Neat Domestic Trading Pty Ltd v Wheat Export Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Neat Domestic Trading Pty Ltd v Wheat Export Authority [2000] FCA 1866

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – whether the Federal Court has jurisdiction to review a corporation’s (AWBI) decisions under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review Act) 1977 (Cth) – whether AWBI’s decisions were of an administrative character – whether AWBI’s decisions were made under an enactment – whether AWBI unlawfully applied an inflexible policy without having regard to the merits of the individual cases – whether AWBI unlawfully purported to delegate its functions under s 57(3B) of the Wheat Marketing Act 1989 (Cth) to AWB – whether AWBI exercised its power improperly under the Wheat Marketing Act.

Wheat Marketing Act 1989 (Cth) ss4, 5, 13(1), 57, 84, 88, 94
Wheat Market Legislation Amendment Act 1998 (Cth)
Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) ss3, 5
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss46, 80, 82, 86

Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321 followed
Evans v Friemann (1981) 35 ALR 428 considered
Hamblin v Duffy (1981) 34 ALR 339 considered
Burns v Australian National University (1982) 40 ALR 707 considered
Glasson v Parkes Rural Distributions Pty Ltd (1984) 155 CLR 234 considered
Reid v Nairn (1985) 60 ALR 209 considered
General Newspapers Pty Ltd v Telstra Corporation (1993) 45 FCR 164 followed
Hutchins v Commissioner of Taxation (1996) 65 FCR 269 followed
Australian National University v Lewin (1996) 68 FCR 87 considered
Salerno v National Crime Authority (1997) 75 FCR 133 considered
Kioa v West (1985) 159 CLR 550 cited
British Oxygen Co Limited v Minister of Technology (1971) AC 610 followed
Rex v Port of London Authority, Ex parte Kynoch Limited [1919] 1 KB 176 considered
Regina v Secretary of State for the Home Department, Ex parte Venables (1998) AC 407 considered
Chumbairux v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1986) 74 ALR 480 considered
Race Course Co-operative Sugar Association Limited v Attorney-General of the State of Queensland [1979] 142 CLR 460 followed

NEAT DOMESTIC TRADING PTY LTD v WHEAT EXPORT AUTHORITY & ORS
N 237 of 2000

MATHEWS J
18 DECEMBER 2000
SYDNEY

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 237 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

NEAT DOMESTIC TRADING PTY LTD
APPLICANT

AND:

WHEAT EXPORT AUTHORITY & ORS
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MATHEWS J

DATE OF ORDER:

18 DECEMBER 2000

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1)   The application be dismissed.

2)   The applicant is to pay the costs of all respondents.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 237 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

NEAT DOMESTIC TRADING PTY LTD
APPLICANT

AND:

WHEAT EXPORT AUTHORITY & ORS
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MATHEWS J

DATE:

18 DECEMBER 2000

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. Since 1 July 1999 the bulk export of wheat from Australia has been potentially exercisable by the third respondent, Australian Wheat Board International Limited (“AWBI”) to the exclusion of all other exporters.  This…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Neat Domestic Trading Pty Ltd v Wheat Export Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 1866
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

NEAT Domestic Trading Pty Ltd, a grain trader, sought judicial review of decisions by the Wheat Export Authority (WEA) to refuse its applications for bulk export permits for durum wheat between November 1999 and January 2000. The WEA’s refusals were based on the Australian Wheat Board International (AWBI), a subsidiary of the Australian Wheat Board (AWB), declining to approve the applications. NEAT challenged these decisions under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) and the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The primary issue was whether AWBI's decisions to refuse export permits were administrative in character and made under an enactment, thus falling within the scope of the ADJR Act. The court examined the nature of AWBI's role and its decisions, considering whether they were commercial or administrative. The court concluded that AWBI's decisions, while influenced by commercial considerations, were integrally connected to managing export markets and were thus administrative in nature.

The court further examined whether AWBI ignored relevant considerations when rejecting NEAT's applications. The evidence showed that AWBI's information was limited to the application forms, which omitted sensitive details such as the identity of the applicant and the overseas buyer. Despite this, AWBI had additional information from NEAT, including claims that NEAT could achieve higher prices for durum wheat than AWB. The court found that AWBI's policy against bulk exports was not unreasonable given the market conditions and that the information provided by NEAT did not compel a different decision. Consequently, the court dismissed NEAT's application and ordered NEAT to pay the costs of all respondents.

Orders

Orders of the court

1) The application be dismissed.

2) The applicant is to pay the costs of all respondents.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case arises because the applicant, NEAT Domestic Trading Pty Ltd (“NEAT”) sought the consent of the WEA for the bulk export of durum wheat on six separate occasions between November 1999 and January 2000. On each occasion the application was refused by the WEA because AWBI declined to approve the application. NEAT has challenged these decisions under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) (“the ADJR Act) also under the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (“the TP Act”).LEGISLATIVE BACKGROUND The central provision in this case is s 57 of the Wheat Marketing Act 1989, which was inserted into the Act by the Wheat Marketing Legislation Amendment Act 1998 (Cth). I shall quote this section shortly. However it is relevant to describe something of the history of this legislation. Until the enactment of the 1989 Act the then Australian Wheat Board (“the Board”) had a monopoly over both the domestic and the export wheat market. The most significant change effected by that Act was the deregulation of the domestic wheat market. The Board continued to exist, and it was anticipated that it would operate commercially in the domestic market. Indeed it was predicted to remain “the dominant force” in the domestic market. However its power of compulsory acquisition was removed. In addition, the funding arrangements of the Board were altered, as was its structure. Government control over the Board was reduced and its accountability to growers increased. As relevant to this case, the Board’s monopoly over the export market was maintained. This was achieved through the then s 57 which, relevantly, provided as follows:“Control of export of wheat57(1)A person, other than the Board, shall not export wheat except with the written consent of the Board.Penalty: $100,000” In 1992 the Act was amended by extending the Board’s functions to include value adding activities such as grain processing or the manufacture of grain products. The 1992 amendments did not affect the Board’s export monopoly. The relevant Minister, Mr Crean, referred to this in his Second Reading Speech (Hansard, House of Representatives, 14 October 1992, p 2155):“On the question of the Wheat Board’s export monopoly, it is clear the majority of growers favour the continuation of the Wheat Board’s single desk export operations. I am aware that there are calls from some growers, and certainly from other commercial interests such as the Australian Grain Exporters Association, to introduce at least a degree of deregulation in Australian export wheat sales. However, the Government has decided that now is not the appropriate time to change the Wheat Board’s export powers.” In 1997 the Act was amended, as the first part of a two-phase process designed to restructure the Board and to transfer most of its marketing and financial functions to companies operating under the Corporations Law. These companies were to consist of a holding company which, under the first phase, was to be a wholly owned subsidiary of the Board (described in the legislation as “nominated Company A”). That company was to have two wholly owned subsidiaries. The first, “nominated Company B”, was to manage wheat pools for export purposes. The second, “nominated Company C” was to conduct domestic wheat trading. It was anticipated that the second phase of the transition would occur in 1999 when the shareholding of the holding company would be transferred to wheat growers, with the result that the company would become owned and controlled by growers. Under the 1997 amendments the second respondent, Australian Wheat Board Limited (AWB), became the holding company (“nominated Company A”). AWBI became nominated Company B, charged with managing wheat pools for growers. These transitional provisions were to apply until 30 June 1999.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

It is apposite at this stage, to turn to the evidence about the applications made by NEAT, and the circumstances of their rejection by AWBI and therefore by the WEA.THE EVIDENCE Background Each of NEAT’s six applications for bulk export permits related to various grades of durum wheat. Durum wheat is used to make hard pasta products. It was described by counsel as occupying a “niche” place in the Australian wheat market. However the evidence indicates that significant quantities of durum are produced in northern New South Wales. Durum wheat is graded according to quality, from ADR1, which is prime quality grain, through to ADR6 and then to ADRF (or ADR Feed), at the lowest end. NEAT is a grain trader which has, for many years, been involved in the marketing of durum wheat in both the domestic and the overseas market. The “pool” system operated by AWBI was described by the two AWBI officers who gave evidence in the proceedings, Nicholas Gomersall and Stuart Richardson. As Mr Gomersall described it, Australian wheat growers have a choice of two marketing options. One is to deliver their wheat to a pool operated by AWBI. The bulk of this wheat will then be stored in silos, with a small percentage stored on farm. The other option is to sell wheat directly to grain traders, such as NEAT, which will then market the wheat either domestically or internationally. (Although, as will be seen, the opportunity for traders to export wheat has, at least over recent times, been limited to non-bulk exports.) According to Mr Gomersall, in the second half of 1999 and the early part of 2000, approximately 50% of Australian durum wheat was traded through AWBI’s pool system. AWBI trades only on the export market, and therefore wheat within its pools will be used solely for export. (It will be recalled that one of the objects of the 1997 amendments to the Wheat Marketing Act was to separate the export trade in wheat, to be conducted by AWBI, from the domestic trade, which is conducted by another AWB subsidiary). AWBI has a separate pool for each grade of durum wheat. The exception to this is ADRF, for which there was no separate pool over much of the time which is relevant to this case (July 1999 to March 2000). Any ADRF wheat received by AWBI during that time was placed into a general “wheat feed” pool. The pool system is designed to maximise returns to growers participating in the pool, by returning to them an average of the prices obtained by AWBI over the life of the pool, a period of approximately eighteen months. Growers who participate in the pool will receive approximately five payments over this period. Growers can also elect to make cash sales to AWBI. In this event they will receive a discounted cash payment, based on current prices at the time of sale. When this happens, the grower’s wheat is placed into the relevant pool but the grower will no longer participate in the pool. Or, to put it another way, the grower will receive no further benefits from the pool. Any profits later derived from more advantageous sales will be returned to those growers who have remained within the pool system.NEAT’s six applications

Decision

Reasons for decision

MATHEWS J
Section 3(1) of the ADJR Act defines a “decision to which this Act applies” as, relevantly, a decision of an administrative character made under an enactment. There is no dispute that decisions of AWBI under s 57(3B) of the Act are “decisions” under the ADJR Act. To adopt the test enunciated by Mason CJ in Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321, AWBI’s decisions under s 57(3B) are substantive, final and determinative of the issues falling for consideration. The real matter in dispute is whether these decisions can be categorised as administrative, and whether they were made under an enactment. I shall discuss each of these questions in turn.WERE AWBI’S DECISIONS ADMINISTRATIVE IN CHARACTER? It is clear that a decision of the WEA to give or withhold a bulk export consent under s 57(3B) is a decision of an administrative character. The WEA is a statutory authority, charged with controlling the export of wheat from Australia. But AWBI is, so its counsel contends, in a very different position. It is a company, formed under the Victorian Corporations Law, and is a wholly-owned subsidiary of AWB, also a company formed under the Corporations Law. Under Article 3.1 of AWB’s constitution, its directors are required to ensure that the business of AWBI is managed with the objective of, inter alia, “maximising the net pool return for Growers who sell wheat into the pools run by [AWBI] by securing, developing and maintaining markets for wheat and by minimising costs as far as practicable”. AWBI’s constitution requires that its directors ensure that the business of the company is managed in a manner which complies with Article 3.1 of AWB’s constitution. AWBI’s counsel submits that the company’s primary focus is therefore a commercial one. In particular, the company is charged with obtaining and maintaining export markets and maximising returns from them. Any decisions made by AWBI under s 57(3B) will be integrally connected with these activities. As such, it is submitted, they are decisions of a commercial rather than an administrative character. A number of cases were referred to by counsel relating to the categorising of decisions under s 3(1) of the ADJR Act. None of them have a direct bearing on the issues raised here. Indeed in the great majority of cases, the question was whether the decisions were administrative in character as opposed to legislative or judicial. However some assistance can be derived from a few of these cases. In Evans v Friemann (1981) 35 ALR 428, Fox ACJ found that a decision of the Board of Examiners of Patent Attorneys that a candidate had failed certain examinations was a decision of an administrative character. His Honour referred to the distinction between administrative, legislative and judicial functions and commented that it had proved “virtually impossible” to arrive at criteria which will distinguish these three concepts in all cases. He observed that sometimes the category into which an act or function will be placed will be decided, at least in part, on historical considerations or on the source of power or the nature of the body to which the power is given. His Honour made the following observations about the ADJR Act.“The Act refers to decisions of an administrative character. It is the character of the particular decision which is to be examined. Often this will present no difficulty. On the other hand, the words used do suggest an analytical approach, and this may present serious difficulties, and on one view, a major restriction on the ambit of the Act. The trouble, already noted in the constitutional cases, is that the concept of the “administrative” is not by itself clear and distinctive, and cannot in practice be treated as if it is. It is necessary to have a reasonably clear idea of the other concepts with which it is to be contrasted. There will be difficulties in this regard, even if there is adherence to the three-fold basic division already mentioned. But what if other functions are brought into the contrast? Should it be said, in the present case, that the decision was more of an educational nature, or that it was a decision respecting examinations, and no more?”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MATHEWS J

In all the circumstances I must conclude that AWBI’s qualification that its policy against bulk export permits would be maintained during “the current market environment” referred to major international market conditions which were unlikely to change in the short-term and which did not change during the relevant period. As such, the qualification is of little relevance to the issues raised in this case.The considerations urged in support of NEAT’s applications If NEAT is to succeed in this aspect of its case it must be able to show that when AWBI rejected its applications in pursuance of its policy against bulk export permits, it ignored material which should have been relevant to its decision. It is thus necessary to examine the material which accompanied NEAT’s applications and the arguments which were presented in their support. The documentation which AWBI received on each occasion from the WEA was, to say the least, sparse. It consisted of the pro forma application sent by NEAT to the WEA with various sections deleted. The deleted sections related to the identity of the organisation applying for the permit as well as the name and address of the overseas buyer. These deletions were in accordance with a protocol previously devised between AWBI and the WEA. The result was that the application form received by AWBI contained only information as to the grade and quantity of wheat, the country of destination, the load port, the proposed shipping period and whether the export was to be in bags, containers or bulk. In the absence of any direct communication between the permit applicant and AWBI this was the only material which AWBI routinely had available to it when considering applications for approval of export permits. In this case, there was also some direct communication between NEAT and AWBI in relation to its applications, although in some cases it is difficult to be certain whether letters from NEAT to the WEA were also sent to AWBI. So far as I can ascertain, AWBI had the following information about each of NEAT’s applications, in addition to the sparse material provided by the WEA.First and second applications NEAT’s first and second applications, Nos 992652 and 992660 were sent to the WEA on the same day, 4 November 1999. They were supported by a faxed and e-mailed letter from Peter Howard of NEAT. The evidence does not indicate whether this letter was sent only to the WEA or to both the WEA and AWBI. It is appropriate in the circumstances to assume the latter. The reasons given by Mr Howard in support of his application were, as relevant here:·that AWB Limited was not quoting a cash price for ADR3 to Australian growers.·that NEAT could achieve a much higher price for ADR3 than the last price quoted by AWB Limited.·that in these circumstances it would be unfair to NEAT and Australian durum growers if AWB Limited were to prevent the granting of a permit.Third and fourth applications NEAT’s third and fourth applications, No 993831, were sent to the WEA on 9 December 1999. They were accompanied by a letter from Mr Howard pointing out that the proposed Italian buyer was prepared to buy from NEAT at the same rate it would pay AWB. As NEAT had lower operating costs than AWB, the return to durum growers from NEAT exports would be higher than from AWB. It is by no means certain that this letter was received by AWBI. However two days earlier, on December 7 1999, Mr Howard faxed a letter to Mr Richardson of AWBI saying that the bids NEAT had received from its overseas buyer would give growers a higher return than AWB’s cash prices for pool returns. The information in both documents was therefore essentially the same.Fifth application