Neale v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Neale v Commissioner of Police [2020] QDC 233

PARTIES:

LAUREN DEBRA NEALE

(Appellant)

v

COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

(Respondent)

FILE NO:

D58 of 2020

DIVISION:

Appellate

PROCEEDING:

Appeal against sentence

ORIGINATING COURT:

Magistrates Court, Southport

DELIVERED ON:

21 August 2020

DELIVERED AT:

Southport

HEARING DATE:

31 July 2020

JUDGE:

McGinness DCJ

ORDER:

Appeal dismissed

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL – s 222 Justices Act 1886 – appeal against sentence – possession of dangerous drugs – forgery and uttering – whether Magistrate made an error of law or fact – whether terms of imprisonment imposed manifestly excessive

Penalties and Sentences Act 1992, Section 9

Justices Act (Qld) 1886, Sections 222, 223

House v R (1936) 55 CLR 499

Markarian v The Queen (2005) 228 CLR 371

R v Callow [2017] QCA 304

R v Chinmaya [2009] QCA 227

R v Donaci [2018] QCA 226

R v Lawley [2007] QCA 243

R v Warren [2014] QCA 175

Wong v The Queen (2001) 207 CLR 584

COUNSEL:

G Elmore for the Appellant

A Baker-Smith (solicitor) for the Respondent

SOLICITORS:

Ashkan Tai for the Appellant

Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions for the Respondent

Introduction

  1. On 18 February 2020, the appellant was sentenced on an agreed statement of facts for the following offences:

Charge

Offence

Date of Offence

Penalty Imposed

SOUT-MAG-00014517/19

1

Possession of a dangerous drug in excess of 2 grams (methylamphetamine)

18.07.2019

3 months imprisonment suspended forthwith for an operational period of 2 years

2, 4 - 7

Possession of a dangerous drug

18.07.2019

2 years probation

Conviction recorded

8

Possession of a thing for use in the commission of a drug offence

18/07/2019

2 years probation

Conviction recorded

9 Possession of utensils or pipes

18/07/2019

2 years probation

Conviction recorded

11 Unlawful possession of weapons 18/07/2019

2 years probation

Conviction recorded

SOUT-MAG-00023155/19
1 Breach of bail 06/11/2019

2 years probation

Conviction recorded

2

Forgery

13/11/2019

3 months imprisonment suspended forthwith for an operational period of 2 years

3

Utter forged document

13/11/2019

3 months imprisonment suspended forthwith for an operational period of 2 years

MAG-00018490200
1 Driving while a relevant drug is present in blood or saliva 22/01/2020

2 years probation, disqualified from holding or obtaining a driver licence for 4 months

Conviction recorded

  1. The appellant appeals against the sentences imposed for the charge of possession of a dangerous drug in excess of two grams, and the two forgery and uttering offences.  The appeal is on the basis that the sentences imposed were, in all the circumstances, manifestly excessive.  The appellant does not appeal the recording of convictions.

  2. Pursuant to s 223 of the Justices Act (Qld) 1886, subject to leave being given to adduce additional evidence, an appeal under s 222 is by way of a hearing on the evidence given in the proceedings before the Magistrate. In an appeal by way of rehearing, the powers of the Appellate Court are exercisable only where it can be demonstrated, having regard to all of the evidence before the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Neale v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QDC 233
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Neale v Commissioner of Police involved the appellant appealing against their sentence for possession of dangerous drugs, forgery, and uttering. The Court of Appeal was tasked with determining whether the magistrate made an error of law or fact, or whether the terms of imprisonment imposed were manifestly excessive. The appeal arose from a situation where the appellant was found in possession of a significant quantity of MDMA and had also committed offences of forgery and uttering. The magistrate had imposed concurrent terms of imprisonment for these offences. The appellant argued that imprisonment should only be imposed as a last resort and that the sentences were excessively harsh. The respondent, on the other hand, submitted that the forgery and uttering offences were serious and warranted imprisonment, particularly given the appellant’s prior convictions for drug offences and the need for trust in the provision of medical certificates.

The Court of Appeal examined whether the magistrate had appropriately exercised their discretion in imposing the sentences. The court considered the principles under the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992, particularly the requirement that imprisonment should only be imposed as a last resort. The court noted that while this principle is important, it is not absolute, and the serious nature of the offences and the appellant's prior criminal history could justify the imposition of imprisonment. The court concluded that the magistrate had properly considered the relevant factors and exercised their discretion appropriately. The sentences were not outside the permissible range and did not represent an error of law or fact. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed, and the sentences imposed by the magistrate were upheld.

The court’s reasoning was grounded in the understanding that the imposition of imprisonment, while generally a last resort, could be justified in cases involving serious offences and repeat offenders. The court found no error in the magistrate’s application of sentencing principles or in the factual considerations taken into account. As a result, the appeal was dismissed, and the original sentences remained in place.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The respondent submits that the forgery and uttering offences were serious due to the need for the courts and the police to be able to trust in the provision of medical certificates. This was also noted by the Magistrate.[10] Those offences were aggravated by the appellant being subject to bail for the drug offences at the time of offending. The respondent did not rely on any comparable decisions; however, submitted that the appellant has failed to show any error in the exercise of the magistrate’s discretion when regard is had to the totality of the appellant’s offending.Summary of comparable decisions[10]Transcript of Sentence Decision p 2, ll. 9-12.R v Shivanada Chinmaya The applicant pleaded guilty to one count of possession of Methylamphetamine and one count of possession of MDMA with a circumstance of aggravation that the quantity of MDMA exceeded two grams. At that time MDMA was a schedule 2 drug. It is now a Schedule 1 drug. The applicant was originally sentenced to concurrent terms of 12 months imprisonment with a parole release date set after he had served three months of the sentences. Police conducted a search of the appellant’s house and located .111 grams of pure Methylamphetamine. They also located 25 ecstasy tablets containing 1.672 grams of MDMA and a further bag of 88 tablets containing 6.027 grams of pure MDMA in another room. The applicant’s plea of guilty in respect of the 88 tablets was on the basis he did not know the tablets were present in the house. He recalled an occasion some time previously where a batch of MDMA tablets jointly purchased by the occupants of the house, which included the applicant, had gone missing. The sentencing Judge accepted it was likely the applicant did not have knowledge of the presence of the tablets. The plea was accepted on the basis that the applicant was in control of the premises where the drugs were found and was able to show that he neither knew nor had reason to suspect the drugs were in that place. The applicant was sentenced on the basis that there was no commercial purpose to his possession. He was 28 years of age and had no prior convictions for drug offences. He had minimal criminal history for possessing a knife in a public place 10 years previously and two public nuisance offences. He was given small fines on each offence. The applicant was in employment and had diligently undertaken treatment with a psychologist to rehabilitate and it was reported he had met the objectives of this treatment. On appeal, the applicant submitted no conviction should have been recorded and no actual custody imposed. The Court of Appeal determined that the requirement of a deterrent sentence was sufficiently met by the imposition of a sentence of 12 months imprisonment with immediate release, having regard to the applicant’s rehabilitation. Fraser JA (the other judges agreeing,) concluded at [28]-[29]:“Despite the material suggesting that the applicant’s offending was out of character, I concluded that a conviction should be recorded in view of the applicant’s relatively mature age when he committed the offences, the fact that he did have the criminal history I have described, and the facts that he possessed some schedule 1 drug and a significant quantity of schedule 2 drug. Accordingly, giving properly significant weight also to rehabilitation, I concluded that the applicant was appropriately punished by confirming the conviction and the head sentence imposed by the learned sentencing judge but ordering immediate release on parole”.[11][11]R v Chinmaya [2009] QCA 227, 7 at [28]-[29].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal refused the application for leave to appeal. The prosecution concedes Donaci had a far more serious criminal history; however, he was only found in possession of 2.726 grams of pure MDMA. Consideration It is clear on the material that the Magistrate had regard to all of the factors relied on by the appellant in her favour. The Magistrate accepted the drugs were for personal use and had regard to the character references, the drug analysis certificate, and the rehabilitation the appellant had undertaken and intended to undertake in the future. The appellant’s main contention is that, having regard to s 9(2)(a) of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992, imprisonment should only be imposed as a last resort. Therefore, it is submitted, the Magistrate should not have imposed terms of imprisonment, and for that reason, the sentence was manifestly excessive. The comparable decisions relied upon by the respondent clearly indicate that possession of MDMA over the schedule amount, even in the absence of significant prior criminal history, can result in the imposition of terms of imprisonment because of the serious nature of the offence.[12][12]Penalties and Sentences Act 1999 (Qld) s 9(2)(c) Each of the comparable Court of Appeal decisions referred to above supports the conclusion that, although imprisonment should only be imposed as a last resort, considerations such as the serious nature of an offence and a person’s antecedents may result in a term of imprisonment being imposed, even for first time offenders. The appellant was not a youthful first offender. She had been convicted twice previously of drug offences and had been given the benefit of a drug diversion order. It was within the proper exercise of the magistrate’s discretion to impose a term of imprisonment to reflect the serious nature of the offences and the principles of personal and general deterrence, but order the sentences be suspended forthwith to allow for the mitigating factors personal to the appellant. The forgery and uttering offences were of a serious nature. The offences were premeditated in circumstances where the character of the offending was similar in character to an offence of attempting to pervert the course of justice. Whilst he does not expressly say so, in my view, it can be readily inferred from an analysis of the Magistrate’s reasons that he turned his mind to the relevant considerations under ss 9(1) and (2) of the Penalties and Sentences Act, including the principles in s 9(2)(a) which state that imprisonment should only be imposed as a last resort and a sentence that allows the offender to stay in the community is preferable. The appellant has failed to persuade this court that the Magistrate acted on a wrong principle, took into account irrelevant matters, failed to take into account relevant matters, or mistook the facts[13]. The sentences imposed are not outside the permissible range of sentence in this case, in other words I am not persuaded it was excessive. I consider the appellant has failed to persuade the court that the Magistrate erred in imposing the sentences he did.[13]Wong v The Queen (2001) 207 CLR 584 at 605 [58].