Nematollahi and Child Support Registrar (Child support)

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

Nematollahi and Child Support Registrar (Child support) [2017] AATA 2704 (15 December 2017)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:           2016/6634

Re:Aria Nematollahi

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Brigadier AG Warner, Member

Date:15 December 2017

Place:Perth

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

......(Sgd).......................................................

Brigadier AG Warner, Member

CATCHWORDS

CHILD SUPPORT – application for Departure Authorisation Certificate (DAC) – circumstances in which Child Support Registrar must issue a DAC - whether Applicant satisfies circumstances in which Registrar must issue DAC – two sets of circumstances not satisfied – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 – s 3(2) – s 72D – s 72L – 72M

CASES

Askew v Child Support Registrar [2014] AATA 354
Bettison and Child Support Registrar [2016] AATA 592
Kay and Child Support Registrar [2015] AATA 429
Onder and Child Support Registrar and Sari (No. 2) [2011] FMCAfam 430
Valve and Child Support Agency [2009] AATA 927

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Guides to Social Policy Law - Child Support Guide - Version 4.27 - Released 20 September 2017

REASONS FOR DECISION

Brigadier AG Warner, Member

15 December 2017

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Aria Nematollahi (the Applicant) has applied to the Tribunal for review of a decision of the Child Support Registrar (the Registrar), made on 30 November 2016, to refuse an application he made for a Departure Authorisation Certificate (DAC) pursuant to section 72L of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Registration and Collection Act).

  2. The Applicant attended the hearing.  Mr Nematollahi’s brother, Mr Arshia Nematollahi,   participated by telephone conference and acted as an advocate for the Applicant.  Ms Sarah Szymaszek, a Farsi translator, assisted the Tribunal.

    ISSUES

  3. The Tribunal must decide whether the Applicant should be issued a DAC.

  4. Section 72L of the Registration and Collection Act sets out two sets of circumstances in which the Registrar must issue a DAC. The legislative considerations are as follows:

    The set of circumstances in section 72L(2)

    ·whether, if the DAC were granted, the Applicant would be likely to return to Australia within an appropriate period; and

    ·whether it is likely that, within an appropriate period, the Registrar would be required to revoke the departure prohibition order (DPO) against the Applicant; and

    ·whether it is unnecessary for the Applicant to give security to secure the person’s return to Australia.

    The set of circumstances in section 72L(3)

    ·whether the Applicant has given security to secure the person’s return to Australia; or

    ·whether the Applicant is unable to provide security; and

    ·whether a DAC should be issued to the Applicant on humanitarian grounds; or

    ·whether refusing to issue a DAC to the Applicant would be contrary to Australia’s interests.

  5. Relevant to the definition of the issue before the Tribunal, the Registrar submits:

    …that it is not open for this Tribunal to consider on the merits whether or not the DPO should have been imposed (O’Neill and Child Support Registrar [2010] AATA 545). The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nematollahi and Child Support Registrar (Child support) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 2704
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for a Departure Authorisation Certificate (DAC) by the Applicant, Mr. Nematollahi, following the issuance of a Departure Prohibition Order (DPO) against him by the Child Support Registrar. The Applicant sought to travel overseas for approximately three months to visit his elderly parents in Iran and to undergo dental treatment in Bali. The Registrar had refused the DAC application, and the Applicant sought a review of this decision before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the circumstances warranted the issuance of a DAC. Specifically, the court had to consider the two sets of circumstances outlined in section 72L(2) of the *Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988* (Cth) under which the Registrar must issue a DAC. These circumstances require the Registrar to be satisfied that the applicant will depart and return within an appropriate period, that the DPO will likely need to be revoked within an appropriate period, and that it is not necessary for the applicant to provide security for their return.

The Tribunal found that the first set of circumstances under section 72L(2) was not met. The Applicant had a substantial outstanding child support liability of $13,676.71, comprising arrears and penalties, and had made no satisfactory arrangements to discharge this debt. Given the Applicant's current payment arrangement of $48.30 per fortnight from social security, it would take approximately 11 years to clear the debt. Furthermore, Iran is not a reciprocating jurisdiction, meaning the child support assessment would be unenforceable if the Applicant remained there. The Tribunal concluded that it was necessary for the Applicant to provide appropriate security for his return, which he had not proposed to do.

Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the Registrar's decision to refuse the DAC. The Applicant's failure to satisfy the criteria for issuing a DAC, particularly regarding the discharge of his child support liability and the lack of proposed security for his return, led to the dismissal of his application.

Background

Background to the litigation

These submissions were not disputed and the Tribunal agrees.FACTS The background facts as detailed in the Registrar’s Statement of Facts, Issues & Contentions (Exhibit 3), and not in dispute, are repeated in part in the following paragraphs 9 – 21. A child support case involving the Applicant was registered in respect of a child born in June 1998 and became collectable by the Department of Human Services (the department) from 28 October 1998 (T5/25-26). A second child support case involving the Applicant was registered in respect of two children born in July 2005 and February 2010 and became collectable by the department from 12 February 2014 (T6/27-31). On 12 June 2015, the Registrar issued a section 72A notice to Link Realty Pty Ltd, trading as Ray White - Port Hedland, to intercept rental income owed to the Applicant. This notice was withdrawn on 4 September 2015 (T15, 79-80). On 18 March 2016, a delegate of the Registrar issued a DPO to the Applicant pursuant to section 72D of the Registration and Collection Act (T20/100), The DPO prevents the Applicant from travelling outside of Australia; the DPO is still in force. On 17 June 2016, the Registrar issued a second section 72A notice to Link Realty Pty Ltd, trading as Ray White - Port Hedland. This notice was withdrawn on 7 January 2017. As at 5 January 2017, the Applicant had an outstanding child support liability of $27,437.71 comprised of $24,297.58 in child support arrears and $3,140.13 in penalties (T30/205). On 11 January 2017, the Registrar issued a third section 72A Notice to Link Realty Pty Ltd, trading as Ray White-Port Hedland; this notice is still in force. On 23 January 2017, the Registrar intercepted a tax refund of $4,162.32 (Exhibit 3, Attachment A). On 25 January 2017, the Registrar intercepted a second tax refund of $9,917.98 (Exhibit 3, Attachment A). As at 29 March 2017, the Applicant has an outstanding child support liability of $13,676.71 comprised of $9,997.60 in child support arrears and $3,679.11 in penalties (Exhibit 3, Attachment A). On 5 October 2016, the Applicant made a verbal application for a DAC. The Applicant requested a DAC to depart Australia to travel to Iran to see his elderly parents, who both suffer from Alzheimer’s disease, and to travel to Bali, Indonesia for urgent dental work (T23/148-151). The Applicant indicated that he wished to depart as soon as practically possible and proposed to remain outside of Australia for a period of up to three months (T23/148). On 30 November 2016, a delegate of the Registrar refused the Applicant’s application for a DAC (T2/3-4). On 13 December 2016, the Tribunal informed the Registrar that the Applicant had lodged an application with the Tribunal seeking review of the Registrar’s decision of 30 November 2016 (T1/1-2).EVIDENCE The evidence before the Tribunal comprised:·a 204 page set of T-Documents (T1-T29);·Applicant’s letter dated18 April 2017, with attached Centrelink Statement and other documents (Exhibit 1);·Applicant’s Submission received 15 June 2017 (Exhibit 2);·Registrar’s Statement of Facts, Issues & Contentions dated 9 May 2017 (Exhibit 3);·Certificate issued under subsection 116(2) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Exhibit 4); and·The oral evidence of the Applicant.RELEVANT LEGISLATION, POLICY AND AUTHORITIES

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 13 December 2016, the Tribunal informed the Registrar that the Applicant had lodged an application with the Tribunal seeking review of the Registrar’s decision of 30 November 2016 (T1/1-2).EVIDENCE The evidence before the Tribunal comprised:·a 204 page set of T-Documents (T1-T29);·Applicant’s letter dated18 April 2017, with attached Centrelink Statement and other documents (Exhibit 1);·Applicant’s Submission received 15 June 2017 (Exhibit 2);·Registrar’s Statement of Facts, Issues & Contentions dated 9 May 2017 (Exhibit 3);·Certificate issued under subsection 116(2) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Exhibit 4); and·The oral evidence of the Applicant.RELEVANT LEGISLATION, POLICY AND AUTHORITIES The legislation governing DPOs and DACs is set out in Part VA of the Registration and Collection Act. Section 3(2) of the Registration and Collection Act provides that it is the Parliament’s intention that the Registration and Collection Act shall be construed and administered to the greatest extent consistent with the attainment of its objects. Section 3(1) of the Registration and Collection Act provides that:Objects of Act(1) The principal objects of this Act are to ensure:(a)that children receive from their parents the financial support that the parents are liable to provide; and(b)that the periodic amounts payable by parents towards the maintenance of their children are paid on a regular and timely basis; and(c)that Australia is in a position to give effect to its obligations under international agreements relating to maintenance obligations arising from family relationship parentage or marriage.Departure Prohibition Orders Section 72D of the Registration and Collection Act authorises the Registrar to make a DPO prohibiting a person from departing from Australia for a foreign country if the following four conditions are met:(a)the person has a child support liability; and(b)the person has not made arrangements satisfactory to the Registrar for the child support liability to be wholly discharged; and(c)the Registrar is satisfied that the person has persistently and without reasonable grounds failed to pay child support debts arising from a registrable maintenance liability under section 17; and(d)the Registrar believes on reasonable grounds that it is desirable to make the order for the purpose of ensuring that the person does not depart from Australia for a foreign country without:(i) wholly discharging the child support liability; or(ii)making arrangements satisfactory to the Registrar for the child support liability to be wholly discharged.Departure Authorisation Certificates Section 72K of the Registration and Collection Act allows a person to whom a DPO has been issued to apply for a DAC. The application for a DAC under section 72L of the Registration and Collection Act must be considered with due regard to the fact that section 72L sets out exceptional circumstances in which the non-achievement of the purpose referred to in section 72D and the views expressed in the matter of Onder and Child Support Registrar and Sari (No.2) [2011] FMCAfam 430 by Monahan FM, who said at [79]:Consistent with the view expressed by Lindgren J in Whittaker; s.72D(1)(d) of the Collection Act is satisfied if it is established by the evidence that the CSA Registrar believed on reasonable grounds that it was desirable to make a DPO for the purpose of “ensuring” that the liable parent does not depart the country at any time in the future without first discharging the child support liability or making arrangements satisfactory to the CSA Registrar for its discharge.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal is satisfied that the criteria in section 72L(2)(a)(i) is not met.Is there any basis that would assist a conclusion that the DPO will be required to be revoked in an appropriate period of time? The Applicant’s child support debt is detailed in the Child Support Payer Transaction Statement 11/11/1998 to 04/01/2017 (Exhibit 3, Attachment A). As at 29 March 2017, the Applicant has an outstanding child support liability of $13,676.71 comprising $9,997.60 in child support arrears and $3,679.11 in penalties. The Applicant has made no submissions, and gave no indication before the Tribunal that he would or could address this liability in any way. The Respondent contends that based on the current payment arrangement of $48.30 per fortnight from his social security payments, the Applicant would require approximately 11 years to discharge the liability (Exhibit 3 para 42.2). In light of these payments, the Tribunal considers that the liability is not completely irrecoverable, but these payments and the Applicant’s circumstances as described to the Tribunal do not support a conclusion that the DPO will be required to be revoked. Is it necessary for the Applicant to give security to secure his return to Australia? Deputy President Forgie and Senior Member Cremean in the matter of Kay and Child Support Registrar [2015] AATA 429, affirmed the decision to refuse the issue of a DAC, highlighting the underlying rationale of the need for a person to give security, that reason being to ensure the person returns for the purpose of discharging his or her child support liability. The Registrar contends that it is necessary for the Applicant to provide appropriate security for his return to Australia for the following reasons:43.1The Applicant’s child support liability is substantial and he has failed to satisfactorily discharge his child support debt as and when it became due and payable.43.2The Applicant’s child support records indicate that a variety of enforcement actions have been taken by the department to partially satisfy the Applicant’s child support liability, including:43.2.1interception of the Applicant's tax refunds on 23 and 25 January 2017; and43.2.1at least nine section 72A Notices (issued on 22 April 2015, 1 May 2015, 12 June 2015, 19 June 2015, 7 August 2015, 28 August 2015, 4 September 2015, 17 June 2016, and 11 January 2017) have been issued to partially reduce the Applicant’s child support debt [T18, 96]. 43.3The Applicant will continue to accrue child support liability until February 2028 based on the current registered child support case.43.4Iran is not a reciprocating jurisdiction pursuant to Schedule 2 of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Regulation 1988. Accordingly, the department would be unable to enforce the child support assessment should the Applicant remain in Iran and fail to return to Australia.43.5Since the DPO was issued on 18 March 2016, the only form of regular payment has been through fortnightly deductions from the Applicant’s social security payment. Centrelink has confirmed in writing that the Applicant’s social security payment is not payable whilst he is overseas for the reason of the Applicant’s proposed travel to Iran [T24, 152](Exhibit 3, para 43).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering whether security is appropriate, the Tribunal ought to consider the surrounding circumstances of the Applicant. Deputy President Tamberlin in Valve and Child Support Agency [2009] AATA 927 at [18] and Senior Member McDermott in Askew v Child Support Registrar [2014] AATA 354 at [21] both found that where an Applicant had not complied with child support obligations, the security should not be substantially less than the amount of the child support liability. CONSIDERATION It is not in dispute that the Applicant made a request for a DAC pursuant to the requirements of section 72L(1) of the Registration and Collection Act. Before the Tribunal the Applicant was at times difficult and sarcastic in answering the Respondent’s questions. The tenor of the Applicant’s oral evidence and the submissions by his advocate, Mr Nematollahi are summarised as follows:·The Applicant’s three children provide an important reason for him to return to Australia. He is a builder and his financial position will improve. His is trying to avoid bankruptcy, his current circumstances are not his fault, and he is receiving benefits from the Department of Human Services. ·The information used by the Registrar was unreliable and included the lie that he owned six houses and had a large income. Further, the Registrar did not consider that Australia was his home and his country of residence.·The suggestion that he would not return to Australia was insulting and inhuman.·The Registrar is a bully who fails to consider the individual and has harassed the Applicant’s family.·The Applicant confirmed that he travelled overseas four times during 2015 but did not pay any child support since January 2015. The Applicant advised that his family will assist with any future travel costs, and he considered that the financial aspects of his overseas travel were outside the jurisdiction of the Registrar.·The Applicant insisted that the DAC should be issued on humanitarian grounds and disagreed with the opinion that the necessary conditions were not met. Particular reference was made to the opinion contained in the Departmental submission dated 21 November 2016, that “Mr Nematollahi’s circumstances justify the issuing of a DAC under humanitarian compassionate grounds, under the condition that the travel is directly to Tehran, Iran and returning directly to Australia” (T23/150).·The Applicant maintained that the Registrar and Centrelink were one and the same and that his receipt of Newstart was sufficient to demonstrate his financial position. He repeatedly maintained that he should not be required to answer questions from the Registrar.Circumstances in which it is appropriate to issue a DAC There are two main sets of circumstances in which the Registrar must issue a DAC (See paragraph 32 above). The first set of circumstances is set out in section 72L(2) of the Registration and Collection Act, and requires the Registrar to be satisfied: (a)that the Applicant will depart from and return to Australia within an appropriate period; and(b)it is likely the DPO will be required to be revoked in an appropriate period; and(c)it is not necessary for an applicant to provide security under section 72M for their return.Is the Tribunal satisfied that the Applicant will return to Australia in an appropriate period if the DAC is issued?