Migration Act.
The applicable Ministerial Direction is Direction 9 – General Direction – Criminal Deportation. The Direction states that the primary considerations are the expectations of the Australian community and, where an applicant is involved in a parental relationship with a child, the best interests of that child.
Issues to be taken into account when evaluating the protection of the Australian community include the seriousness and nature of the offences committed…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Nepson and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affair... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] AATA 930
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court centred on the seriousness and nature of Mr. Nepson's offence, the risk of recidivism, and the deterrent effect of deportation on other non-citizens. Additionally, the court had to weigh these factors against the best interests of Mr. Nepson's children. The court was required to determine if the seriousness of Mr. Nepson's crime warranted deportation, whether his past behaviour indicated a high risk of reoffending, and if his deportation would serve as an effective deterrent to others in a similar situation.
The court found that Mr. Nepson's conviction for assault occasioning bodily harm with circumstances of aggravation was indeed serious, as evidenced by the violent nature of the crime. However, the court also noted that Mr. Nepson had shown remorse, completed a cognitive skills programme with a positive report, and had support from his family. The court considered the risk of recidivism to be low, given Mr. Nepson's completion of the cognitive skills programme and his offer of employment upon release. The court further determined that the deterrent effect of his potential deportation would be significant, particularly given his co-offender's similar warning. Ultimately, the court found that the best interests of Mr. Nepson's children were best served by considering his deportation, given the violent nature of the offence and the potential for future violence.
Background
Background to the litigation
The incident for which Mr Nepson was convicted involved him and his co-offender attacking a stranger in the toilets of a nightclub, repeatedly kicking him and causing extensive injuries. Despite this serious offence, Mr Nepson had no prior record of violent crime; his previous convictions were for shoplifting in New Zealand as a minor and a charge of speeding in Brisbane. Mr Nepson expressed remorse for his actions, accepted full responsibility, and completed the Cognitive Skills Programme in prison, receiving a positive exit report. Although he did not complete other behavioural programmes due to his short stay in prison, he has an offer of employment upon his release and a supportive family to return to. His co-offender, who was his future brother-in-law, is also a New Zealand citizen.
The matter came before the Tribunal as an appeal against a decision made by the Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs to cancel Mr Nepson's visa under Section 200 of the Migration Act. The Tribunal reviewed the decision in light of the relevant Ministerial Direction and the statutory provisions. The Tribunal's review involved assessing the seriousness of Mr Nepson's offence, his risk of recidivism, and the potential deterrent effect of his deportation. The Tribunal also considered the best interests of Mr Nepson's children in accordance with the relevant Ministerial Direction.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the seriousness and nature of the offence committed by Mr Nepson warrant his deportation under Section 200 of the Migration Act.
2. Whether the risk of Mr Nepson reoffending is acceptably low, taking into account his criminal history, his behaviour in prison, and other mitigating factors.
3. Whether the deportation of Mr Nepson would serve as an appropriate deterrent to other non-citizens and align with the expectations of the Australian community.
4. Whether the best interests of Mr Nepson's children should be considered in the decision-making process, and if so, how they should be weighed against other factors.
Held
1. The court concluded that the seriousness and nature of the offence committed by Mr Nepson warrant his deportation under Section 200 of the Migration Act.
2. The court found that the risk of Mr Nepson reoffending is acceptably low, taking into account his criminal history, his behaviour in prison, and other mitigating factors.
3. The court determined that the deportation of Mr Nepson would serve as an appropriate deterrent to other non-citizens and align with the expectations of the Australian community.
4. The court found that the best interests of Mr Nepson's children should be considered in the decision-making process, but they should not override other factors that support deportation.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Mr Nepson is 23 years of age and a New Zealand citizen. He arrived in Australia in January 1996 to join his mother and sister and has not departed since. He has been in a de facto relationship for over 3½ years. He has a son and a step-daughter, both of whom are Australian citizens. In May 1999 he was convicted of assault occasioning bodily harm with a circumstance of aggravation. He was sentenced to 18 months imprisonment to be suspended for 2 years after serving 3 months. It is this conviction which brings him within Section 200 of the Migration Act. The applicable Ministerial Direction is Direction 9 – General Direction – Criminal Deportation. The Direction states that the primary considerations are the expectations of the Australian community and, where an applicant is involved in a parental relationship with a child, the best interests of that child. Issues to be taken into account when evaluating the protection of the Australian community include the seriousness and nature of the offences committed by the applicant, the risk of recidivism and the deterrent effect of deportation on other non-citizens. Considering, firstly, the nature of the seriousness of the offence, Mr Nepson was convicted of assault occasioning bodily harm with circumstances of aggravation. The particulars of the incident are that Mr Nepson and his co-offender attacked a stranger in the toilets of a nightclub and repeatedly kicked him causing extensive injuries. This is a despicable display of violence and the seriousness of the offence cannot be minimised. Considering, secondly, the risk of recidivism, this was not Mr Nepson's first offence - he had been convicted of some shoplifting offences in New Zealand whilst still a minor and had been charged with speeding here in Brisbane. These are offences more of a social pest than those of a career criminal. Mr Nepson has served his time without incident and expressed remorse for his actions at both his sentencing and during interviews with the Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs. He offered no excuses for his behaviour and accepted full responsibility for his actions. Whilst in prison he has completed the Cognitive Skills Programme and received a very positive exit report from the Programme Faciliator. His short stay in prison prevented him from completing any of the other behavioural programmes usually offered by the prison. The applicant has an offer of employment upon his release and a supportive family to which to return. The realisation that his criminal activities could see him removed from this country will also act as a deterrent in the future. The Tribunal assesses the risk of recidivism as acceptably low. The Tribunal is well aware that the risk of recidivism the Australian community expects to bear with respect to serious and violent crimes is very low. The applicant's co-offender was his future brother-in-law who is also a New Zealand citizen. As such, the general deterrent effect would carry some weight in this case, although the co-offender's own warning with respect to deportation would serve a similar purpose.